Coenzyme Q10 and statin drugs

Although drug manufacturers claim that muscle side effects from statin drugs occurs in only around 2% or people or less, my experience is very different.

I see muscle weakness and achiness develop in the majority of people taking Lipitor, Crestor, Zocor, Vytorin, etc. I'd estimate that nearly 90% of people get these feelings sooner or later.

Thankfully, the majority of the time these feelings are annoyances and do not lead to any impairment. Full-blown muscle destruction is truly rare--I've seen it once in over 10 years and thousands of patients.

The higher the dose of statin drug and the longer you take it, the more likely you're going to have muscle aches.

I experienced a strange phemomenon myself today. I worked outdoors for about 4 hours, pulling weeds, digging in the dirt, spreading topsoil. (I have an area of overgrowth in the front yard.) Admittedly, I worked pretty hard and it was a warm, humid day.

I was sore, as you'd expect at age 49. But, much more than that, I was exhausted--my muscles ached and I had barely enough strength to get up the stairs.

Hoping for some relief, I took an extra dose of coenzyme Q10. I usually take 50-100 mg per day. Today, when I felt this overwhelming muscle fatigue, I took an additional 200 mg. Within 10 minutes, I felt a surge of energy. It was, in fact, a perceptible, quite dramatic feeling.

I am thoroughly convinced, through my own experiences on Lipitor (I have a high LDL particle number despite a healthy lifestyle, among other abnormalities), and the experiences of many other people, that coenzyme Q10 can be an extremely useful tool to minimize the muscle aches and weakness of the statin drugs.

If you do indeed need to take one of these agents, coenzyme Q10 is worth knowing about. Supplementing coenzyme Q10 has, for me, been a real lifesaver. For many people, LDL reduction is a crucial part of their heart scan score control program. In my experience, many of them would not be able to take the drug without eozyme Q10.

Blast your LDL with oat bran and almonds

Nearly all of us can use an extra boost in reducing LDL cholesterol. We have a large number of people, in fact, who have reduced LDL into the Track Your Plaque range of 60 mg/dl or less without the use of statin cholesterol-reducing drugs.




Oat bran is among my favorite ways to reduce LDL. Three tablespoons per day is a really effective method to drop your LDL around 20 points. There's twice the beta glucan (soluble, or "viscous", fiber)in oat bran, as compared to the more popular oatmeal. Add oat bran to anything you can think of: yogurt, cottage cheese, vegetarian chili, oatmeal, top desserts with it, etc. Some people struggle to find oat bran in the grocery store. Most health food stores that sell bulk products will have oat bran, usually less than a $1 per pound. Many grocery stores will also have an oat bran hot cereal along with the Cream of Wheat and oatmeal. That's okay, provided the only ingredient is oat bran--no added sugars, etc.





Another dynamite method to reduce LDL 10-20 points is adding raw almonds to your daily food choices. One or two handfuls per day works great. We find it at Sam's Club for around $12.99 for a 3 lb. bag. The plentiful fibers and monounsaturates in almonds keep you full and satisified, take the edge off your sweet tooth, and even blunt the blood sugar rise caused by other foods.

Both these foods are also great ways to combat the metabolic syndrome. Since both fiber-rich oat bran and almonds slow the release of sugars into the blood, blood insulin level is also reduced. This results in a happy cascade of less small LDL, increased HDL, and a reduction in inflammation.

All these wonderful effects contribute to inching you closer to success: dropping your heart scan score.

Pre-diabetes with normal blood sugar

We pay special attention to pre-diabetes, in all its varied manifestations, in the Track Your Plaque program. This is because these factors are potent instigators of coronary plaque growth.

Early in the Track Your Plaque program we ignored these measures. After all, this is a program for heart disease risk reduction, not for mangement of diabetes. But we saw explosive rates of plaque growth when pre-diabetic factors were not controlled--even when cholesterol and related factors were under excellent control.

It became increasingly clear that factors associated with pre-diabetes needed to be managed, as well. This includes small LDL, increased blood sugar, high blood pressure, increased inflammation (as CRP).

Many people, however, have normal blood sugars (100 mg/dl or less) with a high blood insulin level (>10 microunits/ml). (This blood test is available in most laboratories.) This means that they have early resistance to insulin. The pancreas, the source of insulin, responds to the body's unresponsiveness to insulin by increasing insulin production.

Increased blood insulin with normal blood sugar will drive production of higher triglycerides, a drop in HDL, creation of small LDL, and inflammation--and coronary plaque growth, as evidenced by increasing CT heart scan score.

Blood insulin levels can be very effectively dropped by weight loss; exercise; reduction of processed carbohydrates like breads, pretzels, and breakfast cereals; and increased raw nuts and oat products; and vitamin D replacement to normal levels. Drug manufacturers are desperately trying to make this a mandate for drug treatment (Actos, Avandia), but are encountering resistance, since most people without overt diabetes don't want to take diabetic medication (rightly so!).

You and your doctor should consider insulin as a factor to track, especially if you have small LDL, low HSL, or high triglycerides, or any of the other manifestations listed above.

Sometimes small LDL is the only abnormality

Janet is a 58-year old schoolteacher. At 5 ft 3 inches and 104 lbs, she had barely an ounce of fat on her size-2 body. For years, Janet's primary care physician complimented her on her cholesterol numbers: LDL cholesterol values ranging from 100 to 130 mg/dl; HDL cholesterol of 50-53 mg/dl.

Yet she had coronary disease. Her heart scan score: 195.

Lipoprotein analysis uncovered a single cause: small LDL. 95% of all of Janet's LDL particles were in the small category. What was surprising was that this pattern occurred despite her slender build. Weight is a powerful influence on the small LDL pattern and the majority of people with it are overweight to some degree. But not Janet.

How did she get small LDL if she was already at or below her ideal weight? Genetics. Among the genetic patterns that can account for this pattern is a defect of an enzyme called cholesteryl-ester transfer protein, or CETP. This is the exact step, by the way, that is blocked by torcetrapib, the new agent slated for release sometime in future (The manufacturer, Pfizer, is apparently going to sell this agent only packaged in the same tablet as Lipitor. This has triggered an enormous amount of criticism against the company and they are, as a result discussing marketing torcetrapib separately.)

Also note that Janet had a severe excess of small LDL despite an HDL in the "favorable" range. (See my earlier conversation on this issue, The Myth of Small LDL at http://drprevention.blogspot.com/2006/06/myth-of-small-ldl.html.)

With Janet, weight loss to reduce small LDL was not an option. So we advised her to take fish oil, 4000 mg per day; niacin, 1000 mg per day; vitamin D, 2000 units per day; use abundant oat bran and raw almonds, both of which suppress small LDL. This regimen has--surprisingly--only partially suppressed her small LDL pattern by a repeat lipoprotein analysis we just performed. We're hoping this may do it, i.e., stop progression or reduce her heart scan score.

The lesson: Small LDL is a very potent pattern that can be responsible for heart disease, even if it occurs in isolation. And, contrary to conventional thinking, small LDL can occur as an independent abnormality, even when HDL is at favorable levels.

Report from Washington II

Today's discussions at the Society for Cardiovascular Computed Tomography (SCCT) focused on atherosclerotic "plaque characterization".

As CT scanners get better and better at imaging the various components of plaque, some fascinating issues emerge:

--CT heart scans provide insights into what exactly is contained in an individual's atherosclerotic plaque that are not often provided even during heart catheterization. In other words, CT heart scanning is, in many instances, superior to heart catheterization, since it provides images of the artery wall, not just the internal contents.

--Progression (i.e., increase) in heart scan score is a powerful predicter of heart attack risk. Dr. Matthew Budoff of UCLA argued persuasively that the annual rate of increase in score is probably the most accurate measure of risk available, superior to cholesterol and calculated measures like the Framingham risk score.

--Coronary calcium scoring remains the best method to gauge total plaque throughout the entire coronary tree. In a person free of symptoms, the risk of a cardiac "event" (heart attack, death, procedures) is low and additional imaging (like CT angiography) is generally unnecessary.


Dr. Budoff, among the true thought leaders in CT heart scanning, also recounted his perspective on the history of heart scans. He noted that the questions asked through the years have evolved:




1995-2000 Should we do coronary calcium scans?

2000-2002 Do high or low risk patients benefit from coronary calcium scoring?

2003-2004 What is the better scanner, EBT or MDCT?

2006 How often should we perform coronary calcium imaging?


I believe that Dr. Budoff summarizes wonderfully where the Track Your Plaque programs fits into the overall scheme of things: Serial (repeated)CT heart scans to gauge progression or reversal is the wave of the future. We shouldn't just be interested in identifying persons at risk for heart attack. We should also be interested in showing the person at risk exactly how to reduce or eliminate that risk.

Report from Washington





I'm presently attending the Society for Cardiovascular Computed Tomography meetings in Washington, DC, along with 500 of my colleagues. It's exciting to see how interest in CT scanning for heart disease has balloonned in the past couple of years.

Several trends are noticeable today, based on the content and tone of the discussions:

--CT scanning of the heart, and imaging in general, is just getting started. In other words, the capabilities for CT scanners and other devices to detect heart disease (coronary and otherwise) are where the gasoline engine was in the 19th century. Scanning is getting faster, easier, safer, and more precise. Just as few people in 1905 could have predicted that automobiles would be computer-enhanced, high-speed, ubiquitous devices with several per household, the potential for CT imaging for heart disease is truly in its infancy.

--CT coronary angiography (so-called "64-slice CT scans") are not screening tests for hidden coronary disease in people without symptoms. I was grateful that this point has been made and reiterated by several speakers, as this is consistent with our views. Simple CT heart scans for coronary calcium scoring, in contrast, are screening tests. When the radiation exposure of CT angiograms are reduced to tolerable levels, then they may be used as screening tests. We are probably 3-4 years away from this point.

--Both stress testing and heart catheterizations will be partially replaced by CT scanning. In particular, over the next decade, you will see a dramatic drop in unnecessary catheterizations, i.e,, far less people saying "I had a heart cath but they told me that it was normal."


There has been heavy focus on applications of CT scanning for acute settings, particularly the emergency room and hospitals.

What has surprised me is that there is virtually no conversation whatsoever about the preventive uses of CT heart scanning. So far, only Dr. Daniel Berman of UCLA has shown that he has "seen the light": CT scans are a crucial tool for identification of early coronary plaque, and this tells us whether prevention is necessary and with what intensity.

There has been, however, no discussion at all about quantification of plaque in a program of reversal. Perhaps that should come as no surprise, given the imaging-technology focus of this convention. For most of my colleagues, prevention is also not terribly interesting. Identification and treatment of acute disease like impending heart attack is.

Of course, applying the information from your CT heart scan to empower you in a program and reversal is what the Track Your Plaque program is all about. I hope you see the light. I admit that it's not always easy to follow what we are advocating here. Perhaps not too different than telling someone in his horse-drawn buggy that one day he'll be driving a sleek car with onboard computerized mapping, air-conditioning, and micro-chips to modulate engine performance. He's probably tell us we're nuts.

