Are there any alternatives to niacin?

In the Track Your Plaque program, we tend to rely a great deal on niacin. When used properly, 90-95% of people will do just fine and achieve their lipid and lipoprotein goals with the help of niacin, along with their other efforts.

Unfortunately, around 5% of people simply can't take niacin without intolerable "hot flush" effects, or occasionally excessive skin sensitivity--itching, burning, etc.

Why does this happen? These 5% tend to be "rapid metabolizers" of niacin, i.e. they convert niacin (nicotinic acid, or vitamin B3) into a metabolite called nicotinuric acid. Nicotinuric acid is the compound responsible for the skin flush. Most people can slow or reduce the effects of nicotinuric acid by:

--Taking niacin with dinner, so that food slow tablet dissolution.

--Taking with plenty of water. Two 8-12 oz glasses usually eliminates the flush entirely in most people.

--Taking with an uncoated 325 mg tablet of aspirin in the first few weeks or months. Eventually, you will need to revert back to a better stomach tolerated dose of 81 mg, preferably enteric coated. But a full 325 mg uncoated can really help in the beginning, or when you have any niacin dose increases, e.g., 500 mg to 1000 mg.

But even with these very effective strategies, some people still struggle. That's when the question arises: Are there any alternatives to niacin?

Well, it depends on why niacin is being used. If you and your doctor are using niacin for:

Raising HDL--Then weight loss to your ideal weight; reduction of processed carbohydrates, especially wheat products; avoidance of hydrogenated ("trans") fats; a glass or two of red wine per day; dark chocolates (make sure first ingredient is chocolate or cocoa, not sugar), 40 gm per day; fish oil; exercise; other prescription agents (fibrates like Tricor; TZD agents for diabetes; cilostazol (Pletal)). Niacin is by far the most effective agent of all, but, if you're intolerant, raising HDL is still possible through a multi-faceted effort.

Reduction of small LDL--The list of effective strategies is the same as for raising HDL, but add raw almonds (1/4-1/2 cup per day), oat bran and other beta-glucan rich foods like oatmeal. Reduction of processed carbohydrates is especially important to reduce small LDL.

Reduction of Lipoprotein(a)--This is a tricky one. For men, testosterone and DHEA are effective alternatives; for women, estrogen and perhaps DHEA. Hormonal preparations of testosterone and estrogen are stricly prescription; DHEA is OTC. I have not seen the outsized benefits on lipoprotein(a) claimed by Rath et al by using high-dose vitamin C, lysine, and profile, unfortunately. We are clearly in need of better alternatives to treat this difficult and high-risk disorder.

Reduction of triglycerides/VLDL/IDL--I lump these three together since they all respond together. If you're niacin intolerant, maximixing your fish oil can be crucial for reduction of these patterns using doses above the usual starting 4000 mg per day (providing 1200 mg EPA+DHA). Reduction of processed carbohydrates, eimination of processed foods that contain high-fructose corn syrup, and weight loss to ideal weight are also very effective. "Soft" strategies with modest effects include green tea (>6 cups per day) or theaflavin 600-900 mg/day; raw nuts like almonds, walnuts, and pecans; exercise; soy protein.

Reduction of LDL--Lots of alternatives here including oat bran (3 tbsp per day), ground flaxseed (3 tbsp per day), soy protein (25 grams per day), Benecol butter substitute (for stanol esters), soluble fibers like pectin, psyllium, glucomannan; raw nuts like almonds, walnuts, and pecans.

In future, should torcetrapib become available (by prescription), this will add to our available tools for these areas when niacin can't be used. Until now, the alternatives to niacin depend on what you and your doctor are trying to achieve. In the vast majority of cases, HDL, small LDL, triglyceride, etc. goals for heart scan score control can be achieved, even when niacin is not well tolerated.

Is flaxseed oil a substitute for fish oil?


This question comes up so frequently that it's worth going over.

Flaxseed oil is a wonderful oil rich in linolenic acid, which may provide health benefits all by itself. Some authorities have speculated that the substantial reduction in heart attack seen in the Lyon Heart Study, the study that demonstrated the healthy power of the Mediterranean diet, is due to linolenic acid.

Flaxseed oil is also rich in monounsaturates and low in saturates, both desirable qualities. Of course, I'm talking here about flaxseed oil, to be distinguished from flaxseed , which are the intact seeds. The seeds themselves also contain the same oils, but contain other components, specifically lignan, a plant fiber with suspected health benefits like reduction in cancer risk.

Despite all flaxseed oil's wonderful properties, it is definitely not a substitute for fish oil. Why do we use fish oil for our coronary plaque control program (trying to reduce your heart scan score)? Several reasons. Fish oil:

--Dramatically reduces triglycerides, usually by 50% or more.
--Dramatically reduces specific lipoprotein classes like VLDL
--Dramatatically reduces, often eliminates, abnormal postprandial (after-eating) lipoprotein patterns, like IDL (intermediate-density lipoprotein)
--Has been conclusively shown to reduce risk of heart attack and death from heart attack (GISSI Prevenzione Trial).
--Has been shwon to reduce risk of stroke.
--Modifies blood clotting parameters, particularly a 20% reduction in fibrinogen.

Flaxseed oil, or linolenic acid concentrate for that matter, do not accomplish any of these effects, all crucial if you are to gain control over your coronary plaque.

Flaxseed oil and flaxseed remain wonderful nutritional agents for their own reasons. But they will not substitute for fish oil in your program. Only fish oil--the real thing--does the job.

If you have coronary artery disease . . . do you know why?

This conversation is aimed primarily at non-followers of the Track Your Plaque program, because if you were a follower, you’d already know the answer!

I saw a woman in the hospital today. She’d just survived her second heart attack one week earlier. At 51 years old, she was understandably shaken, perhaps terrified. She felt that her future was uncertain and, in fact, had discussed with her husband what he should do to prepare for a future without her.

One week earlier, she’d received three stents that successfully aborted her heart attack. But, as is always the case, the modest delays of ambulance transport, the emergency room preliminaries, then of mobilizing an available cardiologist and catheterization laboratory team, totaled nearly two hours before her stent procedure. Inevitably, a moderate amount of damage had been done to her heart.

Her first “event” had been very similar: very little warning, then 911 and the flurry of activity. Both times, the cardiologists (two different physicians) complimented the patient on her prompt action. Both also called her heart attacks “close calls”.

She defied the odds with two near-death events. So, when I met her a week after her last heart attack, I asked an obvious question: “Has anyone told you why you’re having these heart attacks?”

She looked completely puzzled at first. She then said, “No, not really. I just assumed it was genetic. My mother went through the same thing when she was my age. But she didn’t get as far as I have, since they didn’t have these procedures back then.”

To me, this seems inexcusable: This woman had experienced two brushes with death and no doctor had established a cause. Could this woman’s belief be true, that it’s just genetic?

While there are, indeed, genetic causes for heart disease, the vast majority of these genetic causes are 1) identifiable, and 2) correctable. Genetic does not necessarily mean hopeless. It just means that the usual equation of heart disease risk management (heart disease = LDL cholesterol = need for Lipitor) has limited value. It would be like giving penicillin to people for any and all infections. It will work occasionally, but it will fail miserably in a great many cases. Treating LDL cholesterol with statin drugs is just like that.

Perhaps this woman has lipoprotein(a), a serious genetic trait that predicts heart disease at a young age and is largely unaffected by statin drugs. Or, she may have a severe excess of small LDL, only partially suppressed by statins. If she has the combined pattern of lipoprotein(a) and small LDL, that means she has two statin-unresponsive and significant genetic traits. But they respond to niacin, specific nutritional strategies, and several other agents.

The message: If you have coronary disease, you need to insist on knowing why. “It’s genetic” is not an acceptable answer. “There’s no proof of any heart disease causes beyond cholesterol” is also nonsense. “Everyone gets heart disease, or “hardening of the arteries”, eventually. You just got it a little before everyone else” is also patently ridiculous.

Identifying the causes of your coronary disease (or coronary plaque if you’ve had a CT heart scan) is the first step in developing a program of treatment that provides you with control over this disease.

Have you tried inulin yet?

If you haven't yet tried it to facilitate weight loss, it's really worth giving the new inulin-containing product, Fiber Choice "Weight Management", a try.

Recall (from a prior Heart Scan Blog) that inulin is a vegetable-based fiber found in celery, green peppers, etc. that, when exposed to water, expands to many times original volume. This simple phenomenon yields satiety--a feeling of fullness.


The manufacturer of the product has also added green tea, which has been shown in two small clinical studies to enhance weight loss, though by a different route.

We've been advising patients to chew two of the strawberry flavored tablets one hour before every meal (or with breakfast if you eat immediately in the morning). You'll be satisfied with less food and you'll experience less intense food cravings.

Though no one so far has achieved a huge drop in weight, it does seem to enhance a slow, gradual weight loss larger than achieved by diet and exercise alone. And it's very safe and inexpensive. If you give it a try to help you lose weight, let us know what kind of results you've obtained.

Fish oil update on Life Extension

An article of mine came out in Life Extension Magazine and is available on the online version at:

http://www.lef.org/magazine/mag2006/sep2006_report_omega1_01.htm

This is an update on the heart health applications of fish oil.

Or, go to to www.lef.org and put fish oil into your on-site search and you'll come back to it in future.

Of course, it comes with Life Extension's promotion of its supplements.

Although it's not yet available online, the hard copy version of an article I wrote on homocysteine is available in the October, 2006 Life Extension Magazine. If you're not a member of their program, they'll send you a free copy just for signing up for it without obligation. Go to the home page of www.lef.org to do so. Or, Life Extension is available at newstands if you're in a rush or don't want to sign up for a free copy.

More on Vitamin D

If you haven't done so already, you should subscribe to Dr. John Cannell's free newsletter on vitamin D issues. His newest issue is available at:

http://www.vitamindcouncil.com/newsletter/2006-aug.shtml

A sign-up to subscribe is available on the same page.

I continue to be shocked and amazed at the prevalence and magnitude of vitamin D deficiency in the people I see every day. It's been a beautiful summer with very little rain. Most days have been in the 70-80 degree range--very comfortable to be outdoors in the sun and getting skin expoxure to activate vitamin D in the skin.

Yet, in the vast majority of people I see, summer blood levels of vitamin D are virtually indistinguishable from winter levels. Both hover around the 30 ng/ml range. Summer levels in Wisconsin people seem to be no more than 10 ng/ml higher than winter levels. This remains true even in people who spend a lot of their day outdoors gardening, walking, etc. wearing shorts and a short-sleeved shirt, i.e. with plenty of skin surface area exposed.

I'm at a loss to explain precisely why. Yes, it is Wisconsin. But a direct sun overhead, 75 degree day should be providing plenty of sun. My suspicious is that a combination of factors are at work: people are not spending as much time outdoors as they claim; they often seek shade; use sunscreen; and they're overweight. (Excess weight decreases vitamin D blood levels dramatically, yet another reason not to get fat!)

Read more about vitamin D by checking out Dr. Cannell's insightful comments on the unfolding vitamin D story. He holds nothing back.

Why not just get "perfect" lipids and call it a day?

What if you achieved the Track Your Plaque lipid targets: LDL cholesterol 60 mg/dl, HDL 60 mg/dl, and triglycerides 60 mg/dl?

After all, these are pretty stringent standards. Compared to national guidelines (the ATP-III Guidelines of the National Cholesterol Educational Panel), the Track Your Plaque 60-60-60 goals are laughably ambitious. There's a lot of wisdom hidden in those numbers. The triglyceride level of 60, for instance, is a level at which triglycerides become essentially unavailable for formation of triglyceride-containing lipoprotein particles such as small LDL and VLDL.

If you get to the 60-60-60 target, isn't that good enough? What if you just held your values there and went about your business? Will coronary plaque stop growing and will your CT heart scan score stop increasing?

Sometimes it will. But, unfortunately, many times it will not. The experience generated through clinical trials bear this out. Studies like the St. Francis Heart Study and the BELLES Trial both showed that just reducing LDL cholesterol is insufficient to stop plaque growth. Beyond the Track Your Plaque experience, there's no clinical trial experience that shows whether the 60-60-60 approach does any better.

In our experience, achieving 60-60-60 is indeed better than just reducing LDL. That makes sense. Just raising HDL from the average of 42 mg/dl for a male, 52 mg/dl for a woman adds advantage. Compound this with triglyceride reduction from the plaque-creating equation, and you've doubled success.

But there's even more. What if you had hidden patterns not revealed by conventional lipids? How about lipoprotein(a)? Small LDL? Postprandial (after-eating) abnormalities? Hypertensive effects (more common than you think)!

In 2006, stopping the increase in your heart scan score is, for most of us, not just a matter of taking Lipitor or its equivalent and sitting back. For nearly all of us, stopping the progression of your score is a multi-faceted effort.

Hospitals: Then and Now

It's 1920. The hospital in your city is a facility run by nuns or the church. It's a place for the very ill, often without hope of meaningful treatment, but nonetheless a place where surgeries take place, babies are born, the injured and chronically ill can find care. No one has health insurance and there's no Medicare. Everyone pays what they can. The hospital is accustomed to doling out plenty of care without compensation. For that reason, they welcome donations and sometimes will build new additions or other facilities in honor of a major donor.

