Low HDL makes Dr. Friedewald a liar

There's a $22 billion industry based on treating LDL cholesterol, a fictitious number.

LDL cholesterol is calculated from the following equation:

LDL cholesterol = Total cholesterol - HDL cholesterol - triglycerides/5

So when your doctor tells you that your LDL cholesterol is X, 99% of the time it has been calculated. This is based on the empiric calculation developed by Dr. Friedwald in the 1960s. Back then, it was a reasonable solution, just like bacon and eggs was a reasonable breakfast and a '62 Rambler was a reasonable automobile.

One of the problems with Dr. Friedewald's calculation is that the lower HDL cholesterol, the less accurate LDL cholesterol becomes. If it were just a few points, so what? But what if it were commonly 50 to 100 mg/dl inaccurate? In other words, your doctor tells you that your LDL is 120 mg/dl, but the real number is somewhere between 170 and 220 mg/dl. Does this happen?

You bet it does. In my experience, it is an everyday event. In fact, I'm actually surprised when the Friedewald calculated LDL closely approximates true LDL--it's the exception.

Dr. Friedewald would likely have explained that, when applied to a large population of, say, 10,000 people, calculated LDL is a good representation of true LDL. However, just like saying that the average weight for an American woman is 176 lbs (that's true, by the way), does that mean if you weigh 125 lbs that you are "off" by 41 lbs? No, but it shows how you cannot apply the statistical observations made in large populations to a single individual.

The lower HDL goes, the more inaccurate LDL becomes. This would be acceptable if most HDLs still permitted reasonable estimation of LDL--but it does not. LDL begins to become significantly inaccurate with HDL below 60 mg/dl.

How to get around this antiquated formula? In order of most accurate to least accurate:

--LDL particle number (NMR)--the most accurate by far.

--Apoprotein B--available in most laboratories.

--"Direct" LDL

--Non-HDL--i.e., the calculation of total cholesterol minus HDL. But it's still a calculated with built-in flaws.

--LDL by Friedewald calculation.

My personal view: you need to get an NMR if you want to know what your LDL truly is. A month of Lipitor costs around $80-120. A basic NMR costs less than $90. It's a relative bargain.

Menopause unleashes lipoprotein(a)

Faye was clearly frustrated.

At age 52, she was having chest pains every day. A CT heart scan showed a score of zero. A CT coronary angiogram showed no plaque whatsoever.

"Everything went downhill when my menopause started. I gained weight, I started to have chest pains, my blood pressure went up, my cholesterol shot up."

She saw three physicians, none of whom shed much light on the situation. They ran through the predictable sequence of (horse, not human) estrogens, anti-depressants, suggestions for psychological counseling.

But we checked Faye for lipoprotein(a), which she proved to have at a high level of 182 nmol/l. This explained a lot.

A curious and predictable set of phenomenon occur to females with Lp(a) proceeding through the menopause. As estrogen recedes:

--Lp(a) levels rise dramatically.

--Blood pressure goes up, sometimes creating severe hypertension by mid- to late-50s.

--Chest pain can develop, presumably due to "endothelial dysfunction" or "microvascular angina", both representing abnormal coronary artery constriction facilitated by worsening expression of Lp(a).

All too often, these phenomena get dismissed as simply part of the menopausal package, when they are, in fact, important facets of this very important genetic pattern that confers high risk for heart disease.

If any of this rings familiar for you or a loved one, think Lp(a). Though Faye hadn't yet developed any measurable coronary plaque by her CT heart scan score, it was likely on its way, given the surge in Lp(a) expression as menopause unfolded--unless its recognized and appropriate preventive action taken.

Vitamin D must be oil-based

I've talked about this before, but I need to periodically remind everybody:
Vitamin D must be an oil-based capsule, a gel-cap, not a tablet.

Lisa is one of early success stories: a heart scan score of 447 in her early 40's, modest reduction of CT heart scan score three years ago.

However, Lisa had a difficult time locating oil-based vitamin D. There has, in fact, been a national run on vitamin D and I'm told that even manufacturers are scrambling to keep up with the booming demand. So, she bought tablets instead and was taking 3000 units per day.

