Back to basics: Coronary calcium

After having my attentions pulled a thousand different directions these past 6 months, with the release of Wheat Belly and all the wonderful media attention it has attracted, I've decided to pick up here with a series of discussions about the fundamental issues important to the Track Your Plaque program and prevention and reversal of coronary atherosclerotic plaque.

I fear the discussions at times have drifted off into the exotic. This is great because this is how we learn new lessons, but we can never lose sight of the basics, else we risk losing control over this disease.

Imagine you've got a beautiful new car. You wax it, gap the spark plugs, rotate the tires, etc. and it looks brand-new, just like it came off the dealer's lot. 50,000 miles pass, however, and you realize you've forgotten to change the oil. Ooops! In other words, no matter how meticulous the attention to transmission, tires, and paint job, neglect of the most basic responsibility can ruin the whole thing. We can't let that happen with heart health.

If we propose to reverse coronary atherosclerotic plaque, we've got to have something to measure. First, it tells us whether we have atherosclerotic plaque in the first place, the stuff that accumulates and blocks flow and causes anginal chest pains, and ruptures like a little volcano and causes heart attacks. Second, it gives us something to track over the years to know whether plaque has grown, stopped growing, or been reduced. Without such a measure, you will be driving without a speedometer or odometer, just guessing whether or not you've gotten to your destination.

Of course, the conventional approach to heart disease and heart attack is not to track atherosclerotic plaque in your coronary arteries, but to track some distant "risk factor" for atherosclerotic plaque, especially LDL cholesterol. But LDL cholesterol is flawed at several levels. First, it is calculated, not measured. The nearly 50-year old Friedewald equation used to calculate LDL cholesterol is based on several flawed assumptions, yielding a value that can be 20, 30, or 50% inaccurate as a rule, only occasionally generating a value close to the real value. (No point in publicizing this problem, of course: Why compromise a $27 billion annual cash cow?) It also ignores the effect of diet. (No, cutting fat does not reduce LDL for real, only the calculated value. Cutting carbohydrates, especially wheat--"healthy whole grains"--slashes measured LDL values like NMR LDL particle number and apoprotein B.)

But all risk factors are, at best, snapshots of the situation at that moment in time. They change from day to day, week to week, month to month, year to year. If you do something dramatic in health, like lose 50 pounds, you can substantially change your risk factors values, like LDL cholesterol and HDL cholesterol. But you may not modify the amount of atherosclerotic plaque in your heart's arteries.

Measuring the amount of atherosclerotic plaque in your heart's arteries is, in effect, a cumulative expression of the effects of risk factors up until the moment of measurement.

There are several stumbling blocks, however, in the concept of measuring coronary atherosclerotic plaque. We cannot measure all the unique components of plaque, such as fibrous tissue like collagen, or degradative enzymes like collagenases, or inflammatory proteins like matrix metalloproteinase, or the debris of hemorrhage and inflammation. We struggle to contemporaneously mix in measures of bloodborne inflammation, coagulation and viscosity, and physiological phenomena of the artery itself, like endothelial dysfunction, medial (muscle) tone, and adventitial fat.

So we are left with semi-static measures of total coronary atherosclerotic plaque like coronary calcium, obtainable via CT heart scans as a calcium "score." No, it is not perfect. It does not reflect that moment's blood viscosity, it does not reflect the inflammatory status of the one nasty plaque in the mid-left anterior descending, nor does it reflect the irritating sheer effects of a blood pressure of 150/95.

But it's the best we've got.

If anyone has something better, I invite you to speak up. Carotid ultrasound, c-reactive protein, ankle-brachial index, stress nuclear studies, myoglobin, skin cholesterol, KIF6 genotype . . . none of them approach the value, the insight, the trackability of actually measuring coronary atherosclerotic plaque. And the only method we've got to gauge coronary atherosclerotic plaque that is non-invasive and available in 2012? Yup, a good old CT heart scan calcium score.

Comments (42) -

  • cancerclasses

    1/30/2012 4:58:24 AM |

    What about Pulse Wave Velocity (PWV) and Digital Pulse Analysis (DPA)?  
    From the Townsend Letter May 2010 article "Breakthrough in Clinical Cardiology: In-Office Assessment with Pulse Wave Velocity (PWV) and  Digital Pulse Analysis (DPA) by Brian Scott Peskin, BSEE, with Robert Jay Rowen, MD":  http://goo.gl/vihZO
    "This article explores an exciting, noninvasive, easy-to-use, and economical method of assessing patients’ cardiovascular physiologic status that is backed by more than 25 years of advanced research in medical physics. A 2007  Clinical Medicine article points the way to better clinical treatment of CVD, stating: “Arterial stiffness measured by pulse wave velocity (PWV) is an accepted strong, independent predictor of cardiovascular events and mortality.” 1   Anesthesiologists are well aware of this technology, used for monitoring purposes. While pulse oximetry became standard in the operating room and in other critical care areas as a detector of hypoxemia – all pulse oximeters are fundamental photoelectric plethysmographs – PWV has been largely ignored. This is unfortunate, as PWV (plethysmographic) information itself may provide important clues regarding the CV condition of the patient.2  With this advanced technology, cardiovascular science has moved forward, but many physicians have yet to appreciate these advances. As stated in the 1993 issue of the Journal of Hypertension, “Wave reflection is not a subject with which most physicians are familiar and only given mention in undergraduate physiology courses.” Little has changed.

    As this article was going to press, however, “Arterial Stiffness
    and Cardiovascular Events: The Framingham Heart Study,” by
    Gary F. Mitchell, MD, et al. (Circulation. 2010;121:505–511)
    was published and featured on Medscape, stating: “In this
    study, we assessed the incremental value of  adding pulse
    wave velocity [PWV] ... to a risk model that includes standard
    risk factors for a first cardiovascular event. … Adding pulse
    wave velocity led to significant reclassification of risk and
    improvement in global risk prediction. … [W]e need to focus
    our efforts on identifying and implementing interventions that
    can prevent or reverse abnormal aortic stiffness in order to
    prevent a marked increase in the burden of disease potentially
    attributable to aortic stiffness.”  The specific intervention/
    solution will be given later in this article."

    Also, "This video is a preview of a lecture given at the 2010 18th international A4M conference in Orlando."  http://goo.gl/S1xth

    Disclosure: I have no known conflicts of interests in conveying this information, I do not own stock or any financial interests in any of the companies making or distributiing this equipment.