Volunteeers are common, since the wards are understaffed and generally suffering from a shortage of trained nurses and personnel associated with the church. Drugs, such as they are, are often prepared from basic ingredients in the hospital pharmacy. Product representatives hawking medicines and devices are virtually unheard of.

Though their therapeutic tools are limited, the physicians are a proud group, dedicating their careers to healing. The majority of the medical staff volunteer large portions of their time to care for the poor who come to the hospital with very advanced stages of disease: metastatic tumors, advanced heart failure, debilitating strokes, overwhelming septicemia, etc.

Hospitals are usually governed by a board of clergy and physicians who make decisions on how to apply their limited resources and continually seek charitable donations.


Fast forward to present day: Hospitals are high-tech, professional facilities with lots of skilled people, complicated equipment,and capable of complex procedures. While they still house people with advanced illnesses, the floors are also filled with people with much earlier phases of disease. In general, they do a good job, with quality issues scrutinized by a number of official agencies to police practices, incidence of hospital-related infections, medication errors, care protocols, etc.

The hospital of 2006 is a more more effective place than the hospital of 1920. But its aims and operations are different, also. Though some churches are still involved in hospitals, more and more are owned by publicly-traded companies that answer to shareholders--shareholders who want share value to increase. Though donations are still sought, much of the revenues are obtained by concentrating on profitable, large-ticket procedures. More procedures are often generated by advertising.

Because they operate to generate profits, several hospitals in a single city or region compete with one another. The 21st century has therefore witnessed the phenomenon of hospital-owned physicians: more and more practicing physicians are employees of their hospital. That way, the physician brings all his patients and procedures to his hospital, not to a competitor. The top of the funnel is the primary care physician, who tends to see all disease when it first occurs. The primary care physician then sends the patient to the specialist, who is obliged (by contract) to perform his/her procedure in the hsopital paying their salary.




Representatives from companies manufacturing and selling expensive hospital equipment and drugs are everywhere, falling over themselves to gain attention of the physicians using their equipment and the hospital buyers who make purchasing decisions. Millions of dollars can be transacted with just one sale.

The number of volunteers has dwindled. The poor and uninsured are commonly diverted elsewhere, often to a government-funded, and often second-rate, institution. Hospitals measure success by comparing annual revenues and numbers of major procedures.

The hospital of 2006 is a vastly different place than 1920. If you're expecting charitable treatment, compassion, and selfless care, you're in the wrong century. In 2006, the hospital is a business. You don't expect charitable treatment at Wal-Mart or from your car dealer. Don't expect it from your hospital. They are businesses and you are a customer. Recognize this fact, lose the nostalgia for the hospitals of yesterday, and a lot more will become clear to you.

The dreaded small LDL particle

Brian is a 59-year old landscape architect whose starting CT heart scan score was 276.

Brian's food choices at the start were deplorable: a pound of sausage per week, sometimes more; butter on anything and everything; up to two pounds of cheese per week; hot dogs; etc. His lipoproteins were accordingly just as miserable: low HDL, high triglycerides, excessive (postprandial, or after-eating) IDL. Small LDL was a particularly stand-out pattern, with 95% of all LDL particles in the small category.

Brian made a dramatic turnaround in lifestyle and corrected all of his patterns--except for small LDL. After one year, small LDL still occupied 95% of all LDL particles, even though the quantity of LDL had been reduced. In order to help convince Brian that correction of his small LDL was going to be necessary to achieve control oover coronary plaque, I suggested that he undergo another heart scan. His score: 435, or a 57% increase.

Each day that passes, I gain more and more respect for small LDL as a cause for coronary plaque growth. Conventional thought among lipid experts is that small LDL should no longer be a factor if total LDL (e.g., LDL particle number) is reduced. But our experience suggests otherwise: when small LDL persists, we tend to see continued, sometimes frightening, plaque growth.

I therefore asked Brian to intensify his efforts: additional weight loss off his somewhat prominent abdomen (since visceral fat increases small LDL), further reduce wheat products and processed carbohydrates, increase niacin (to 1500 mg per day), and use more raw almonds and oat bran.

Don't let small LDL get the best of you. It is a nasty, sometimes persistent abnormality that has impressive effects on plaque growth.

Winning Through Intimidation

Do you remember the book, Winning Through Intimidation by author Robert J. Ringer?



In his 1984 bestseller, author Ringer details how to succeed in business by overwhelming clients and competition by appearing hugely successful and powerful. Rather than a business card, he'd hand out an elegant book to represent himself. He'd show up in a limousine to a meeting, even when he could barely afford it. He used these tactics, even when he was a small-fry, in commercial real estate and built a successful business following such techniques.

This reminds me a lot of what happens in conventional medical practice: The large and successful hospitals, filled with trained staff and technology, exude legitimacy and success. How can they possibly be wrong? Such overwhelming know-how and multiple levels of expertise mustbe right!

Let's be grateful that we do have access to such high-tech, capable care. Unfortunately, just as Mr. Ringer used deceptive practices to appear something he wasn't, this is also true in hospitals. Not all physicians have your best interests in mind. Their principal concern is how profitable your care can be for them--can you be persuaded to have your stent, bypass, etc.. After all, look around you: Aren't all this equipment and personnel impressive? Aren't you intimidated?

The patient that most recently drove home this issue for me recently was a smart and capable executive who came in for consultation. He had been told by his internist that a surgery (to replace his aorta, a HUGE procedure) was probably necessary. In my view, it was not--his process was simply not that far progressed. The risks for danger over the next several years was virtually nil. Unfortunately, this man, now confused and worried, sought an opinion from the chief of thoracic surgery (in the usual white coat and with professorial demeanor, I'm sure) in a major metropolitan hospital (in Chicago), who promptly rushed him off to the operating room.

The pathology report, cleverly not mentioned in any other of the hospital documentation, showed what I had suspected: this man had mild disease that wasn't even close to requiring surgery. But, with all that technology, $100,000 or so of costs, chief of surgery who looked the part, etc.--they must be right!

Robert Ringer's concepts only ring too true for hospitals and some of the unscrupulous physicians in practice. Don't allow yourself to be intimidated.
The Westman Diet

The Westman Diet

Dr. Eric Westman has been a vocal proponent of carbohydrate restriction to gain control over diabetes, as have Drs. Richard Bernstein, Mary Vernon, Richard Feinman, and Jeff Volek.

Several studies over the years have demonstrated that reductions in carbohydrate content of the diet yield reductions in weight and HbA1c (glycated hemoglobin, a reflection of average blood glucose over the preceding 60-90 days).

Among the more important recent clinical studies is a small experience from Duke University's Dr. Eric Westman. In this study, obese type 2 diabetics reduced carbohydrate intake to 20 grams per day or less: no wheat, oats, cornstarch, or sugars. Participants ate nuts, cheese, meats, eggs, and non-starchy vegetables.

After 6 months, average weight loss was 24.4 lbs, BMI was reduced from 37.8 to 34.4. At the end of the study, 95% of participants on this severe carbohydrate restriction reduced or eliminated their diabetes medications.

That was only after 6 months. Note that the ending BMI was still quite well into the obese range. Imagine what another 6-12 months would do, or achieving BMI somewhere closer to ideal.

Curiously, this idea of severe low-carbohydrate restriction to cure or minimize diabetes is not new. Sir William Osler, one of the founders of Johns Hopkins Hospital and author of the longstanding authoritative text, Principles and Practice of Medicine, advocated an diet identical to Dr. Westman's diet. So did Dr. Frederick Banting, discoverer of the pancreatic extract, insulin, to treat childhood diabetics. Before insulin, Banting and his colleagues at the University of Toronto used carbohydrate elimination (less than 10 g per day) to prolong the lives of children with diabetes.

This lesson was also learned many times during war time, when staples like bread were unavailable. The Siege of Paris in 1870 yielded cures for diabetes in many (or at least they stopped passing urine that tasted--yes, tasted--sweet and attracted flies), only to have it recur after the siege was over.

These are lessons we will have to relearn. As long as the American Diabetes Association and most physicians continue to advocate a diet of reduced fat, increased carbohydrate that includes plenty of "healthy whole grains," diabetics will continue to be diabetics, taking their insulin and multiple medications while developing neuropathy (nervous system degeneration), nephropathy (kidney disease and failure), atherosclerosis and heart attack, cataracts, and die 8 to 10 years earlier than non-diabetics.

All the while, we've had the combined wisdom from antiquity onwards: Carbohydrates cause diabetes; elimination of carbohydrates cures diabetes.

(This applies, of course, only to adult overweight type 2 diabetics, not type 1 or some of the other variants.)

Comments (71) -

  • Kris @ Health Blog

    3/26/2011 7:20:19 PM |

    It is absolutely ridiculous that doctors don't understand how to cure diabetes with a low-carb diet.

    This is just really basic biochem 101, carbs release insulin, and prolonged excess insulin causes insulin resistance, then diabetes.

    This seems so simple that almost anyone with any small knowledge of biology should understand it, yet the main diabetes experts in the world don't.

    I sometimes wonder if the "experts" don't want to give out simple solutions, since then half of them will eventually be unemployed and they won't be experts anymore. Kind of like how the oil companies obviously don't want us to invent renewable energy sources.

  • Anonymous

    3/26/2011 7:47:36 PM |

    Dr. Davis, just to nitpick for clarity,

    I'm assuming in the second paragraph "reductions in weight loss and HbA1c" is really meant to read "reductions in weight and HbA1c".

  • Jenny

    3/26/2011 8:31:26 PM |

    Sadly, what the studies show is that when these low carb weight
    loss studies are continued past six months, invariably the weight loss stops dead for most participants.

    This is true even in studies where the researchers tested for ketones in urine to ensure that people were eating what they said they were eating. The six month prolonged (and often permanent) stall is a repeatable low carb diet phenomenon.

    My own polls among the low carb community verify this finding. Most people with diabetes will report they easily drop 15-20% of starting weight on a low carb diet but after that weight loss often comes to a complete halt even in my sample population which was made up of people with diabetes who had continued to maintain A1cs in the 5% range.

    There are some lucky people for whom this won't be true, but they are a minority and tend to be male.

    Since they are enthusiastic and vocal you tend to run into them online. The people whose experience is more typical tend to blame themselves and keep quiet.  

    The real benefit of low carb dieting is in how it controls blood sugar. That effect will persist.

    But long term diets of all types, including the low carb diet, downregulate the metabolism in ways that make it progressively harder to lose weight.

    The big problem with posts like this one is that they raise false expectations--if you do well the first six months, a year later wow! That kind of false expectations eventually lead to frustration, feelings of failure, self-blame and almost inevitably diet failure and regain.

    I can't tell you how many people I've seen posting on online support groups who did well for those first six months but ended up crashing off their diets a year later because they couldn't lose any more weight.

    So after 13 years of observing people dieting with the low carb diet, I'm convinced that it's best to start the diet because of the blood sugar benefits--not with the dream of reaching what is all too often an unrealistic weight goal.

    Figure that you'll lose 15-20% of your starting weight (you'll lose more if you are very heavy). Maybe you will be one of the small number of lucky people who do much better, in which case it will be a lovely surprise.

    That way, you won't end up blowing off the diet once weight loss stops at a level where you still are much heavier than you had hoped to be.

  • justdoinglife

    3/26/2011 10:47:22 PM |

    The economics are not right for doctors to cure diseases. Healthy people do not come back until the next disease. Such is life. Doctor should only be paid for cures, when one exists.

    We need to take charge of our own health and stop eating sugar, grains, manufactured oils and eatable products. Get a bit of exercise most days, and live a bit.

    but what do I know

  • Susan

    3/27/2011 12:14:55 AM |

    My perception:  I live in the "Deep South", home of the most obese people in the world.  The frustration for many health care professionals is in the unwillingness of patients to significantly change their diet.  It seems culturally mandated for many people to eat a certain way.  I fear that most obese people in the south would rather take medications than adhere to a diet such as this.  We can hardly blame the health care industry for this.

  • Anonymous

    3/27/2011 1:12:07 AM |

    But what about the normal weight relatively young (41) type two diabetic?  (BMI 24)  Could I lose 20 pounds to be model slim?  Yeah. And I do eat low carb, although not 10 gram low carb.  And I have gotten my Hba1c to 5.4.  But, my insulin is crazy high, I hit 90 at my last glucose challenge.  I think it would be a big help if we acknowledged that diabetes is a SYMPTOM of a variety of related but not identical diseases.  Not everyone ate their way to diabetes, and while diet can totally help control symptoms, for me neither maintaining a proper weight nor controlling my carbs has solved the underlying problem, which seems to be a severe insulin resistance.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/27/2011 1:38:24 AM |

    Might Jenny's observation and Nigel's study reference be reconciled somewhat ? I'll tag on my disclaimer of being unqualified to judge low carb or specific diets; since I've never struggled with weight or diabetes, and am not a doctor.

    The study Nigel linked was done with all Kuwaiti subjects. In that country co-sanguinity in marriage is practised by +/- 54.3 % of Kuwaitis. And 1 in 5 are reported to be diabetic.

