Healthy smoothies

I've now seen several people who have either caused themselves to be diabetic or to have other phenomena associated with excessive consumption of carbohydrates, all by innocently indulging in a carbohydrate-packed smoothie every morning.

Kay, for instance, has a smoothie of a half-pint blueberries, a banana, a scoop of whey, low-fat yogurt, a cup of milk every morning. The rest of her diet was fairly healthy: salads with oil-based dressing for lunch, salmon and asparagus for dinner, only an occasional carbohydrate indulgence outside of her morning smoothie ritual. Yet she had a HbA1c (a reflection of prior 60 to 90 days average blood sugar) at the near-diabetic range of 5.9%.

The mistake most people make when making smoothies is relying too heavily on carbohydrates like fruit. A smoothie like the one made by Kay can easily top 50, 60, or 70 grams carbohydrates per serving, more than sufficient to send blood sugars up to 150 mg/dl or more.

So what can you put in your smoothie and not send you over the edge to diabetes, small LDL, and all the other undesirable phenomena of excessive carbohydrates? Here's a list:

--coconut milk, unsweetened almond milk. Less desirable: milk, full-fat soymilk
--ground flaxseed
--oils: flaxseed oil, coconut oil (melted), extra-light olive oil, walnut oil
--dried coconut
--extracts: vanilla, almond, coconut, cherry, hazelnut
--spices: cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger
--herbs: mint leaves, cilantro
--cocoa powder (unsweetened)
--nut or seed butters (peanut butter, almond butter, sunflower seed butter)
--tofu
--exotic ingredients (ingredients you wouldn't expect in a smoothie): spinach, kale, cucumber

How do you sweeten a smoothie? This is what trips up most people. If you resort to fruit like bananas, pineapple, or apple, you will readily send your blood sugar skyward. Honey, agave syrup, and sugar, of course, all increase blood sugar and/or have the adverse effects of fructose. Be careful of yogurt, also, for similar reasons.

Therefore, to sweeten your smoothie, consider:

--Small servings of berries, e.g., 8-10 blueberries, 2 strawberries, a few wedges of apple, half a kiwi
--Non-nutritive sweeteners like stevia, Truvia, sucralose, xylitol, erythritol. Also, sugar-free (sucralose-based) syrups like those from DaVinci and Torani are useful. (Just be aware that non-nutritive sweeteners can increase appetite--use sparingly.)

Also, note that, if you have divorced yourself from wheat, cornstarch, and sugars, your desire for sweet should be much reduced. Foods other people find just right will taste sickeningly sweet to you. You might therefore find that foods like peanut butter or coconut milk have a mild natural sweetness; added sweetness is only minimally necessary.

Coming next: I'll share a smoothie recipe or two of mine. Anyone want to share a recipe?

Comments (51) -

  • Vladimir

    3/15/2011 2:34:37 AM |

    2 cups almond milk
    1 Tablespoon Flax Oil
    Cinnamon, Nutmeg
    Broccoli Sprouts or Microgreens (from Trader Joes)
    Kale (half a bunch)
    Spinach or Chard (half a bunch)
    A small bit of watercress
    Mint
    Basil
    2 Avacados

    It makes 6-8 cups, and I drink it over two days.
    1 packet Truvia
    A handful of blueberries
    Occasionally, a scoop of unsweetened cocoa powder, a few pieces of celery, or a cucumber.

  • john

    3/15/2011 2:46:05 AM |

    1 cup of unsweetened So Delicious coconut milk, 4 pastured omega 3 raw eggs, Nutiva coconut manna (large tablespoon) 1/4 cup of raw heavy cream, 1/4 cup of raw unsulphured coconut flakes and 1/4 of Navitas 100% cacoa nibs with cinnamon, nutmeg, one packet of stevia with inulin, and one teaspoon of 100% cacoa powder, Maca powder and Chia powder.....all blended with ice to make a daquari like breakfast drink.  The carb level is below 10 gms and it is loaded with protein and MCT.  Total Paleo smoothie to start a day.

  • Patty

    3/15/2011 2:47:56 AM |

    With all due respect, I'll never understand the need for smoothies as long as there are eggs. Smile

  • Anonymous

    3/15/2011 3:16:29 AM |

    KEFIR!!

  • Charles R.

    3/15/2011 5:05:55 AM |

    Coconut milk and avocado, sweetened with Truvia and/or a few blueberries.

    I have to try Vladimir's recipe though. I've never done the green thing...

  • Onschedule

    3/15/2011 5:12:50 AM |

    @Patty

    Eggs for me too, please!

  • Nigel Kinbrum

    3/15/2011 7:51:06 AM |

    I still have all of my teeth. I prefer to eat my food, not drink it.

    Smoothies (and milk) are ideal for babies and people who can't chew.

  • Anonymous

    3/15/2011 11:01:03 AM |

    Once I gave up artificial sweeteners in additon to added sugars, my sense of sweet changed dramatically.  A lot of foods I used to love are now sickeningly sweet.

    It took me months to adjust to my new taste buds, and initially, I was not thrilled about theh change.  However, it did remove the need for virtue to avoid sweets.

  • Chuck

    3/15/2011 12:36:56 PM |

    i am curious what the blood glucose response to fruit would be in the presence of a fat like fish oil or coconut milk?  doesn't fat blunt this process?

  • Anne

    3/15/2011 12:44:33 PM |

    4 raw eggs (from organically reared and free range hens certified salmonella free) and a few berries all whisked up - simple and yum.

  • Kurt

    3/15/2011 1:14:52 PM |

    I've cut way back on the fruit in my smoothie, and replaced some with a stalk of celery, which gives it a fresh taste.

  • Davide Palmer

    3/15/2011 2:03:45 PM |

    I think it is safe to say that diabetics should generously include blueberries in their diets. Blueberries actually may increase insulin sensitivity, lower blood glucose, triglycerides and abdominal fat.

    http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/04/090419170112.htm

  • nybean

    3/15/2011 5:57:47 PM |

    here's a couple of my favorite smoothies.

    Hemp-Whey smoothie
    1 scoop unsweetened whey powder (vanilla or chocolate)
    1 scoop Hemp protein powder
    1/4 c. coconut milk
    1 packet stevia sweetener
    4 oz unsweetened keifer
    8 oz hemp milk.
    Options - add a few blueberries, or almond extract, or cocoa powder, or grated unsweetened coconut

    Green Smoothie
    8 oz V8 or other veggie drink
    juice from 1 lemon
    1-2 inch fresh ginger, sliced
    1-2 cloves garlic
    1 tsp turmeric
    3 ribs celery, coarsely chopped
    1 cup fresh baby spinach
    1/2 cup fresh parsley
    1/2 green pepper
    1/2 avocado
    1 T flax oil or 1 scoop hemp protein

  • Dan

    3/15/2011 6:11:24 PM |

    Does anyone have any cookbook or recipe website recommendations for what ingredients I should eat? I've cut way back on sugar and carbs and have lost some weight. I'd like to take things to the next level, but I'm really struggling with finding recipes, especially with a variety of ingredients. I feel like eggs and veggies are the only foods "allowed". Thanks in advance for any help.

  • Stephen

    3/15/2011 6:15:56 PM |

    Very nice topic.  While I minimize these for myself I make one for my 2.5 year old.  I has to many carbohydrates but the trade is to get some nutrients he would otherwise not get.

    This morning was 1/2 Banana, Coconut water 2tbs, 1tbs raw cocoa powder, Almond butter 1tsp, 1 egg from a local farm, heavy raw cream 1/4 avocado, 1 cup raw spinach.