  • Anne

    1/30/2012 5:55:03 AM |

    Hi Dr. Davis, I had a CT scan done about 5 years ago and the results were frightening, it was 1050. I was shocked because I ate healthy, low fat, plenty of healthy  wheat, how could this happen. My Dr. sent me for an EKG ultrasound and ever test possible and all  the tests were perfect. As you know I have changed to no wheat, high fat, low carb way of eating and I gained 5 lbs but my triglycerides came down to 61, LDL is 153 . My other numbers are high but I read that can happen when you have hypothyroidism c reactive protein is 0.7 MG/L. My Dr. said that the clinic that tested my CT scan are no longer in business in Michigan so I don't know if the plaque improved or got worse, any suggestions?

  • Donald Kjellberg

    1/30/2012 7:58:51 AM |

    I have been thinking about the subject of getting back to the basics a great deal lately.

    Trying to synthesize everything into one concept made me realize how complex this whole process of prevention is. I too have been peering into windows on the road of better health.  What a complex and wonderful set of the diversity our homeostatic responses convey.

    What are the basics to me now? I'll serve it up in one word, food . . .

    What we eat determines profoundly how our body responds to the many factors contributing to heart disease (and other systems dysfunctions). One thing I learned along the way is over 50 different species of bacteria have been identified in arterial plaque (in addition to other pathogens).

    Going back to the basics tells me to eat foods that not only reduce markers associated with heart disease but also considers dietary factors that may optimize immune responses and pathogen suppression. Cutting out wheat provides great capital in healing the gut. It sets the groundwork for improved cellular communication and neurological feedback mechanisms.

    . . . and that's getting back to the basics. It sure isn't simple, but learning to prepare and serve up the right type of foods sure can sweeten the journey even if it gets us of track every now and then.

  • JC

    1/30/2012 1:06:30 PM |

    I have a friend who had a 16 slice scan and had a 0 calcium score.Several week after the scan he had a heart attack.Can you point out some studies which show the correlation of calcium scores to cardio incidents?What is the data to suggest it's a better marker than the others such as cholesterol,CRP,etc.

  • JC

    1/30/2012 1:17:26 PM |

    I'm on a near vegan diet as recommended by Dr Joel Fuhrman.It did not solve all my medical issues but it did tame my blood glucose(from the 130s to the low 80s)and my blood pressure(from 210/110  to 125/70).When I tried a diet heavy in meat and fat and low in carbs(50G/day)my blood pressure went up to 150/85.I have a type of salt sensitive hypertension(low renin) that may be a factor.Comments?

  • nina

    1/30/2012 7:57:37 PM |

    I have a friend who has had a stent, bypass and several cardiac incidents.  I find it tough to persuade him to follow your regimen and he's terrified that areas of his heart muscle have died and that there is no hope for him.

    Do you have examples of people who have successfully recovered from such a dire state of health in their 60's?  

    Nina

  • Ronnie

    1/31/2012 1:07:20 AM |

    My 54-year old husband also received a score of 0 on his 64-slice CT scan.  He's had no heart issues, however, he is overweight, has hypertension, he's insulin resistant and he has low HDL and elevated ApoB and LDL-P.  Because of his 0 score he feels he's not at risk.  How can I convince him otherwise?

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/31/2012 2:27:23 AM |

    Yes, I have, Nina. But the answers cannot be found in conventional healthcare with yet more procedures and drugs.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/31/2012 2:29:13 AM |

    There's no comparison. Coronary calcium scores as a measure of coronary atherosclerosis wins, hands down.

    But it is not perfect. While heart attacks at a score of zero are distinctly uncommon, they can happen.

    For a full discussion of the studies documenting this, I would invite you to read the Track Your Plaque book available through the www.trackyourplaque.com website.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/31/2012 2:29:49 AM |

    Hear, hear, Donald! You are singing my tune.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/31/2012 2:30:54 AM |

    Hi, Anne--

    Yes, simply find another center that performs heart scans. They are actually done fairly widely now. It's often not advertised since, like mammograms, they don't make any money.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/31/2012 2:31:49 AM |

    HI, Cancer-

    You are getting in to issues like endothelial dysfunction that are beyond the scope for this discussion.

    Perhaps something to talk about in future.

  • cancerclasses

    1/31/2012 9:22:08 PM |

    Well to me it''s kinda all the same but I''m also not a practicing cardiologist, and I may have been influenced by this: http://goo.gl/lfsQ7
    "Endothelial dysfunction is thought to be a key event in the development of atherosclerosis and **predates** clinically obvious vascular pathology by many years. This is because endothelial dysfunction is associated with reduced anticoagulant properties as well as increased adhesion molecule expression, chemokine and other cytokine release, and reactive oxygen species production from the endothelium, all of which play important roles in the development of atherosclerosis. In fact, endothelial dysfunction has been shown to be of prognostic significance in predicting vascular events including stroke and heart attacks. Because of this, endothelial function testing may have great potential prognostic value for the detection of cardiovascular disease, but currently the available tests are too difficult, expensive, and/or variable for routine clinical use."  

    I know tests have real costs associated with them, but is seem like DPA/PWV  plus the 64 slice MDCT plus coronary calcium would give a fairly complete picture.  I notice two of the three used in this report with the DPA performed at a later date. http://goo.gl/MS6Gp

  • cancerclasses

    1/31/2012 10:32:21 PM |

    The Oxidized LDL Triple Marker test?

  • PeteKl

    2/1/2012 3:02:01 AM |

    Hi Nina,

    It is hard to say what your friend''s future might hold without knowing how much damage has been done by his "cardiac incidents".  However assuming he is not bedridden, I wouldn''t call his situation hopeless.  If he can still walk around and climb a flight of stairs, I would guess there is still a reasonable amount of heart function left to enable him to live a mostly normal life.  He just needs to avoid losing even more.

    I am younger than your friend (48), but I also had a (very unexpected) MI and emergency bypass a little over a year ago.  My MI was rather mild, but it definitely did some damage.  I am well aware of the fear and sense of hopelessness that your friend is feeling.

    I started following the Doctor''s program about 10 months ago.  I can''t say for sure whether it will help or not, but it definitely makes my numbers look good so I am optimistic.  I would like to have a heart scan to track my own situation, but most places won''t do them if you have already had bypass so I am flying a little blind (BTW Doctor, has there been any change in this situation?).  I also started cardiac rehab a few weeks after my surgery and now exercise at least an hour a day 5-6 times a week.

    I''m not sure what to attribute this to (probably a combination of things), but I am pretty much back to normal.  I was never a super athlete, but I feel I can do anything a normal, fit 48 year old man can do and then some.  This was even confirmed by a recent stress test.  

    For example, I am currently on vacation and spent my afternoon swimming in the ocean and walking several miles up and down the boardwalk.  If someone had told me something like this was possible a year ago, I would have told them they were full of it.  Yet here I am.  

    So do I think your friend could recover? Yes I do.  He may not do as well as I have, but I suspect he can likely do much better than he thinks possible.  However it will take time and effort and may require taking  a few chances like trying the Doctor''s program (his own doctors probably won''t be thrilled).  Sitting at home waiting for a miracle likely won''t work.