She came in for a routine check. Lisa's 25-OH-vitamin D3: 17 ng/ml, signifying severe deficiency, the same as if she were taking nothing at all. (Recall that we aim for 50 ng/ml.)

In other words, vitamin D tablets do not work. It is shameful. I see numerous women taking calcium tablets with D--the vitamin D does not work. I've actually seen blood levels of zero on these preparations.

You may have to look, but if you want to enjoy the extraordinary benefits of vitamin D replacement, it must be an oil-based capsule. Carlson's and Vitamin Shoppe have excellent prepartions. They raise blood levels substantially and consistently, and they're inexpensive. We pay $5.99 for a bottle of 120 capsules.

Vitamin D for $200?

What if vitamin D cost $200 rather than $2?

In other words, what if cholecalciferol, or vitamin D3, was a patent-protectable agent that would sell for an extravagant price, just like a drug?

Vitamin D would be the hot topic. There would be TV ads run during Oprah, slick magazine two-page spreads with experts touting its outsized benefits, insurance companies would battle over how much your copay should be.

The manufacturer would host large fancy symposia to educate physicians on how wonderful vitamin D is for treatment of numerous conditions, complete with dinner, a show, and gifts. They would hire expert speakers to speak, scientists to have articles ghost-written, give out knick knacks with the brand label inscribed--just like Lipitor, Actos, Vytorin, ReoPro, Plavix . . .

After all, what other "drug" substantially increases bone density (up to 20% in adult females), enhances insulin responses 30% (equivalent to the TZD drugs, Actos and Avandia), and slashes colon cancer risk?

But it's not a drug. That is both vitamin D's strength and its weakness. It's a strong point because it's natural, phenomenally helpful across a variety of conditions, and inexpensive. It is also a weakness because, at $2 a month, no one is raking in the $12 billion annually that Pfizer makes for Lipitor that allows it to fund an enormous marketing campaign.

Vitamin D is a "discovery" of huge importance for health, including making reductions of CT heart scan scores far more likely for more people. And it comes without a prescription.

What's up with garlic?


Fanatic Cook has posted an excellent summary on the recent negative attention cast on garlic preparations, at least for LDL cholesterol reduction.

Go to http://fanaticcook.blogspot.com to view.

I think Fanatic Cook is right--despite the lack of LDL reducing effects, it doesn't necessarily mean no benefit whatsoever. Anti-coagulation and anti-inflammatory effects, in particular, are well proven.

I do think, however, that it argues more in favor of sticking to whole cloves, rather than supplements. The benefits are also likely small. I would view garlic as a soft advantage for your plaque control program. You can do fine without it. You might do slightly better with it.

Drop the pretense

Most hospitals maintain the "Saint _____" in their names, despite many having little or nothing to do with the church.

Out of 15 hospitals in my area, 13 are named after saints.

In my view, a more honest name would be something like "ABC Medical Enterprises, Inc." The profit motive, aggressive marketing tactics, and high CEO salaries would make better sense then. The trend to convert practicing physicians from professionals acting on behalf of patient welfare into paid employees would also be clearer.

Imagine Walmart were to change its name to "St. Mary's Emporium" Would it modify your perception of their business? I think it would. It would cause many people to believe that maybe their work was, at least in part, charitable and being done for the public welfare. But Walmart makes such pretense--they are in business for profit, just like all businesses.

It's time for the pretense to be dropped. Hospitals are cut-throat profit-seeking operations, operating under the guise of charitable, tax-free institutions. It's the farthest thing from the truth.

John Cannell on Vitamin D

You can always count on Dr. John Cannell for unique perspectives on vitamin D. I reprint here his unfailingly entertaining and informative Vitamin D Newsletter on whether vitamin D replacement enhances physical performance.

The whole vitamin D "discovery" sometimes worries me. Vitamin D has proven to be an unbelievable, remarkable, dramatic boon to health, including facilitation in dropping CT heart scan scores. Yet the answer was always right in front of us. It worries me that you and I might have the answer to important questions right within our grasp all along--but don't know it. What if the same were true, say, for cancer? That is, a profound answer is right there, but our eyes just pass right over it.