    This is generally consumed by him over a full day so the overall impact is lower.

  • Anonymous

    3/15/2011 9:48:12 PM |

    Right on Patty! Eggs rule.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/15/2011 10:07:05 PM |

    Wow! Great ideas.

    I, too, prefer whole foods. But many people like the idea of making a smoothie and consuming it on the run, so I try to help them make healthier alternatives.

    Smoothies can be a delicious indulgence on occasion, too. My favorite is to combine unsweetened cocoa powder with peanut butter, along with unsweetened almond milk and some coconut milk. A little sweetener is required due to the bitterness of the cocoa. It tastes like a Reeses peanut butter cup.

  • Laura

    3/15/2011 11:39:31 PM |

    I am a long time reader of this AWESOME blog - thanks Dr. Davis for all your time and effort. Thanks also to all that comment - I read every single one.

    As Dr. Davis said, some excellent ideas here. I myself love a couple of eggs for breakfast but when the weather warms up I like doing a smoothie instead. Mine includes:

    4 cups or so leafy greens (organic baby spinach, kale, dandelion, collards etc)
    1/2 can coconut milk
    2 Tbsp coconut oil
    2 eggs (raw)
    a handful of frozen berries (maybe 1/4 cup)
    a drop of vitamin K2

    You can add darn near anything to this (fish oil, cod liver oil, other powdered or liquid supplements). It looks green but the taste is not objectionable. It is not sweet but the handful of berries makes it palatable without overloading the carbohydrates. I have tested my blood sugar after drinking this and most often even after only 1 hour, a nice even 78. I drink the whole thing for breakfast M-F and it fills me up until early afternoon. It also gives me a great sense of satiety that I don't get with anything else - I just feel good!

    For people who like having a smoothie/shake I really encourage you to add some leafy greens. I think the best one to start with would be organic baby spinach. It is very mild and an excellent way to add some to your diet.

  • Lori Miller

    3/16/2011 12:01:33 AM |

    I've started making eggnog (sugar-free and alcohol-free, of course) for breakfast. I throw in my vitamins, too. I've choked on pills before, so this is a good way to take them.

    @Davide, the study you refer to is a rat study funded by people who sell blueberries. The article doesn't say what the rest of the diet was, but if it was low-nutrient pseudo-food that's sometimes used in rat studies, adding back pretty my anything with nutrients would have improved the rats' health. In real life, eating a bunch of fruit raises your blood sugar if you're diabetic.

  • Lori Miller

    3/16/2011 12:02:55 AM |

    Oops--make that "pretty much anything."

  • Ari

    3/16/2011 1:57:39 AM |

    Hey, Doc.

    Blueberries are supposedly extremely healthful.

    You wrote something about 8-10 blueberries to put into a smoothie.  Is that the amount one should eat to get full advantage of their healthful properties without the disadvantages of their sugar?

    Can one eat more if combined with other low glycemic foods that will presumably blunt the effects of the sugar?

    Thanks.

  • Ari

    3/16/2011 2:00:41 AM |

    Doc,
    You wrote in a comment:

    "A little sweetener is required due to the bitterness of the cocoa. It tastes like a Reeses peanut butter cup."

    Sounds good.  What sweetener do you recommend?

    Thanks

  • Christin Shacat

    3/16/2011 2:35:59 AM |

    I've been diagnozed with pre-diabetes (fasting glucose: 105mg/dl, HGB A1C 5.8%) last July and have since then been trying to lose weight and change my diet. Luckily, my lipid panel seems ok (Chol 160mg/dl, triglyc 107mg/dl, HDL 60mg/dl, VLDL 21mg/dl, LDL 79mg/dl). However, I have been having a hard time finding low GI foods/snacks that will let me life within a 1600 cal/day diet to maintain sufficient cal deficit for weight loss of ~1-1.5 lbs/week.

    Here is the smoothie I have been making, not for breakfast, but rather for post-gym recovery and "dinner-dimmer" to avoid binging.

    1/4c frozen blueberries

    1c unsweetened vanilla almond milk

    1t ground chia seeds

    1t glutamine

    1sc whey protein powder (Jillien Michel's)

    1/2 banana

    1-2c spinach



    Fairly satisfying and pretty yummy!

  • Anonymous

    3/16/2011 5:46:48 AM |

    Is a smoothie made with fruit that bad for you if you exercise on a regular basis. ie. 1 hour a day fairly intense workout. Won't all the carbs be "used up".  My smoothie
    All organic ingredients
    eggs
    spinach
    coconut milk
    chia seeds
    cinnamon
    blueberries
    bannana

  • Gillian

    3/16/2011 11:53:44 AM |

    Dr Davis
    How can peanut butter be good.
    Think about the lectins.

    "The far bigger concern, however, is that peanuts contain lectins which are believed to have inflammatory and atherogenic potential.  Most plants contain lectins, some of which are toxic, inflammatory, or both. Many of these lectins are resistant to cooking and to digestive enzymes, and some have been scientifically shown to have significant GI toxicity in humans. Lectins from grains (especially wheat) and legumes (including peanuts and soybeans) are most commonly associated with aggravation of inflammatory and digestive diseases in the body. (As an aside, dairy from cows fed grain-based diets can also contain these grain-derived lectins.)

    Recent research by Dr. Cordain has suggested that these lectins may effectively serve as a “Trojan horse” allowing foreign proteins to invade our natural gut defenses. Cordain reports, “An experiment conducted by Dr. Wang and colleagues and published in the prestigious medical journal Lancet revealed that PNA got into the bloodstream intact in as little 1-4 hours after subjects ate a handful of roasted, salted peanuts.” (Unfortunately, the abstract of this study is not available without a subscription.) The lectins can cause damage well beyond the gut – commonly in joints, brain, and skin of affected individuals. Continued exposure of the gut by these toxins leads to a persistent stimulation of the body’s defense mechanism in a dysfunctional manner, i.e. autoimmune disease. (Allergies fall into that category as well.)" from Dr Loren Cordains Paleo Diet

  • Anonymous

    3/16/2011 1:11:19 PM |

    8 oz. unsweetened silk almond milk
    1/2 avocado
    1 teaspoon cinnamon
    handful of 10% unsweetened cocao
    2-4 oz. blueberries or 2 whole strawberries.

  • Anonymous

    3/16/2011 1:14:34 PM |

    previous comment mistake.

    make that handful 100% unsweetened cocao, not 10% unsweetened cocao.

  • kris

    3/16/2011 2:15:19 PM |

    whey powder
    coconut milk
    cocoa powder
    stevia
    vanilla seltzer (Polar)
    few ice cubes
    Opt: raw egg

  • andrea

    3/16/2011 2:38:23 PM |

    Nutty Monkey
    unflavored or vanilla whey powder of your choice
    1/2C coconut milk
    1/2C unsweetened almond milk
    spoonful almond butter
    1t banana flavor
    1/2t coconut flavor
    1/2t vanilla
    as much ice as you do or don't want

  • Anonymous

    3/16/2011 3:07:07 PM |

    Peanuts to my knowledge are extremely unhealthy due to lectins

  • Patty

    3/16/2011 4:26:21 PM |

    I always use home made kefir fermented 24 to 48 hours room temp and another few days in fridge to get rid of almost all the sugar.  My favorite smoothie:
    12 oz kefir (from raw milk)
    1 egg (yes raw but only from one local farmer)
    1 1/2 tablespoonsful cocoa powder
    1/2 avocado when I have
    1/2 tsp glucomannan powder
    and whatever else I feel like throwing in including left over veggies.
    Because my kefir is so sour, I do use stevia to sweeten.