    One thing I should mention is that resolving your friend''s difficulty may require more than just fixing his heart.  Having a major cardiac event is extremely traumatic.  Depression and anxiety disorders are common afterward.  From what I have heard, as many as 80% experience it.  Unfortunately most doctors won''t tell you this and they definitely don''t want to deal with it.  At best they will prescribe another pill.

    I was fortunate to have a sister who is a professional counselor.  She realized how distraught I was after my surgery and immediately recommend I start seeing someone.  It was great advise.

    The counselor I saw didn''t have any magical advice that suddenly made me feel better.  What she did  was help me work through what had happened and put it in proper perspective.  Once I could  do that, I started finding increasing motivation to get well.  It took a while (I have had at least 30 sessions over that past year), but it works.  BTW, most insurance will usually cover it.

  • Joanna

    2/1/2012 5:12:55 PM |

    I agree with you Pete, my husband, mid-50''s had a very serious MI about four months ago, also completely unexpected as he appeared in great health with no risk factors.  And although we don''t have all the answers yet about how much damage was done, we know it was a lot.  He is exercising at rehab (he was a regular exerciser before) as well as on his own and has been feeling almost like himself - and considering how serious his condition was this is pretty amazing.  He was already doing a number of the things Dr. Davis advocates and has since added more.
    Pete, if I may ask, do you know what your ejection fraction is now and what it was post MI?  We are struggling to get answers at this stage as to whether this will ever improve and how long it may take.  His is still low despite how well he feels.

  • nina

    2/1/2012 8:26:07 PM |

    Many thanks for the responses.  

    I know that conventional treatments aren''t the answer, but convincing my friend of that is another challenge.  I seem to have several friends who think reducing carbs is harmful and unnatural.  (I''m off sugar and grains, substituting almond flour, flax and desiccated coconut without any problem.)

    Nina

  • Ronnie

    2/2/2012 2:29:40 AM |

    Why aren''t most doctors doing calcium scoring tests instead of stress tests that only show late stage blockages?  If heart attacks occur when arteries are slightly blocked, it appears that calcium scoring should be the first test done on high risk patients.  Is it because the medical community is slow to accept change from the usual way of doing things?  Or is it the fault of the insurance companies who are notorious for not paying for new fangled tests?  I''m a total layman, but I''m high risk (APOE4) and the only test I received was a nuclear stress test (which was negative).  If I want to know my calcium score, I would have to pay $500 out of my pocket to Princeton  Longevity Ctr to have them do it as my doctor will not order it.

  • PeteKl

    2/2/2012 6:46:48 AM |

    Hi Joanna,

    As I mentioned, my MI was rather mild and I don''t think my EF ever went down substantially.  During my surgery (which started about 12 hours after my MI) my EF was measured at 55 percent.  A few weeks ago when I had my stress echo I measured 60 percent at rest and 55 percent under stress (to my knowledge these values are considered normal for most people).  I will admit that overall I was luckier than most people in this area.

    However keep in mind EF only gives you part of the picture.  There are many other variables.  A person can have a completely normal EF and still have major problems.  During my surgery my heart rhythm was very unstable.  My surgeon originally wanted to do a triple bypass but he ended up skipping the third one because he decided it was too risky.  On the other hand someone can have a low EF and still live a long and active life.

    Even if I had your husband''s full medical record, I can''t tell you exactly what his EF means.  You really need to discuss this further with his doctor.  However the following statement you made I think gives a good indication of where you probably stand:

    “He is exercising at rehab (he was a regular exerciser before) as well as on his own and has been feeling almost like himself – and considering how serious his condition was this is pretty amazing.”

    You are right.  This is pretty amazing.  Based on my own experience at cardiac rehab this doesn''t always happen.  I know it isn''t very scientific, but if he looks good and feels good he is probably doing just fine.  His EF might be low, but it must be high enough or he would be having all kinds of problems.

    While it might be nice to see a higher EF, from what you have described I''m not sure it would make a big difference.  It sounds like he either can or soon will be able to do everything he was capable of pre-MI.  If this is correct, it is fantastic news.  Personally I would probably stop worrying about his EF and instead concentrate on making sure he continues to retain every bit of heart muscle he has left.  

    However I am by no means an expert on all of this.  Perhaps the Doctor can weigh in with some better advice.

  • Renfrew

    2/2/2012 4:40:55 PM |

    Now, the most important question:
    HOW do we get rid of the calcium in our arteries ???
    Does Magnesium help as a calcium  antagonist? Chelation?
    Renfrew

  • Gene K

    2/2/2012 7:44:52 PM |

    Why $500? I paid $85 to have my calcium score heart scan done at a local hospital in the Chicago area. Check with radiology departments in the area hospitals.

  • Gene K

    2/2/2012 7:46:25 PM |

    Read Dr Davis''s Track Your Plaque book, 2nd edition, to get the answer.

  • Renfrew

    2/2/2012 8:04:53 PM |

    Dr. Davis,
    I am living in Germany and cannot get the book. About 6 months ago you said you will make it available in downloadable pdf format. Any progress on this front?
    Thanks.
    Renfrew

  • Ronnie

    2/2/2012 8:50:03 PM |

    I was thinking that the 64 slice CT scan was  the only test that measured calcium score, and Princeton Longevity charges $500 (give or take) for it.  I could get it there without a prescription; I would think I''d need a prescription to get the test at a hospital.  I''ll look into it, thank you.

  • Joanna

    2/2/2012 8:50:11 PM |

    Thanks so much Pete.  And you are right, we are doing everything we can to retain as much heart muscle as we can - unfortunately we have been told that with such a low EF, even if he feels great, he is at much greater risk of sudden cardiac arrest and may need an ICD (an internal defibrillator) implanted - something that is both very expensive and may interfere with some of the work he does.  So we wait.  We have been told that his EF may come up over time but no one will give us any odds of this happening (for some people it seems it never does) or over how long a period of time it may take to improve.  

    I would also like to tell Nina to urge her friend to do cardiac rehab/exercise as this seems to be one of the differences between people who are successful in their recovery and those who aren''t.

  • Gene K

    2/2/2012 9:34:12 PM |

    No prescription was necessary in my case. They sent the results to me directly, and also to the doctor who they asked me to specify.

  • Gene K

    2/2/2012 10:16:57 PM |

    Yes, the book is available for download for TYP members.