    The data is very admirable; my suggestion is that the data trend may not exactly transfer to a modern Caucasian population; which is essentially interbred from migration and war (rape). This may be why Jenny sees a +/- 6 month plateau among her respondents and the co-sanguine Kuwaitis saw changes continue for a year +.

    Genetic poly-morphisms influence fasting glucose (GCK, G6PC2 and MTNR1B), are implicated in Hb1Ac, triglyceride levels, HDL levels & so on. That said, I personally would try the low carb approach if I was diabetic.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/27/2011 1:47:27 AM |

    edit my previous text to read  "... cross-bred from migration ...." instead of inter-bred.

  • Stargazey

    3/27/2011 4:38:41 AM |

    Just personal experience here, but I'm a postmenopausal female and have lost 35% of my starting weight by doing low-carb. I've maintained that loss for four years. My BMI is 21.0.

    For me, the key to reaching goal was the realization that eventually calories start to count. Low-carb has a natural appetite-limiting effect, but it is not a perfect tool. For people like me who have rather robust appetites, it becomes necessary to keep track of carbs for health and calories for weight loss and weight maintenance.

    I wish low-carb weight loss were as quick and easy as Dr. Atkins made it out to be, but it's not. Prescription drugs, thyroid issues and exercise all factor into the equation, but after a certain amount of weight has been lost on low-carb, the sad fact has to be faced: calories count.

  • Peter

    3/27/2011 1:27:27 PM |

    I just read the article on the front page of the American Diabetic Association website where they compared the benefits of a low carb vs. low fat diet for diabetics, and they said the big advantage of the low carb diet was you can reduce or eliminate insulin.  It seems like this idea is getting more and more respect from mainstream medicine.

  • Gretchen

    3/27/2011 3:33:59 PM |

    I agree with Jenny that it's cruel to promise people that their diabetes will be "cured" by ANY treatment, including drugs, diet, exercise, or a combination of the above.

    It sets up unrealistic goals and is equivalent to the nurse who tells obese people that if they'd just lose 10 pounds their diabetes would "go away."

    It's simply not true. Type 2 diabetes is caused by faulty insulin-producing beta cells as well as insulin resistance, and that is often genetic.

    Some people in very early stages of diabetes, when they're still producing a lot of insulin, can return to near-normal blood sugar levels with various regimens. Low carbing is one.

    But if those people resume eating carbs, their blood sugars will go into diabetic ranges. They're not cured. They're just well controlled.

    I have type 2 and I'm on a LC diet to control blood sugar, but I also take metformin and inject a basal insulin once a day or my blood sugars will be higher (I'm not comfortable with fasting or premeal numbers over 100, which they can be without the insulin).

    I was diagnosed in late stage of type 2, and nothing we know about today will bring my beta cells back.

    Please don't promise people false cures.

  • Geoffrey Levens

    3/27/2011 4:05:14 PM |

    Anon posted "But what about the normal weight relatively young (41) type two diabetic? (BMI 24) Could I lose 20 pounds to be model slim? Yeah. And I do eat low carb, although not 10 gram low carb. And I have gotten my Hba1c to 5.4. But, my insulin is crazy high, I hit 90 at my last glucose challenge."

    Just sounds like insulin resistance to me.  Some causes are transient fat in blood stream from high fat meals (In my experience in my body, saturated fat is more of a culprit than unsaturated by a very large measure), excess body fat and lack of muscle (lots of people are what I call "skinny fat").  Low carb diet, in one sense bypasses the problem since w/ low carb you don't produce much blood sugar load at once so the insulin resistance makes little difference.

  • Geoffrey Levens

    3/27/2011 4:10:26 PM |

    I had fairly high postprandial readings (175-180's at one hour) and rising A1c.  Low carb per Bernstein made me feel terrible and worse the longer I did it though it did lower my sugar readings dramatically.  Now I eat a very high carb diet and about 30% fat (from whole, raw, seeds and nuts) but all the carbs are in high fiber veg and fruits and beans (with their resistant starch component)(occasional starchy veg and rarely whole grains NOT flour) and my one hour postprandials are in low 120's to teens and my most recent A1c was 4.7

  • Lori Miller

    3/27/2011 4:49:39 PM |

    My mother is a type 2, overweight diabetic. She's been helped tremendously by Dr. Davis's advice to eat low-carb and avoid wheat. But even on a VLC diet, her fasting blood sugar is typically in the 120s. Her diabetes was uncontrolled for 20 years, and her blood sugar was wonky for probably most of her adult life. She's never going to be back to normal.

  • LifeCoachAndy

    3/27/2011 6:05:26 PM |

    Excerpt, ' Experiments described in the medical literature have tested the effects of high-fat diets on insulin intolerance. In one study, healthy young medical students were fed a very high fat diet containing egg yolks, heavy cream, and butter, and within two days all of the students had blood sugar levels high enough to be labeled diabetic.1 Complex carbohydrates have been shown to have the opposite effect.

    Again I am not saying that low fat diet will work for everyone, but I think it worth trying, expecially if low car dose not work.

  • LifeCoachAndy

    3/27/2011 6:11:06 PM |

    Sorry my previous post was not posted so do it again,
    I think what people dont understand, that fat reduces insulin sensitivity and effectiveness, so when glucose and fat present inthe blood stream need much more insulin to maintain glucose homeostasis, and in many people even hyperinsulinaemia cannot compensate. Listen a few interviews with Dr. Delgado, dr. McDougle they explain it more clearly. When you keep your fat intake under 10%, the insulin is much more sensitive , sure you need to eat whole grain, proper carbs, and not junk cereals, breatds etc.
    However, low carb diet works when people restict carbs, so they are able to maintai low blood glucose,  but once they consume more carbs,  blood sugar goes sky high.

    Moreover, in some studies, has been shown, that when people eat fat diet, even pure sugar does not cause glucose spikes, as it is immediately regulated by insulin. , here i do not advocate eating sugar.
    Another study Hollenbeck C, Doner CC, Williams RA, Reaven GM. The effects of variations in percent of naturally occurring complex and simple carbohydrates on plasma glucose and insulin response in individuals with non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus. Diabetes 1985; 34:151.

  • Darrell D.

    3/27/2011 8:48:06 PM |

    http://www.joe-cannon.com/home/wp/can-type-ii-diabetes-be-cured/comment-page-1/#comment-1394

    "I make the bold statement that type II diabetes can be cured because I care and I desperately want people to know the facts about type II diabetes that few people appear to have ever been told. I want people to know:

    "1. Type II diabetes will go away -and stay away – in most people who take care of their health.

    "2. Most people don’t have to get type II diabetes. Most type II diabetes is environmental  (eating too much and exercising too little).

    "3. Losing a little weight and getting some exercise every day – even 20 minutes a day – can make profound changes not only on type II diabetes, but how long that diabetic lives."

    Apparently Joe Cannon, personal trainer, whom I quote, believes most type 2s can be cured. Through 12 years of diabetes, type 2, I have exercised by ass off. I went from the typical ADA advice which didn't work for several years, to following Protein Power which brought management, to Dr. Berstein, which brought more and better management but didn't cure it. Found Dr. Davis's web site about 2 years ago and have been reading every post, becoming increasing radical in my approach. Dropped the steel cuts oats, added niacin, fish oil, you name it, I did it. Just ordered Dr. Ron Rosedale Diet because he says  diabetes can be cured in most cases. Okay, which radical approach is going to cure diabetes? I am one of your readers that is taking your words in your blog as a personal challenge. And I'm taking the personal trainer to task as well. I expect to be cured in six months (and am devoting six months to do that!) I expect you to continue to give fabuous advice, and as your experiment of one, I expect this to happen. I now have adopted the theme: "Diabetes is the Terminator"--it canot be reasoned with, doesn't show pity, and absolutely will not stop until you are dead!" Sorry if I sound desperate, but some of us are taking your words to heart!

  • Anonymous

    3/27/2011 10:49:45 PM |

    Type 2 diabetes will rise and rise until people stop overeating. I see it around me everyday. Obese friends/relatives. For the last 20 years I'v watched them live an unhealthy lifestyle. Now it is catching up on them. One relative, age 48 type 2 diabetic, and one friend diagnosed last year. Age 52. Both have not changed their diet since diagnosis. Each carries an average of 60 extra pounds.
    They were given nutritional guidance from a dietician, and I gave them websites to check out. Neither is interested in changing their lifestyle.

    They refuse to change. Period. I'm sure there are thousands more like them out there......

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/28/2011 3:51:02 AM |

    Fat is not all the same or always acting as we think. An unusual poly-petptide in the intestine is upregulated by fat; and it follows a diurnal rhythm (inactive at night).

    After "fasting" in response to
    the first meal the body synthesizes bile acids for digestion of fat intake. When their litocholic and chono-de-oxy-cholic acids hit the small intestine they
    interact with bile's Farnesoid X Receptor. This  upregulates Fibroblast Growth Factor 19 (FGF 19) in the intestines.

    FGF 19 cycle is at maximum 1.5 to 2 hours after the post-prandial bile production kicked off; and bile synthesis had largely came on and abated. If the breakfast had no fat content then FGF 19's "on" trigger of specific bile acids can be low.

    FGF 19 for it's part acts somewhat like a hormone; it integrates into a feed back loop. Humans have at least 22 different types of FGF with distinct action.

    FGF 19 acts in turn to upregulate the anti-diabetic protein Insulin-like Growth Factor BP2. So there is less insulin resistance and blood glucose levels drop.

    FGF 19 accelerates adaptive thermogenesis by  upregulating Uncoupling Protein 1 (UCP 1); the mitochondria energy gets "spilled" as heat. This makes the metabolic rate go higher and fatty acids are oxidized for energy.

    Weight gain from fat is, in this scenario, less; but mostly from less liver cell fat. There is increased fatty acid oxidation burning for useful energy, since the mitochondria energy supply shifted from ATP delivery.

  • revelo

    3/28/2011 4:05:23 AM |

    "Carbohydrates cause diabetes; elimination of carbohydrates cures diabetes."

    "Type 2 diabetes will rise and rise until people stop overeating."

    Stupid slogans like the above just confuse what is already a complex issue. To reiterate what has been said so many time, we have plenty of evidence of societies where carbs make up 65% or more of daily calories, but those societies show little obesity, diabetes, or heart disease, and they show long-life expectancy. The Japanese are a fine example of a developed society which eats a carb-based diet, and refined carbs at that, but doesn't have a diabetes epidemic. Clearly, carbs is NOT the problem.

    And just as clearly, plenty of fat type II diabetics want to lose weight, but they can't. It is perfectly realistic to ask people to suffer hunger for a few months while getting down to normal weight. What is not realistic is asking them to suffer for the rest of their lives. So the real question is, why is causing people to have such huge appetites? And that is not an easy question to answer.

    I grew up in the 1960's and everyone then was eating plenty of refined wheat, sugar and partially-hydrogenated vegetable oils, but people weren't fat like they are nowadays. Perhaps the manufacturers of processed foods have simply gotten much better at arranging fat, sugar and salt so as to make food irresistible. Perhaps it is a cultural thing: the same media brainwashing that has everyone wanting to supersize their house (McMansions) and car (SUV's) has them wanting to supersize their bodies as well. Perhaps the tendency towards obesity started after WWII, when food finally became cheap, and it simply took several generations for people to get accustomed to the idea of eating as much as they want, instead of treating food like something valuable not to be wasted. (Ever heard the expression "puts meat on the table?" Yes, there really was a time when an hour of labor at minimum wage didn't buy that much meat.)

    If there is a magic bullet to the diabetes epidemic, it will have to do with appetite suppression. My impression, based on my own experiences and observations of people around me, is that low-fat/high-carb is more effective in the long-run at curbing appetite than low-carb/high-fat, at least for most people. In other words, the convention wisdom is right.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/28/2011 5:37:28 AM |

    Japan obesity (BMI > 30 kg/m2) in 1990 - 1994  was nationally 3%. Japan statistic then for the overweight (BMI = 25 - 29 kg/m2) was 24% of men and 20% of women.

    Adults were over weight 4 times more than they were in 1960 statistics; and mostly in the rural population. The 1994 school children (age 6 to 14) had 5 - 11 % obesity.

    Data is from my notes (source was a Japanese translation) and I haven't looked up current statistics. Those 1994 obese school kids are all adults now
    of course.

    A recent analysis suggests that the lowest rate of death in East Asians (Japan, China, Korea) is for those with BMI of 22.6 to 27.5. This is similar to the European Prospective Studies Collaboration data of BMI = 23 - 27 as having least death risk in Caucasians.  

    In obese East Asians with BMI >35the risk of death was 1.5 times greater. However, those with a BMI of 15, or less, saw their risk factor go up by 2.8 times. In those with super low BMI the theory is underlying co-morbidity is involved, like respiratory disease.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/28/2011 6:26:37 AM |

    Coconut (like Doc's header image) has a  long 12:0 chain of lauric acid in it's fat that contributes to food satiety. It upregulates Glucagon-like Peptide 1 (GLP 1) release in the intestines.