I'll continue to update if any news relevant to our interests crops up in these meetings.

What about the Track Your Plaque failures?

I’d love to tell you that the Track Your Plaque program track record is of 100% success. It’s not.

It is very successful. But we’ve had some people who have failed and failed BIG. These are the people who've undergone bypass surgery, received one or more stents, or had heart attacks. Lesser failures are the people who’ve had large, undesirable increases in heart scan scores of >30% in one year. (The expected rate of increase in your heart scan score without preventive efforts is 30% per year, on average.)

What can we learn from those failures? There were several characteristics that stand out among this small group:

· Non-compliance--meaning they just didn’t stick with it. They started out right but then rapidly lost interest in maintaining all the pieces of the program and neglected their fish oil, niacin, gain weight, etc. Matthew did this and ended up with three stents to his left anterior descending. His slow start was due to skepticism that the program worked and just plain forgetfulness.

· Extreme stress--One of our earliest failures was a 38-year old man whose heart scan score doubled in one year, despite doing everything right. But three family members, all close to him, died within the space of six months, including his mother and a brother. I regard this as one of those instances in which we were powerless, unfortunately, though it is a graphic example of the power of unresolved stress and grief.

· Having a “better way”--These are the couple of people who were convinced that they had a better way to control their heart scan score. David firmly believed that his two dozen supplements and exercise program would drop his score. Instead, they permitted a 42% increase. Lee relied exclusively on chelation, along with several supplements of his own design. Lee had three-vessel bypass surgery.

· Starting too late--Gerome started with a score of 1179, but also was having chest pressure with emotional stress. His stress test was abnormal, with the entire upper half of his heart not receiving blood with exercise on a stress nuclear study (“anterior ischemia”). Gerome received four bypass grafts. Unfortunately, Gerome never really had a chance to engage in the Track Your Plaque program, since his health and safety were in jeopardy as soon as he started.

Have we had any big failures of people who did everything right, were compliant, were not subject to extreme stress (more than just job stress, or financial worries), didn’t neglect the basic requirements of the Track Your Plaque program, and had sufficient time (at least 6 months to 1 year)? No, thankfully, we have not.

No one who has stuck to the program has had a big failure.

Be smarter than your cardiologist

“Do you need a stent?”

Sad to say, but that sentence condenses the wisdom of over 90% of practicing cardiologists.

Prevention of heart disease means take Lipitor or some other statin and cutting the saturated fat in your diet. That’s it. Maybe throw in exercise.

Regression of coronary plaque? That phrase has only entered the conversation since the AstraZeneca-supported trial of Crestor succeeded in achieving 8% regression of plaque (Track Your Plaque Members: See News) as demonstrated by intracoronary ultrasound.



In other words, in the minds of my colleagues, it can’t be true until a drug company tells them it’s true. It’s beyond me why this brainwashing of otherwise intelligent people has occurred, but it is blatantly evident in practice.

Fish oil is another example. The spectacular benefits of fish oil have been known for 20 years. But only recently has it become a “mainstream” practice to recommend fish oil, largely because a drug manufacturer has put a preparation through the rigors of FDA approval (Omacor) and is now marketing directly to physicians. All of a sudden, fish oil is a good thing? No, it’s just achieved legitimacy in the eyes of practitioners because it graces marketing literature.

If you’re reading this, you’re likely interested in coronary plaque regression using the only tool available for you to measure, track, and regress coronary plaque: CT heart scans. Intracoronary ultrasound will achieve the same goal, but it is an invasive procedure performed at heart catheterization, involves threading a wire and imaging probe all the way down the artery, involves real risk of tearing the inner lining of the artery, and is costly (around $14,000-$20,000 for the entire package). Do it every year? That’d be nuts.

If you’re thinking about coronary plaque regression, using fish oil, concerned about patterns like low HDL and small LDL, aware of the vitamin D deficiency issue as a coronary risk factor, etc., you are far more aware than the vast majority of practicing cardiologists. They are interested in what new brand of anti-coagulant to use during their heart catheterization (because the product representative gushes about the new agent—only $1200 a dose!). Or, they are interested in gaining the procedural skills to put in a new device like a biventricular pacemaker. Regress/reverse coronary plaque? What for?

You already know that a conversation about coronary plaque reversal will not be obtained in your cardiologist’s office. Your family practice doctor or internist? Fat chance! Knee arthritis, pap smears, pneumovax inoculations, sore throats, gout, back pain—they’re spread far too thin to know anything more than the most superficial amount about coronary plaque control. Most know nothing.

That’s where we come in. That’s our mission: Educate people about the extraordinary tools that you have available to you, all in the cause of control or reversal of coronary plaque.

Why am I here?

Frank came to the office for an opinion, sent by his (proactive) family physician.

"I really don't know why I'm here, to be honest."

Two years earlier, Frank had a heart attack, survived and received two stents to his circumflex coronary artery. He now took Zocor and his LDL cholesterol was a reasonably favorable 89 mg, total cholesterol 183 mg.

"I walk with my wife every other day. I've been avoiding fish fries. You'll never see me eat fast food."

Frank was correct: If we were going to engage in the conventional approach to coronary disease, Frank was on the right track. We would have postponed his next heart attack or procedure by a couple of years. Stroke, aneurysm, and other atherosclerotic manifestations would be set back, likewise, a few years.

Would Frank have profound control over his disease? Absolutely not. In fact, his disease had probably advanced a huge amount just in the two years since his stents were placed and he was on his "prevention" program. Without his current effort, his coronary plaque would be expected to grow 30% per year. On Zocor and his modest lifestyle efforts, plaque growth was probably in the 14-28% per year range.

So I explained the unique Track Your Plaque approach to Frank. First, we start with a CT heart scan to establish where he was starting. Although he had two stents in his circumflex artery, we still had two other arteries (LAD, right coronary) to score and track.

We then attempt to identify all hidden causes of his heart disease and then correct them.

Of course, Frank had multiple hidden causes:

--HDL too low at 38 mg/dl
--Small LDL-severe, in fact, with 95% of all LDL particles in the small category
--Triglycerides too high
--Excesses of several triglyceride-containing particles (VLDL, IDL)
--Pre-diabetes--Frank had both a borderline high blood sugar and a high insulin level. This is a sure-fire stimulus to coronary plaque growth.
--A severe deficiency of vitamin D (<20 ng/ml)
--An excessivelyhigh blood pressure during exercise--With a blood pressure of 190/102 on the treadmill.

There were others(!), but that was the bulk of the causes behind Frank's coronary disease.

Once Frank recognized that there was indeed a huge panel of hidden causes for heart disease, not just too much fat in his diet and LDL cholesterol, he jumped into the program head first.

The message: The conventional approach is absurdly oversimplified, a certain path to failure for the majority of people. Even if you don't have known coronary disease like Frank, but just have a heart scan score >zero, the same principles apply to you.

Catheterization to “define coronary anatomy”

Gary is an avid jogger. On an average day, he runs 5-6 miles at a good clip. On two occasions recently, however, Gary experienced an ache in his left shoulder at mile 4. It was a toothache-like feeling, but he kept on going without difficulty.

Gary also had a heart scan score of 370.

Upon hearing of Gary’s score and his shoulder sensation, the cardiologist who saw him advised a heart catheterization “to define coronary anatomy”. (This is a real incident.)


What exactly does that mean? Why would Gary’s cardiologist need to define it?

In my view, this is an absurd notion. No one needs to “define coronary anatomy”. This catch-all phrase is commonly used to justify heart procedures. I believe what the cardiologist is saying is that it’s the easiest (for the cardiologist) and perhaps most generously reimbursed method to determine whether Gary’s symptoms are warning of an impending heart attack or not.

The problem is that the question can also be answered quite well by doing a stress test. Though not perfect diagnostic tests, stress tests are useful when symptoms are present that are doubtful in nature. Gary’s left shoulder ache could have been related to his heart, but the likelihood was that it was not. A stress test would have answered the diagnostic question quite adequately.

Instead, this man was subjected to an invasive test that was likely unnecessary. This happens dozens, if not hundreds, of times per day just around here. Nationwide, it is an epidemic of malpractice.

There are, indeed, times when a person should proceed directly to a heart catheterization. This is commonly and appropriately performed when a person develops unstable heart symptoms, such as chest discomfort or breathlessness at rest while not doing anything physical, or if the frequency is increasing, or if a stress test shows an important abnormality. There is no question that heart procedures can be lifesaving at times.

The problem is that thousands of people every year are scared into these procedures inappropriately. Beware!
To get low-carb right, you need to check blood sugars

To get low-carb right, you need to check blood sugars

Reducing your carbohydrate exposure, particularly to wheat, cornstarch, and sucrose (table sugar), helps with weight loss; reduction of triglycerides, small LDL, and c-reactive protein; increases HDL; reduces blood pressure. There should be no remaining doubt on these effects.

However, I am going to propose that you cannot truly get your low-carb diet right without checking blood sugars. Let me explain.

Carbohydrates are the dominant driver of blood sugar (glucose) after eating. But it's clear that we also obtain some wonderfully healthy nutrients from carbohydrate sources: Think anthocyanins from blueberries and pomegranates, vitamin C from citrus, and soluble fiber from beans. There are many good things in carbohydrate foods.

How do we weigh the need to reduce carbohydrates with their benefits?

Blood sugar after eating ("postprandial") is the best index of carbohydrate metabolism we have (not fasting blood sugar). It also provides an indirect gauge of small LDL. Checking your blood sugar (glucose) has become an easy and relatively inexpensive tool that just about anybody can incorporate into health habits. More often than not, it can also provide you with some unexpected insights about your response to diet.

If you’re not a diabetic, why bother checking blood sugar? New studies have documented the increased likelihood of cardiovascular events with increased postprandial blood sugars well below the ranges regarded as diabetic. A blood sugar level of 140 mg/dl after a meal carries 30-60% increased (relative) risk for heart attack and other events. The increase in risk begins at even lower levels, perhaps 110 mg/dl or lower after-eating.

We use a one-hour after eating blood sugar to gauge the effects of a meal. If, for instance, your dinner of baked chicken, asparagus brushed with olive oil, sauteed mushrooms, mashed potatoes, and a piece of Italian bread yields a one-hour blood sugar of 155 mg/dl, you know that something is wrong. (This is far more common than most people think.)

Doing this myself, I have been shocked at the times I've had an unexpectedly high blood sugar from seemingly "safe' foods, or when a store- or restaurant-bought meal had some concealed source of sugar or carbohydrate. (I recently had a restaurant meal of a turkey burger with cheese, mixed salad with balsamic vinegar dressing, along with a few bites of my wife's veggie omelet. Blood sugar one hour later: 127 mg/dl. I believe sugar added to the salad dressing was the culprit.)

You can now purchase your own blood glucose monitor at stores like Walmart and Walgreens for $10-20. You will also need to purchase the fingerstick lancets and test strips; the test strips are the most costly part of the picture, usually running $0.50 to $1.00 per test strip. But since people without diabetes check their blood sugar only occasionally, the cost of the test strips is, over time, modest. I've had several devices over the years, but my current favorite for ease-of-use is the LifeScan OneTouch UltraMini that cost me $18.99 at Walgreens.