  • PeteKl

    2/3/2012 6:12:17 AM |

    Hi Joanna,

    I''m going to make a guess here (and hopefully someone who knows more about this will correct me if I am wrong), but I suspect the issue isn''t so much a low EF by itself, as much as it is that a higher EF indicates greater recovery of the damaged heart muscle.  My understanding is that when an MI causes damage to heart muscle, it usually isn''t the loss of pumping capacity that causes death.  Instead the loss of muscle causes an electrical disturbance in the heart''s rhythm causing it to lose its ability to pump  blood.  This is why even a mild MI like mine can be fatal and explains why my surgeon was so concerned (See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myocardial_infarction#Pathophysiology).

    I suspect what your husband''s doctor might be concerned about is that he may be having a certain amount of arrhythmia because of the damage to his heart.  Apparently this is quite common after an MI and it is also something doctors don''t typically explain very well (at least mine didn''t).  

    After my surgery I was put on the drug amiodarone to help control my heart rhythm (which it did).  However this drug has some rather nasty side effects so they try to pull you off of it as soon as possible.  I stopped taking it after about a month and almost immediately developed some arrhythmia.  

    Fortunately the type of arrhythmia I developed (PVC''s) are usually considered benign.  But it was still extremely disconcerting since no one really explained to me what was going on.  The only thing I was ever told (or at least ever heard) was probably the same thing you have heard 50 times – “if you have any chest discomfort or shortness of breath, go to the emergency room” (needless to say this is not comforting advice).

    I am still having some PVC''s, but they have become increasing less frequent.  The bottom line is that the heart can essentially rewire itself, but it takes time.  Part of the point I am trying to make is that this might occur even if his EF doesn''t change.  

    Again this is a guess since I don''t have much information, but I suspect your husband''s doctors may be waiting to see how well your husband''s heart repairs itself (which may take a year or more) and they will then decide if he needs an ICD.  I''m also guessing they are currently controlling his heart rhythm with some type of drug (there are many) and they eventually want to take him off of it.

    Unfortunately it is my understanding that all you can do is wait.  There is currently no way of predicting who will fully recover and who won''t.  There are simply too many variables.

    However I think there are several factors in your husband''s favor.  The first is that he is young and most of his body''s natural repair mechanisms (which are considerable) are still functional.  

    He is also enthusiastic about doing his cardiac rehab.  The gradual stress of exercise essentially helps remodel and strengthen the heart.  Oddly enough many people don''t do this.  I''m sure your husband has already noticed that many patients quit cardiac rehab (and most likely stop exercising)  at the end of Phase II (about 12 weeks).  Just the fact that your husband is willing to continue with an exercise program puts him in a completely different class.

    Finally he is willing to modify his lifestyle.  He is changing the way he eats and, unless you are withholding something, probably doesn''t smoke or have some other equally bad habit.  When I was recovering from my surgery, my younger brother was in one of the waiting rooms when another patient, who had obviously also recently had heart surgery, was wheeled into the room next to him and started a conversation.  At some point during the conversation the man turned to my brother and said “I really hope when I get out of here they will let me smoke again”.  Like I said, your husband is in a completely different class.

    I know there are at least a few supplements out there that may help heal a heart''s electrical system.  Magnesium and CoQ10 are two that I have heard might help (try googling them for more info).  I doubt they will cause a miraculous recovery, but they might give him that little extra kick that helps him avoid the ICD.  I''m sure there are others on this site that know a hundred times more than I do.  Assuming what I have discussed is even roughly correct, perhaps a few of them can make an even better recommendation.

    I know all of this is frustrating, but try not to give up hope yet.  Four months is still early in the recovery process.  I remember being told that recovery would take at least a year and that turned out to be about right.  Also keep in mind (as I''m sure you have already discovered) that the recovery process is typically a series of two steps forward and one step back.

    BTW, no matter what might happen, please remember your husband is extremely fortunate to have you by his side.  There are many people who don''t have a person they can rely on to help figure this all out.  I doubt my recovery would have been as successful as it has been without the help I received from my partner and my family.  I now understand why so many people simply give up.  The recovery process simply becomes too overwhelming.

  • Roger

    2/4/2012 10:01:12 PM |

    I''ve gotten my calcium score for $50 at a DFW hospital with a 50% off coupon.  The result didn''t take 10 minutes to come out: a big zero! I will be back in 5 years.

  • Ronnie

    2/5/2012 2:47:57 PM |

    Gene, how was your score if you care to share?

  • Gene K

    2/5/2012 6:49:23 PM |

    No secret here, but unless zero, the dynamics are more important than the absolute number. At least, if I understand the whole TYP program correctly. My score was 213 in Feb 2010 and 191 this time, in Sep 2011.

  • Ronnie

    2/5/2012 10:05:46 PM |

    You''re going in the right direction, Gene.   That''s great!

  • Dr. William Davis

    2/7/2012 3:59:06 AM |

    Hi, Renfrew--

    We make the Track Your Plaque Guide available to our members without charge (except our membership fees to cover the costs of operating the website).

  • Dr. William Davis

    2/7/2012 3:59:40 AM |

    Hi, Ronnie--

    The laws differ from state to state. You can always call a center and ask.

  • Stan (Heretic)

    2/9/2012 3:25:12 AM |

    @JC,

    I hope Dr. Davis will respond, and I hope you don''t mind if I respond meantime. (Dr. Davis, please  correct me if my post is not accurate enough)

    I am not a doctor but 150/85 that you had on a high meat, fat and low carb, seems still OK!   Its not clear to me why did you have to change that diet?   Have you not quit a LC diet too prematurely  perhaps?  Experiences of other high fat low carb nutrition proponents in Europe (see especially  books by Dr. J.K.)  have shown that it takes about 2 years to see a significant effect upon cardiovascular health for patients with advanced arteriosclerosis.      

    I hope Dr. Davis can step in to, clarify this.  I know you are above retirement and male but it may help to provide your exact age and a history of your hypertention.  Even if you were practicing some sport and have clear coronary arteries, your peripheral arteries may still be partially occluded creating a condition conjusive towards a hypertention.   AFAIK it is possible to have clear coronary (heart) artieries and at the same time have occluded peripheral arteries.   Also your pre-diabetes may have been a factor too on the SAD since high insulin makes arteries less flexible.
    Stan

  • JC

    2/9/2012 1:40:33 PM |

    Thanks Stan,I looked at my old blood pressure readings to refresh my memory and many of the readings were in the low 170s/90 but the median score was around 156-160/85-88.The rapid rise scared me but it was fun while it lasted because I love butter,meat,cheese,and tons of fat.I don''t know how my low renin hypertension fits into this but I am very sensitive to sodium/salt.The only salt/sodium I get is that found naturally in vegetables,beans,nuts,and potatoes.
    Many years ago (around 2006) you posted some data that correlated blood pressure with cornary events and the link was not as strong as you would expect given all the hysteria about blood pressure.I would have to be convinced blood pressure in the 170s and 180s was not that serious before I would go back to the paleo style diet again.My near vegan diet has also tamed my blood glucose which is now consistently below 85.Before that in was in the 97-99 range.A number of years ago before I lost about 80 lbs it was in the mid 130s.