Anyway, we should all keep our eyes open and perhaps you and I will continue to identify the most powerful tools available that return control over heart disease to us and take it away from the perverse, procedural hospital formula that still reigns.

If you haven't done so already, be sure to visit Dr. Cannell's website, www.vitamindcouncil.com.



The Vitamin D Newsletter
March, 2007

Peak Athletic Performance and Vitamin D

"No way doc." I had just finished telling my patient about the benefits of vitamin D, telling him he should take 4,000 IU per day, using all the techniques I had learned in 30 years of medical practice to convince someone proper treatment is important. But, he knew the U.S. government said he only needed 200 IU per day, not 4,000. He also knew the official Upper Limit was 2,000 IU a day. "What are you trying to do doc, kill me?" I told him his 25(OH)-vitamin D blood test was low, only 13 ng/ml. He had read about that too, in a medical textbook, where it said normal levels are between 10 and 40 ng/ml. "I'm fine doc;" adding "Are you in the vitamin business?" I explained I was not; that the government used outdated values; that recent studies indicate ideal 25(OH)D levels are about 50 ng/ml; and that they indicated that he needed about 4,000 IU per day to get his level up to 50. "No thanks doc, I'm fine."

So I tried a different tact. I brought him copies of recent press articles. "Look," I said, "look at these." Science News called vitamin D the Antibiotic Vitamin. The Independent in England says vitamin D explains why people die from influenza in the winter, and not the summer. U.S. News and World Report says almost everyone needs more. Newsweek says it prevents cancer and helps fight infection. In four different recent reports, United Press International says that: it reduces falls in the elderly, many pregnant women are deficient , it reduces stress fractures, and that it helps heals wounds.

He glanced at the articles, showing a little interest in stress fractures. Then he told me what he was really thinking. "Look doc, all this stuff may be important to old guys like you. I'm 22. All I care about are girls and sports. When I get older, maybe I'll think about it. I'm too young to worry about it. I'm in great condition." I couldn't argue. He was in good health and a very good basketball player, playing several hours every day, always on indoor courts.

What could I do to open his eyes? As an African American, his risk of early death was very high, although the risk for blacks doesn't start to dramatically increase until their 40's and 50's. Like all young people, he saw himself as forever young. The U.S. government was no help, relying on a ten-year-old report from the Institute of Medicine that is full of misinformation.

I tired to tell him that the 200 IU per day the U.S. government recommends for 20-year-olds is to prevent bone disease, not to treat low vitamin D levels like his. I pointed out the U.S. government's official current Upper Limit of 2,000 IU/day is the same for a 300 pound adult as it is for a 25 pound toddler. That is, the government says it's safe for a one-year-old, 25-pound, child to take 2,000 IU per day but it's not safe for a 30-year old, 300-pound, adult to take 2,000 and one IU a day. I mean, whoever thought up these Upper Limits must have left their thinking caps at home. Nevertheless, nothing worked. My vitamin D deficient patient was not interested in taking any vitamin D.

What are young men interested in? I remembered that he had told me: "Sex and sports." Two years ago I had researched the medical literature looking for any evidence vitamin D enhanced sexual performance. Absolutely nothing. That would have been nice. Can you imagine the interest?

Then I remembered that several readers had written to ask me if vitamin D could possibly improve their athletic performance? They told me that after taking 2,000 to 5,000 IU per day for several months, they seemed just a little faster, a little stronger, maybe had a little better balance and timing. A pianist had written to tell me she even played a better piano, her fingers moved over the keys more effortlessly! Was vitamin D responsible for these subtle changes or was it a placebo effect? That is, did readers just think their athletic performance improved because they knew vitamin D was a steroid hormone precursor (hormone, from the Greek, meaning "to set in motion")?