Checking after-meal blood sugars is, in my view, a powerful means of managing diet when reducing carbohydrate exposure is your goal. It provides immediate feedback on the carbohydrate aspect of your diet, allowing you to adjust and tweak carbohydrate intake to your individual metabolism.

Comments (60) -

  • Anne

    1/19/2010 3:29:13 PM |

    I can attest to the fact that doctors ignore what happens to blood glucose after eating. My fasting BG has always been normal but my glucose tolerance tests have always been high. My last glucose tolerance test a few yrs ago went to 201. My doctors told me I had some insulin resistance but assured me that I did not have to do anything about it because my fasting was OK.

    About 1 year ago, after reading this blog and others, I bought a glucometer. Yes, my fasting was "normal" but I could easily push it up to 200 by eating. I did just what Dr. Davis recommends. I used the glucometer to figure out what I can eat and how much I can eat. I am able to keep my blood glucose below 120 now. The glucometer is a powerful tool.

    Is it possible my ignored elevated post meal blood sugars did damage? Well, lets see, I have peripheral neuropathy and have had cardiac bypass. Giving up gluten 6 yrs ago greatly improved my PN and relieved my of shortness of breath and pitting edema. Getting my blood glucose down will make a difference too.

    I recommend Blood Sugar 101 http://www.phlaunt.com/diabetes/

  • sdkidsbooks

    1/19/2010 5:09:59 PM |

    Going to get a glucose meter today and start checking.  Is there a desirable number or range for glucose before and after or is it about how much or how little it rises without regard to the number?
    Seems like somewhere around a 100 is what you are advocating.  

    If a person is not diabetic, is it helpful at all to know your A1C when getting routine blood work done?  Just wondering...

    Thanks.

    Jan

  • Anonymous

    1/19/2010 6:38:43 PM |

    You can get Wavesense Keynote test strips from Amazon for about 35 cents per strip -- the best deal I've ever seen.  (The meter is about $35 there.)  

    I am curious about the right time to test.  If blood sugar goes to 160 at 30 minutes, but is down to, say, 100 at one hour, is that ok? Why is one hour (not 30 mins or 2 hours) the key number?

  • Gretchen

    1/19/2010 7:02:35 PM |

    Ground meat is often cut with breadcrumbs. I won't eat ground meat or meatloaf at a restaurant or potluck supper.

    Balsamic vinegar contains up to 3 g of glucose per tablespoon. And most people do add sugar to salad dressings. One restaurant I went to boiled down cider vinegar until it was sweet.

    You can use those urine glucose test strips to test foods for the presence of glucose before you eat them. If it's starch, you have to chew the food a bit first to break down the starch. See Richard Bernstein's "Diabetes Solution."

  • Anonymous

    1/19/2010 7:16:36 PM |

    When exactly do you take the measurement?  One hour after the start of a meal or one hour after the end?  Sometimes when we eat out, a meal can take an hour or more to finish.

  • DrStrange

    1/19/2010 7:48:44 PM |

    One caution is that blood sugar meters are only accurate to plus or minus 20% which is a huge variance.  Also, many (probably worst w/ the Walmart Relion or similar budget meters) are not very consistent so you can't just compare to a lab test and calibrate.  

    What I generally do is take 3 (or even 4) readings within a few seconds of each other, toss any wild outliers, then average what is left.  If you try this a few times, depending on your meter, you may be shocked at how much difference there is between the readings.

  • Calvin

    1/19/2010 7:51:01 PM |

    Dr. Davis--Great post--I totally agree. Even if someone isn't diabetic or prediabetic (myself),  investing in a glucose meter, then self-testing (especially post postprandial) has got to be one of the absolute best investments one can make in personal health.

    I once read that if most diabetics (and I'll add prediabetics too) had invested in a meter years before their diagnosis, mostly likely they could have/would have avoided many of their accompanying negative health conditions today.  

    That said, there is still a lot of "cognitive dissonance" with regards to diet and health--I think the meter really helps to reinforce the cognition portion of that phrase thereby reducing the dissonance half.  

    And using a glucose meter can actually be fun!

  • Future Primitive

    1/19/2010 10:33:28 PM |

    Here's an example of carbo loading on yam and plantain - there was a 7 hour "fast" prior to eating and then taking the measurements.

    http://tinyurl.com/bg-set-001

    mg/dL is marked at a few key points on the right hand side.

    What I don't get is how to interpret the second rise and fall after the two hour mark ... though it is still inside the post-absorptive window (which closes 3-5 hours after eating, IIRC).

    I'm pretty certain a glass of red wine explains the initial drop to 65 mg/dL, btw.

    Also, for those that would like to make their own graph, it's easy to grab the url and fill in your own data (it's a google charts thing).

  • notrace

    1/20/2010 12:04:01 AM |

    Will there still be production of small LDL from excess blood glucose even if there is ample available glycogen storage space? That is, will the liver simultaneously manufacture LDL and glycogen?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 2:37:04 AM |

    When do you start to count your one hour.  From the time of your first bite of food, or when you have  finished your last bite.  Since it takes about 20-30 minutes to finish eating, when to start the one hour count down is important.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 2:58:57 AM |

    Hi, Anne--

    What a perfect example of the power of postprandial testing!

    Yes, Jenny Ruhl at http://diabetesupdate.blogspot.com  provides a wealth of insight into blood sugar issues. We will also be releasing an in-depth Special Report on this issue on the www.trackyourplaque.com website.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 3:00:50 AM |

    In answer to the questions on timing of blood sugar checks:

    I am guilty of oversimplification. The peak timing of blood sugar varies on the foods consumed and the mix of foods consumed. It will also vary from individual to individual. I believe a reasonable way to start out is to check 60 minutes from the completion of a meal. Even better, you might occasionally perform your own time-course study: Check blood sugars every 30 minutes to determine when you tend to peak.

  • Coach Jeff

    1/20/2010 12:58:55 PM |

    Since an LC diet causes insulin resistance, (Actually a GOOD and protective thing within the context of an LC diet)wouldn't a long-term low carber get a sort of "false positive" reading of high blood sugar from ANY high carb meal?

    Also, what do you think of the theory (that seems to really be gathering momentum lately) that fructose is the actual cause of insulin resistance, while on a "high carb" diet, and that glucose/starch is relatively benign?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 1:12:53 PM |

    I got a blood glucose monitor after I starting taking niacin for HDL (had read that niacin could raise blood glucose) and it was an eye opener. Now I know what foods to avoid.

    Jeanne

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 1:43:47 PM |

    Gretchen--

    Great thoughts. I forgot about the bread crumbs in ground meat issue.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 1:45:17 PM |

    Coach--

    I think it's a matter of degree: While fructose is clearly a very bad player, glucose/starch are not benign, just less bad. Look at the responses we can generate with glucose tolerance testing using 75 grams of glucose.

  • Peter

    1/20/2010 2:55:25 PM |

    Since a simple way to reduce after-meal glucose readings is to eat smaller meals and eat more often, I don't quite understand why you think it's a bad idea.

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 3:27:43 PM |

    Bloodsugar101 suggests timing from the start of the meal. I always set a timer anyway, and it is easier to do before beginning to eat than at the end of the meal. This can feel awkward at first in restaurants, but I look at it as a way to get the word out.

    The occasional checks every 30 minutes is an excellent suggestion. Anytime you go over 140, you're causing damage. Even if it is only for brief periods, you want to be sure this is not one of your staple foods!

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 8:07:02 PM |

    What has happended to your trackyourplaque forum? I can't reach it anymore? Server crash without any backups? :-(

  • P

    1/20/2010 9:26:25 PM |

    hmmm. How painful is it to check the blood sugar that often?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 10:13:42 PM |

    I'm curious to know how to interpret blood sugar readings on the background of a healthy weight and a low-carb diet, with no known diabetes.  

    My fasting sugar is the same as it was before going low-carb (mid-70s).  However, it now takes a lot fewer carbs to spike my postprandial sugars.  

    An example: after 25 grams of carb in the form of a small serving of sweet potato with butter, my 45 minute postprandial reading, measured in triplicate, was 135.  I'm guessing the peak was even higher.  In case it matters, I'm a 36yo woman with a BMI of 18.9.  

    Should I be unconcerned by this kind of spike as long as my typical meals don't spike my sugar?  Is this just the normal insulin resistance caused by a low-carb diet, as Coach Jeff mentioned in his comment?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 11:06:20 PM |

    Dr. Davis, you said, "While fructose is clearly a very bad player, glucose/starch are not benign, just less bad. Look at the responses we can generate with glucose tolerance testing using 75 grams of glucose."

    This does not prove anything about what causes insulin resistance in the first place though.  The person having a response to glucose during a tolerance test may have originally gotten their insulin resistance from fructose.  You can't use fructose in the test since it doesn't raise blood sugar, you can only use glucose.  

    To put it another way, people who don't have insulin resistance don't have abnormal responses to glucose during glucose tolerance tests.  Does that exonerate glucose?  Not really.  

    What I'm saying is you can't indict glucose OR fructose based solely on what is seen in a glucose tolerance test.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/21/2010 11:59:56 AM |

    Anon--

    Blood sugars are too high. Either too much carbohydrate in the diet or something has caused an abnormal insulin response. While the dangers are not acute, there are long-term consequences of blood sugars this high.

  • frogfarm

    1/21/2010 3:02:19 PM |

    Dr. Davis, if you can spare a moment I hope you would comment on this:

    http://fanaticcook.blogspot.com/2010/01/should-you-take-vitamin-d2-or-vitamin.html

    where Dr. Michael Holick (Mr. Vitamin D, from the look of his pedigree) claims D2 is equally as effective as D3 in raising and maintaining 25OHD levels?

  • DrStrange

    1/21/2010 3:43:05 PM |

    There are two main causes of insulin resistance, dietary fat and possibly fructose.  Fructose is not a cause for many as they can eat a mostly fruit diet without issues but for some it is a big factor.  There are "must have" essential fatty acids needed in proper amounts and ratio, perhaps a bit more fat is needed.  Beyond that minimum amount, any additional adds to insulin resistance. The amounts and ratios are all present in an all plant diet without the addition of any add oils or fats and that w/ minimal nuts/seeds (maybe an ounce of flax).

    After being on strict McDougall diet (total dietary fat approx 10% and no refined carbs, no animal products, no junk) for about 18 months, I did a 75 gm glucose tolerance test and had them do an extra point at 30 minutes just in case. My highest peak was 114.  Previously, on low carb diet I would go to 185 or higher. [I am 5'3" and 110 pounds so small body mass; lbs body per gm glucose if that makes any difference]

  • TedHutchinson

    1/21/2010 8:49:40 PM |

    @ frogfarm said...
    I find it very strange people take this particular study seriously.