    So going back to a plaeo style diet I would have to accept higher blood pressure and blood glucose levels....170sBP and high 90s FBG.If I am convinced that those levels are safe it would change my perspective.

  • David

    2/12/2012 8:08:15 AM |

    Dr. Davis,

    Can you clarify the issue of measuring soft plaque?  My understanding is that soft plaque is more unstable and therefore more of a concern that hard plaque.  Does a Ca score infer soft plaque so gives us some sense of soft as well as hard plaque, or gives us no indication at all of soft plaque?  Would the PLA2 test be a better marker of soft plaque than the Ca score?

    Thanks for your great work!
    David

  • David

    2/22/2012 5:09:52 AM |

    Followup to my last question:
    wouldn''t a carotid ultrasound give us a better sense of soft plaque?  Combined with results for PLA2?

    David

  • Emidio

    3/12/2012 11:33:53 PM |

    Another form of very dangerous form of LDL...the glycated one:
    http://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/60/7/1973.full

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/16/2012 12:34:28 AM |

    Absolutely. See the several blog posts back some time about this.

    Also a full length Special Report on the Track Your Plaque website will be coming out.

  • Joanie

    2/8/2013 8:46:56 PM |

    Can someone clarify which CT scan is the recommended "coronary calcium score"? I have been told by 2 medical centers here that they perform BOTH 1.) a "coronary calcium score" CT scan which costs (approximately) $150 and uses no contrast material. In that test, they scan the area from the top to the bottom of the heart, and visualize calcium that may exist in that field. This would include part but not all of the lungs, plus all of the heart.

    2.} a coronary calcium scan CT which costs (approx) $1,700 and does use contrast material, injected into a vein. The scan visualizes the heart aided by the contrast in the vessels. This also is a way to measure calcium.

    WHICH test does Dr. Davis recommend? I've been searching the blog and find repeated mentions of "calcium score" but must have missed a way to discriminate which CT test is the right one? Would appreciate any help with this. Thanks!

  • patricia sage

    3/13/2014 10:49:16 PM |

    I take Calcium with Vitamin K2.
    Vitamin K2 helps direct calcium to the bones and teeth(where it belongs), keeping the calcium from attaching itself to the arteries.
    Natural sources are Natto, egg yolk, butter...problem is I don't like the cholesterol in egg yolk and butter and I don't like the taste of Natto.
    I found this online and order it online as well http://tinyurl.com/q8fjc93
    It is made in USA; head office is in California. That's why delivery and shipping is free in USA. Delivery took about 3 to 7 days.  It has Omega 3+ as well as CoQ10 and Vitamin K2 and it is Extended release(long-term effect).

Loading

Beating the Heart Association diet is child's play



In response to the Heart Scan Blog post, Post-Traumatic Grain Disorder, Anne commented:


While on the American Heart Association diet my lipids peaked in 2003. I even tried the Ornish diet for a short time, but found it impossible.

Total Cholesterol: 201
Triglycerides: 263
HDL: 62
LDL: 86

After I stopped eating gluten (I am very sensitive), my lipid panel improved slightly. This past year I started eating to keep my blood sugar under control by eliminating sugars and other grains. Now this is my most recent lab:

Total Cholesterol: 162
Triglycerides: 80
HDL: 71
LDL: 75


Isn't that great? This is precisely what I see in practice: Elimination of wheat and sugars yields dramatic effects on basic lipids, especially reductions in triglycerides of up to several hundred milligrams, increased HDL, reduced LDL.

Beneath the surface, the effects are even more dramatic: reductions or elimination of small LDL particles, reduction or elimination of triglyceride-containing lipoproteins, elimination of the marker for abnormal post-prandial (after-eating) lipoproteins, IDL, reduced c-reactive protein. Add weight loss from abdominal fat stores and reduced blood pressure.

In fact, I would go so far as to speculate that, if the entire nation were to follow Anne's lead and eliminate wheat and sugars, "need" for 30% of all prescription medications would disappear. The incidence of diabetes would be slashed, the U.S. would no longer lead the world in obesity.

Anne and I are not the first to make this observation. It has also been made in several studies, such as:

The Duke University study of low-carbohydrate diets in type II diabetics. In this study, 50% of low-carb participants became non-diabetic: They were cured.

One of the many studies conducted by University of Connecticut's Dr. Jeff Volek, demonstrating dramatic improvement in glucose, insulin (reduced 50%) and insulin responses, and lipids.

Dr. Ron Krauss' early studies that hinted at this effect, even though the "high-fat" diet wasn't really low-carbohydrate.

If wheat and sugar elimination has been shown to achieve all these fabulous benefits, why hasn't the American Heart Association spoken in favor of this dietary approach and other- low-carbohydrate diets ? Why does the American Heart Association maintain its "Check-Mark" stamp of approval on Cocoa Puffs and Count Chocula cereals?

Victim of Post-Traumatic Grain Disorder

Heart Scan Blog reader, Mike, shared his story with me. He was kind enough to allow me to reprint it here (edited slightly for brevity).



Dr. Davis,

I was much intrigued to stumble onto your blog. Heart disease, nutrition, and wellness are critically important to me, because I’m a type 2 diabetic. I’m 53 and was diagnosed as diabetic about 5 years ago, though I suspect I was either diabetic or pre-diabetic 5 years before that. Even in a metropolitan area it's next-to-impossible to find doctors sympathetic to any approach beyond the standard get-the-A1c-below 6.5, get LDL <100, get your weight and blood pressure normal, and take metformin and statins.

I’m about 5’10-and-a-half and when I was young I had to stuff myself to keep weight on; it was an effort to get to 150 pounds, and as a young man, 165 was the holy grail for me. I always felt I’d look better with an extra 10-15 pounds.
I ate whatever I wanted, mostly junk, I guess, in my younger years.

When I hit about age 35, I put on 30 pounds seemingly overnight. As I moved toward middle age I became concerned with the issue of heart health, and around that time Dr. Ornish came out with his stuff. I was impressed that he’d done a
study that supposedly showed measurable decrease in atherosclerotic plaque, and had published the results of his research in peer-reviewed journals. It looked to me as though he had the evidence; who could argue with that? I tried his plan on and off, but as so many people note, an almost-vegan diet is really tough. It was for me, and I could never do it for any length of time. But given that the “evidence” said that I should, I kept trying, and kept beating up on myself when I failed. And I kept gaining weight. I got to almost 200 pounds by the time I was 40 and have a strong suspicion that that’s what caused my blood sugar to go awry, but my doctor at the time never checked my blood sugar, and as a relatively young and healthy man, I never went in very often.