  • Patty

    3/16/2011 4:33:51 PM |

    I hope you don't mind if I take issue with a few things:  Lots of recent information on artificial sweeteners increasing risk of heart attack and stroke.  There are lots of other problems with sucralose and aspartame too.  Peanuts are virtually all contaminated with a mold toxin called aflatoxin and should be avoided.  Extra light olive oil has been heavily processed, often with chemicals and is more toxic than healthy.  I'm hoping you meant extra virgin olive oil?

  • Anonymous

    3/16/2011 6:02:52 PM |

    One odd comment by Dr. Davis seems to be the low amount of blueberries.

    Most berries don't contain that much fructose, and blueberries (anthocyanins) have health benefits on their own. Even for lipid numbers --
    http://inhumanexperiment.blogspot.com/2009/08/anthocyanins-from-berries-increase-hdl.html


    I don't think 5g of sugar from half a cup of berries will put someone over the edge, if taken with fiber and/or protein. I have also read that blueberries will actually lower one's serum glucose levels.

    And did you mean extra-virgin olive oil?

  • kris

    3/16/2011 6:14:11 PM |

    i also do the egg-nog thing:

    raw eggs
    cream or coconut milk
    vanilla extract
    stevia
    freshly grated nutmeg on top

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/16/2011 7:22:20 PM |

    Continued great ideas!

    Ari--

    While there are individual differences, 8-10 blueberries will just stay below the threshold of most people's tolerance before boosting blood glucose. (It can vary, depending on what else you eat with it, time of day, your weight and state of insulin sensitivity, etc.)

    I prefer stevia. Xylitol and erythritol are other excellent choices, provided you watch out for appetite stimulation.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/16/2011 7:24:38 PM |

    Comments about peanuts--

    I know of those data. I'm just not sure about how genuine those concerns are.

    While I love Cordain's work and I have read the few studies on this question, I am not convinced that anything but habitual and substantial exposure has any adverse effect. In other words, if I have a tablespoon of peanut butter once or twice a week, does that really have adverse effects?

    There are indeed foods that can exert undesirable health effects in such small doses. I'm not convinced that peanuts are among them.

  • Gene K

    3/16/2011 7:24:49 PM |

    Dr Davis once mentioned that a level handful of berries is all you can eat in one day. I still love my cup of dark berries (from a Three Berries bag from Costco) every night on top of the handful, which I eat with almond milk and flaxseed in the morning. Given that I don't eat other carbs or dairy, I wonder whether this is why my Hemo A1c is now 5.7, which is high for a non-diabetic.

  • Ari

    3/16/2011 8:35:38 PM |

    Doc,
    Is heavy cream a good ingredient for a smoothie?  Being unable to find any coconut milk with kosher certification, I figured that heavy cream sounded tasty.

    I figured if it's milk fat rather than lactose, the insulin increase might be small.

    Any thoughts?

  • Anonymous

    3/16/2011 8:47:41 PM |

    Large handful spinach
    half avocado
    2 cups water
    2 packets sun crystals (2g sugar total)

  • Anonymous

    3/18/2011 1:51:19 AM |

    For those of you that use greens, what type of blender do you use?  Will a standard type blender work, or do you have a Vitamix?

    Teresa

  • Anonymous

    3/18/2011 2:04:50 AM |

    1/3 cup frozen blueberries
    2 tbs flaxseed
    1/3 cup 2% plain yogurt (homemade)
    1.5 cups spinach
    1/3 avocado
    1/3 cup coconut milk
    1.5 scoops Optimum Nutrition  Gold Standard Whey
    enough water to blend
      416 calories
      35 g protein
      24 g carbs (10 g sugar, 5.3 grams fiber)
      24 grams fat (2.5 omega-3)

  • Anonymous

    3/18/2011 5:58:15 PM |

    Insulinotropic Properties of Dairy Protein.


    Milk consumption modifies the insulinemic and glycemic response to carbohydrate-rich food in both type II diabetic and healthy subjects [42]. A population-based prospective study (CARDIA) revealed that dairy consumption was inversely associated with the incidence of all components of the insulin resistance syndrome (IRS) among overweight individuals (BMI>=25kg/m2). Each daily occasion of dairy consumption was associated with 21% lower odds of IRS. These associations were similar for blacks and whites and for men and women [43]. Of the milk proteins, whey leads to higher pre-meal insulin concentrations than casein [44] and may contain the predominant insulin secretagogue because the insulin area under the curve (AUC) after preloads of 25 g carbohydrate with 18.2 g of whey protein was 50% higher than after milk or cheese [42]. Addition of whey to a meal containing rapidly digested and absorbed carbohydrates, stimulated greater plasma insulin concentrations (+57% after lunch) and reduced postprandial blood glucose (–21% at 120 min AUC) in type II diabetic subjects [45]. Amino acids may be the primary factor accounting for the insulinotropic effect of whey protein. Healthy subjects that ingested mixture of leucine, isoleucine, valine,lysine and threonine resulted in glycemic and insulinemic responses similar to those after whey ingestion [46] suggesting that branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs) are the major determinants of insulinemia as well as lowered glycemia caused by the whey drink. However the BCAA mixture did not stimulate incretin (GIP and GLP-1) response while the whey drink did suggesting that the action of whey is not simply related to amino acid content and presumably due to the action of peptides. The authors concluded that whey-induced hyperinsulinemia occurs by two or even more separate pathways, one connected to the significant increment in certain amino acids but the other connected through the incretins, which are believed to interact with bioactive peptides derived from proteins [46].

  • Anonymous

    3/18/2011 6:10:38 PM |

    Continuation...
    My understanding of the research paper segment I posted above (google for source if curious) is that:
    1- yes, milk increases insulin production, confirming the blog starting premise
    BUT
    2- opposing the blog unproven conclusion that does NOT lead to diabetes, on the contrary:

    A population-based prospective study (CARDIA) revealed that dairy consumption was inversely associated with the incidence of all components of the insulin resistance syndrome (IRS) among overweight individuals (BMI>=25kg/m2). Each daily occasion of dairy consumption was associated with 21% lower odds of IRS. These associations were similar for blacks and whites and for men and women [43]. O

  • Gillian

    3/18/2011 6:38:54 PM |

    Dr Davis
    Can it be healthy to eat sunflower seed butter(with a lot Omega 6)
    extra light olive oil(that is refined) and Soymilk (we all know that it is unhealthy)

    Read opinions from Weston-Price Foundation about Soy.


    Happy if when giving advice about recipe tell us that some of the ingredients can we
    only eat once or twice a week.

    I allways read your blog and have liked it very much.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/20/2011 12:26:55 AM |

    Hi Annonymous,
    I am following your comments here and from an earlier posting I believe. Well, am trying to organize some ideas; basicly thinking out loud here. At this point I am not dealing with the diabetic individual's response or diabetic case management.

    Some comparative charts I've seen tracking levels of both insulin and blood glucose simultaneously over a few hours come to mind. The initial "spike" in insulin was followed by lesser "flush" of insulin many (not a few, nor several) minutes later, and again a mini "blip" or two  farther along in time. While the blood glucose, for it's part, did not follow a linear rise and linear decline either.

    If my memory serves the two factors (insulin increases and blood sugar waves)did not coincide in a proportionate overlay pattern . There was an initial relationship seemingly involving insulin and blood sugar showing up to be seen, as we expect in first meal of the day.