    At the end of the trial none of the participants had 25(OH)D levels above 30ng/ml, so they all remained vitamin D insufficient.
    IMO it is unacceptable medical practice to knowingly give people an amount of a supplement that leaves them at such a low 25(OH)D level they remain unable to properly absorb calcium and well below the 58.8ng/ml level at which human breast milk flows replete with D3.
    So too little vitamin D of any kind leaves you vitamin D deficient.
    Is that such a remarkable finding?

    BUY DISCOUNT Ostoforte 50,000 IU (also called Drisdol) ONLINE 50,000 IU (100 capsules)  $168.99 USD
    or you can choose
    Vitamin D3 $26.95 for 100 X 50,000iu capsules.
    Who, but a fool, chooses to pay $169 when there's a better, cheaper alternative costing only $27?
    Or choosing an oilbased gelcap still saves loads of money.
    Healthy Origins, Vitamin D3, 10,000 IU, 360 Softgels $23.95

    I'm not sure of the point or the common sense, involved in trying to prove a synthetic drug, humans have to convert to D3 anyway, may, in trivial amounts too low to get anybody out of insufficiency, may be as good as a natural, cheaper, product or that equivalence seen in a few persons at a very low dose level, also applies at the sensible, natural levels, desirable for optimum health outcomes.

    While there are cases like this listed in Pubmed it is clear some people do not absorb nor are able to use Vitamin D2.
    We report a case of a 56-year-old woman who received supratherapeutic doses of ergocalciferol (150,000 IU orally daily) for 28 years without toxicity.

    A small trial of just 68 people is unlikely to pick up cases like the above.

    Grassrootshealth Banner Graph shows the amounts people have been taking and the 25(OH)D levels they have achieved.
    6000~8000iu approx 1000iu/daily for each 25lbs you weigh generally produces a natural level at which the body is able to store a sufficient reserve of D3 to be effective at times of crisis.
    This LEF study is another example showing 5000iu/d is not sufficient to get most people above 50ng/ml.

    As Holick knows perfectly well human skin naturally makes 10,000iu/daily given a few minutes full body UVB exposure. It does that for a purpose. Only when researchers start using equivalent EFFECTIVE amounts of the same NATURAL Vitamin D3 biologically identical to the form human skin NATURALLY makes, will we see an improvement rates of chronic illness.

  • Anonymous

    1/21/2010 9:13:05 PM |

    Dr Strange, if you're eating low carb, you have to prep for a GTT by carb-loading for 3-5 days beforehand.  Your pancreas won't be prepared to handle 75g of carb unless you give it a few days to rev up insulin production first.

    The reason that you had no problem with the GTT while McDougalling was that your body was used to high-carb loads, and so the test posed no challenge to your pancreas.

  • TedHutchinson

    1/21/2010 9:33:39 PM |

    Testing in Pairs
    Although this idea is for diabetics I feel it may also be useful for others wanting to see how particular food/exercise choices affect their numbers.
    There is also a short video, a downloadable record form and an example to consider.

  • Anonymous

    1/22/2010 5:22:55 AM |

    I can support what others are saying: before I went low carb, I could eat carbs and my blood glucose would never go above 120; now I eat pretty low carb and a single sweet potato can take me to 150.  I guess one should either eat extremely low carb or extremely high carb to avoid glucose spikes.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/22/2010 3:04:13 PM |

    I worry that chronically eating high-carbohydrate, while generating an "accommodation" response that blunts postprandial blood sugars, will generate pancreatic BURNOUT by constantly challenging the pancreas to overproduce insulin.

  • Vladimir

    1/22/2010 3:47:56 PM |

    I too find that my post-meal glucose goes up much more after I do have carbs, if I'm eating low carb than high carb.  It's kind of amazing, and a little worry-some.

    However, if I eat very low carb, my fasting glucose is in the low 80s, while if I have more carbs, it's in the high 90s the next morning.  For example, I have (following the blog's advice) had absolutely no wheat and minimal sugar since Dec 27.  My fasting glucose had fallen into the low to mid 80s.  Two days ago, I had a large cookie after lunch --  My first wheat/sugar in 3 weeks.  The next morning, my fasting glucose was 98.

  • DrStrange

    1/22/2010 3:57:49 PM |

    Insulin resistance is the key here and dietary fat is a major contributor to IR.  I simultaneously took insulin levels w/ the blood sugar readings in the 75 gm glucose tolerance test above, and they were consistently low normal to slightly below normal, starting w/ undetectable level at fasting. Readings were:

    fasting < 2
    30 minutes = 3
    60 minutes = 5
    120 minutes = 14
    180 minutes = 8


    reference ranges given on lab report:
    fasting  < 17
    30 minutes = 6-86
    60 minutes = 8-112
    120 minutes = 5-55
    180 minutes = 3-20


    Doesn't seem like too much risk of burn out there!  And again, the reason for the low insulin output generating a fairly flat and low sugar curve was that without excess dietary fat (7-10% of total calories), there is dramatically reduced insulin resistance.

  • Matt Stone

    1/22/2010 6:47:00 PM |

    Thanks for bringing up the importance of blood sugar levels. I've done the same thing with my followers in my recent eBook on type 2 Diabetes, Metabolic Syndrome, and Prediabetes.

    What I have done is take it a step further. Instead of noting what my blood sugar reaction is to a large meal full of high GI starch and trying to avoid it, my focus has been finding ways to improve my glucose tolerance to such a meal.

    My glucose response to food is now far better than any single person following the advice of this blog. That much I can guarantee. It is not luck. It is not genetics. I watched my numbers fall as I followed insights that I gained from several years of intense investigation on the subject.

    The big thing that low-carb authors are missing is that unrefined carbohydrates can improve glucose response to food, even if they cause a larger rise in blood sugar in the short-term.

    My blood sugar now peaks at levels below 80 mg/dl after meals, something that the medical and nutrition-sphere probably considers to be impossible. But it's not. It's glucose metabolism perfection, but it's not achieved through limiting glucose intake. In fact, that can make your response to glucose worse, not better.

  • I Pull 400 Watts

    1/22/2010 9:58:30 PM |

    When you say low carb, what percentage of your calories are coming from carbs? Talking under 30% here?

  • Ateronon

    1/23/2010 6:43:30 AM |

    Off topic here but wish you would discuss salt and its effect on heart disease. There has just been a well publicized news story on it:

    http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/01/21/salt.intake/

    Do you recommend cutting salt intake to your patients?

    Great blog!

  • DrStrange

    1/23/2010 9:38:02 PM |

    "...if I eat very low carb, my fasting glucose is in the low 80s...  Two days ago, I had a large cookie after lunch -- My first wheat/sugar in 3 weeks. The next morning, my fasting glucose was 98."

    Yes, the high fat content of low-carb diet causes insulin resistance!  If you ate low fat (around 10% total calories max) for a couple weeks then you would maintain the lower fasting sugar after a carb load. Though if that cookie had a lot of fat in it, that could be enough to kick up the insulin resistance again.  One other possibility is if you are gluten intolerant, the stress to your system of eating wheat cookie could make fasting bg higher.

  • Vladimir

    1/24/2010 3:28:38 AM |

    Dr. Strange, Do you have any evidence that a diet high in healthy fats -- I'm a vegetarian, so I get little saturated fat -- causes insulin resistance?  I've never seen that theory propounded, and the mechanism seems implausible to me.

  • Matt Stone

    1/24/2010 5:57:21 PM |

    Dr. Strange-

    Interesting thoughts and you are right to question low-carb dogma as well as to show that insulin resistance is the core problem - and that a very high-fat, low-carb diet worsens the core problem.

    Anyone questioning this has not researched the issue thoroughly enough.


    However, you are making the same mistake. Eating a high-carb, low-fat diet for an extended period of time, while lowering your fasting glucose and insulin levels, also makes your glucose tolerance worse.

    Let me explain...

    If you have a basline meal, let's say, a slab of baby back ribs with cornbread and baked beans, and your 1-hour pp is 140 mg/dl, fasting the next day is 100, then you have good base numbers to track improvement.

    Eat low-carb, high-fat for 10 weeks, eat that same meal (ribs), and both your fasting and pp glucose levels will be higher than they were before you went low-carb. This means you're in worse shape than before the experiment.

    If you eat low-fat, high-carb for 10 weeks, and you eat a slab of ribs, cornbread, and baked beans...
    You're pp and FG will measure into the stratosphere (my 1-hour pp actually hit 173 mg/dl breaking a low-fat escapade...nutritarian).

    Both diets made your glucose metabolism worse in response to your baseline meal.  In other words, both strategies give you better numbers in the interim while making you fundamentally unhealthier (not to mention eating low-fat will make you crave more fat and low-carb will make you crave more carbs).

    What I've found is how to improve your glucose levels and insulin sensitivity in response to normal mixed food ratios. That's where real healing is achieved. A low-carber or a "low-fatter" will never get to a point where he or she can eat a large mixed meal with lots of fat, carbohdyrates, protein, and calories without having high postprandial spikes and high fasting glucose levels. Only someone who can eat 2 baked potatoes with 2T of butter and an 8-ounce untrimmed ribeye with fasting levels in the 70's and pp's in the 70-90 range is truly healthy and free of insulin resistance. I've found the secret to achieving that, and it is not low-fat, low-carb, or low-calorie.

    If such a meal sends your blood sugar half way to Mars, then you need to fix that!  Not avoid it!

  • Anonymous

    1/24/2010 11:32:13 PM |

    @ Matt Stone:

    Stop spamming! Yes, "everyone is wrong but I have figured it all out but for won't tell you what it is unless you go to my web site and pay me" is a spam, plain and simple. Please stop it.

  • DrStrange

    1/25/2010 12:42:19 AM |

    MattStone said: "Only someone who can eat 2 baked potatoes with 2T of butter and an 8-ounce untrimmed ribeye with fasting levels in the 70's and pp's in the 70-90 range is truly healthy and free of insulin resistance."

    That is somewhat how I used to eat and my fasting sugar level was creeping skyward.  Switched to low carb and felt gradually worse and worse for the 9 months I did it.  Switched to low-fat/starch based diet and have been feeling very well and not craving fat at all.  I do eat a little over an ounce per day of flax and pumpkin seeds for EFA boost.

    On 4 different occasions over the past couple years I have sent my blood sugar way up from one meal of moderate fat intake.  One was from eating all the seeds in a medium sized Delicata squash in one meal, maybe 1/2 cup or a bit more.

    Admittedly my liver is not in the best of shape due to much solvent exposure working in surfboard industry years ago and this my contribute...

    Don't have evidence handy but my understanding is that saturated fat is the biggest contributor to IR, much more so than unsaturated. There is some saturated fat in veg foods, some are very high in fact like coconut.

  • DrStrange

    1/25/2010 1:53:35 AM |

    Matt, Have read some on your blog site and think I get the overall picture of what you are doing but...

    What about the demographic data showing increasing cancer rates w/ increasing consumption of animal protein?  And the at least transient damage from meals high in sat. fat?:

    http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/short/48/4/715
    Consumption of Saturated Fat Impairs the Anti-Inflammatory Properties of High-Density Lipoproteins and Endothelial Function
    CONCLUSIONS: Consumption of a saturated fat reduces the anti-inflammatory potential of HDL and impairs arterial endothelial function. In contrast, the anti-inflammatory activity of HDL improves after consumption of polyunsaturated fat. These findings highlight novel mechanisms by which different dietary fatty acids may influence key atherogenic processes.