I’ve had bouts of PSVT [paroxysmal supraventricular tachycardia, a rapid heart rhythm] every now and again since I was 12 or so. I used to convert the rhythm with Valsalva, but as I moved into my forties, occasionally my blood pressure would be elevated and it made me nervous to do the procedure because it was my understanding that it spikes your blood pressure when you do it. So I began going to the ER to have the rhythm converted, which they do quite easily with adenosine. On one of my infrequent runs to the ER to get a bout of PSVT converted, they discovered my blood glucose was 500 mg/dL, and I’d never experienced any symptoms! They put me in the hospital and gave me a shot of insulin, got it town to 80 mg/dL easily,
diagnosed me as diabetic, and put me on 500 mg. metformin a day.

I was able to get my A1c down to 7, then down to 6.6, and about that time I read a number of Dr. Agatston’s books, and began following the diet, and pretty quickly got my A1c down to 6.2, and my weight down, easily, to 158. That was fine with my doctor; he acted as though I was in good shape with those numbers. Soon I ran into Dr. Bernstein’s material, and came face to face with a body of research that suggested I needed to get the A1c down to below 5! That was both discouraging and inspiring, and frankly it’s been difficult for me to eat as lo-carb as I appear to need to, so I swing back and forth between 6.2 and 6.6. I know I need to work harder, be more diligent in my carb control, and I see with my meter that if I eat low-carb I have great postprandial and fasting blood sugars, but since I don’t particularly get any support or encouragement from
either my doctor or my wife for being so “radical,” it’s hard to pass the carbs by.

One thing that always confused me was that though I saw on my meter that BG [blood glucose] readings were better with a lo-carb diet, and though I saw the preliminary research suggesting that lo-carb could be beneficial in controlling CVD, I didn’t understand why Ornish had peer-reviewed research demonstrating reversal of atherosclerosis on a very-lowfat diet. How could two opposing approaches both help? I wondered if it were possible that one diet is good for diabetes, and the
other good for heart health. That would mean diabetics are screwed, because they always seem to end up with heart disease.

From time to time I’d look for material that explained this seeming contradiction. I was determined to try to stay lo-carb, simply because I saw how much better my blood sugars are when I eat lo-carb; but it’s hard in the face of this or that website that tells you about all the dangers of a lo-carb diet and that touts the lo-fat approach. That tends to be the conventional wisdom anyway.

Finally in one of those searches I came across your material, and saw you offer what was at last an explanation of what Ornish had discovered--it wasn’t a reversal of atherosclerotic plaques he was seeing; it was that his diet was improving endothelial dysfunction in people who had had high fat intakes.

Odd as it may seem to you, that little factlet has been enough to allow me to discard entirely the lingering ghost of a suspicion that I ought to be eating very-lowfat. In fact, I was very excited to see your claim that your approach can reverse atherosclerotic plaque.

It would be nice to find a doctor who’d be supportive of your approach. My doctor isn’t much interested in diet or
nutrition. He just wants my weight in the acceptable range, my blood pressure good, and my LDL 100 or below (which I know isn’t low enough). He’s not particularly interested in getting a detailed lipid report. I hope I can talk him into ordering one so that it’s more likely I can get it covered by my insurance.

I very much appreciated the links you gave to Jenny’s diabetes websites, and I’ve resolved to get even better control of my BG by being more diligent with my diet. I’m planning on joining your site, reading your book, and following your advice. I just have this sort of deflating feeling that it would have been better if I’d stumbled upon this before I had diabetes. Still, it’s nice to have a site that offers to laypeople the best knowledge available concerning how to take care of their heart.



Mike is yet another "victim" of the "eat healthy whole grains" national insanity, the Post-Traumatic Grain Disorder, or PTGD. The low-fat dietary mistake has left many victims in its wake, having to deal with the aftermath of corrupt high-carbohydrate diets: diabetes, heart disease, and obesity.

We should all hope and pray that "low-fat, eat healthy whole grains" goes the way of Detroit gas guzzlers and sub-prime mortgages.

Drug industry "Deep Throat"

A Heart Scan Blog reader brought the following letter from a former pharmaceutical sales representative to congress to my attention.

Interesting excerpts:

As a former drug representative for Eli Lilly, I spent 20 months increasing the market share of my company’s drugs. I was recruited fresh from college with an eager desire to employ my degree in molecular biology and biochemistry. Shortly after my hiring, it became clearly apparent that a drug sale had much more to do with establishing personal relationships than it did with understanding the latest science. However, any doubts I held regarding the effectiveness of such methods were dispelled by the results of my persuasiveness and the financial rewards I received for my efforts. The latter also helped me rationalize the many ethically dubious situations I routinely encountered in my work. Upon my departure from the industry, I began working for the public’s health. Seven years later, as a result of my experiences and education I am more convinced than ever that the goals of the pharmaceutical industry often stand in direct conflict with the practice of ethical and responsible medicine. Nothing in my recent research causes me to believe that my experiences were anything but typical of the training and practice of the majority of drug reps plying their trade today.


“There’s a big bucket of money sitting in every [doctor’s] office.” – Michael Zubillaga, Astra Zeneca Regional Sales Director, Oncology


The majority of drug reps entering the work force today are young and attractive. The ranks of reps are replete with sexual icons: former cheerleaders, ex-military, models, athletes. Of course, as a sales job, the reps must be eloquent and convincing. Depending on the population, certain ethnicities are preferred either to make the rep distinct among other reps or to provide them with a cultural advantage in connecting with their clients. Noticeably lacking among most new reps is any significant scientific understanding. My personal case illustrates this point rather vividly: In my training class for Eli Lilly's elite neuroscience division, selling two products that constituted over 50% of the company's profits at the time, none of my 21 classmates nor our two trainers had any college level scientific education. In fact, that first day of training, I taught my class and my instructors the very basic but crucial process by which two nerve cells communicate with one another. It is very likely that the majority of my class couldn't explain the difference between a neuron and a neutron prior to sales school. While it's certainly a bonus to have a scientifically educated representative, it is far from a primary recruitment criterion. Youth is a much higher criterion for the sales position.

Sales representative trainers are almost always veteran sales representatives and consequently, much of the training they offer is implicit in the anecdotes they give. This informal training parallels the standard training offered by the industry and in many ways compliments it. It is tacitly accepted by management and perceived as the "real" training by many veteran sale representatives. Among the more dubious "unofficial" lessons a new rep learns are: how to manipulate an expense report to exceed the spending limit for important clients, how to use free samples to leverage sales, how to use friendship to foster an implied "quid pro quo" relationship, the importance of sexual tension, and how to maneuver yourself to becoming a necessity to an office or clinic.