    Bloggers seem to propose the  hormone insulin activates in response to blood sugar, "drives" (or tries to drive) glucose into cells and then both go back to discrete levels (if there is no metabolic syndrome). In other words it's unexplicitly
    represented as a one step, two step, bow out until next time eat and go back to some baseline.

    Studies charting one and not the other give an incongruous picture; the two (insulin and blood glucose) don't seem to dance just with respect to each other. I think this is what you found with the insulin raising properties of dairy/whey having an inverse (reducing) effect in living humans of insulin resistance.

    If you have any insight into the signaling role of the hormone insulin I'd like to hear it. Maybe you'd post it back over on the recent thread where Doc showed the insulin response chart. The topic here is "smoothies".

  • Anonymous

    3/21/2011 10:24:53 PM |

    You are right about the misplacememt of my earlier posts - they are not about smoothies but whether dairy is bad or good, the topic of the previous blog.  I've reposted there as well, but here is the summary:

    According to research (CARDIA cited above), and regardless of insulin/glucose curves,  DAIRY LOWERS YOUR RISK OF DIABETES.  The more daily servings, the lower the risk.

    If you disagree please present support information. This matters to us all who read this type of blog and care for what we eat.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/22/2011 2:28:33 AM |

    test - had problems posting

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/22/2011 2:50:50 AM |

    Again Annon.,
    My thinking is that the factor in dairy responsible for what your study found is Insulin-like Growth Factor (IGF); not insulin.
    IGF, a hormone acting protein, has hypo-glycaemin effect; it lowers blood sugar. IGF also improves kidney function, engenders nitrogen balance and decreases cholesterol.

    IGF I & II are found in cow's milk, but not in whey. The % of IGF content varies with phase of lactation the cow is experiencing.

    IGF I in human milk ranges from 1.5 to 19.0 ng/mL -1; at different post natal stages. IGF II in human milk ranges from 2.7 to 35.0 ng/mL -1; at different post natal stages.

    IGF I in cow milk ranges from 2.0to 101.0 ng/mL -1; while IGF II
    ranges from 2.0 to107.0 ng/mL -1 at different lactation stages. So my suggestion is to look at dairy's IGF to explain the benefit you allude to.

    IGF BP2 (insulin-like growth factor binding protein 2) is an
    "anti-diabetic" protein; and when upregulated it modulates any acute hypo-glycemic
    action of IGF.

    I post this here because your last post on "insulin secretagogue" was brief.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/23/2011 1:58:17 AM |

    Might-o'chondri-AL--

    My apologies in the difficulties you are encountering posting comments.

    I found several of your comments in the "spam" device set up by Blogger. Once I recognized your insightful commentary and name, I de-spammed them.

    I suspect that the Blogger/Google people have expanded their reach for potential spam. Unfortunately, it can mean that meaningful commentary like yours gets mislabeled.

  • Greg

    6/15/2011 3:15:39 PM |

    I'm late to the party, but I want to offer (as others have) that ripe avocados make for an incredible smoothie ingredient.  I recently made one comprised of the following simple ingredients: ice, avocado, heavy cream, sugar-free Torani syrup (vanilla).  It was spectacular, and I'm sure that it is easy to adapt and vary it according to personal tastes.

  • jpatti

    5/28/2012 9:44:44 PM |

    Some practical info... if you put melted coconut oil in  smoothie, then add a bunch of cold ingredients, you wind up with chunks of frozen coconut oil all over the place.

    Instead, add the melted coconut oil to a pastured egg and blend to emulsify.  Now when you add the berries or peaches and milk and such, the coconut oil will stay smooth within your smoothie, which is supposed to be a SMOOTHIE, not a CHUNKY.  ;)

    My favorite ingredients besides eggs and coconut oil (which are the basis of all my smoothies, having given up on all protein powders in favor of pastured eggs) are leftover cold coffee, cocoa, raw milk, cream, frozen blueberries (1/2 cup), frozen other berries (full cup), shredded dried coconut, nut butters, stevia to taste - not all at once.  Sometimes, I like a mocha/coffee smoothie, sometimes a fruit smoothie, sometimes a nut butter/chocolate smoothie (can do a "nutella" flavored one or an "almond joy" flavored one).  

    Sometimes, I change the flavors up with DaVinci sugarfree syrups, but honestly, I don't consider that "health food".  I've never noticed a reaction to sucralose, but feel it is generally safer to use stevia if one has bg issues, and small amounts of maple syrup or molasses if one does not (they taste too strong to overdo like white sugar).

Loading

Blood sugar lessons from a Type I diabetic

A friend of mine is a Type I, or childhood onset, diabetic. He's had it for nearly 50 years, since age 6. He's also in the health industry and is a good observer of detail.

He made the following interesting comments to me recently when talking about the effects of various foods on blood sugar:

"When I eat normally, like some vegetables or salad and meat, I dose up to 10 units of insulin to control my blood sugar.

"If I eat a turkey sandwich on two slices of whole wheat, I usually dose 15 units. The bread makes my blood sugar go to 300 if I don't.

"If I eat a Cousins's Sub [a local submarine sandwich chain], I dose 15 units. The bread really makes my blood sugar go up.

"I can only eat a Quarter Pound from McDonald's once a year, because it make my blood sugar go nuts. I dose 15-20 units before having it, and I feel like crap for two days afterwards.

"If I eat Mexican food, I have to dose 15-20 units. For some reason, it's gotten worse over the years, and I need to dose higher and higher.

"Chinese food is the absolute worst. I dose 20-25 units before eating Chinese. I'll often have to dose more afterwards, because my blood sugar goes so berserk."


Nothing beats the real-world observations on the impact of various foods on blood sugar than the observations of people with Type I diabetes. All the insulin they get is in a syringe. Dosing needs to match intake.

Personally, though I love the taste of Americanized Chinese food, I've always been suspicious of what exactly goes into these dishes. But I was unaware of the blood sugar implications.

The impact of Mexican I believe can be attributed to the cornstarch used in the tacos and tortillas, though I also wonder if there are other starches being snuck in, as well.

Lessons about omega-3s from Japan















Image courtesy of apc33.

Japan provides a useful "laboratory" for studying the effect of a culture that relies heavily on eating fish.

The JELIS Trial, the topic of a previous Heart Scan Blog post, showed that supplementation with the single omega-3 fatty acid, EPA, 1800 mg per day (the equivalent of 10 capsules of 'standard' fish oil that contains 180 mg per day of EPA, 120 mg of DHA) significantly reduced heart attack in a Japanese population. Interestingly, this benefit was additive to the already substantial intake of omega-3 fatty acids among the general Japanese population, a population with a fraction of the heart attacks found in western populations like the U.S. (approximately 3% over 5 years in Japanese compared to several-fold higher in a comparable American group).

While there may be genetic and other cultural and lifestyle reasons behind the dramatically reduced cardiovascular risk in Japanese, it is undeniably at least partially due to the increased intake of omega-3 fatty acids from fish. Incidentally, the purported benefits of omega-3 fatty acids provide a vigorous counter-argument to the idea that all humans should be vegetarians.

Anyway, if we were to take some lessons from the Japanese and their greater habitual intake of omega-3 fatty acids from fish, they might include:

--Rural and coastal Japanese are the sub-populations with the highest reliance on fish, about a quarter-pound a day. (Gives new meaning to the idea of a "Quarter Pounder," doesn't it?) This is at least five-times greater than the intake of an average American.

--Likewise, the blood level of omega-3s in the blood of Japanese is 5-fold higher than in Americans.