    And this one is a little concerning (its title tells the tale):
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18263705
    Glucose and leptin induce apoptosis in human beta-cells and impair glucose-stimulated insulin secretion through activation of c-Jun N-terminal kinases.

    More on low fat diet and atherosclerosis:

    http://www.heartattackproof.com/resolving_cade.htm

    It is a fascinating concept that increasing leptin dramatically reduces insulin resistance.  Leptin secretion seems to be induced by increasing glucose level, so eating starch (unrefined carbs like potatoes, whole grains, etc)which converts directly to glucose, should raise leptin level.  What I do not understand is the need for high fat and saturated fat in the diet, nor the need for "overfeeding."  We do need a certain amount of fat in our diets, but a plant based diet, with the addition of an ounce or so of selected seeds/nuts does seem to cover the 10-15% calories from fat we need without the increased disease risks of higher fat intake, and the risks from intake of large amounts of animal protein.

  • billye

    1/25/2010 5:03:20 PM |

    All 42 comments are amazing,

    Lots of varied comments here.  How do you suppose we all arrived here in the first place?  Our genes traveled through the ages,  without the benefit of all of this information.  How did they do this you might ask?  Simple, our ancient ancestors ate what their genes required for survival, full fat wild animal product, supplemented by a few wild not very starchy roots pulled from the ground, and seasonal wild not very sweet tree fruit.  This progressed throughout the last 2.5 million years.  That is how we got here.  Where we went wrong is when agriculture and farming started about 10,000 years ago followed by industry.  Our genes did not change much in the last 2.5 million years of eating high saturated fat including all high fat organs and marrow from the bones, with limited seasonal veggies and fruit.  They did not have the benefit of the sage advice of modern traditional medicine, or electronic devices to guide them, relative to the easy to treat by lifestyle change metabolic syndrome diseases.  Weren't they lucky?  Lest you think I am disparaging all doctors, I am not.  G-d forbid you have a broken leg or a disease that is congenital or inherited  that is difficult or near impossible to treat and need a physician, this group of dedicated highly trained professionals are  a life raft, and much appreciated.  I practice what I preach.  I went from a very ill patient to one that has reversed many of the metabolic syndrome illness that I suffered.  I trust the wisdom of my ancient ancestors and my doctors who practice out of the box evolutionary medicine to guide me.

    Billy E

  • Jared

    1/25/2010 5:04:46 PM |

    The information and anecdotes you provide about various heart disease issues is very interesting and useful. There is a registered dietitian in the Kansas City Area that has produced a series of informational videos about weight loss, nutrition and healthy living that you may be interested in. Here is her latest Nutrition 101 Video Series: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KZCjcCTCOE&feature=related

    Thank you and happy heart month!

  • TedHutchinson

    1/25/2010 5:44:47 PM |

    @ Dr Strange
    Nutrition and Metabolism  Dietary fat research
    Perhaps you haven't yet read the Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease Patty W Siri-Tarino, Qi Sun, Frank B Hu, and Ronald M Krauss, Jan. 2010
    showing there is no significant evidence for concluding that dietary saturated fat is associated with an increased risk of CHD or CVD.

    With reference to Consumption of Saturated Fat Impairs the Anti-Inflammatory Properties
    The mitochondria of people new to consuming coconut oil will not be  adjusted to it. It takes time to acquire appropriate gut flora. A single ingestion of an unfamiliar dietary substance will have different effects from long term use of the same substance.

    Any single trial comparing an omega 6 frequently consumed with a type of saturated fat the general public are not generally accustomed to will fail to spot the long term benefits of MCT (coconut oil, saturated fat) consumption.
    MCTs suppress fat deposition through enhanced thermogenesis and fat oxidation. MCT's preserve insulin sensitivity. MCTs regulate production of adipocytokines (e.g., adiponectin.

  • DrStrange

    1/26/2010 12:37:51 AM |

    Billye, you might want to read these.  It is true that ancestors ate full fat wild game, which is very very lean.  Also, 100% of it ate its natural diet and not corn, soy, and synthetic supplements and drugs.  Also, they most likely ate primarily a lot of starchy roots, leaves, flowers, insects, whatever they could collect and some meat when they could get that.  The meaty, beefy, caveman is a romantic fantasy.  They also did not live very long so degenerative diseases of aging were not an issue

    http://diabetesupdate.blogspot.com/2009/09/lets-not-twist-history-to-support-our.html

    http://diabetesupdate.blogspot.com/2009/11/saying-something-over-and-over-doesnt.html

  • billye

    1/26/2010 2:06:40 PM |

    Dr. Strange,

    The reasons that ancient peoples expired at a relatively young age was because diseases that are cured today through the use of antibiotics such as malaria along with the many natural disasters that occurred throughout the ages account for this fact.  However, what they did not die from were the diseases of the metabolic syndrome that you attribute inaccurately to degenerative diseases of old age. They are brought on by the standard American diet.  The degenerative diseases that you mention are first found in ancient egyptians from about 12,000 years ago after the advent of agriculture.  The patients can do their own trials under the watchful eye and monitored by their doctors.  The plain fact is that when switching to an ancient evolutionary lifestyle most of the diseases of the metabolic syndrome  reverse themselves.  This is being accomplished by thousands of people all over the world today, including my self.  You might read the well documented by clinical trials, Good Calories Bad Calories by G. Taubes, and Trick and Treat by B. Groves.  

    Billy E

  • billye

    1/26/2010 3:30:08 PM |

    DR.Strange,

    This is a P.S.  Archaeologists have found many human bones that had cut marks inflicted by other waring clans, along with the fact that the population of those times was very small compared to today's populations.  This is in contrast to the huge carnivore animal populations that walked the earth devouring humans who were in their food chain.  Also of note was the proven fact that ancient populations prized the fattest parts of the animal, brains, organs, and marrow from the bones etc.

    Billy E

  • donny

    1/26/2010 4:33:37 PM |

    Dr Richard Bernstein is in his mid-70s, and has type I diabetes. His diet is around 30 grams of carbohydrate a day, and he has no fear of saturated fat. It beggars the imagination that a man like him, whose pancreas hasn't produced any of it's own insulin in over half a century, should live to a ripe old age (as a male type one diabetic, he's already done this, and he ain't done yet.), but that the same diet should be deadly to the non-diabetic. Maybe he's lucky; but, before he learned to tightly control his own blood sugars, (and with as little insulin as possible), he suffered all kinds of complications, hardening of the arteries, high triglycerides, low hdl, early kidney disease, etc. I think Dr Bernstein and his patients provide proof of concept for what Dr Davis is trying to accomplish here for those suffering insulin resistance, whether they happen to be diabetic or not.
    Matt, you can't test insulin levels with a glucose meter. You also can't test any possibly progressive damage to glucose homeostasis that *might* be caused by a high everything diet over the course of years or even decades in a matter of weeks or months. Nor can you say flat out that your metabolism has been "healed" by such a diet. Has your system healed, or was it just healthy enough in the first place that over time it was capable of making the hormonal adjustments necessary to function well on a mixed diet? Can everybody make that leap?
    The thing about leptin and insulin resistance... one of the effects of leptin is to decrease the appetite for carbohydrate. (Maybe by increasing ketosis? or at least lipolysis.) It's almost like carbohydrate restriction is built right into the system.;)

  • DrStrange

    1/27/2010 12:22:58 AM |

    "...of note was the proven fact that ancient populations prized the fattest parts of the animal, brains, organs, and marrow from the bones..."

    Proven?  How they do that?

  • Anna

    1/27/2010 5:12:13 AM |

    FYI, a few tips I have picked up in the years I have been testing my BG,

    For the least amount of pain sensation when lancing my finger, I take the blood sample from the *side* of my finger tip, *not* on the pad or the tip.    

    If you have chronially cold hands it can be hard to get a good enough sample.  Wash hands with warm water first, dry well.  Swing arm in a big arc few times if necessary, to force more blood to the hands.  Sometimes my house is a bitt chilly but my car is warm from the sun in the driveway.  A few minutes sitting in the sunny car warms up my hands considerably, making a blood drop easy to get.

    It's ok to slightly "milk" the finger from the palm to the tip once, but with warm hands and a few pre-lancing "swings" (described above), that shouldn't be necessary.  It shouldn't take a lot of "milking" to get a good enough sample.

    There's no need to change the lancet tip for each test sample if you are the only one using the lancet (with clean hands, of course).  In fact, the lancet tips become more comfortable with use.  I change the tip only when it becomes dull and uncomfortable.  It goes without saying the lancet tip should always be changed if it is used to get a blood sample for another person.

    Speaking of clean hands, be sure there is no sugar on your hands or it can affect your results.  Wink

  • TedHutchinson

    1/27/2010 1:04:07 PM |

    @ Anna
    Thanks for tips. I've just started testing (following Dr D's suggestion)
    Bit surprised at some of the numbers.
    5.7=102mg/dl premeal
    8.1=146mg/dl 1hr after meal
    Chicken portion in curry sauce + carrots
    Probably tikka sauce (bought ready meal sugar listed 3rd in marinade and in sauce. Won't buy that again.
    Generally between 6.1 and 6.9 110mg/dl~125mg/dl

  • billye

    1/27/2010 2:20:12 PM |

    Dr. Strange,

    There is so much Paleolithic archaeological proof that ancient populations prized brains, organs, and marrow from bones, that it boggles the mind.  Have you not read about the thousands of bones along with tools found in ancient caves? They were smashed to get at the brains and marrow.  I call your attention to the Quarterly Review Of Biology, Vol 79, No1 March 2004, one of the many studies and reports out there.  Meat eating - dietary shift to increased regular consumption of fatty animal tissues in the course of hominid evolution as mediated by selection for "meat adaptive" genes.  This selection conferred resistance to disease risks associated with meat eating also in life expectancy.  The data was produced at the University of southern California, Los Angeles California.  This argument is long over, unless you wish to ignore all of the indisputable archaeological proof available.  Lets get on with out of the box medicine which supports health.  

    Billy E, nephropal.com

  • The Accidental Farmer

    1/29/2010 12:30:13 PM |

    Coach Jeff said: Since an LC diet causes insulin resistance, (Actually a GOOD and protective thing within the context of an LC diet) . . .

    I am new to this blog, got the link from the Taubes Talk yahoogroups board, and I am curious about this statement.  Why is IR good and protective?  I eat a very high fat diet, as well as low carb, as that is what seems to control my hypoglycemia the best, and so this statement seems counter-intuitive.  Or am I mistaken in thinking that hypoglycemia is a sign that one is developing insulin resistance?  If so, then it would seem that if something relieves the symptoms of hypoglycemia, then it is not leading to further insulin resistance.