The most troubling aspect of pharmaceutical sales is systematic befriending of our clients. In addition to the psychological profiling mentioned above, drug reps are taught to constantly be on the lookout for personal effects that will help us connect to our doctors. When entering an office for the first time, we nonchalantly survey it for clues to ingratiate ourselves with our client. Similarly, conversations are intentionally steered into the realm of personal details such as religion, family, or hobbies to acquire similar information. As a matter of training, we collect this data subtly. In the course of a conversation with clients, we may glean facts about their prescribing preferences, the dates of their children’s birthdays, where they were born, or what music they enjoy. Training encourages us to commit these details to memory just long enough to return to our cars and instantly type up a “call report” listing the details of our conversation. On a daily basis, we connect our computers to a central database that uploads the information we’ve acquired, allowing us to share it with our partner drug reps and company marketers. Subsequently, drug reps interweave pieces of conversation specifically tailored to appeal to their client drawn from personal information that wasn’t necessarily shared with them. For example, Dr. Jones will be nothing but grateful when I supply him with a cake celebrating his children’s birthday when, in fact, he told my partner (and not me) the birthdates several months prior in a personal conversation.


The writer's comments ring true: The relentless attention-grab of sales representatives, using clever tactics that include access to detailed records of physician prescribing habits, big smiles and eye-winking, are detailed perfectly.

There's nothing wrong with a business doing its job by marketing its products and services. What is so wrong about this picture is that one side is so well-equipped, heavily funded, with access to extraordinary resources that the other side (physicians) don't have. And the physicians aren't the victims--YOU are.

A middle-aged, receding hairline physician, faced with a 28-year old attractive woman asking all manner of ingratiating questions but knowing full well what she is doing, having strategized for weeks on how to manipulate the behavior of her "mark," is helpless.

Like the mortgage-backed security crisis, we've reached another phenomenon of crisis proportions. Direct-to-consumer drug advertising, drugs for non-conditions and well people, pinpoint marketing of drugs to physicians--it's all gone too far.

Personally, drug representatives are not welcome in my office. This generally prompts puzzled, followed by angry, looks from the representatives, often traveling with a district supervisor hoping to help polish their pitch. If patients didn't request free samples, the reps would not step foot in the office.

Triglyceride Buster-Update

In the last Heart Scan Blog post, I described Daniel's experience reducing his triglycerides from 3100 mg/dl to around 1100 mg/dl with use of omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil, along with modifications in his diet. This was accomplished in the space of around two weeks.

An update: Daniel has continued another 10 days on his fish oil, along with elimination of wheat, cornstarch, and sugars.

Repeat triglyceride: 202 mg/dl. That's 93.5% reduction in the space of three weeks--no drugs involved.

Daniel really did nothing extraordinary. He simply followed the simple advice I provided to take a moderate dose of EPA+DHA from over-the-counter fish oil supplements, along with elimination of the foods that are extravagant triggers of triglycerides.

He's got just a little further to go to achieve the biologically ideal level of less than 60 mg/dl. You can see that it is not really that difficult--provided someone didn't load you down with nonsense about "cutting your fat," or statin or fibrate drugs.

Triglyceride buster

Two weeks ago, Daniel started with a triglyceride level of 3100 mg/dl, a dangerous level that had potential to damage his pancreas. The inflammatory injury incurred could leave him with type I diabetes and inability to digest foods, since the insulin-producing capacity and the enzyme producing capacity of the pancreas are lost.

Daniel added 3600 mg of omega-3s per day. Within 10 days, his triglycerides dropped nearly 2000 mg to just over 1100 mg/dl--still too high, but an incredible start.

The power of omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil to reduce triglycerides is illustrated most graphically by people with a condition called "familial hypertriglyceridemia" that is responsible for triglyceride levels of 500, 1000, even several thousand milligrams. That's what Daniel has. Given appropriate doses of omega-3s, triglycerides drop hundreds, even thousands, of milligrams.

No question: Omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil are the best tool available for reduction of triglycerides. The effect is dose-dependent, i.e., the more you take, the greater the triglyceride reduction.

How omega-3s exerts this effect is unclear, though there is evidence to suggest that omega-3s suppress several nuclear receptors involved in triglyceride (VLDL) production and increase the expression or activity of the enzyme lipoprotein lipase, an enzyme that clears triglycerides from the blood.

I am continually surprised at the number of people with high triglycerides who are still treated with a fibrate drug, like Tricor, or a statin drug, when fish oil--widely available, essentially free of side-effects, with a proven cardiovascular risk-reducing track record--should clearly be the first choice by a long stretch.

Among its many benefits, omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil also:

Reduce matrix metalloproteinases (MMP)--Two fractions of MMPs, MMP-2 and MMP-9, are inflammatory enzymes present in atherosclerotic plaque that are suspected to trigger plaque "rupture." Omega-3s have been shown to reduce both forms of MMP.

Block uptake of lipids in the artery wall--Suggested by a study in mice.

Modify postprandial responses--In the first few hours after eating (the "postprandial" period), a flood of digestive byproducts of a meal are present in the bloodstream. While research exploring postprandial effects is still in its infancy, it is clear that omega-3 fatty acids have the capacity to favorably modify postprandial patterns. One common surrogate measure for postprandial abnormalities is intermediate-density lipoprotein, or IDL, that we obtain in fasting blood through lipoprotein panels like NMR and VAP. With sufficient omega-3s alone, IDL is completely eliminated.

Unfortunately, most of my colleagues, if they even think to use omega-3s, choose to use the prescription form, Lovaza. Indeed, several representatives from AstraZeneca, the pharmaceutical outfit now distributing this miserably overpriced product, frequently barge their way into my office poking fun at our use of nutritional supplements instead of the prescription Lovaza. "But insurance covers it in most cases!" they plead. "And your patients will know that they're getting the real product, not some fake. And they'll have to take fewer capsules!"

I never use Lovaza to reduce triglycerides, even in familial hypertriglyceridemia--the FDA-approved indication for Lovaza--and have not yet seen any failures, only successes.

Newsweek, Time, and other fronts for the drug industry

I used to believe that conventional print media--newspapers, magazines--were unbiased, untouchable flames of truth. Perhaps there was a time when this was true, when the young reporter, eager to change the world, uncovered the story that righted some huge wrong.

Those days are drawing to a close.

Today, the once powerful print media are collapsing due to the competition of the cheaper, broader reach of the internet.

Jogging does NOT cause heart disease


Periodically, I'll come across a knuckleheaded report like this one from Minneapolis:

Marathon Man’s Heart Damaged by Running?


Of course, the obligatory story about how a cardiologist came to the rescue and "saved his life" with a stent follows. In other words, a stent purportedly saved the life of this vigorous man with no symptoms and high capacity for exercise.