    GLP1 is secreted in the endocrino-cyte "L" cells and is one of the hormone group called incretins; some GLP is also active in the brain. GLP 1 inhibits gastric secretion, gastric emptying and digestive secretion from the pancreas.

    It does enhance the release of insulin, which in this scenario
    (GLP 1 activated) occurs in the context of slowed digestion; so blood sugar drops in real time. GLP 1 also stymies the release of glycogen (stored liver glucose) and the body is driven to burn something else.

    GLP 1 does not provoke hypo-glycemia; the body burns it's fatty acids to run on. In fact if the individual does NOT graze between meals the satiation potential of coconut oil can work for up to 1.5 days worth of meals.

    It seems coconut's lauric acid fat works on GLP 1 with a timed phase that also kicks in +/- 3 hours after a meal. This has the affect of getting some insulin out to sweep away the blood glucose and force the body to burn fatty acids.

    Coconut's effect was greater than that of other fats; like milk fat, linoleic acid,stearic acid and oleic acid. Palm oil is more similarly satiating to coconut oil than other those other fats.

    I detail this as a suggestion how dieters can keep the weight they lost off. Read Doc's old posts and you will see his objection to "grazing" food between meals; it supplants the GLP 1 surge benefits.

    Here is a closing observation to amplify what others have infered. When western packaged foods switched out of palm and coconut oil shoppers lost the strongest activators of GLP1. Obesity from over eating got worse as we snacked up calories that sneak up on the waistline.

  • justdoinglife

    3/28/2011 7:43:52 AM |

    It is normal for people to overeat when food is readily available. That is a biological characteristic that has aided survival. We live in a time of excess. We need to learn to live normal in a abnormal world.

    I try to do that by avoiding sugar, grain, manufactured oils and other eatable products.

    but what do I know

  • Stargazey

    3/28/2011 2:07:25 PM |

    Might-o'chondri-AL, thanks for that mini-treatise on coconut oil. Lately I have been eating two tablespoons of coconut oil for breakfast as part of my weight maintenance program. I have noticed that the coconut oil is able to produce satiety as well as lower my blood sugar, but I had no idea why it worked.

  • Anonymous

    3/28/2011 2:39:14 PM |

    Some folks are very sensitive.  Control is probably a better word than cure, but the message is the same.  Low carb helps many folks with their blood sugar which is what seems to be so damaging.  It almost seems as though some cannot see beyond their own world views ("it isn't anyone's fault other than some medical-industrial complex", paraphrasing) when presented with evidence that INDIVIDUALS can help themselves, though some choose not to.

  • Lyford

    3/28/2011 3:40:49 PM |

    "Cure" implies that you no longer have diabetes, that you can eat whatever whenever and maintain normal blood sugars.  For almost everyone diagnosed as diabetic, that's not ever going to happen.  

    Diabetes -> High blood sugar -> complications

    You cannot change condition one - if you're diabetic, you're diabetic.  You can't really do much with link two - high blood sugar is going to cause complications in everyone who isn't killed by something else first.  But many type 2 diabetics can break link 1 and maintain normal blood sugars by limiting (or effectively eliminating) the amount of carbohydrate in their diets.

    But "cure" is definitely the wrong word to use.

  • Helen

    3/28/2011 9:39:20 PM |

    This is an interesting discussion.  Like "Anonymous" who is a young diabetic with a BMI of 24, I didn't eat my way into diabetes, and if I could eat my way out of it, I would have by now.  

    To M-Al and proponents of both low-carb and low-fat approaches, my experience tells me that type II diabetes is definitely NOT one disease, and (I'm getting to be a broken record on this forum I'm afraid) therefore the best regimen for control won't be the same for each person.  I do believe that many diabetics benefit from low-carb, and some from low-fat.  I suspect you will find refugees from one diet in the forums of the other - e.g., people for whom one alternative didn't work.

    One thing you probably can't do as a diabetic is eat both fats and carbs. And diabetes is so complex - a research article I read said that many diabetics seem to have disturbed lipid *and* carbohydrate metabolisms.  So where do you go from there?  Plus, you just dump sugar from your liver for no good reason, regardless.  This is why many diabetics (most?) will need to add medications to their diet and exercise routines.

    To commenters saying things like, "I know why there's diabetes - everyone's eating too much":

    Look at all of us: we're on a health blog.  We all have in common an unusual interest in health matters.  The fact that some people not reading this blog do not want to change their habits doesn't make it okay to blame diabetics for their disease.   Easy for you to say if it hasn't happened to you.

  • Gabriella Kadar

    3/28/2011 11:07:45 PM |

    What people do not take into consideration is that blood glucose is not dependant solely on dietary intake.  The liver dumps glucose into the blood stream in response to catecholamines.  Beta cells do not respond to endogenously produced glucose.  Glucose not utilized by the brain and the skeletal muscles will circulate for long periods of time.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/29/2011 12:34:52 AM |

    Hi Helen,
    Me, for my part, am just trying to examine the science of what Doc says works. It intrigues me, as do your comments.

    Whatever the causes of insulin resistance it starts unnoticed. The pancreas cells that should respond to circulating glucose go awry.

    Beta cells don't polarize their
    mitochondria membranes in the "normal" response to blood sugar (for many reasons, as you say).The Potassium ( K+) Channel is ruled by ATP and is unable to perform it's K+ channel function; it closes up for those people. (Mitochondria in other tissue can still be functioning normally.)

    So that Beta cell's mitochondrial
    Calcium ( Ca++) Channel gets a disorganized electrical charge. The Ca++ can't reach the triggering level the islet
    cell needs to put out insulin.

    A rhythmic swinging of Ca++ between the cell's mitochondria and that cell's cytoplasm (interior) is what sustains "normal" insulin activity. Why this happens, when and to whom is as you say  variable.

    First comes that pancreatic
    islet Beta cell mal-function, which instigates body's
    insulin resistance and then that
    individual shows symptom of hyper-glycemia (high blood sugar). If that kind of Beta cells' mitochondria mis-step (detailed above)is happening when someone's body tries
    to respond to blood glucose Doc's carbohydrate restriction is logical (to me).

    Insulin resistance apparently starts for adults long before blood glucose tests indicate
    even "pre-diabetes"; by age 60 +/-  1 in 5 will become Type II diabetic in the U.S.A. It seems with age our Beta cell mitochondria get out of whack and what we got away with in youth is not going to last forever.

    Genetic, epi-genetic and age are part of the disease progression; diabetes is a process, not a static condition over time. Abnormal Beta cell workings can lead to improper protein structure of the insulin molecule itself.

    This afflicts the Endoplasmic Reticulum (ER)where proteins are supposed to be appropriately folded. The erroneous protein configurations trigger the cell to "opt" for pre-programmed death (apoptosis, kind of like cell "suicide").

    That apoptosis is what eventually
    causes the diminished number of Beta cells in Type II diabetes.
    Early on Type II diabetics are not neccessarily suffering from dying Beta cells, or even always shrunken (atrophied) ones.

    Once the Type II diabetic's Beta cells die, then they suffer irreversable insulin insufficiency. That person has no response to hyper-glycemia and again Doc's regimen makes sense (and,I think he alluded to
    adding prescription diabetes drugs in certain individual cases).

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/29/2011 1:29:59 AM |

    Anon about typo: Thanks for catching that. Now fixed.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/29/2011 1:33:27 AM |

    Hi, Jenny--

    Thanks, as always, for your insights.

    However, I am witnessing something different. I see 30, 40, 70, 80, 100 lbs of weight loss, followed by profound reversals of diabetes and all its associated measures.

    I suspect that many of the people you are talking to are not really following the diet that has the potential, in most diabetics but not in all as you well know, to completely reverse diabetes. It is a matter of the intensity of diet, the long-term commitment, and knowing what feedback tools to monitor.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/29/2011 1:33:49 AM |

    Just doing--

    Well said!

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/29/2011 1:36:24 AM |

    Gretchen--

    Same response as that to Jenny.

    I was diabetic 20 years ago. No longer. I have a long list of former diabetics. It ain't that tough.

    There are indeed people who are physiologically incapable of reversing or ending diabetes. Jenny's LADA, for instance, can only be minimized, not completely reversed.

    But, as much as I respect the opinions of both of you very sophisticated ladies, I disagree with you on this issue. In fact, I would crudely estimate that 70-80% of all current diabetics, with the proper insight and information, can completely rid themselves of diabetes. This is no false hope.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/29/2011 1:42:12 AM |

    Revelo--

    You are venturing very close to my Zero Tolerance Policy for rude behavior. Nonetheless, you often have insightful comments, so I'll let this one pass.

    Having done this in many patients, I can tell you it works in many, perhaps most, thought not all. There are too many paths to this place called diabetes, variable residual beta cell function, variable leptin status, variable adiponectin status, varying apo E status, etc. to allow 100% generalizations.

    The important lesson here is that MANY people, me included, who can kiss diabetes goodbye.

    Incidentally, I made myself diabetic 20 years ago eating low-fat, high- carb while jogging 5 miles a day.

  • Rick

    3/29/2011 1:54:54 AM |

    Another typo? About the paper you link to, is about a "small experience" or a "small experiment"?

  • Stargazey

    3/29/2011 2:40:14 AM |

    Just to be argumentative Smile

    Dr. Davis, if you are no longer diabetic, how could you start with a blood sugar of 84 mg/dl, eat 4 ounces of whole wheat bread, and then have a blood sugar of 167 mg/dl one hour later?

    In search of wheat: Einkorn and blood sugar

    I'm not a physician, but a postprandial blood sugar of 167 might indicate that your diabetes has not been cured.

  • PJNOIR

    3/29/2011 7:27:14 AM |

    after losing 70 lbs, even at 6:2 225 lbs, I was still in the Obese category.  I am not a bigbfan of one size fits all number ranges.  

    btw:  funny how it is the last ten lbs as if the number is the same. most low crabbers lie about their REAL carb intake.. We forget how quickly they add up.  


    Calories do NOT count.

    better the last ten is harder than the first fifty.

  • PJNOIR

    3/29/2011 7:35:36 AM |

    GRAND control but no cure.

  • Gretchen

    3/29/2011 1:29:19 PM |

    'I see 30, 40, 70, 80, 100 lbs of weight loss, followed by profound reversals of diabetes and all its associated measures."

    Dr Davis, with all due respect, if I lost 100 pounds, I'd weigh 20 pounds, which doesn't sound very appealing to me.

    As I noted, *people who are diagnosed in early stages of diabetes when they're still producing a lot of insulin* can go into remission with any kind of weight loss diet. These are the patients you're seeing.

    But they're not CURED. If they regain the weight, they'll have the same problems again.

    And people who aren't grossly overweight when diagnosed can't even go into remission by reducing carbs and giving up wheat. There are many many reports of this on the discussion boards and the anger the patients feel because medical people promised them something that didn't happen. They lose faith in doctors and try all kinds of alternative treatments, some of which could be dangerous.

    I think it's fine to tell patients that they MAY find that the weight loss puts them into remission. But to tell them that any diet will cure their diabetes is cruel, IMHO.

    If you had diabetes 20 years ago, then you still have it. Nondiabetics can be grossly overweight and maintain normal blood sugar levels. Some very obese people aren't even very insulin resistant.

    Human physiology is complex, and simplistic slogans (it used to be "fat makes you fat") are misleading.

    (BTW, Jenny is MODY, not LADA).

  • Gretchen

    3/29/2011 3:06:24 PM |

    I thought of an analogy: Someone is alcoholic. He gets counseling and gives up alcohol. Is he no longer alcoholic?

    I don't think so. Nonalcoholics can have one or two drinks and stop. He can't. He's controlled, but not cured.

    A lot of this controversy involves definitions. If you define "diabetes" as an A1c in the 4s, which is found in truly healthy young people, then if you get your A1c down that low with diet, you're not diabetic.

    But if you define diabetes as an inability to eat a lot of carbohydrate without going over 120 mg/dL, then you could have a low A1c on a low-carb diet and still be diabetic.

    Here are some quotes from lists from people who tested nondiabetic relatives:

    "My non-diabetic husband has never tested above 4.7 (85) and I've tested him a few times 1 and 2 hrs after amazing carb loads - 200g plus in 1 meal. Once after a Christmas dinner with 2 desserts (one dessert was sugar pie) and once after a pasta+white bread+dessert meal. After gigantic amounts of pancakes and gobs of maple syrup. He stays pretty much rock-steady."

    "I took my glucometer down for Thanksgiving and tested everyone an hour and two hours after the big meal with potatoes and pies etc. My brother in law's BG was only 82!"  and "I did the same thing with my siblings...including a sister who is close to 400 pounds. She was 84, my other sis who is about 220 lb was 75 and my brother who is thin was 100."

    It's not just weight.

    I don't like to argue about this, because I think you're doing a lot of good by urging people to cut carbs. But I think we need to face facts. Weight is an important factor, but not the primary cause of diabetes.

  • Anonymous

    3/29/2011 3:45:45 PM |

    I think that Grtchen's comment sums it up well. Dr Davis is a cardiologist. He also has a strong interest in nutrition and its impact on cardiovascular health. He is not an endocrinologist. And this shows in many of his comments regarding diabetes.