--The average intake of omega-3s (EPA + DHA) among a broadly-selected population of Japanese is 850 mg per day (320 mg EPA; 520 mg DHA). Intake ranges from 300 mg per day all the way up to 3100 mg per day.

--Greater omega-3 intake (EPA + DHA) is associated with lesser carotid intimal-medial thickness, an index of body-wide atherosclerosis.

--Japanese have far less heart attack and stroke despite greater prevalence of smoking (nearly half of Japanese) and drinking.

--Total fat intake (percent of calories) is nearly identical between Americans and Japanese. It's the proportion of fat calories from omega-3 that is greater, the proportion of omega-6 that is less in Japanese.


The Japanese eat their fish in ways that we do not: As sashimi (raw, as with sushi in its various forms like Nigiri and Chirashi); fried in tempura; shaved, dried fish sprinkled on about anything you can imagine (it's not as bad as it sounds); as a snack, as in dried cuttlefish (which you can purchase in packages as a portable, sweetened fish that you eat on-the-run--I know it sounds awful, but don't poke fun at it until you've tried it); in "soups" with soba noodles. Fish is commonly consumed with rice and soy sauce, as well as other soy-based foods, such as tofu, miso (soy bean paste), or natto. 


I believe that there are some lessons to take from the Japanese and their fish-consuming habits:

1) An omega-3 fatty acid intake of at least 1000 mg per day yields measurable cardiovascular benefits. 

2) Despite the fears over mercury and pesticide residues in fish, this seems to not have played out to be a real-life effect in the Japanese, who consume five-fold greater quantities of fish. 

3) My mother was right after all when she encouraged us to eat more fish. 


DIRECT Study result: Low-carb, Mediterranean diets win weight-loss battle

Drs. Iris Shai and colleagues released results of a new Israeli study, the Dietary Intervention Randomized Controlled Trial (DIRECT) Trial, that compared three different diet strategies. Of those tested, a low-carbohydrate diet was most successful at achieving weight loss.

You can find the full-text of the study on the New England Journal of Medicine website.

322 participants followed one of three diets over two year period. Compared head-to-head, the (mean) weight loss in each group was:

• 2.9 kg (6.4 lbs) for the low-fat group
• 4.4 kg (9.7 lbs) for the Mediterranean-diet group
• 4.7 kg (10.3 lbs) for the low-carbohydrate group

(Average age 52 years at start; average body-mass index, or BMI, 31.)

The conclusion was that the low-carb diet performed the best, with 60% greater weight loss, with the Mediterranean diet a close second.


The diets

The low-fat diet was based on the American Heart Association diet, with 30% of calories from fat (10% from saturated fat) and food choices weighted towards low-fat grains, vegetables, fruits, and legumes and limited additional fats, sweets, and high-fat snacks; calorie intake of 1500 kcal per day for women and 1800 kcal per day for men was encouraged.

The Mediterranean diet was a moderate-fat diet rich in vegetables, with reduced red meat, and poultry and fish replacing beef and lamb. Total calories from fat of 35% per day or less was the goal, with most fat calories from olive oil and a handful of nuts. Like the low-fat program, calories were limited to 1500 kcal per day for women, 1800 kcal per day for men.

The low-carbohydrate diet was patterned after the popular Atkins’ program, with 8% participants achieving the ketosis that Dr. Atkins’ advocated as evidence that a fat-burning metabolism was activated, rather than sugar-burning as fuel. For the 2-month “induction phase,” 20 grams of carbohydrates per day was set as the goal, followed by 120 grams per day once the weight goal was achieved. Unlike the other two diets, calories, protein and fat were unlimited.


Weight loss, lipids, inflammation

You can see from the weight loss graph that the low-carb approach exerted the most dramatic initial weight loss. Interestingly, much of the weight-loss benefit was lost as the carbohydrate intake increased, by study design, back to 120 mg per day. However, the other two diet approaches showed similar phenomena of “giving back” some of the initial weight loss.

The low-carbohydrate diet exerted the greatest change in cholesterol, or lipid, panels: increased HDL 8.4 mg/dl vs. 6.3 mg/dl on low-fat; the triglyceride response was the most dramatic, with a reduction of 23.7 mg/dl vs. 3.7 mg/dl on low-fat. Interestingly, the LDL cholesterol-reducing effect of all three diets was modest, with the most reduction achieved by the Mediteranean diet.

The inflammatory measure, C-reactive protein (CRP), was reduced most effectively by the low-carb and Mediterranean diets, least by the low-fat diet. HbA1c, a measure of long-term blood sugar, dropped significantly more on the low-carb diet.

When the final dietary composition was examined, interestingly, there really were only modest differences among the three diets, with 8% less calories from carbs, 8% greater calories from fat, comparing low-carb to low-fat, with Mediterranean intermediate.



Taken at face value, this useful exercise quite clearly shows that, from the perspective of weight loss and correction of metabolic parameters like triglycerides, HDL,CRP, and blood sugar, low-carbohydrate wins hands down, with Mediterranean diet a close second.

It also suggests that a return to a carbohydrate intake of 120 mg/day allows a partial return of initial weight lost, as well as deterioration of metabolic parameters after the initial positive changes.

Although the study has already received some criticism for such potential flaws as the modest number of Atkins’ followers achieving ketosis (8%), suggesting lax adherence, and the reintroduction of the 120 mg/day carbohydrate advice, I can suspect that these may have been compromises drawn to satisfy some Institutional Review Board. (Whenever a study is going to be conducted involving human subjects, a study needs to pass through the review of an Institutional Review Board, or IRB. IRB’s, while charged to protect human subjects from experimental abuses, also tend to be painfully conservative and will block a study or demand changes even if they are not dangerous, but just veer too far off the mainstream.)


However, several unanswered questions remain:

1) How would the diets have compared if the carbohydrate restriction were continued for a longer period, or even indefinitely? (The divergences would likely have been dramatic.)
2) Will low-carb exert the same cardiovascular event reduction that the Mediterranean approach has shown in the Lyon study and others?
3) Are there effects on health outside of the measures followed that differ among the three diets, such as cancer? (I doubt it, especially given the modest real differences over time. But this will be the objection raised by various "official" organizations.)


I would further propose that:

Low-fat diets are dead

The AHA will cling to their version of low-fat diet, based on difficulty in changing course for any large, consensus-driven organization, not to mention the substantial ($100’s of millions) revenues derived from endorsing low-fat manufactured products. The AHA will also point to the lack of difference in LDL cholesterol among the three, since they cannot get beyond the fact that there’s more to coronary risk—a lot more—than LDL.


Off-the-shelf diets achieve off-the-shelf results

If you just need a T-shirt, a medium might fit fine. But if you’d like a nicely fitting suit or dress, then tailoring to your individual proportions is needed. When aiming towards maximizing benefits on lipoproteins and coronary risk, none of these diets achieve the kinds of changes we often need for coronary plaque reversal, as in the Track Your Plaque program. That requires making dietary changes that exert maximal effects on lipoprotein patterns.

Do I sell heart scans?

I came across a criticism of the Track Your Plaque program recently that suggested that it was nothing more than a program to sell CT heart scans.

Huh?

I suppose if you say that the Track Your Plaque program is nothing more than a way to sell heart disease prevention, omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil, vitamin D, better nutrition, and better identification of causes of heart disease . . . well, I believe that would be true.

But is the program a "front" to sell heart scans?

No, it is not, nor has it ever been.

I've heard about these peculiar suspicions about the program before. Though I've never taken them seriously, let me clear up any lingering uncertainty:


--I have no relationship with any heart scan center, scanning facility, or hospital other than to interpret heart scans.