The active form of vitamin D is a steroid (actually a seco-steroid) in the same way that testosterone is a steroid and vitamin D is a hormone in the same way that growth hormone is a hormone. Steroid hormones are substances made from cholesterol, which circulate in the body, and work at distant sites by "setting in motion" genetic protein transcription. That is, both vitamin D and testosterone regulate your genome, the stuff of life. While testosterone is a sex steroid hormone, vitamin D is a pleomorphic (multiple function) steroid hormone.

All of a sudden, it didn't seem so silly. Certainly steroids can improve athletic performance although they can be quite dangerous. In addition, few people are deficient in growth hormone or testosterone, so when athletes take sex steroids or growth hormone they are cheating, or doping. The case with vitamin D is quite different because natural vitamin D levels are about 50 ng/ml and, since almost no one has such levels, extra vitamin D is not doping, it's just good treatment. I decided to exhaustively research the medical literature on vitamin D and athletic performance. It took me over a year.

To my surprise, I discovered that there are five totally independent bodies of research that all converge on an inescapable conclusion: vitamin D will improve athletic performance in vitamin D deficient people (and that includes most people). Even more interesting is who published this literature, and when. Are you old enough to remember when the Germans and Russians won every Olympics in the 60's and 70's? Well, it turns out that the most convincing evidence that vitamin D improves athletic performance was published in old German and Russian medical literature.

With the help of my wife and mother-in-law, both of whom are Russian, and with the help of Marc Sorenson, whose book Solar Power is a must read, I finally was able to look at translations of much of the old Russian and German literature. When one combines that old literature with the modern English language literature on neuromuscular performance, the conclusion is inescapable. The readers who wrote me are right.

If you are vitamin D deficient, the medical literature indicates that the right amount of vitamin D will make you faster, stronger, improve your balance and timing, etc. How much it will improve your athletic ability depends on how deficient you are to begin with. How good an athlete you will be depends on your innate ability, training, and dedication. However, peak athletic performance also depends upon the neuromuscular cells in your body and brain having unfettered access to the steroid hormone, activated vitamin D. In addition, how much activated vitamin D is available to your brain, muscle, and nerves depends on having ideal levels of vitamin D in your blood - about 50 ng/ml, to be precise.

Why would I write about such a frivolous topic like peak athletic performance when cancer patients all across this land are dying vitamin D deficient? Like many vitamin D advocates, I have been disappointed that the medical profession and the public don't seem to care about vitamin D. Maybe people, like my young basketball player, will care if it makes better athletes. So, Hey! You jocks! Listen up! I'm talking speed, balance, choice reaction time, muscle mass, muscle strength, squats, reps, etc. Important stuff. Here's the Vitamin D Council's first ever sports quiz.


1. Vitamin D-producing UVB radiation improves athletic performance and may have been widely practiced by German and Russian Olympic athletes in the 1960's and 70's.


True. I found tantalizing evidence the Russians and especially the Germans were on to this during the 60's and 70's when those two nations took turns placing number one and number two in the Olympics every year?


For example, in 1938, Russian researchers reported that a course of ultraviolet irradiations improved speed in the 100-meter dash in college students compared to matched controls, both groups undergoing daily training. Average 100-meter dash times decreased from 13.51 seconds to 13.28 seconds in the non-irradiated controls, but from 13.63 seconds to 12.62 seconds in the irradiated students. Here we see training improved times but training and irradiation improved times much more. Obviously, irradiation or vitamin D would not render the same magnitude of improvements in world-class sprinters, but they would be happy with a few milliseconds.