  • TedHutchinson

    2/9/2010 3:09:04 PM |

    Following Dr Davis's suggestion I bought a Lifescan Onetouch Ultraeasy from Ebay.
    With too many readings higher than I expected, I needed a better way of recording numbers.
    The people at the freephone number at this link
    Lifescan Onetouch will send a cable and software to load and record your readings quickly and easily directly from the meter together with a simple Quick Start Manual.
    As they don't charge for the disk it's quicker and easier than downloading the software, the cable makes the data transfer from meter even quicker.

    People with different makes of meter may like to download the software anyway and enter their figures manually.
    When you have entered a few days readings, the graphs make it easier to see trends.

  • Ron

    2/11/2010 3:09:33 PM |

    I've always been skeptical about the concept that saturated fat increases insulin resistance and here's an article that addresses that fact directly:

    http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2010/02/saturated-fat-and-insulin-sensitivity.html

  • DrStrange

    2/11/2010 8:01:33 PM |

    "I've always been skeptical about the concept that saturated fat increases insulin resistance..."

    Compared to mono fat, not much if any difference.  Try comparing to very low fat diet ie about 10% of total calories and you will clearly see that fat in and of itself, if too much in diet, will indeed greatly increase IR.

  • Andreas

    2/15/2010 12:57:46 PM |

    Dr. Davis, I followed your advice and bought a glucometer. I got severe cravings from time to time. So last time I could not resist I checked my blood sugar. That was after I ate about 300g of nuts, drank a bottle of red wine and ate a big family chocolate bar. The glucometer showed 86 mg/dl which is within normal range. How is that possible?

    Do you have any further recommendations what to look out for in a case like this? I would really like to find the reason and overcome those cravings. I'm not overweight, in fact more the athletic kind of guy. I started eating paleo/EF about a year ok and am doing mostly great except for the cravings.

    Thank you!
    Andreas

Loading
8 mg, triglycerides of 210 mg, an unimpressive LDL of 133 mg but comprised of 99% small LDL, and excessive IDL (meaning that he was unable to clear dietary fats after eating).

At 5 feet 10 inches, Jerry weighed 190 lbs. He showed a slight excess bulge at the tummy, but hardly obese.

Jerry's history was remarkable, however, for the amount of carbohydrates he ate. "I'm addicted to bread. I love it! If I smell a loaf of fresh baked bread, I sometimes eat the whole loaf!"

Jerry also admitted to over-indulging in bagels (whole wheat), pretzels, low-fat snack chips, Raisin Bran cereal, Cheerios, and noodles. In fact, many days he'd have 5 or 6 servings of any of these foods. He also complained of an extraordinary amount of bowel gas and cramping. "Sometimes, I'm afraid to go to a group function. I might embarass myself."

I suggested an experiment: For a 4 week period, completely eliminate wheat-containing products--breads, pretzels, breakfast cereals, pasta, etc. In their place, increase intake of protein foods like eggs, raw almonds and walnuts, low-fat yogurt, cottage cheese, chicken, fish, and use healthy oils (olive, canola, grapeseed, flaxseed) more liberally.

Just four weeks later, Jerry came to the office a new man: 8 lbs lighter, brighter, with bursts of energy he hadn't had in years. And no gas!

Lesson: Wheat-based carbohydrates can be the culprit behind many lipoprotein patterns, especially low HDL, high triglycerides, small LDL, and others. Wheat can also be responsible for a myriad of abdominal symptoms, even joint pains and rashes. In its most extreme form, it's called "celiac disease". But experiences like Jerry's are quite common--not as obvious and dramatic as full-blown celliac disease, but smouldering and destructive, nonetheless.

Track Your Plaque expert, Dr. Loren Cordain of Colorado State University, tells us that, in his reconstruction of the history of human illness, there was an extraodinary surge in disease just about the time when humans began cultivating wheat around 8000 B.C. (Track Your Plaque members: Read Dr. Cordain's fascinating interview at http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_04-005cordaininterview.asp.)

Do you need to eliminate wheat products entirely from your diet? It's something to think about, particularly if you share any of the difficulties that Jerry had.


*In general, I do not recommend heart scanning as a self-prescribed tool for chest pain or other symptoms. Symptoms should always be discussed with your doctor.

Hospital Administrators' Wish List

I've known enough hospital administrators over the years to understand what most of them want.

Of course, most of them want to deliver high quality care to patients in a safe, efficient setting. They want to comply with national standards of performance, attract quality physicians to use their facilities, and appeal to patients as a desirable place to obtain care.

But one fact is hard for many administrators to ignore: 30% of a hospital's revenues and 50% of their profits come from heart services.

So, if your hospital administrator had a wish list, I believe that among their wishes would be:

--More heart catheterizations, angioplasties, stents, and bypass surgery.
--More pacemaker and defibrillator implantations.
--More heart attacks.
--More heart failure with need for intravenous infusions, defibrillators, and bi-ventricular pacemaker implantations.
--More heart valve surgery.

Highly successful hospitals do more of these procedures than less successful hospitals.

Are you getting the picture? Heart care is a business. It's not very different than Target, Home Depot, or McDonalds--businesses eager to sell more of their product. Yes, there is attention to detail, quality, and competitiveness, but the bottom line is "sell more product, make more profit."

Keep this in mind the next time you catch one of the many TV or newspaper ads, radio spots, physician "interviews", or other media pitches in your town. Does Target run ads for the public good or to generate profitable sales? Does your hospital run ads to broadcast its contribution to public welfare or to generate profitable "sales"? Pretty clear, isn't it?

Poor, neglected vitamin D!

We now routinely check blood levels of vitamin D in all our patients. I am reminded everyday that, if you're a resident of a northern climate (as we are in Wisconsin and similarly in Michigan, Washington, New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, etc.), the overwhelming likelihood is that you are deficient in vitamin D. And not just a little deficient, but severely deficient.

As humans, we're meant to obtain vitamin D through exposure to sunlight. This was how humans evolved. We are all ill-equipped to get vitamin D through nutritional sources. The average (Wisconsin) patient we see has vitamin D blood levels of 17-30 ng/dl. Most authorities would agree that a level of 30 ng or less would constitute severe deficiency. An ideal level is probably around 50 ng, what many (but not all) residents of southern climates like Florida, Texas, and Hawaii have if they get frequent sun exposure.

When vitamin D levels are normal, bone health is maximized (inhibiting osteoporosis); prostate, uterine, breast, and colon health is heightened and cancer risk diminished; pre-diabetic and diabetic patterns are suppressed and blood sugar reduced; blood pressure drops 10 mgHg, on average;and inflammatory measures like C-reactive protein are substantialy reduced. But, of greatest interest to us, coronary plaque is easier to regress.

Although our experience in the last several hundred people is still anecdotal, I believe that I'm seeing a dramatic increase in the amount and rapidity of coronary plaque regression. People we've struggled with are suddenly regressing. People with higher heart scan scores (e.g., >500) are regressing more readily.

We're accumulating our data and it will take a couple more years to develop it in a scientifically-useful format. But, in the meantime, adding vitamin D to your program or having your vitamin D level checked may be among the most important steps you can take to gain control over coronary plaque. Be sure to ask your doctor to get the right blood test: it must be 25-OH-vitamin D3. (The wrong test is the 1,25-OH2-vitamin D3; though they look and sound the same, they measure very different parts of the vitamin D pathway.) Also, Track Your Plaque members: read Dr. John Cannell's tremendous summary of the vitamin D experience on the Track Your Plaque website.

Leave the greatest legacy to your children

Phyllis was dumbfounded when she learned of her heart scan score of 995. At age 56, this placed her solidly in the 99th percentile--a score that grouped her with the worst 1% of scores for women her age. Track Your Plaque followers know that scores of 1000 (just days away, given the expected 30% increase in score per year!) pose a risk of heart attack, symptoms leading to stent or bypass, or death of 25% per year.

But after Phyllis gathered her thoughts and thought it over, her first question was "What about my children?"

A natural response for a mother. Phyllis' "children" actually ranged in age from 26 to 37. We talked about how, given her high score, she'd probably been creating plaque in her coronary arteries for 20 years. This triggered her mother's concern for her kids.


This is probably the #1 most useful lesson for all of us. If we learn of our own risk for heart disease, we can pass our concerns on to our children. Imagine how much more well-equipped you could be if you started out with the advice and experience of a parent who'd identified and then conquered their heart disease risk.

Pass your awareness and knowledge on to your children, particularly if they are 30 years old or more.

Interestingly, my own personal experience with my 14-year old son taught me a lesson or two. I had previously assumed that, at age 14, how could he be even remotely interested in these issues? (I have a terrible family history of heart disease and I have a high heart scan score myself.) When my son asked that we check his lipid values (I talk about this more than I'd like to admit!), we did a fingerstick lipid panel in my office. Lo and behold, his HDL (good) cholesterol was a shocking 31 mg--exceptionally low for a teenager. His risk for heart disease over the long-term is very high.

Much to my surprise, this awareness has triggered a genuine interest in healthy eating. It's not uncommon to see him examine food labels and to report to me that "Hey, Dad. Can you believe that this yogurt has 43 grams of carbohydrates?"

Pass on the lessons you've learned to your children and to the important people in your life. This is probably the most crucial lesson you can take from the Track Your Plaque experience.

Half effort will get you half results

Greg walked into the office.

"Just back from a 10-day Caribbean cruise, Doc. It was fabulous."

"Yes, but I see you're 14 lbs heavier. What happened?"

"Well, you know, a 24-hour a day open brunch. Anything and everything you wanted. But I only had dessert twice."

"Did you exercise?"

"Come on, Doc! It was vacation!"

With this serious indiscretion, Greg gained 14 lbs in 10 days. That's a total surplus of 49,000 calories Greg put in his body over that period. 49,000!

Greg had started the cruise 40 lbs overweight. Now, he's 54 lbs overweight. The pre-diabetic tendency he showed earlier was now full diabetes. All associated lipoproteins blossomed with it--small LDL, a drop in HDL of 5 points, triglycerides skyrocketing to 320.

He blew it.

Can Greg turn back? Yes, he most likely can, given a serious and rapid effort to lose the weight he gained on the cruise and more.

But can he do it? I doubt it.

Someone who allows himself to gain an extraordinary quantity of weight, completely neglects exercise, then blows it off as having some fun will never succeed.

In all honesty, this is someone who shouldn't waste his time in the Track Your Plaque program. He will fail--period. By failure I mean he will experience explosive plaque growth over the next few years and then end up with stent(s), heart attack, bypass surgery. Some people will die. He will also--should he survive--experience the long-term complications of diabetes, such as retinal disease, kidney impairment, loss of sensation to his feet and legs, and on and on. His life will be substantially abbreviated.

To me, there's no choice. But Greg and many people like him are fooling themselves if they believe that a half-hearted effort will allow them to succeed in controlling or reversing heart disease. Maybe we'll come up with some magic supplement or prescription medication that will erase his heart disease in a few days.