I do not own a scanner, I have no financial interest in a scanner or scanning center, nor have I ever had any interest. I also have no plans to do so in the future. Let business people in the imaging business do that. I want no part of it. I have seen what these people go through and, frankly, I want no part of it, nor do I want the appearance that I am advocating scans to make money. I'm accused of trying to make money from scans even when I do not have any financial interest!


--I do not sell heart scans or imaging packages, nor have I ever done so.

You can't buy a scan through Track Your Plaque, The Heart Scan Blog, or through me. To me, heart scans are simply a measuring tool to identify the extent of coronary plaque, as well as a tracking tool to follow its course. Without it, there would be no Track Your Plaque. But there is also no alternative. The closest alternative would be carotid intimal-medial thickness, a technique, while useful, is a distant second choice to indirectly gauge coronary plaque by examining the thickness of the carotid lining (not carotid plaque). Perhaps in 10 years, a better measure to gauge and track coronary plaque will emerge that has superior aspects over CT heart scanning. If reasonable, safe, accessible, and quantitative, then Track Your Plaque may adopt that technology as its measuring tool.

Track Your Plaque is not about heart scanning; Track Your Plaque is about measuring and tracking plaque that, in 2008, is still best accomplished with CT heart scans.


--I make loads of money from heart scans and Track Your Plaque.

Yeah, right.

Track Your Plaque is a volunteer venture for my team; none of us get paid a penny for doing all we do, including me. We charge a membership fee on the website (somewhere around $6-7 a month) to pay our expenses, such as code writing for our proprietary software (much of it remains under development), printing costs, modest legal costs, the costs of doing business (e.g., accountant). Despite the fact that Track Your Plaque and the Heart Scan Blog occupies a substantial part of the day of the Track Your Plaque team, none of us are reimbursed for our time. I do believe, however, that this concept is so enormously powerful that it will, someday, pay us all enough to allow us to devote more time and effort to it.

Personally, I can't wait to devote more time and effort to this concept that is simple, logical, and effective. More research is needed, more development is needed, more discussion is needed. Right now, it is all accomplished outside of our busy schedules, including my full-time cardiology practice. I continue to have 7 am procedures, middle-of-the-night calls, weekend hospital rounds and emergencies (though virtually none of these are the patients involved in prevention, but the "other" people: atrial fibrillation, elderly heart failure patients, rhythm disorders, cardiomyopathies, pulmonary hypertension, peripheral vascular disease, the non-compliant).


--The book, Track Your Plaque, is a gimmick to sell you a heart scan.

No, it's a program that relies on this technology. But there's no special deal, no discounts, no steering to heart scan centers that I have a special arrangement with. No such thing exists, nor has there ever been such an arrangement.


I've heard it all. Early on, when I was helping my friend, Steve Burlingame and his wife, Nancy, set up Milwaukee Heart Scan, I helped by providing medical oversite, education of physicians and public, and interpreting heart scans. After all, in the "early days," nobody knew anything about heart scans. It was a long, hard climb against ignorance, habit, entrenched thinking, stubbornness, and stupidity. I've been paid next to nothing for all this. I told Steve long ago that, given the extraordinary expenses of maintaining an independent scanning center, that he should first pay his expenses, pay his technologists, receptionists, and nurse, pay himself, then pay me for reading scans if he had any money left over. Most of the time, Steve had nothing left over and I was paid nothing.

So, while some of my colleagues were assuming that I was rolling in money from "promoting" heart scans, the reality was that I was doing nearly everything for free. (It certainly wasn't the high life I was living; I don't drive a Mercedes, take fancy vacations, none of that. In fact, I work about 51 weeks a year.)

Why do I do this if it doesn't yield a big flow of money? Because I believe in it as a superior path to the conventional. If I were simply interested in making more money--I wouldn't do it. I would simply do what all my cardiology colleagues are doing: more heart catheterizations, more angioplasties and stents, learning how to do carotid stents, iliac stents, peripheral angioplasty, renal stents, acquiring the skills to put in defibrillators, new device insertion like umbrellas in the interatrial septum, etc. There's plenty more money in that. It's also not that hard. I know, because that is my background: high-risk cardiac interventions. That's what I was trained to do, that's what I did from a number years, until I started to see that this was nothing more than "putting out fires" in people who became increasingly ill and reliant on bail-out procedures. It makes lots of money, but it is also fundamentally wrong.

So, no, I do not sell heart scans, nor is the Track Your Plaque program or The Heart Scan Blog meant to promote heart scans except as a tool for tracking this disease.

That's it, pure and simple.

Plaque is the new cholesterol

Which is more important: cholesterol or coronary plaque?

Ask what Dr. Michael Eades' calls "statinators," and you will likely receive a befuddled look. Or, you might receive comments like "Measuring plaque has never been shown to reduce mortality."

While risk factors for heart disease are important, no doubt (my office practice is about half lipid consultation and complex hyperlipidemia management), for many they have become an end in themselves. In other words, LDL cholesterol in particular dominates thinking so much that it has caused many to exclude the fact that plaque---coronary atherosclerotic plaque---is the disease itself.

Dozens of studies, from the St. Francis Heart Study to the 25,000-participant UCLA registry, to the recently-released MESA database (ethic differences, women, as well as superiority to carotid measures) have repeatedly shown that heart scan scores (coronary artery calcium scores) are superior to conventional risk factors (usually via the Framingham risk score) for predicting future heart attack and other events. And the differences are not minor incremental differences. The predictive power of plaque measurement via heart scanning is multiples better: 4 times, 10 times, 20 times or more in various subgroups.

Much of what we do in medicine is not based on long-term studies of outcome, pitting some diagnostic measure or treatment against placebo. It is already standard practice to measure plaque via heart catheterization, crudely via stress testing, and increasingly popular CT coronary angiography. None of these methods have been subjected to studies comparing testing vs. not testing in a large population, followed by some program of prevention to assess differences in mortality, heart attack, and other events.

Why should heart scan be held to such a standard?

Dr. Scott Grundy, lipid guru and one of the experts who sat on the Adult Treatment Panel-II for lipid management guidelines, recently stated [emphasis added]:

"Imaging has at least 3 virtues. It individualizes risk assessment beyond use of age, which is a less reliable surrogate for atherosclerosis burden; it provides an integrated assessment of the lifetime exposure to risk factors; and it identifies individuals who are susceptible to developing atherosclerosis beyond established risk factors. Also of importance, in the absence of detectable atherosclerosis, short-term risk appears to be very low."

Well said, and from a vocal statinator, to boot.

Sadly, Dr. Grundy goes on to say how plaque imaging can serve to better determine who will benefit from statin drug use.

Of course, you and I know that there is far more to reduction of cardiovascular risk applied to a framework of serial plaque quantification ("tracking plaque"!) than statin drugs. I doubt that a man as intelligent as Dr. Grundy truly believes this. I suspect that he is simply stating what he knows what will be published without resistance in the standard medical literature, trying to achieve a modest incremental success just by raising consciousness about heart scanning and plaque imaging: first things first.

Maybe next will be a plaque-tracking, or even a plaque-reducing, mainstream conversation, just like the one we've been conducting for the past four years.

Track Your Plaque success story blows it

Joe was a Track Your Plaque Success Story. With a starting heart scan score of 278, he dropped it 12 months later to 264, a 5% reduction. Though not a huge reduction, Joe's risk for a heart attack or other coronary event was virtually zero. I was very proud of Joe.