Does vigorous exercise, whether it's marathon running, long-distance biking, or triathlons, cause coronary disease? Should all vigorous athletes run to their doctor to see if they, too, need their lives to be "saved."

Let me tell you what's really going on here. People with the genetic pattern lipoprotein(a), or Lp(a), tend to be slender, intelligent and athletic. For genetic reasons, these people gravitate towards endurance sports like long-distance running. Lp(a) is a high-risk factor for coronary disease. It is the abnormality present in the majority of slender, healthy people who are shocked when they receive a high heart scan score or have a heart attack or receive a stent. (I call Lp(a) "the most aggressive known coronary risk factor that nobody's heard about.")

The association between endurance exercise and heart disease is just that: an association. It does not mean that exercise is causal. Having seen coronary plaque detected with heart scans in many runners, virtually all of whom demonstrated increased Lp(a), I believe that Lp(a) is causal.

Unfortunately, the man in the Minneapolis story, now that his life is "saved," will likely be advised to take a statin drug and follow a low-fat diet . . . you know, the diet that increases Lp(a).

Warning: Your pharmacist may be hazardous to your health

Pharmacists can be very helpful resources when it comes to questions about prescription drugs.

The operant word here is drugs.

What they are most definitely not expert on are nutritional supplements. In fact, a day doesn't pass by without having to dispell one falsehood or another conveyed to a patient about a nutritional supplement by a pharmacist.

Among the more common falsehoods told to patients by pharmacists:

"You have to take Niaspan. Sloniacin doesn't work."

Patent nonsense. A few years back, I was the largest prescriber of Niaspan in Wisconsin. Although I am embarassed to admit it, I also spoke for the company, educating fellow physicians on the value of niacin for correction of lipid disorders.

Then I shifted to Sloniacin due to cost--it costs 1/20th the cost of prescription Niaspan. I examined the pharmacokinetic data (pattern of release in the body), the published literature (e.g., the famous HATS Trial), and have used Sloniacin over 1000 times in patients. In my experience, there is no difference: no difference in efficacy, no difference in safety, no difference in side-effects. There is a BIG difference in price.

Unfortunately, most pharmacists get their information on niacin from the Niaspan representative.


"You shouldn't be taking vitamin D supplements. I have prescription vitamin D here."

What the pharmacist means is that you should replace your vitamin D3, or cholecalciferol--the form recognized as vitamin D by the human body--with the plant form of vitamin D, vitamin D2 or ergocalciferol.

Since when is a plant form of a hormone (vitamin D is a potent hormone, not a vitamin; it was misnamed) better than the human form?

I've previously talked about this issue in a blog post called Vitamin D for the pharmaceutically challenged.

The notion that D2 is somehow superior to the real thing, D3, is absurd. I use D3 only in my practice and have checked blood levels thousands of times. As long as the D3 comes as a gelcap, drops, or powder in a capsule, it works great, yielding predictable and substantial increases in blood levels of 25-hydroxy vitamin D. If it comes as prescription D2 (or over-the-counter D2), I have seen many failures: no increase in blood levels of vitamin D or meager increases.

Prescription status is no guarantee of effectiveness.


"Why do you need iodine? You already get enough from food."

The NHANES data over the last 25 years argue otherwise: Iodine deficiency is growing, particularly as people are avoiding iodized salt and the iodine content of processed foods is diminishing. The explosion in goiters in my office also suggest this is no longer a settled issue.

On the positive side, it is exceptionally easy to remedy with an inexpensive iodine supplement. That is, until the pharmacist intervenes and injects his bit of nutritional mis-information.


I'm not bashing pharmacists. In fact, Track Your Plaque's own Dr. BG has a pharmacy background, and she is an absolute genius with nutritonal supplements. But she is a rare exception to the rule: Most pharmacists know virtually nothing about nutritional supplements. You might as well ask your hairdresser.

"Healthy" people are the most iodine deficient

Ironically, the healthiest people are the most likely to be deficient in iodine.

Why?

Healthy people tend to:

--Avoid iodized salt because of public health advice to limit sodium
--Use sea salt to obtain minerals like magnesium--but sea salt contains little iodine
--Limit meat--Carnivores obtain more iodine than vegetarians or vegans. In one study, up to 80% of vegans were iodine-deficient (Krajcovicova-Kudlackova M et al 2003).
--Exercise--Substantial amounts of iodine are lost through sweating. In a study of high school soccer players, 38.5% were severely iodine deficient, compared to 2% of sedentary students (Mao IF et al 2001).


That is indeed what I am seeing in my office, as well: The healthiest, most attentive to healthy eating, and most physically active are the ones showing up with small goiters (enlarged thyroid glands) and increased TSH and low free T4 levels.

Why am I checking thyroid and talking about iodine? Because even the smallest degree of thyroid dysfunction can double, triple, or quadruple your risk for cardiovascular events. See the posts Is normal TSH too high? and Thyroid perspective update.

What kind of iodine do you take?

The results of the latest Heart Scan Blog poll are in.

204 respondents answered the question:


Do you take an iodine supplement?

The responses:

Yes, I take Iodoral, Lugol's, or SSKI
26 (12%)

Yes, I take potassium or sodium iodide
19 (9%)

Yes, I take kelp tablets or powder
64 (31%)

No, I rely on generous use of iodized salt
23 (11%)

No, I don't supplement iodine at all
66 (32%)

Isn't iodine something you put on cuts and scratches?
6 (2%)


I am heartened by the number of respondents taking iodine in some form. After all, iodine is an essential trace mineral. Without it and health suffers, often dramatically.

However, I am concerned by the percentage of people who don't supplement iodine at all: 32%. Interestingly, this is approximately the proportion of people who come to my office who also do not supplement iodine who are now showing goiters, or enlarged thyroid glands due to iodine deficiency. Goiters lead to hypothyroidism (low thyroid hormone levels), followed by hyperactive nodules, not to mention undesirable effects like weight gain, fatigue, hair loss, constipation, intolerance to cold, higher LDL cholesterol and triglycerides, and heart disease.

11% of respondents report using lots of iodized salt. This may or may not be sufficient to provide enough iodine to prevent goiter and allow normal thyroid function. The success of this strategy depends to a great extent on how often salt is purchased. Salt that sits on the shelf for more than a month is devoid of iodine, given iodine's volatility.

I am also favorably impressed by the number of people who take "serious" iodine supplements like Lugol's solution, Iodoral, or SSKI. Of course, people who read The Heart Scan Blog tend to be an unusually informed, healthy population. The 12% of people in the poll who take these forms of iodine does clearly not mean that 12% of the general population also takes them. But 12% is more than I would have predicted.

On the Track Your Plaque website, we are awaiting an interview with iodine expert, Dr. Lyn Patrick. I'm hoping for some juicy insights.