  • semsons.group

    3/29/2011 5:11:37 PM |

    Stargazey,

      I'm not diabetic, neither my wife, both of use can get 170 mg/dl after a vegetable sandwich with white bread. So, from my perspective your comment does not make much sense.

  • Alex

    3/29/2011 6:23:02 PM |

    Seems to me that low carb with elimination of grains and fructose would be a necessity for anybody with impaired glucose tolerance or diabetes.  Depending on how bad your insulin sensitivity is, you may have to switch from saturated fat to mono-unsaturated as well.  Add an hour a day of physical activity and I expect a significant percentage of diabetics/prediabetics will be off their meds.  The others will hopefully at least stabilize and not get worse.  Are they "cured"?  Not exactly...they still can't eat all that sugary stuff we all like to eat.
    But here's how I look at it.  Maybe they were never "sick" to begin with.  Maybe they were just poisoning themselves with foods they were never adapted to eat. After prolonged and sustained exposure to these poisons they got sick. Remove the poison and they no longer have the "disease" of diabetes.  I wonder what percentage of diabetics this definition of "disease" might apply to?

  • rhc

    3/29/2011 6:53:47 PM |

    @GeoffreyLevens
    I would be interested in how much exercise you do along with your diet to keep your bloodsuger (and A1C) that low.

  • PJNOIR

    3/29/2011 8:28:06 PM |

    exercise has little positive effect on blood sugar in the short term, in fact, in early efforts to control my numbers without meds, exercise would increase BS numbers after excerise. But in the long term, as a means to repair the body, it is very positive with diet.

  • Anonymous

    3/29/2011 9:17:43 PM |

    I find that exercise is a significant way to control blood sugar level. For me, a 30-min brisk walk (breathing hard at end) will reduce a 150+ blood sugar to under 125 mg/dL.
    I have found that the time of day for exercise is important. Physiologically we release glucose from liver glycogen prior to and on wake-up, preping our metabolism for activity so to speak. With increasing insulin resistance blood sugar will rise from the released glucose. Blood sugar is controlled by the insulin release in nondiabetics. Diabetics and the insulin resistant, can verify this with a series of fasting morning sugar checks, say on rising every 20 mins for an hour. By the way, this is known as the "dawn effect". For diabetics, the effect seems to be compounded with rigorous morning exercise. Exercise later in the day does not seem cause a problem. I had to go low carb (reducing stored hepatic glycogen) to reduce this natural response.
    This is my experience, and I am a DMT2. Be curious to hear about impact of exercise from you non-diabetic types.

    semsons.group: You may not consider yourself a "diabetic" but hitting a one-hour postprandial blood sugar of 170 after eating a sandwich is not healthy. Increased postprandial blood sugar levels is a sign of possible insulin resistance and a prediabetic condition.
    Continuous glucose monitoring studies show that for healthy individuals blood sugar rarely rises over 130 mg/dL and then only briefly during a 24-hour period. It is generally beleieved that blood sugar levels over 140 mg/dL are harmful.

  • Dr. William Davis

    3/29/2011 10:19:17 PM |

    I use the term "cure" loosely. "Latent" would be a better term.

    Personally, I run HbA1cs of around 4.7%, fasting glucose below 90 mg/dl, and postprandial glucoses of less than 100 mg/dl. In other words, no diabetes.

    However, if I have whole grain bread, cookies, and pretzels, I will be fully diabetic in short order, especially if I gain weight.

    I've seen this played out many, many times.

  • Stargazey

    3/29/2011 11:26:16 PM |

    Thanks, Dr. Davis. I suspected that might be the case.

    On a related topic, semsons.group and his wife may wish to avoid vegetable sandwiches with white bread.

  • Gretchen

    3/30/2011 1:01:46 AM |

    Dr Davis, thanks for clarifying your terminology. The reason I'm so adamant about avoiding the word "cure" is the following.

    I knew a man who was Dx'd with type 2. He did all the right things and got his BGs into normal ranges. So he thought he was cured and stopped testing. Nondiabetics don't test, and he was cured and nondiabetic, right?

    Then he had a piece of cake for his birthday. It was pretty good. Soon he was having cake every Sunday. Then every day. Then he forgot about the diet altogether. He was cured, right?

    One day he noticed he was thirsty all the time and decided to test. His BG was in the 400s or 500s. He wasn't worried. He knew what to do and went back to the diet that "cured" him before.

    Only this time it didn't work. He'd burned out his beta cells with high glucose. And he had to start injecting insulin.

    If instead of being told he was cured, he'd been told he was in remission but still had to be careful, he might have tested and discovered the problems before they were irreversible.

    This also illustrates the benefit of early diagnosis. If you wait too long, the condition may become irreversible no matter how strict your diet.

  • Lori Miller

    3/30/2011 1:59:12 AM |

    A difference between Dr. Davis's patients and typical low-carb dieters is that the patients may be taking more supplements of the right kind. There's a whole school of thought that overweight is caused by lack of nutrients, especially minerals. I believe that whacking out the empty, carby calories is important, but I also believe you need vitamins and minerals to metabolize fat--including your own fat. It's often forgotten that Dr. Atkins recommended supplements, and even wrote a book on the subject.

    In some studies I've seen, low-carb dieters were allowed, over time, to go back to eating more and more carb. (I'm sure this happens sometimes in real life, too.) Naturally, they stopped losing weight.

  • Anonymous

    3/30/2011 2:39:32 AM |

    Has anyone used supplements like lipoic acid ? (The R version is supposedly superior). It is used in Germany as a treatment in diabetes.

  • Anonymous

    3/30/2011 4:19:26 AM |

    Revelo: No, my comments are not stupid. I have yet to see a Type 2 diabetic within their normal weight range, AND eating healthy. I am surrounded by fat relatives/co-workers who live on highly processed boxed packaged foods, morning, day, and night at home and work place.  

    Myself and only 2 others bring our lunch to work from home, the rest on a daily basis eat out at Taco bell, Burger King, Pizza Hut, MsDonalds, etc. Now imagine doing this again for dinner??

    How much more can your body take of this diet before you become a DIABETIC?? I see it day in and day out before my eyes people eating themselves into Type II Diabetes.

  • Megaera

    3/30/2011 4:37:09 AM |

    Interesting: when Jenny points out that a theory applied doesn't actually work, the response isn't, "hm, perhaps the theory isn't right..." it's, "Well, then you have to be doing it wrong."  So, if I go on a rigorously-applied low-carb diet (no grains of any kind, no vegetable starches, limited fruits, no juices, fats being animal and EVOO only, and I STILL don't lose even a single pound despite cycling 20+ miles per day, Dr. Davis will unblushingly inform me that it's my fault, it's not that there's something wrong with the theory.  This is the case, by the way -- been doing this as a test since January. FWIW, my blood sugar, which before January, was typically 80 or so in the morning is now 120+, as often as not.  I'm not impressed with the results of this "health" approach, which hasn't changed even one of my health issues for the better, and appears to have worsened several rather significantly.

  • PJNOIR

    3/30/2011 12:15:09 PM |

    Meg:  Not a single pound?   Then something is very unusual.  Many of us know Jenny and her work and are familiar with her POVs. But not a single pound and claims of worse health leaves many of us speechless, What in the world would one expect to hear on an internet forum?  


    Annom-  I have used R  acid large doses twice a day. I cannot say that it worked by itself. I stopped when money got tight and didn't start again. It was a part of many things I was doing at a time when I was having my best results away from using any meds. I am thinking of going back to it and a few other things.

    As for exercise, only heavy lifting, strength training had any effect on my BS numbers on the short term. Walks and aerobics increased the numbers.  Type II is different for all of us. My best numbers are when I wake up and at night. go figure.

  • Helen

    3/30/2011 1:15:56 PM |

    To Anonymous, who said:

    "Revelo: No, my comments are not stupid. I have yet to see a Type 2 diabetic within their normal weight range, AND eating healthy. I am surrounded by fat relatives/co-workers who live on highly processed boxed packaged foods, morning, day, and night at home and work place."

    Well, then you have yet to meet me.  And my father-in-law.  Your tone is very judgmental and your comments uninformed.  About 1/4 of type II diabetics are not overweight.  I have always eaten healthfully - people are always commenting on it, and now they say, "Diabetes - you?"

    On the other hand, most obese people do not have diabetes, even though they may have other health problems.  Diabetes can be triggered by a poor diet and overweight, which lead to insulin resistance, but you have to have other, usually genetic, risk factors to develop diabetes.

  • Gretchen

    3/30/2011 1:16:01 PM |

    Anonymous, I once gave a talk to a local diabetes group. What really impressed me was that there were very few obese people in the audience. One man with a "beer belly," but most were post middle age women, not skinny, but not fat. Some were thin.

    I find it sad when people blame the victims. I think it's a form of self-protection. "Well, I don't do those things, so I'll never get disease X."

    I know a lot of people with diabetes who eat healthy diets, but I live in a rural area where most of us have vegetable gardens and some raise animals for meat as I used to.

    When you work in an urban area where everyone else in the office goes to fast food places for meals (I once noticed there was nothing but fast food available in the Harvard Medical School area and I wondered if they were trying to drum up business), it's difficult to be different, especially if you're the only one. Lots of peer pressure. People hate "holier than thou" eaters.

    I recently heard a talk on obesity by Jeffrey Friedman, who discovered leptin. He said many people think obesity is caused by gluttony and sloth, adding that "this view is mostly espoused by thin people." He thinks genetics has a very large role.

    Anonymous, have some compassion and have the courage to use your real name.

  • Helen

    3/30/2011 1:17:05 PM |

    Megeara, I have had a similar experience, although I did lose weight on low-carb.  It may be that this diet simply isn't compatible with your particular genetic profile and how you handle lipids and carbs.  Try some other approaches, keep checking your blood sugar, and see what works best for you.

    By the way, I find that supplemental fish oil and also vitamin C drive my blood sugar up.  (Both of these personal experience were backed up by research, I discovered.)  Check out if any supplements you are taking might be driving your numbers up.

  • Stargazey

    3/30/2011 1:41:24 PM |

    Megaera--just a thought--are you doing anything close to zero-carb? For some reason, in people over 50 a zero-carb diet can cause elevated blood sugar.

    I tried a zero-carb diet a couple of years ago, thinking it would help me lose weight and stave off diabetes. Instead, I gained weight and my fasting blood sugars went above 100 mg/dl for the first time in my life. I surveyed a bunch of people at my blog and found that those over 50 had similar experiences. (Google: Stargazey Observations on Protein Intake, if you want to read about it.)

  • CarbSane

    3/30/2011 3:28:04 PM |

    I tend to agree with what Stargazey is getting at here and Dr. Davis has since rephrased:  VLC is not a cure for diabetes.  VLC is clearly one way of managing one of the major symptoms implicated in health risks associated with diabetes (e.g. hyperglycemia -> glycation).  

    However, eating VLC does not cure diabetes, which at its core is pancreatic beta cell dysfunction.  Indeed it seems it can exacerbate the dysfunction as illustrated by the anecdotal evidence (don't like it but we have no real studies on this that I am aware of) that long term low carbers become more and more sensitive to any carb in the diet = worsening glycemic control.  

    A normal person can handle quite the glucose excursion and mounts an appropriate insulin response to handle it.  A diabetic cannot handle this, and neither can VLC'ers or the advice to carb up with 150g/day for several days in advance of an OGTT would not be circulating around the web.

    Can diabetes be cured?  Well, apparently yes.  I'm not suggesting gastric bypass surgery, but the remission rate - as in cessation of meds and "passing" an OGTT - is remarkable in morbidly obese diabetics undergoing the procedure.  In the 80-85% range in a matter of days/weeks prior to significant weight loss.  

    This tells me that our beta cells are remarkably more resilient than we give them credit for - we're talking some of the most deranged metabolisms snapping back to "normal" relatively quickly.

    In the short run, especially in IR obese and with weight loss, low carb generally seems to be a more successful approach.  But long term, more moderate approaches with higher carb and lower fat intake seem to be better, especially once compliance is taken to account.  

    (In Westman, after randomized assignments of 97 participants, 10 of those who drew the LCKD diet didn't show up to do the study, while only 3 of the LGID did.  So they started with 38 and 46 respectively.  Of these 5 KD's dropped out for refusal/dissatisfa41%ction with the diet while only 2 dropped out of GI diet.  17 total dropped from each group.  So from assignment to completion,  27/48 = 56% of screened recruits effectively dropped the LCKD while only 20/49 = 41% dropped out of LGID.  This can definitely impact results.  And the post-6 month rebound is common in longer term studies.)

    The results in the 2 year Shai study for example:  http://carbsanity.blogspot.com/2010/09/shai-and-diabetes.html

    Nuttal's group has achieved some excellent results absent weight loss with their LoBAG diets - high protein (30%) with 20,30 or 40% carb splitting the 70% baby with fat.  http://carbsanity.blogspot.com/2010/09/lobag-diets-for-treatment-of-type-ii.html

    I think Dr. Davis is an example of what Dr. Dansinger (who treats diabetics with a relatively low carb but less extreme version than others) refers to as a "carb cripple".