Among the culprit lipoprotein patterns that caused Joe's plaque was lipoprotein(a), or Lp(a). Niacin was therefore crucial to his program. It was among the principal reasons he dropped his heart scan score and reduced his risk for heart attack so dramatically.

Since he retired, Joe has been freewheeling around the country, traveling and having a great time. He consequently stopped thinking about his heart disease and Lp(a). He also tired of the occasional hot flushes he'd experienced with niacin. Though the flushes were promptly aborted by drinking two glasses of water, he simply didn't want to be bothered.

So when Joe saw this interesting and tantalizing "flush-free niacin" on the store shelf, he grabbed it.

Joe came back to the office. His blood pressure was 190/94, so high that he was having occasional chest pains from it (which can happen when something called "left ventricular diastolic dysfunction" develops from hypertension). His lipoprotein patterns were terrible, including a big upward jump in Lp(a) and drop in HDL. So I asked him to have another heart scan right away: Score 371, a 40% increase. In other words, his program went down the toilet.

Why?

Simple: Flush-free niacin. I've said it before (No flush = No effect and No flush niacin kills) and I'll say it again:

Flush-free or No-flush niacin is a complete, unadulterated, completely ineffective SCAM.

Flush-free or no-flush niacin is not a substitute for niacin. Joe is yet another example of how dangerous this scam can be. It turned one of our great success stories into a failure.

Please, please, please do not fall for this misleading and potentially dangerous scam product. While the product itself is not intrinsically dangerous, it denies you the benefits of the real thing: niacin.

Thankfully, the mistake in Joe's program was caught before a heart attack or other catastrophe. He did manage to pass a stress test, though with a flagrantly out-of-control blood pressure response. We'll get him back on track--but with niacin, the real thing.

Dr. Cannell comments on vitamin D lab tests

As always, Dr. John Cannell of The Vitamin D Council continues to teach us new lessons about vitamin D.

Apparently, Dr. Cannell is swamped with the attention that vitamin D is drawing, largely due to his efforts to publicize the enormous deficiency of Americans and his great talent for articulating the science. The most current newsletter, while a bit haphazard, makes some excellent new points that I reprint here.

(I did not reprint his conversation about "any form of vitamin D" being acceptable. My experience differs: In nearly 1000 patients who have taken vitamin D supplements, my experience is that most tablet forms are inconsistently absorbed, sometimes not absorbed at all. I therefore advocate only use of gelcaps or liquids. I'm told by members of Track Your Plaque, however, that they are witnessing reliable increases in blood levels of vitamin D by taking the powdered form of Bio Tech Pharmacal's product.)


Does it matter what reference lab my doctor uses?

Yes, it might make a huge difference. A number of methods exist to measure 25(OH)D in commercial labs. The two most common are mass spectrometry and a chemiluminescence method, LIAISON. The first, mass spectrometry, is highly accurate in the hands of experienced technicians given enough time to do the test properly. However, in the hands of a normally trained technician at a commercial reference lab overwhelmed with 25(OH)D tests, it may give falsely elevated readings, that is, it tells you are OK when in fact you are vitamin D deficient. The second method, chemiluminescence, LIAISON, was recently developed and is the most accurate of the screening, high throughput, methods; LabCorp uses it. Quest Diagnostics reference lab uses mass spec. Again, both Quest and LabCorp are overwhelmed by 25(OH)D requests. The problem is that the faster the technicians do the mass spec test, the more inaccurate it is likely to be. If your 25(OH)D blood test says "Quest Diagnostics" on the top, do not believe you have an adequate level (> 50 ng/ml). You may or may not; the test may be falsely elevated. Let me give you an example. A doctor at my hospital had Quest Diagnostics do a 25(OH)D. It came back as 99 ng/ml of ergocalciferol. He is not taking ergocalciferol (D2), he has never taken ergocalciferol, only cholecalciferol, and he is not taking enough to get a level of 99 ng/ml, 50 ng/ml at the most. His email to Dr. Brett Holmquist at Quest about why Quest identified a substance he was not taking went unanswered other than to say "any friend of Dr. Cannell's is a friend of ours."

Long story short: if your lab report says "LabCorp" on the top, it is probably accurate; if it says Quest Diagnostic, it may be falsely elevated. While LabCorp has also been overwhelmed with 25(OH)D requests, the LIAISON method they use is relatively easy to do and does not rely on technician skill as much as the mass spec methods do. I'm not saying this because I'm a consultant for DiaSorin, who makes LIAISON, I'm saying it because it is true. If you don't believe me, get Quest to make me an offer to be their consultant at 10 times what DiaSorin is supposed to be paying me ($10,000 per year) and see how fast I turn Quest down. If Quest fixes their test, I'd love to consult. The ironic thing: I've made both Quest and LabCorp lots of money via this newsletter, the website, and by repeatedly telling the press that people need to know their 25(OH)D level, which has contributed to the skyrocketing sales of 25(OH)D blood tests.

Demand for vitamin D tests soars as nutrient's potential benefits touted.

Here you can help. Find out which labs in your town use Quest Diagnostics and which use LabCorp. Have a 25(OH)D test at both labs the same day (you will have to pay for them yourself). Then send both results to the Vitamin D Council address below. If Quest Diagnostics does not fix their 25(OH)D test, the Vitamin D Council will fix it for them.



My doctor prescribed Drisdol, 50,000 IU per week. What is it?

Drisdol is a prescription of 50,000 IU tablets of ergocalciferol or D2. Ergocalciferol is not vitamin D but it is similar. It is made by irradiating ergosterol, which is found in many living things, such as yeast. D2 is not normally found in humans and most studies show it does not raise 25(OH)D levels as well as human vitamin D (cholecalciferol or D3) does. However, Drisdol is a lot better than nothing. The best thing to do, if you are vitamin D deficient, and a human, is to take human vitamin D, cholecalciferol, A.K.A. vitamin D3.



What is the ideal level of 25(OH)D?

We don't know. However, thanks to Bruce Hollis, Robert Heaney, Neil Binkley, and others, we now know the minimal acceptable level. It is 50 ng/ml. In a recent study, Heaney et al enlarged on Bruce Hollis's seminal work by analyzing five studies in which both the parent compound, cholecalciferol, and 25(OH)D levels were measured. It turn out that the body does not reliably begin storing the parent compound (cholecalciferol) in fat and muscle tissue until 25(OH)D levels get above 50 ng/ml. The average person starts to store cholecalciferol at 40 ng/ml, but at 50 ng/ml, virtually everyone begins to store it for future use. That is, at levels below 50 ng/ml, the body is usually using up the vitamin D as fast as you make it or take it, indicating chronic substrate starvation, not a good thing.

Hollis BW, Wagner CL, Drezner MK, Binkley NC. Circulating vitamin D3 and 25-hydroxyvitamin D in humans: An important tool to define adequate nutritional vitamin D status. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol. 2007 Mar;103(3-5):631-4.

Heaney RP, Armas LA, Shary JR, Bell NH, Binkley N, Hollis BW. 25-Hydroxylation of vitamin D3: relation to circulating vitamin D3 under various input conditions. Am J Clin Nutr. 2008 Jun;87(6):1738-42.



I have advanced renal failure and I'm on dialysis, how much vitamin D should I take?

The same as everyone else. Since I have told you about commercial labs ripping you off, let's add some drug companies. Patients with advanced renal failure need activated vitamin D or one of it's analogs, available by prescription. This is very important as their kidneys cannot make enough 1,25-dihydroxy-vitamin D (calcitriol) to maintain serum calcium. However, the rest of their tissues activate vitamin D just fine and when those tissues get enough, and when the kidneys get more vitamin D, the calcitriol spills out into the blood, lowering their need for prescription calcitriol or one of its analogs. The companies that make the analogs don't like that, it means reduced sales. So these companies do nothing, the scientists behind these companies say nothing, and renal failure patients die prematurely from one of the vitamin D deficiency diseases.