Don't count on it. I'll make no bones about it. Controlling and reversing heart disease requires a commitment--a full commitment to eat and live healthy, to follow the advice we give, and not engage in serious indiscretions that erode your efforts. If you believe that taking 40 mg of Lipitor is all you're going to need to regress heart disease, plan on your first stent or heart attack within a few years. And you'll hobble to the doctor's office in the meantime.
Heart disease is everywhere

Heart disease is everywhere

If you ever need convincing that heart disease is everywhere, you should do what I do: subscribe to Google Alerts and have them forward news anytime the search phrase "heart attack" crosses the web. (Just go to Google, click on "more" to the right of the search bar, and follow the links.)


Some recent samples:


Workmates resuscitate driver after heart attack

A woman coal mine truck driver had a heart attack and required resuscitation with a defibrillator 3 times on the way to the hospital.





Heart attack kills groom at reception
A 34-year old man died during his wedding reception, leaving behind his 26-year old new wife.






Heart attack ruled as cause of crash

An Alabama man drove his pick-up truck into oncoming traffic while suffering a heart attack.






Heart-attack victim to return to Hamburg stage


Country music artist, Michael Harding, suffered a heart attack and cardiac arrest during a performance. He is apparently recovered and returning to the stage.



That's just a sample from the last two days. While you and I are carry on a conversation on reversal of heart disease, our neighbors and friends drop over every day. Even though I witness successful heart disease reversal routinely, the rest of the world is not participating.

Pass it on: Coronary disease is identifiable, preventable, controllable, and reversible.
Loading
All posts by william-davis

Let's make it a lot easier

The American Heart Association just released a new set of consensus guidelines on heart disease prevention in women: Evidence-Based Guidelines for Cardiovascular Disease Prevention in Women: 2007 Update

For those of you following the Heart Scan Blog and the Track Your Plaque program, there will be little new in the guidelines. In fact, you'll wonder if the date on the front of the report should be 1987, rather than 2007. Did you know that you should exercise and eat healthy?

Take a look at the list of risk factors for coronary vascular disease (CVD) listed in the report:

Major risk factors for CVD, including:
Cigarette smoking
Poor diet
Physical inactivity
Obesity, especially central adiposity
Family history of premature CVD (CVD at <55>

Progress: You'll notice that buried inside the list is "Evidence of subclinical vascular disease (e.g., coronary calcification)". Just a few short years ago that wouldn't have even been included.

The Track Your Plaque contention is that, for the great majority of women, this list could be shortened to one item: coronary calcification. As time goes on, the people who argue and draft these guidelines will come to the realization that coronary calcification is the disease--it's not a risk for the disease, a predictor of the disease. Coronary calcification is the disease itself. The other items on the list recede way into the background when you know whether or not coronary atherosclerosis is present, i.e., you know your heart scan score (of coronary calcium).

The report goes to say such things as taking a little bit of fish oil is a good idea, maintaining a normal blood pressure is desirable. . . yada yada yada. You've heard this all before.

A major part of the treatment guidelines are devoted to LDL cholesterol reduction with statin agents. You shouldn't be surprised. It's amazing what $22 billion dollars in revenues will buy.

A closing paragraph reads:

'Population-wide strategies are necessary to combat the
pandemic of CVD in women, because individually tailored
interventions alone are likely insufficient to maximally prevent
and control CVD. Public policy as an intervention to
reduce gender-based disparities in CVD preventive care and
improve cardiovascular outcomes among women must become
an integral strategy to reduce the global burden of
CVD.'


Say that again? If you understood that bit of gobbledygook, you're a lot smarter than me.

Don't look to the American Heart Association report for any new ideas. It reminds me of the politician who reminds everybody of what a devoted family man he is: It has nothing to do with his policies. It just makes him look good. If compared to prior report, the 2007 report does indeed represent progress--but just oh so little.

No wonder nobody talks about real prevention

Take a look at this eye-opening statement taken from a well-written NY Times article about Dr. Arthur Agatston, the South Beach Diet and now South Beach Heart Program books:


'We have made major improvements in prevention,” Dr. Gregg W. Stone, the director of cardiovascular research at Columbia University, says. “But it’s difficult. It takes frequent visits, a close relationship between a physician and a patient and a very committed patient.'

Which is exactly the atmosphere Dr. Agatston’s practice tries to create. Nurses there give patients specific cholesterol goals to meet and help them deal with the side effects of the drugs they are taking. A nutritionist, Marie Almon, meets with patients frequently enough to discuss real-life issues like how to stick to a high-fiber Mediterranean diet even on a cruise or a business trip.

There is only one problem with this shining example of a medical practice: it is losing money.



From NY Times, January 24, 2007. What’s a Pound of Prevention Really Worth? (Find the full text at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/24/business/24leonhardt.html?ex=1172379600&en=4268a738e82857da&ei=5070.)

It gets at one of the fundamental reasons why your cardiologist will probably never talk to you about an intense approach to prevention: it doesn't pay. Because John Q. Cardiologist focuses, instead, on how to increase procedural volume, train how to put in the next best defibrillator, etc., there is little consciousness about preventive issues. Just the simple matter of taking fish oil causes their eyes to glaze over.

That's why the Track Your Plaque program exists: it is a portal for the kind of information you cannot get. Of course, you could read all the scientific studies, attempt years of trial and error, and try to gain a sense of how to do this yourself. Or you could follow this program. We are proud to not worry about generating procedural profits. We ar unbiased by drug or medical device money. We say exactly what we mean.

By the way, we are on a current push to really "beef-up" our online discussions via real-time chat. Long-term, we'd like to be able to offer chat with our staff many hours every day. Be patient. It will happen, but not today.

HDL and vitamin D

I know of no published reports on this question, but I've now seen numerous people experience significant jumps in HDL with raising blood vitamin D to 25-OH-vitamin D3.

Last week, for example, I had a man who had struggled with raising HDL from a starting level of 28 mg/dl. On niacin, exercise, weight loss, fish oil, red wine, and cilostazol (a prescription agent that I use occasionally that raises HDL), his HDL rose to 41 mg/dl--better, but hardly to our goal.

I added vitamin D, 4000 units, and raised his 25-OH-vitamin D3 level from 22 ng/ml to 53 ng/ml. Next HDL: 73 mg/dl! Small LDL improves along with a rise in HDL.

Not everybody's response is this dramatic. I see more typical rises of 5 to 10 mg/dl every day. I'm uncertain of why the response is inconsistent, though people who begin with lower vitamin D levels seem to experience a larger HDL increase. I wonder if the partial normalization of insulin and glucose responses is at work, or some anti-inflammatory effect.

Vitamin D provides so many other benefits, as well as HDL-raising. I hope you've gone to the effort to have your blood level checked to determine your replacement need. If not, now's the time. February represents your nadir (lowest point) for 25-OH-vitamin D3 blood levels.

Even more Michael Pollan

"Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.

That, more or less, is the short answer to the supposedly incredibly complicated and confusing question of what we humans should eat in order to be maximally healthy. I hate to give away the game right here at the beginning of a long essay, and I confess that I’m tempted to complicate matters in the interest of keeping things going for a few thousand more words. I’ll try to resist but will go ahead and add a couple more details to flesh out the advice. Like: A little meat won’t kill you, though it’s better approached as a side dish than as a main. And you’re much better off eating whole fresh foods than processed food products. That’s what I mean by the recommendation to eat “food.” Once, food was all you could eat, but today there are lots of other edible foodlike substances in the supermarket. These novel products of food science often come in packages festooned with health claims, which brings me to a related rule of thumb: if you’re concerned about your health, you should probably avoid food products that make health claims. Why? Because a health claim on a food product is a good indication that it’s not really food, and food is what you want to eat."


Michael Pollan, author of my latest favorite book, The Omnivore's Dilemma, wrote a wonderful piece for the New York Times entitled "Unhappy Meals". You can find the full text at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/28/magazine/28nutritionism.t.html?ex=1172120400&en=a78c20f4da0cdc7b&ei=5070. (Another favorite read of mine, The Fanatic Cook's Blog at , alerted me to Pollan's article. Incidentally, take a look at the Fanatic Cook's latest posts--very entertaining and informative. She's got incisive insight into foods as well as a great sense of humor.)

Pollan goes on to say that...

"...typical real food has more trouble competing under the rules of nutritionism, if only because something like a banana or an avocado can’t easily change its nutritional stripes (though rest assured the genetic engineers are hard at work on the problem). So far, at least, you can’t put oat bran in a banana. So depending on the reigning nutritional orthodoxy, the avocado might be either a high-fat food to be avoided (Old Think) or a food high in monounsaturated fat to be embraced (New Think). The fate of each whole food rises and falls with every change in the nutritional weather, while the processed foods are simply reformulated. That’s why when the Atkins mania hit the food industry, bread and pasta were given a quick redesign (dialing back the carbs; boosting the protein), while the poor unreconstructed potatoes and carrots were left out in the cold.

Of course it’s also a lot easier to slap a health claim on a box of sugary cereal than on a potato or carrot, with the perverse result that the most healthful foods in the supermarket sit there quietly in the produce section, silent as stroke victims, while a few aisles over, the Cocoa Puffs and Lucky Charms are screaming about their newfound whole-grain goodness."


Not everything Pollan says is new, but he says it so eloquently and cleverly that he's worth reading. If you haven't yet read Omnivore's Dilemma, or just want a condensed version of the book, the New York Times piece is a great piece of the world according to Michael Pollan.

My life is easy

In the old days (the 1980s and 1990s), practicing cardiology was very physically and emotionally demanding. Since procedures dominated the practice and preventive strategies were limited, heart attacks were painfully common. It wasn't unusual to have to go to the hospital for a patient having a heart attack at 3 am several times a week.

Those were the old days. Nowadays, my life is easy. Heart attacks, for the most part, are a thing of the past in the group of people who follow the Track Your Plaque principles. I can't remember the last time I had a coronary emergency for someone following the program.

But I am reminded of what life used to be like for me when I occasionally have to live up to my hospital responsibilities and/or cover the practices of my colleagues. (Though I voice my views on prevention to my colleagues, the most I get is a odd look. When a colleague recently covered my practice for a weekend while I visited family out of town, he commented to me how quiet my practice was. I responded, "That's because my patients are essentially cured." "Oh, sure they are." He laughed. No registration that he had witnessed something that was genuine and different from his experience of day-to-day catastrophe among his own patients. None.)

I recently had to provide coverage for a colleague for a week while he took his family to Florida. During the 7 days, his patients experienced 4 heart attacks. That is, 4 heart attacks among patients under the care of a cardiologist.

If you want some proof of the power of prevention, watch your results and compare them to the "control" group of people around you: neighbors, colleagues, etc. Unfortunately, the word on prevention, particularly one as powerful as Track Your Plaque, is simply not as widespread as it should be. Instead, it's drowned out in the relentless flood of hospital marketing for glitzy hospital heart programs, the "ask your doctor about" ads for drugs like Plavix, which is little better than spit in preventing heart attacks (except in stented patients), and the media's fascinating with high-tech laser, transplant, robotic surgery, etc.

Prevention? That's not news. But it sure can make the slow but sure difference between life and death, having a heart attack or never having a heart attack.