  • Anonymous

    3/30/2011 3:46:40 PM |

    I use the antioxidant R-lipoic acid as a supplement.
    Daily:  3x 200mg R-Lipoic Acid
    1x 1000 mg Evening Primrose Oil
    1x 1000 mcg Biotin
    As suggested by Richard Bernstein in his book, “Dr. Bernstein's Diabetes Solution: The Complete Guide to Achieving Normal Blood Sugars.” The Evening Primrose Oil provides gamma-linolenic acid (GLA) that is believed to increase the effectiveness of the lipoic acid effect. The biotin replaces the body’s supply consumed in the lipoic reaction.
    The R-isomer is believed to be better utilized than the S-isomer.
    In Germany, R-lipoic acid is used to relieve diabetic peripheral neuropathy, however, the supplement is given intravenously.

    I can not say that it has improved my blood sugar control but I continue to use it more as a “universal antioxidant”, and because of Bernstein’s endorsement. R Bernstein, a type 1 diabetic, is an endocrinologist and one of the original proponents for the use of at-home meters for measuring blood sugar levels in diabetics. He is one of the very early supporters of low carbs for blood sugar control in diabetics. He is in his 70s.

    I am a type 2 diabetic on metformin and low-carbs, maintaining HbA1cs at the low-end of 5%.

    For supplements this is the most expensive one I take. I go back and forth between the Doctors Best and Life Extension products, whatever is cheaper on Amazon at the time.

    Perhaps Jenny/Blood Sugar 101 can add a few more comments …

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/30/2011 6:48:26 PM |

    Very interesting to me here, thanks everyone. Beta cells, in human adults, have their individual life span; they are not replaced from stem cells.

    A few at a time, of the already differentiated, Beta cells duplicate themselves. New ones form and in the absence of hyper-glycemia (high blood sugar) can become larger than their progenitors.

    This might explain how Doc gets latency, CarbSane suggest a "snapping" back, and why standard carbohydrate intake does not always induce diabetes. Each Beta cell has more than one mitochondria in order to sustain it's insulin role.

    Another commentator mentions that as some Type II diabetics age they (diabetics) do better off the low carbohydrate diet. Maybe the very slow time which Beta cells self-duplicate in has reached a good formation (in those individuals) and best to  "use it, or lose it".

    A low carb period gives fresh Beta cells enough of a break from high blood sugar then they can become large. Then that co-hort of Beta cells can follow the "normal" response; which is to get larger in response to  insulin demand from blood sugar (ex: when middle age Type II diabetic does "better" off of a strict low carb diet).

    What stops Beta cell self-duplication in Type I diabetes is the auto-immune T cell "attack". The immune system stymies regeneration.

    In Type II diabetes the inability to prevent toxic exposure side effects can be what impedes Beta cell self-duplication. Distorted  down-stream signal pathways can affect the transcription of a "fledgeling" Beta cell's replication of it's actin cyto-skeleton .

  • Stargazey

    3/30/2011 8:51:34 PM |

    Might-o'chondri-AL, if you don't mind my asking, where do you get all your information? Are you a graduate student, perhaps?

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/30/2011 10:29:42 PM |

    Hi Stargzy,
    I'm "semi-retired" 60 year old who hopes to avoid degeneration as I age. I've been investigating how to live well for over 40 years. Doc's blog appeals to me because he has clinical cases to draw on and good input from his readers.

    When I first began looking into things maintaining health the science was much different. I am just trying to organize my thoughts on contemporary research to preserve my mental capacity.

  • CarbSane

    3/31/2011 12:43:28 PM |

    In the Westman study, it bears noting that the gender and racial make-up of the "completers" - which is all that counts for comparisons - varies considerably between the diet study groups:
    LKCD:  67% female, 67% white, 24% African-American
    LGID:  79% female, 45% white, 52% African-American

    On the "carbohydrates cause diabetes" front, I remain unconvinced.  When one looks at populations who are most susceptible to developing the disease, what does they tell us?  The traditional Pima ate an 80% carb diet and had low diabesity.  Expose to SAD - rates soar.  Japanese in Japan eating traditional diet with lots of rice = low diabesity rates.  Expose to SAD = rates soar.  The SAD is lower in carb by % (generally comes in at 40-45% carb for "usual" diet in studies) than the traditional diets.  So how can we say that carbs cause diabetes?

  • Helen

    3/31/2011 3:53:49 PM |

    I tried to post this before, but it got lost.  

    A question for Dr. Davis:  When you got diabetic blood sugars on a "healthy, whole grain" diet, were you supplementing with niacin and fish oil, which you recommend on your site?  I'm curious, because both are associated with impaired glucose tolerance in type II diabetics, and I have seen the effects of fish oil on my own glucose control.  There's a theory I've read that, while niacin has cardiovascular benefits, which is why you recommend it, food fortification with niacin may be in part responsible for increased rates of diabetes.  

    Is it possible that niacin is beneficial with low-carb, but deleterious with high-carb?

  • revelo

    3/31/2011 5:29:51 PM |

    Sorry for that comment above.

    Afghans (people of Afghanistan) eat a wheat based diet. In fact, wheat bread is almost the entire diet of many of them (and they suffer from iodine deficiency and other problems as a result). But they have little obesity, little diabetes, no problems with insulin-resistance:

    http://maisonneuve.org/pressroom/article/2010/nov/15/the-diseases-affluence/

    Things are more complicated than simply "carbs = bad".

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    3/31/2011 11:03:59 PM |

    Hi Helen,
    Niacin induces vaso-dilation ("flush") from the action of prostaglandins on capillaries Prostaglandins are made from the lipids stashed in our membranes.

    This is how fish oil DHA/EPA (n-3) and poly-unsaturated vegetable oil (n-6) are involved; these can form Arachidonic Acid (AA)for making prostaglandins. Aspirin (salicylic acid) works as an anti-inflammatory because it blocks the AA pathway engendering prostaglandins.

    1876 salicylate was known to decrease diabetic's glucose in their urine. A modern study showed injected salicylate restored acute (ie: 1st) insulin response to glucose in
    10 out of 12 Type II diabetics who were administered prostaglandin.

    For the 2nd insulin phase, with a few gr. glucose challenge, 12 out of 12 Type II diabetics had a 4x increase in their 2nd insulin response (ie: with a
    salicylate booster before glucose administered and having those prostaglandins they got to start the test.)Prostaglandins,
    in Type II diabetics, interfere with insulin response; in the controls the prostaglandins did not blunt the 1st nor the 2nd insulin "pulse" put out.

    Women (some) "flush" from effect of prostaglandins at lower concentrations (ie: less niacin)than men (some). This is believed to be related to estrogen levels; suggesting that
    post-menopausal women should review their original pre-menopausal niacin dose.

    Doc specificly stated no one should take more than 1,500 mg. niacin without medical supervision (ex: liver enzymes
    that monitor inflammation
    tests). Diabetics who see their blood sugar worsen and/or liver
    tests worsen while taking niacin, might be able to find their individual dose that does not induce levels of prostaglandins interfering with insulin phases 1 and/or 2.
    Aspirin, as a salicylate, could be an additional way to block AA (thus prostaglandins)and foster timely insulin secretion for glucose clearance.

  • LifeCoachAndy

    4/2/2011 9:04:52 AM |

    Another latest study showed that carbs and fats do not mix well and results into high blood sugar. YOu need to read the full studyy, to see the whole picture. healthy subjects were given hig fat meal (only fat) in the morning and their glucose and insulin remained at the fasting level for the next 5 hours. Then they were given coffee or nothing and then did glucose challenge. Sugar shut sky high (10 mmol/l ~180sh). Coffein further increases glucose.

    This study again demonstrates that fat even after many outs of eating got negative effect on glucose. If if you eat low carb diet thats ok, but like most peole eat 30-40% energy from fat that leads to disaster.
    'An Oral Lipid Challenge and Acute Intake of Caffeinated Coffee Additively Decrease Glucose Tolerance in Healthy Men ' http://jn.nutrition.org/content/early/2011/02/23/jn.110.132761.abstract

    THis give some explanation why low fat diet work on some ppl.
    Also emaging what wouldve happen if this study was done with diabetics.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/2/2011 4:28:38 PM |

    Hi L/C/Andy,
    Is it more likely that caffeine's classic effect on the adrenals, causing the liver to naturally put glycogen (sugar storage molecule)into circulation, is the reason blood glucose "surged" after coffee? I admit to not having read the study, so this is speculation.

Loading
All posts by william-davis

CRP and Jupiter

What is C-reactive protein (CRP)?

It is a blood-borne protein that originates in the liver and serves as an index of the body's inflammatory state. It is triggered by yet another inflammatory signal molecule, interleukin-6.

What triggers this cascade of inflammatory markers? Any inflammatory stimulus, such as being overweight, lack of exercise, vitamin D deficiency, viral illness no matter how trivial, any inflammatory disease like arthritis, small LDL, high triglycerides, poor diet rich in processed foods, resistance to insulin, any injury, incipient diabetes, hidden cancer, lack of education (no kidding), etc.

In other words, many, many conditions, from trivial to serious, trigger increased inflammatory markers like CRP.

A recent analysis (Genetically elevated C-reactive protein and ischemic vascular disease of persons with genetically elevated levels of CRP) suggests that CRP does not, by itself, cause atherosclerotic disease. CRP is therefore simply a marker for conditions that heighten inflammatory responses.

The AstraZeneca people sponsored the enormous JUPITER study of the statin drug, Crestor, that has been causing a stir, mostly glowing pronouncements of how the world would be a better place if everyone took Crestor.

In JUPITER, nealry 18,000 people (men 50 years and over, women 60 years and over) took 20 mg per day Crestor for two years. Participants all had starting LDL cholesterols in the "normal" range of no higher than 130 mg/dl and elevated CRP of 2 mg/dl or greater.

Crestor treatment resulted in 44% reduction in nonfatal heart attack, nonfatal stroke, hospitalization for unstable angina, revascularization (bypass surgery, stents) and death from cardiovascular causes. The reduction in nonfatal heart attack was most marked at 55%.

Admittedly, these are impressive results. Benefits held true for both males and females. At the very least, JUPITER should put to rest some of the fringe arguments that statins do not reduce cardiovascular events. They do. There is no sense in arguing against that. While we might argue about the value of statins in various subsets of people, there is no doubt that they do indeed exert a significant effect.

However, contrary to the hype and broad pronouncements of my colleagues, my concerns are:

1) Rather than shotgun the inflammatory response with a statin drug regardless of cause, doesn't it make more sense to ask why a specific individual has an increased CRP in the first place? For instance, if the answer is vitamin D deficiency, doesn't correction of the deficiency make more sense? (Vitamin D by itself reduces CRP around 60%--more than statin drugs.) Not to mention you obtain all the extraordinary benefits of vitamin D restoration, such as reduced cancer risk, increased bone density, relief from winter "blues," rise in HDL, etc. How about junk foods, obesity, and unrelated inflammatory conditions? Would we therefore indirectly be treating obesity with Crestor?

2) Crestor 20 mg per day, contrary to the study and to many statin studies, will not be tolerated for long by the majority. Muscles aches are not common--they are inevitable, sometimes incapacitating. While JUPITER showed 15% of both treatment and placebo groups experienced muscle effects--no different--this is wildly contrary to real life.

3) While there was a 55% reduction in the number of heart attacks, there continued to be a substantial number of heart attacks in the Crestor treatment arm. Clearly, reduction of CRP with Crestor, while helpful, is not a cure.

I view studies like JUPITER as simply an interesting piece of semi-scientific evidence, tainted to an unknown degree by commercial interests (including those of Dr. Paul Ridker, one of the principal investigators). It is not a mandate to use Crestor carte blanche in people with elevations of CRP.

My interpretation of these data in a practical sense is that Crestor 20 mg per day as sole therapy is useful in a disinterested, non-compliant patient who is unwilling to make substantial changes in lifestyle and nutrition. Helpful? Yes, but hardly an invitation for the world to take Crestor.

I believe that doesn't include any of the readers of this blog.

Nutritional approaches: Large vs. small LDL














It is now a rare person who does not have at least some proportion of their LDL cholesterol as small particles. I estimate that, of the people who come to the office or report their data on the Track Your Plaque website, 90% have at least 40-50% small LDL particles. Some people have 100% small LDL particles. The sample NMR lipoprotein report shows the result for someone with a severe small LDL pattern (the tallest red bar labeled 1354 nmol/L, compared to the 74 nmol/L of the tiny red bar of large LDL.)

The nutritional approach for small vs. large LDL differs. Small LDL particles are most sensitive to carbohydrate intake; large LDL particles are more sensitive to saturated fats.

The conventional "heart healthy" diet that restricts saturated fat reduces large LDL but exerts no effect on small LDL. Thus, a diet that is restricted in saturated fat and weighed more heavily with "healthy whole grains" triggers small LDL particles. Followers of the conversations here recognize that small LDL particles are flagrant triggers for coronary plaque; they have, in fact, become the number one most common cause for heart disease in the U.S.

When you have lipoproteins tested, you can therefore gauge the likely result obtained when specific dietary changes are made. Follow the low saturated fat advice, large LDL will drop modestly, but small LDL skyrockets.