Vieth R. Vitamin D toxicity, policy, and science. J Bone Miner Res. 2007 Dec;22 Suppl 2:V64-8.



When I asked my doctor for a 25(OH)D blood test, he just laughed and said it was all idiotic. What can I do?

Help me unleash the dogs of war, the plaintiff attorneys. If you read about past nutritional epidemics caused by society, such as beriberi or pellagra, you will realize that education alone will take decades. Physicians successfully fought against the idea that thiamine deficiency caused beriberi for decades. However, things are different now. The agents of change in modern America, as obnoxious as they are, are plaintiff attorneys. Once the first malpractice lawsuits claiming undiagnosed and untreated vitamin D deficiency led to breast cancer, autism, heart disease, etc., get past summary judgment, and they will, and end up in front of a jury, and they will, things will change rapidly. One of the main reason physicians do what they do is fear of lawsuits. In a matter of months, arrogance and ignorance will give way to 25(OH)D tests and vitamin D supplementation.

Goodwin JS, Tangum MR. Battling quackery: attitudes about micronutrient supplements in American academic medicine. Arch Intern Med. 1998 Nov 9;158(20):2187-91.


And, to help support Dr. Cannell's efforts (I sent him a check for $250 a few months back; time for more), here is his contact info:

John Cannell, MD
The Vitamin D Council

Send your tax-deductible contributions to:

The Vitamin D Council
9100 San Gregorio Road
Atascadero, CA 93422

Privileged information

In 1910, taking a person's blood pressure was considered revolutionary, a high-tech practice that was of uncertain benefit.

Dr. Harvey Cushing of Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore had observed a blood pressure device while traveling in Europe, developed by Dr. Sciopione Riva-Rocci. Cushing brought this new technology back with him to the U.S. and promptly promoted its use, convinced that this insight into gauging the forcefulness of blood pressure would yield useful clinical insights.

But, in 1910, practicing physicians rejected this new technology, preferring to use their well-established and widely practiced technique of pulse palpation (feeling the pulse), skeptical that the new tool added value. Medical practice of the day was rich with descriptions of the strength and character of the pulse: pulsus parvus et tardus (the slow rising pulse of aortic valve stenosis), the dicrotic notch of aortic valve closure transmitted to the pulse, the "water-hammer" pulse of aortic valve insufficiency.

Over the next 20 years, however, the medical community finally gave way to the new technique, although only physicians were allowed to use blood pressure devices, as nurses were regarded as incapable of mastering the skills required to perform the procedure properly.

Stethoscopes were also gaining in popularity in the early 20th century, but were also the exclusive province of physicians trained in their use. Nurses were not allowed to use stethoscopes until the 1960s. Even then, nurses were not allowed to call them "stethoscopes," but "nurse-o-scopes" or "assistoscopes," and the nurses' version of the device was manufactured to look different to avoid confusion with the "real" doctor's tool.

And just half a century ago, if you wanted to look at a medical textbook, you would have to go to the library and ask for special permission. The librarian would lower her glasses and look you up and down to determine whether or not you were some kind of pervert. Only then might you be granted permission to peer into the pictures of organs and naked bodies.

Such has been the spirit of medicine for centuries: Medicine and its practices are meant to be secret, the insider knowledge of a privileged few.

Fast forward to 2008: The Information Age has overturned the rules of privileged information. Now you have access to the same information as I do, the same information available to practicing physicians. The playing field has been levelled.

Curiously, while information access has advanced at an instantaneous digital pace, attitudes in medicine continue to evolve at the traditional analog crawl. Many of my colleagues continue to be dismayed at the new public access to health information, belittle patients for excessive curiosity about their health, lament the erosion of their healthcare-directing authority. And while new concepts race ahead as we race towards a wiki-like collective growth in healthcare knowledge, physicians are still mired by their reluctance to abdicate their once-lofty positions as chief holders of secrets.

I believe that this is part of the reason why family doctors and cardiologists have been slow to adopt technologies like heart scans and self-empowering programs like Track Your Plaque: processes that take heart disease prevention away from the hands of physicians and place more control into the hands of the people.

Imagine the horror felt by physicians in 1935 of a young upstart nurse boldly trying to use a stethoscope to take a patient's blood pressure. You can imagine the internal horror now being felt as you and I dare to take control over heart disease and deny them the chance to put in four stents, three bypass grafts, then direct our future health habits.

But technology has a way of marching on. It will encounter resistance, bumps, and blind-alleys, but it will go on.

Dr. Jeffrey Dach on the Track Your Plaque program

Dr. Jeffrey Dach posted a great piece on his blog, Bioidentical Hormone Blog , about his perspective on the Track Your Plaque program.

It's worth reading even for those familiar with the program, just to see a slightly different perspective. He also included many great graphics to illustrate his points.

CAT Coronary Calcium Scoring, Reversing Heart Disease












Also, see Dr. Dach's Heart Disease: Part 2, for some novel thoughts.

Vitamin D and programmed aging?

As we age, we lose the capacity to activate vitamin D in the skin.

Studies suggest that, between ages 20 and 70, there is a 75% reduction in the ability to activate vitamin D. The capacity of conversion from 25 (OH) vitamin D to 1,25 di(OH) vitamin D also diminishes.

Holick M. Sunlight and vitamin D for bone health and prevention of autoimmune diseases, cancers, and cardiovascular disease.



From Holick, M. 2006

This would explain why 70-year olds come to the office, just back from the Caribbean sporting dark brown tans, are still deficient, often severely, in blood levels of vitamin D (25(OH) vitamin D). A tan does not equal vitamin D.














Courtesy Ipanemic


A practical way of looking at it is that anyone 40 years old or older has lost the majority of ability for vitamin D activation.

This often makes me wonder if the loss of vitamin D activating potential is nature's way to get rid of us. After all, after 40, we've pretty much had our opportunity to recreate and make our contribution to the species (at least in a primitive world in which humans evolved): we've exhausted our reproductive usefulness to the species.

Is the programmed decline of vitamin D skin activation a way to ensure that we develop diseases of senescence (aging)? The list of potential consequences of vitamin D deficiency includes: osteoporosis, poor balance and coordination, falls and fractures; cancer of the breast, bladder, colon, prostate, and blood; reductions in HDL, increases in triglycerides; increased inflammation (C-reactive protein, CRP); declining memory and mentation; coronary heart disease.

Isn't that also pretty much a list that describes aging?

A fascinating argument in support of this idea came from study from St Thomas’ Hospital and the London School of Medicine:

Higher serum vitamin D concentrations are associated with longer leukocyte telomere length in women

Telomeres are the "tails" of DNA that were formerly thought to be mistakes, just coding for nonsense. But more recent thinking has proposed that telomeres may provide a counting mechanism that shortens with aging and accelerates with stress and illness. This study suggests that both vitamin D and inflammation (CRP) impact telomere length: the lower the vitamin D, the shorter the telomere length, particularly when inflammation is greater.
















Data supporting vitamin D's effects on preventing or treating cancer, osteoporosis, lipid abnormalities, inflammation, cardiovascular disease, etc., is developing rapidly.

Now the big question: If declining vitamin D is nature's way of ensuring our decline and death, does maintaining higher vitamin D also maintain youthfulness?

I don't have an answer, but it's a really intriguing idea.