My bread contains 900 mg omega-3

Phyllis is the survivor of a large heart attack (an "anterior" myocardial infarction involving the crucial front of the heart) several years ago. Excessive fatigue prompted a stress test, which showed poor blood flow in areas outside the heart attack zone. This prompted a heart catheterization, then a bypass operation one year ago.

FINALLY, Phyllis began to understand that her unhealthy lifestyle played a role in causing her heart disease. But lifestyle alone wasn't to blame. Along with being 70 lbs overweight and overindulging in unhealthy sweets every day, she also had lipoprotein(a), small LDL particles, and high triglycerides. The high triglycerides were also associated with its evil "friends," VLDL and IDL (post-prandial, or after-eating, particles).

When I met her, Phyllis' triglycerides typically ranged from 200-300 mg/dl . Fish oil was the first solution, since it is marvelously effective for reducing triglycerides, as well as VLDL and IDL. Her dose: 6000 mg of a standard 1000 mg capsule (6 capsules) to provide 1800 mg EPA + DHA, the effective omega-3 fatty acids.

But Phyllis is not terribly good at following advice. She likes to wander off and follow her own path. She noticed that the healthy bread sold at the grocery store and containing flaxseed boasted "900 mg of omega-3s per slice!". So she ate two slices of the flaxseed-containing bread per day and dropped the fish oil.

Guess what? Triglycerides promptly rebounded to 290 mg/dl, along with oodles of VLDL and IDL.

A more obvious example occurs in people with a disorder called "familial hypertriglyceridemia," or the inherited inability to clear triglycerides from the blood. These people have triglycerides of 800 mg/dl, 2000 mg/dl, or higher. Fish oil yields dramatic drops of hundreds, or even thousands of mg. Fish oil likely achieves this effect by activating the enzyme, lipoprotein lipase, that is responsible for clearing blood triglycerides. Flaxseed oil and other linolenic acid sources yield . . .nothing.

Don't get me wrong. Flaxseed is a great food. As the ground seed, it reduces LDL cholesterol, reduces blood sugar, provides fiber for colon health, and may even yield anti-cancer benefits. Flaxseed oil is a wonderful oil, rich in monounsaturates, low in saturates, and rich in linolenic acid, an oil fraction that may provides heart benefits a la Mediterranean diet.

But linolenic acid from flaxseed is not the same as EPA + DHA from fish oil. This is most graphically proven by the lack of any triglyceride-reducing effects of flaxseed preparations.

Enjoy your flaxseed oil and ground flaxseed--but don't stop your fish oil because of it. Heart disease and coronary plaque are serious business. You need serious tools to combat and control them. Fish oil is serious business for triglycerides. Flaxseed is not.

More Omnivore's Dilemma

Another irresistible quote from Michael Pollan’s book, The Omnivore’s Dilemma:

“In many ways breakfast cereal is the prototypical processed food: four cents’ worth of commodity corn (or some other equally cheap grain) transformed into four dollars’ worth of processed food. What an alchemy! Yet it is performed straightforwardly enough: by taking several of the output streams issuing from a wet mill (corn meal, corn starch, corn sweetener, as well as a handful of tinier chemical fractions) and then assembling them into an attractively novel form. Further value is added in the form of color and taste, then branding and packaging. Oh yes, and vitamins and minerals, which are added to give the product a sheen of healthfulness and to replace the nutrients that are lost whenever whole foods are processed. On the strength of this alchemy the cereals group generates higher profits for General Mills than any other division. Since the raw materials in processed foods are so abundant and cheap (ADM and Cargill will gladly sell them to all comers) protecting whatever is special about the value you add to them is imperative.”

A food manufacturer’s nightmare is when you and your family shop in the produce aisle in the grocery store. Produce is unmodified (aside from the pesticide and genetic-engineering issues), not added to, and therefore of no interest to the food manufacturer, since no additional profit can be squeezed out of it. If you pay 45 cents for a cucumber, there’s no room for a processor to multiply it’s return.

Vegetables and fruits have imperfections, no doubt, particularly pesticide residues and the “dumbing-down” of some foods to increase their desirability (e.g., green grapes, what I call “grape candy”). But vegetables and fruits are the closest you can get to foods that are essentially unmodified by a food manufacturer. Due to the absence of processing, they are not calorie-dense like a bag of chips; they include all the naturally-occurring healthy factors like flavonoids that food scientists have, thus far, struggled and failed to identify, quantify, and control; and they lack all the unhealthy additives that processed foods require for extended shelf life, palatability, and reconstitution (anti-separating agents, emulsifiers, sweeteners, etc.)

Vegetables, in particular, should be the cornerstone of your plaque control program. Not breakfast cereals, breads, bacon, sausage, mayonnaise, fruit drinks and soda, all the foods that worsen the causes of coronary plaque and raise your heart scan score.

If you would like to understand how the current perverted state of affairs in food have come about, Pollan’s book is must reading.

Pollan's The Omnivore's Dilemma


“ ‘You are what you eat’ is a truism hard to argue with, and yet it is, as a visit to a feedlot suggests, incomplete, for you are what what you eat eats, too. And what we are, or have become, is not just meat but number 2 corn and oil.”

Author Michael Pollan offers unique, enlightening, and entertaining insights into the food we eat in his new book, The Omnivore’s Dilemma: A natural history of four meals.

Pollan draws parallels between the dilemma of the primitive human living in the wild, having to stumble through the choices of animals and plants that could nourish or kill, and the ironically modern return of this phenomenon in present-day supermarkets. While the dangers of food choices aren’t as immediate as in the wild (eat the wrong mushroom or herb, for instance, and you die), they can nonetheless be life-threatening, or at least health-threatening. Hydrogenated oils, high-fructose corn syrup, carageenan, guar gum. . .“What is all this stuff anyway, and where in the world did it come from?”

Among the issues Pollan discusses is that of modern cattle raising practices: the rush to fatten a cow from an 80 lb calf to a 1200-pound, bloated cow over a period of 14 months. Nature created this animal to mature over a 4 to 5 year period through grazing, thus it’s beautifully “engineered” ruminant system that allows it to digest cellulose in grasses, a process that humans and other mammals are incapable of. The pressures to bring greater quantities of beef to market at a reduced price and make more money have resulted in a farming industry that encourages the incorporation of unnatural, often inhumane practices like corn feeding (rather than grass grazing), refeeding of bovine body parts (thus “mad cow disease”), and widespread and chronic administration of hormones and antibiotics.

(I can't help but think that the rapid and perverse fattening of cattle by industrial "farming" is paralleled by the fattening of the eating American. After all, we are the hapless recipients of this flood of cheap, unhealthy, plasticized food.)

The industrialization of food has de-personalized the act of eating. You no longer have any connection with the green pepper in your salad (unless you grew it yourself), nor do you have any appreciation for the suffering of the cow in your hamburger. Worse, the distortion of livestock raising practices has modified the food composition of meat. Range-fed animals, leaner and richer in omega-3 fatty acids, have been replaced by the marbled, saturated fat-rich modern grocery bought meats.

This is a theme that Pollan reiterates time and again: how food processing adds value to the manufacturer, often starting with a healthy ingredient but modifying it, adding ingredients, taking out others, until it’s something decidedly unhealthy. Yet the manufacturer will trumpet the fact that a healthy ingredient is included. Breakfast cereals are the most blatant example of this. What the heck are Cheerios but an over-processed attempt to make more money out of the simple oat?

Pollan’s eloquent and unique insights into food are definitely worth reading.

As always, per our Track Your Plaque policy, I recommend Mr. Pollan’s book strictly on its merits. We obtain no “cut”, commission, or other financial gain by recommending his book. Track Your Plaque members pay their modest membership fee for truth. They do not pay for us to advertise something that provides hidden advantage to us. We do not advertise, editorialize to steer you towards a specific product or service. What we say, we truly believe.

The most frequently asked question of all

The most frequently asked question on the Track Your Plaque website:

"Can you recommend a doctor in my area who can help me follow the Track Your Plaque program?"

This is a problem. Unfortunately, I wish I could tell everyone that we have hundreds or thousands of physicians nationwide who have been thoroughly educated and adhere to the principles I believe are crucial in heart disease:

1) Identify and quantify the amount of coronary atherosclerotic plaque present. In 2007, the best technique remains CT heart scans.

2) Identify all hidden causes of plaque. This includes Lp(a), post-prandial disorders, small LDL, and vitamin D deficiency.

3) Correct all patterns.


But we don't.

You'd think that this simple formula, as straightforward and rational as it sounds, would be easily followed by many if not most physicians. But Track Your Plaque followers know that it simply is not true. My colleagues, the cardiologists, are hell-bent on implanting the next new device, providing a lot more excitement to them as well as considerably more revenue.

The primary care physician is already swamped in a sea of new information, going from osteoporosis drugs, to arthritis, to gynecologic issues, to skin rashes and flu. Heart disease prevention? Oh yeah, that too. They can only dabble in heart disease prevention a la prescription for Lipitor. That's quick and easy.

Nonetheless, I believe we should work towards identifying the occasional physician who is indeed willing to help people follow a program like Track Your Plaque. As we grow, we will need to identify some mechanism of professional education and we will maintain a record of these practitioners. But right now, we're simply already stretched to the limit just doing what we are doing.

If you come across a physician who practices in this fashion and you've had a positive relationship, we'd like to hear about it.

Do stents kill?

There's apparently a lively conversation going on at the HeartHawk Blog (www.hearthawk.blogspot.com). Among the hot topics raised was just how bad it is to have a stent.

I think that my comments some time back may have started this controversy. I've lately noticed that having a stent screws up your heart scan scoring in the vicinity of the stent. I was referring to the fact that I've now seen several people in the Track Your Plaque program do everything right and then show what I call "regional reversal": unstented arteries show dramatic drops in score of 18-30%, but the artery with a stent shows significant increase in score.

This is consistent with what we observe in the world outside Track Your Plaque when stents are inserted. Someone will get a stent, for instance, in the left anterior descending artery. A year later, there will be a "new" plaque at the mouth of the stent or just beyond the far end. This is generally treated by inserting another stent. Use of a drug-coated stent seems to have no effect on this issue.

Now, my smart friends in the Track Your Plaque program would immediately ask, "Does this mean you continually end up chasing these plaques that arise as a result of stents? Do you create an endless loop of procedures?"

Thankfully, the majority of times you do not. Rarely, this does happen and can lead to need for bypass surgery to circumvent the response. But it is unusual. The tissue that grows above and below stents does seem to be unusually impervious to the preventive efforts we institute.

Perhaps there's some new supplement, medication, or other strategy that will address this curious new brand of plaque growth. Until then, you and I can only take advantage of what is known. If it's any consolation, the plaque that seems to grow because of a previously inserted stent seems to lack the plaque "rupture" capacity of "naturally-occuring" plaque. It is, indeed, somehow different. It is more benign, less likely to cause heart attack. It's always been my feeling that this tissue behaves more like the "scar" tissue that grows within stents, causing "re-stenosis", a more benign, less rupture-prone kind of tissue.