(Image courtesy Liposcience, Inc.)


Eliminate sugars, wheat, and cornstarch and you will see small LDL plummet (along with total LDL).

As an aside, my personal observation is that the "need" for statin cholesterol drugs can be reduced dramatically by paying attention to this important LDL size distinction.

Factory hospitals

Twenty years ago, the American farming industry experienced a dilemma: How to grow more soybeans, corn, or wheat from a limited amount of farmland, raise more cattle and hogs in a shorter period of time, fatter and ready for slaughter within months rather than years?













(Image courtesy Wikipedia)

The solution: Synthetically fertilize farmland for greater crop yield; “factory farms” for livestock in which chickens or pigs are crammed into tiny cages that leave no room to turn, cattle packed tightly into manure-filled paddocks. As author Michael Pollan put it in his candid look at American health and eating, The Omnivore’s Dilemma:


“To visit a modern Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation (CAFO) is to enter a world that for all its technological sophistication is still designed on seventeenth-century Cartesian principles: Animals are treated as machines—“production units”—incapable of feeling pain. Since no thinking person can possibly believe this anymore, industrial animal agriculture depends on a suspension of disbelief on the part of the people who operate it and a willingness to avert one’s eyes on the part of everyone else. . .”


Pollan goes on to argue that the cultural distance inserted between the brutal factory farm existence of livestock and your dinner table permits this to continue:


“. . .the life of the pig has moved out of view; when’s the last time you saw a pig in person? Meat comes from the grocery store, where it is cut and packaged to look as little like parts of animals as possible. The disappearance of animals from our lives has opened a space in which there’s no reality check on the sentiment or the brutality . . .”


The same disconnect has occurred in healthcare for the heart. The emotional distance thrust between the hospital-employed primary care physician, the procedure-driven cardiologist, the crammed-into-a-niche electrophysiologist (heart rhythm specialist) or cardiothoracic surgeon whose principal concerns are procedures—with an eye always towards litigation risk—mimics factory farms that now litter the landscape of the Midwest. The hospitals and doctors who deliver the process see us less as human beings and more as the next profit opportunity.

The “factory hospital” has allowed the subjugation of humans into the service of procedural volume, all in the name of fattening revenues. Never mind that people are not (usually) killed outright but subjected to a succession of life-disrupting procedures over many years. But whether livestock in a factory farm or humans in a factory hospital, the net result to the people controlling the process is identical: increased profits.

The system doesn’t grow to meet market demand, but to grow profits. The myth that allows this growth is perpetuated by the participants who stand to gain from that growth.

See hospitals for what they are: businesses. Despite most hospitals retaining "Saint" in their name, there is no longer anything saintly or charitable about these commercial operations. They are ever bit as profit-seeking as GE, Enron, or Mobil.

Medicare and The Law of Unintended Consequences

This post carries on the line of conversation begun in The Origins of Heart Catheterization: Part I and Part II.



While Dr. Sones labored in the relative obscurity of his catheterization laboratory, the American public was experiencing a crisis in healthcare availability, particularly among the over-65 age group. The population of elderly in the U.S. was growing rapidly. Between 1950 and 1963, their ranks grew from 12 million to 17.5 million. The cost of hospital care was also increasing 6.7% annually, several times the rate of increase in the cost of living of the time. From 1950 to the day of Dr. Sones’ discovery, the average cost for a day in the hospital jumped from $29 to $40. As a result, private health insurance carriers were forced to increase rates, driving premiums higher and farther out of reach for many. Half of all elderly were uninsured. Many feared that, while the sophistication of medical services advanced, healthcare was becoming increasingly unavailable to many, perhaps most, Americans.

The pivotal contribution that ignited wide dissemination of healthcare technology didn’t come from a physician, nor someone in healthcare. It was spurred by a nearly-forgotten bureaucrat. Without the behind-the-scenes laboring of this one man, the present healthcare system might be quite different.

It was largely the work of Nelson H. Cruikshank, an ordained Methodist minister with a Master of Divinity degree and veteran of battling for rights of the elderly and poor deprived of health care. For 10 years, Cruikshank served as director of the AFL-CIO's Social Security Department and had been instrumental in getting the Social Security Disability act passed. Working on the side of organized labor but maintaining the public demeanor of a church pastor, Cruikshank gained a reputation as a fighter for the working man, one who didn’t back down from a political brawl. In an interview regarding the question of corporate-retained earnings for capital investment, he blasted the practice, calling it "taxation by corporation without representation. Through prices paid for consumer goods, buyers are providing capital for industries over which they have no control and from which they receive no dividends” (Time Magazine, Dec. 20, 1948).

For years, Cruikshank lobbied tirelessly on behalf of American unions to bring the new national healthcare bill, known as Medicare, to a vote on the floor of Congress. Numerous efforts at a national program had languished for a decade before Medicare was drafted, and the Medicare legislation remained bottlenecked for years in committees. Cruikshank’s relentless and forceful persuasion was instrumental in finally bringing the bill to a vote. Among the most vocal opponents Cruikshank parried was the American Medical Association (AMA), terrified that the new program would lead to loss of control over healthcare delivery and reimbursement. The AMA labeled Medicare "the most deadly challenge ever faced by the medical profession."

Cruikshank proved how tough he was when he faced off with Dr Morris Fishbein, then president of the AMA, in a radio debate. Oscar R. Ewing, attorney and Democratic political organizer under the Truman administration, offered these reminiscences of the debate:

“Dr. Fishbein described the horrible confusion that existed in the [government-run] British Health Service that had recently been established in Britain. He told of the utter confusion that he found existed when he was in England a few weeks previously; that there were long queues in every doctor's office, that doctors were overburdened with paper work; that a mother who wanted an extra allowance of milk for her sick child had to get a doctor's prescription for it and then go to the Health Department for permission to buy the milk. Dr. Fishbein painted a picture of complete confusion.

“After Dr. Fishbein had described all these horrible details he found existing when in England a few weeks earlier, Mr. Cruikshank pulled out this particular diary [published in a nationally-syndicated column called “Dr. Fishbein's Diary” ] of Dr. Fishbein in which he described his last visit to London. He had arrived in London Friday morning and that afternoon had gone out to spend the weekend with Lord and Lady so-and-so at their country place; that he'd come back to London Monday morning, had stopped by the Health Department to pick up some papers, and had gone on to catch the noon plane for Paris. So the questioner then asked, "Well, is your appraisal of the British Health Service based on those few hours in London?" The question was a stinger and pretty much discredited Dr. Fishbein.”


(Interview by Mr. J.R. Fuchs, April 29, 1969; Harry S. Truman Library Archives)



Cruikshank went on to point out that Dr. Fishbein had indeed never visited the offices of British general practitioners and had spent his brief stay in the company of British aristocracy, attending the Olympics, then making the rounds of Parisian night clubs. Fishbein stumbled through the remainder of the interview, trying unsuccessfully to cover up his gaff. Dr. Fishbein was forced out of his post as AMA president by his peers shortly following the humiliating episode.

Largely due to the years of behind-the-scenes maneuvering by Mr. Cruikshank, on July 30, 1965, President Lyndon Johnson signed the Social Security Amendment that enacted the Medicare program. The legislation that survived into law included Medicare Part A, the portion of the program providing payment for hospital-based diagnostic and treatment services, and Medicare Part B, allowing payment for office-based services and outpatient diagnostic tests.

Finally, after decades of political battles, a national healthcare bill had been passed. Although benefits were restricted to only those eligible for Social Security benefits, it represented a start, a first step toward greater access to healthcare for the broader American public.

At first, the full implications of the Medicare program were not apparent. But as healthcare technology advanced, including that sparked by Sones’ innovation in coronary imaging, Medicare, much as engineered in large part by Nelson Cruikshank, proved a bonanza of payment for heart procedures. Medicare also set the pace for the payment for procedures by non-government, private health insurance.

Thus the stage was set. Thanks to Medicare, over the next 40 years cardiovascular healthcare services, yielding generous revenue for practitioners and hospitals, exploded on the scene, much to the surprise of many, including the AMA. When then president of the American College of Cardiology, Dr. Charles Fisch, was asked how the passage of Medicare affected cardiology, he replied, “It made cardiologists rich, as simple as that” (American Cardiology: The History of a Specialty and Its College, W. Bruce Fye, MD). Indeed, from its introduction in 1965 to 1980, Medicare payments for health claims ballooned 10-fold from $9.6 billion to $105.7 billion, a substantial portion of which went to pay for cardiology claims.

Little did Nelson Cruikshank, ministerial defender of the working man, anticipate that the Medicare he helped engineer would prove to be the catalyst for explosive growth of the modern cardiovascular healthcare system. Ironically, the program of healthcare-for-all that Cruikshank envisioned has, over the last 40 years, soured into a self-serving system that has been corrupted by the profit motive.

In too many instances, it’s a system that uses the working man as its victim, rather than its beneficiary.

Quieting the insulin storm

The cycle of eating, satiety, and hunger is largely driven by insulin and blood sugar responses.

For instance, if I eat a bowl of Cheerios, my blood sugar will surge to 140 mg/dl or higher (how high depending on insulin sensitivity). The flood of sugar from this Frankenfood triggers the release of insulin; blood sugar then settles back down.

The decline in blood sugar back down to normal or below normal powerfully triggers hunger. Variable degrees of shakiness, mental fogginess, and irritability also commonly occur. Most people experience this to some extent; some experience an exagerrated version called "reactive hypoglycemmia" and can suffer peculiar personality changes, irrational and even violent behavior.

Foods made with wheat or cornstarch raise blood sugar higher and faster than table sugar. Accordingly, blood sugar and insulin swing more widely with these food: highs are higher, lows are lower. People who therefore follow the standard mantra of "eat plenty of healthy whole grains" therefore experience a 2-3 hour long cycle of eating, brief satiety, and recurrent hunger. Cravings for snacks, impulsive eating, and overeating all occur during the period when blood sugar has dropped and hunger is powerfully triggered.

Eliminating this up and down fluctuation is therefore key to regaining control over appetite, losing weight, reducing small LDL and triglycerides, reducing blood sugar, and putting out the fires of inflammatory responses.

You can accomplish this by:

1) Eliminating foods that trigger the exagerrated rises in blood sugar--Wheat, cornstarch, polished rices, white and red potatoes, and candy.

2) Adding a healthy oil to every meal--a strategy that prolongs satiety and helps suppress sugar-insulin fluctuations.


The ful nuts and bolts details of this diet will be released with the New Track Your Plaque Diet. Part I has already been released; part II is coming any day on the Track Your Plaque website.

Scare tactics

"You're a walking time bomb."

"I can't be responsible for what happens to you."

"Your blockage is in the artery called the 'widow-maker.'"




Familiar lines? These are the well-rehearsed warnings commonly used by cardiologists to persuade a patient to undergo a procedure (heart catheterization and all that follow).

Something happens when you hear these words about your health. Most people's resolve to explore alternatives, get another opinion, think it over, promptly crumbles when they hear these words. These particular warnings have been time-tested and are surprisingly effective.

Unlike many other conditions, heart disease does indeed result in catastrophic events without warning. Unlike, say, cancer, heart disease can wreak damage suddenly. That's all true.

What bothers me is the vigor with which the opportunity for hospital procedures is pursued.

The thinking is that hospitals procedures = saving a life. In the vast majority of people, this is nonsense. Procedures like heart catheterization, stents, bypass, do save lives if someone is in the throes of a catastrophe. The problem is that most people who undergo procedures are not in the midst of catastrophe and have every hope of avoiding it altogether with some simple efforts towards prevention.

Imagine this conversation: "Yes, Mr. Smith, you do have heart disease, Even though you have no symptoms and your stress test is normal, I believe that we should 1) identify the causes of your heart disease, then 2) correct them. Of course, if you don't want to engage in this prevention process, then there may be a point at which heart procedures may be necessary. But I believe that you have great hopes of avoiding them and avoiding heart attack."

Self-Directed Testing

In the last Heart Scan Blog post, I listed the poll results on success vs. failure in trying to obtain requested blood work through doctors. The results of that informal poll revealed that a substantial number of people encounter resistance to one degree or another in trying to obtain blood tests.

But the world of self-directed testing is growing. In addition to your ability to circumvent your doctor by getting your own blood work done, you can now:

--Obtain many imaging tests on your own--Heart scans can be obtained without your doctor's involvement, for instance. The ultrasound screening services, like that offered by Lifeline, mobile services that provide carotid, abdominal aorta, and osteoporosis screening services; full body scans, and others.
--Identify and treat some conditions--Internet information has gotten quite powerful to assist individuals in recognizing when a condition might be present. (However, this is also a landmine for trouble if not properly used.)
--Genetic testing--While just in its infancy, direct-to-consumer genetic testing is now offered by two outfits that I'm aware of.
--Unusual laboratory tests--e.g., heavy metals, omega-3 fatty acid content, cancer markers.

One drawback to the emerging world of self-directed testing: There is no insurance coverage. However, this will become less and less of an issue as time passes, since it is clear that most Americans will need to bear a greater portion of healthcare costs in future, since some conventional services may even be rationed for cost containment; higher copays and the emergence of medical savings accounts, providing the individual with more control over how healthcare dollars are spent; competition in self-directed healthcare services, which will reduce costs. Imagine, for instance, several more direct-to-consumer services to obtain blood tests appear. They will need to compete on price and service.

While my colleagues are terrified of the potential for abuse of such tests, my reaction is the opposite: I am enormously excited by the potential for individuals to seize more and more control over their health.

Of course, with greater freedom comes greater responsibility. But the long-term net result will be, in my view, a healthier, more satisfied healthcare consumer with reduced healthcare costs.

Self-testing

Here are the results of the latest Heart Scan Blog poll (84 respondents):


When you ask your doctor to perform a specific blood test, does he/she:


Do it without question?
38 (44%)


Do it but express reservations?
25 (29%)


Do it very grudgingly?
13 (15%)


Refuse outright?
9 (10%)



I was encouraged that 44% of respondents are/were able to obtain the blood work they requested without resistance. Sadly, however, the majority do either encounter reluctance or outright resistance.

Why would your doctor impose barriers to your ability to obtain laboratory tests? Well, several potential reasons:

1) He/she feels that they are charged with your health safety, and you might be led down a misleading, potentially dangerous path.

2) He/she feels that the tests are truly unnecessary and that you will be wasting the money of the "system."

3) He/she doesn't understand the tests, or is unfamiliar with them.

4) He/she feels that the doctor should be in complete control, not you. How dare you try to usurp the doctor-as-dictator of your health!


In reality, number 1 is understandable but rarely occurs. I have indeed have had requests, though rare, for outrageously inappropriate tests for the issue at hand, usually due to a misinterpretation of some information by the patient.

I'm not sure how often number 2 truly is. For instance, it is not uncommon for the doctor to have an ownership stake in the laboratory. There are several large primary care groups in Milwaukee who are notorious over-users of laboratory tests, with extraordinary batteries of dozens of tests every few months on the flimsiest reasons , clearly motivated by . . . money. On the other hand, there are physicians who do consciously try and order tests rationally and cost-effectively. I suspect that this is a minority.

I feel quite confident that number 3--your doctor's ignorance--is probably the most common reason he/she is reluctant or refuses to allow you access to a test. Most respondents I suspect are referring to many of the tests that I have been advocating, such as lipoprotein testing, lipoprotein(a), and vitamin D blood levels. I am uncertain how any of these could be construed to be dangerous. But ignorance of the value of these tests is rampant and resistance is nearly always based on not having explored these issues and having no appreciation for their importance. Of course, the beleaguered primary care physician is, no surprise, inundated by so much information across such a wide range that he/she has become expert at nothing, barely able to even deliver the full scope of genuine up-to-date primary services any longer. My colleagues, the cardiologists. . . well, you know my feelings about their attitudes: If it doesn't make money, then why should I bother? Devote months or years studying something that doesn't ring the cash register?

I see this dilemma as yet more evidence of the growing disenchantment with the doctor-as-gatekeeper model, the centuries old paternalistic "I will tell you what to do and you will do it." It worked when the doctor was educated and had access to knowledge you could never realistically obtain because you couldn't read, or you were too poor to afford books and education, or because medical information was made privy only to select people.

It's not that way anymore: The information you have access to is the same information my colleagues and I have access to: a level playing field. Along with the changing rules of the game, the game itself must eventually change.

I believe that people should have access to self-testing. Indeed, there is a growing industry of direct-to-consumer laboratory testing, such as that offered by Life Extension and LabSafe . For the most part, these offer tests without potential insurance reimbursement.

But the landscape is changing: We are just beginning a new age of self-empowerment, self-directed healthcare.

Whenever I say this, some people are angered that the majority of people will be too lazy, stupid, or poor to join the movement. What I am not saying is that we should agitate to make the system a patient-only directed process and completely remove the doctor. What I am saying is that the patient should and will play an increasingly important role in determining the content and direction of his/her care, especially as the patient becomes far more knowledgeable about issues relevant to his/her health.


The new tools of health measurement

If there were a new mantra of the new science of insight into health and long life, it would be “measure, measure, and measure.”

Never before in history have we had access to the analytical, laboratory, imaging, quantifying health tools that we have today. We can locate, scan, measure, all down as far as the level of basic codons of the genetic sequence.

The health-inquiring public has so far been permitted just a tip-of-the-tongue taste of these quantitative phenomena in such things as cholesterol values (“know your numbers!”) and blood pressure. Women now discuss their bone density scores over coffee, men their PSAs (prostate specific antigen).

But a curious irony has emerged: Like early 20th century males uncomfortable with women battling for suffrage, healthcare professionals, themselves comfortable with measurements and numbers, are distinctly uncomfortable when some of the same information falls into the hands of the healthcare consumer.

These phenomena play out in especially dramatic fashion in the world of heart health. The public now has broad access (many without a doctor’s order) to an extraordinary array of health measurement tools that can potentially yield enormous benefits for prevention of the most common conditions, information that can be applied by tracking over time.

Measures like heart scan scores, vitamin D blood levels, lipoprotein(a)--measures that most doctors have little or no interest in obtaining, yet they serve crucial roles in maintaining and tracking your health.

The new paradigm is emerging: the tools are getting better and better, they are becoming more accessible.

Increasing sales, growing the business

I continue my portrayal of the fictional hospital, St. Matthews. Though fictional, it is based on real facts, figures, and situations.

Despite their success, administrators at St. Matthews’s Hospital continually fret over how to further expand their enterprise.

Market share can be increased, of course, by competing effectively with other hospitals, but that can be a tough arena. After all, St. Matthews’ competitors deliver pretty much the same services, and draw areas for patients overlap. The last thing the hospital wants is the appearance that heart care is a “cookie cutter” process, the same everywhere. In fact, this trend has hospital administrators wringing their hands. Two competing hospital systems in town recently launched multi-million dollar ad campaigns employing some of the same aggressive tactics St. Matthews’ marketers used successfully in past.

If St. Matthews is going to grow, new markets will need to be explored. What other strategies can a hospital system use to continue climbing the growth curve?

St. Matthews’ hospital administrators have drawn a number of lessons from other businesses. How about squeezing more procedures out of the population you already take care of? That’s an age-old rule of business: your easiest sales come from repeat customers. A former stent patient is going to “need” annual nuclear stress testing ($4000), more stents (about $25,000–39,000 per hospitalization), CT angiogram ($1800–2400), bypass surgery ($84,000), and so on. “Check-up” catheterizations, though clearly of little or not benefit to patients, are silently encouraged, yet another example of the bonanza of repeat procedures possible.

The lesson that “once a heart patient, always a heart patient” has been honed to an art form in business practices at St. Matthews and other hospitals like it. If you enter the system through your primary care physician or cardiologist, there’s an excellent chance you’ll end up with several procedures, diagnostic and therapeutic, over the ensuing years. Accordingly, St. Matthews provides a very attentive after-discharge follow-up program, complete with access to friendly people, phone centers, “support groups,” and even an occasional festive get-together, all in an effort to ensure future return to the system.

All in all, the St. Matthews Hospital System is a hugely successful operation. It provides jobs for thousands of area residents and provides high-tech, high-quality healthcare. Like any business—and no doubt about it, St. Matthews is a business with all the trappings of a profit-seeking enterprise—it grows to serve its own interests. The tobacco industry didn’t grow to its gargantuan proportions by doing good, but by selling a product to an unsuspecting public. So, too, hospitals.

Curiously, hospitals like St. Matthews continue to operate under the sheltered guise of not-for-profit institution with the associated tax benefits, ostensibly serving the public good. This means that all end-of-year excess revenues are re-invested and not distributed to investors. But non-profit does not mean that individuals within the system can’t benefit, and benefit handsomely. Under St. Matthews’ non-profit umbrella, many businesses thrive: 35 pharmacies, extended care facilities to provide care after hospital discharge, drug and medical device distributors, even a venture capital arm to fund new operations. The financial advantage conferred by “non-profit” status has permitted the hospital to compete with other, for-profit businesses, at a considerable advantage. For this reason, attempts have been made over the years to strip them of what some believe is an unfair advantage; all have failed.

While profits may not fall to the bottom line, money does indeed get paid out to many people along the way. Executives, for instance, pay themselves generous salaries and consulting fees, often from several of the entities in this complex business empire. Physicians are brought in as “consultants” or are awarded “directorships” for hundreds of thousands of dollars per year—Director of Research, Director of Cardiovascular Services, etc. Don’t forget the $3.7 million dollar annual salary paid to the CEO.

Hospitals and doctors have a vested interest in preserving this financial house of cards. They will fiercely battle anyone or anything that threatens the stream of cash. During a recent meeting of important doctors at St. Matthews Hospital, one cardiologist bravely voiced his concern that bypass surgery was performed too freely on too many patients in the hospital. The doctor was promptly and quietly asked to remove himself from the meeting. Several days later, he received a letter announcing his dismissal from the committee.

The silent conspiracy conducted by hospitals and cardiologists serves their own purposes better than the good of the public. Under the guise of good works, hospitals continue to promote strategies which are, for the most part, outdated, inefficient, inaccurate, and expensive. But that’s the rub. Expensive to you and your insurance company means more money for the recipient: your hospital and cardiologist, and the powers that support them. All this occurs while the real solutions that are of benefit to the public continue to be overlooked, hidden in the shadows.

Top Doctor

Dr. Robert Connors is the hospital’s most prized cardiologist.

Practically a fixture in the cath lab, he generates more revenues for the hospital than any of his colleagues. Last year alone, he performed over 1500 procedures, bringing in $18 million dollars to the cath lab, $27 million to the hospital. Dr. Connors is very good at what he does: 55-years old, he has been involved in high-tech heart care since the “early days,” 25 years ago, when hospital procedures really took off.

During his career, he has personally performed over 25,000 heart procedures and has built a reputation as a skilled operator of complex coronary procedures. Because of his skills, he enjoys a vigorous flow of referrals for procedures from dozens of primary care physicians. His skill has also earned him referrals from cardiologist colleagues who seek his abilities for difficult cases.

On any day, Dr. Connors typically schedules up to 12 procedures. His entire day is spent in the cath lab, usually from 7 am until 6 pm. He meets many patients for the first time on the catheterization laboratory table as staff shave their groin, preparing for the procedure. Much of the procedure itself is not even performed by Dr. Connors, but by one or another cardiologists-in-training, a “fellow,” or member of the fellowship the hospital proudly maintains as a clinical teaching institution. Nor will Dr. Connors talk to most patients at the close of the procedure. He leaves that to either the fellow or a nurse. Dr. Connors views himself as a procedural specialist, not someone who has to take care of patients. He gave up seeing patients in his office over 10 years ago.

Dr. Connors’ procedural enthusiasm gained him the attention of drug and medical device manufacturers. Because Dr. Connors lectures widely and advises colleagues, his comments can dramatically alter perceptions of the value of a technology. He has, on many occasions, catapulted an unpopular device to most-asked-for among colleagues, bringing millions in revenues to the manufacturer. One particularly lucrative arrangement he made around 10 years ago involved a “closure” device, a $400 single-use plug used to close the access site made during heart catheterizations. By swaying his colleagues at St. Matthews Hospital, 50 orders per day (one per procedure) tallied $20,000 every day, $7.1 million dollars per year for the manufacturer. Although he’d used other devices on the market, the 5,000 shares of stock he was offered encouraged him to issue glowing comments to colleagues on the superiority of this specific brand of closure device. Now over 90% of all catheterizations at St. Matthews conclude with the device manufactured by the company in which Dr. Connors maintains partial ownership.

Negative comments, on the other hand, topple other products when Dr. Connors sees fit to pan them. For this reason, device and drug manufacturers run straight to Dr. Connors to gain his good graces as soon as possible after a product is released into the market. Because the competition is just as likely to do the same, it has often come down to a bidding war, the company providing the most lucrative arrangement most likely to win.

Thus, Dr. Connors proudly boasts of how many times he has flown to Hawaii, Europe, and other exotic locations at industry expense. He also boasts of how, for $100,000 paid to him for a “consulting fee,” he can overturn the choice of products lining hospital shelves. As the hospital’s annual budget for coronary devices will top $84,000,000 this year, device manufacturers regard the sum paid Connors as a profitable investment.

Despite his lofty status in the hospital, Dr. Connors has long expressed a love-hate relationship with St. Matthews. While he enjoys his work and has made a more than comfortable income, he has long felt that the hospital administration didn’t truly appreciate his contributions. Five years ago, he therefore demanded that he be made “Director of Research.” After all, he had hired a nurse to help him coordinate enrollment of patients into several device trials brought to him by medical device manufacturers. When he encountered an initial lukewarm response from hospital administrators, he threatened to take his “business” elsewhere to a competing hospital. St. Matthews’ administrators gave in. They provided him with the title he wanted, along with $100,000 annual “stipend.”

True story, though names have been changed to protect the guilty.

Is Dr. Connors just an “outlier” among colleagues who toe a more conservative line? Or does his brand of commercial enterprise in hospital heart care represent the ideal that they seek, brazenly and ambitiously seeking to expand the procedural solution to heart disease to the exclusion of patient care and real human interaction?