Gorkin Z, Gorkin MJ, Teslenko NE. [The effect of ultraviolet irradiation upon training for 100m sprint.] The Journal of Physiology of the USSR [Fiziol, z. (RSSR)] 1938; 25: 695-701. (In Russian)



If you want to know what early German thinking was on this, read this summation of the German literature:

"It is a well-known fact that physical performance can be increased through ultra-violet irradiation. In 1927, a heated argument arose after the decision by the German Swimmers' Association to use the sunlamp as an artificial aid, constituting an athletic unfairness, doping, so to speak. In 1926, Rancken had already reported the improving effect of sunlamp irradiation on muscle work with the hand-dynamo-graph. Heib observed an improvement in swimming times after repeated irradiations. In thorough experiments, Backmund showed that a substantial increase in muscle activity happens after radiation of larger portions of the body with an artificial sunlamp; that this performance increase is not caused through local - direct or indirect - effects on the musculature, but through a general effect. This general effect, triggered by ultra-violet irradiation, is caused by a systemic effect on the nervous system." (p. 17)


Parade GW, Otto H. Die beeinflussung der leistungsfahigkeit durch Hohensonnenbestrahlung. Zeitschrift fur Klinische Medizin (Z Klin Med),1940;137:17-21 [In German]


In 1945, two Americans measured the cardiovascular fitness and muscular endurance of 11 male Illinois subjects undergoing training in an indoor physical education class, comparing them to 10 matched controls. Both groups underwent similar physical training. Treatment consisted of ultraviolet irradiation, given in the nude, up to two minutes per session, three times per week, for ten weeks in the late fall and winter. After ten weeks, the treatment group had a 19% standard score gain in cardiovascular fitness compare to a 2% improvement in the control students. To regular readers of this newsletter, it should come as no surprise that the un-irradiated control group reported twice as many viral respiratory infections as the treatment group.


Allen R, Cureton T. Effects of Ultraviolet Radiation on Physical Fitness. Arch Phys Med 1945: 10: 641-44.


In 1952, the German sports medicine researcher, Spellerberg, reported on the effects of wholesale irradiation of athletes studying and training at the Sports College of Cologne - including many elite athletes - with a "central sun lamp." He irradiated the athletes in their bathing suits, on both sides of their bodies, for up to ten minutes, twice a week, for 6 weeks. He reported a "convincing effect" on athletic performance and a 50% reduction in sports injuries. Results were particularly impressive for swimmers, soccer, handball, hockey, and tennis players, as well as for boxers and most track and field athletes. He reported that irradiation leading to burns, further irradiation of athletes having achieved peak performance, and irradiation within 24 hours of competition, all impaired athletic performance. Their results were so convincing, the Sports College of Cologne officially notified the "national German and International Olympic committee." (p. 570)


Spellerberg AE. [Increase of athletic effectiveness by systematic ultraviolet irradiation.] Strahlentherapie 1952; 88: 567-70. [In German]


In 1952, Ronge exposed 120 German schoolchildren to UV lights installed in classrooms and compared them to 120 un-irradiated control children. Over a two-year period - excluding summer vacations - he tested both groups with a series of six cardiovascular fitness tests using a bike ergometer. Un-irradiated children showed a distinct seasonality in fitness, with the highest values right after summer break and the lowest values in the spring. Treated children showed no seasonal differences in physical performance. Differences in work performance between the irradiated and un-irradiated children were most conspicuous in the spring with 56% difference between the two groups. In a final experiment, he gave 30 children in the control classrooms 6.25 mg (250,000 IU) of vitamin D as a single dose in February and found their performance had "increased considerably," one month later but did not report the actual numbers. He concluded that vitamin D, either as a supplement or induced via UV irradiation, improved physical performance.


Ronge HE. [Increase of physical effectiveness by systematic ultraviolet irradiation.] Strahlentherapie 1952; 88: 563-6. [In German]

In 1954, another researcher, at the Max-Planck Institute for Industrial Physiology in Dortmund, Germany, administered three different wavelengths of UV light over 8 weeks to university students. He found that ultraviolet light in the vitamin D-producing UVB range was consistently effective in reducing resting pulse, lowering the basal metabolic rate, and increasing athletic performance. UVA had no effect; interestingly, artificial UVC irradiation (the atmosphere normally completely filters out UVC radiation and thus it's not naturally present on earth) also gave some positive results.


Lehmann G. [Significance of certain wave lengths for increased efficacy of ultraviolet irradiation.] Strahlentherapie. 1954 Nov;95(3):447-53. [In German]


In 1956, Hettinger and Seidel irradiated seven subjects in two different experiments: athletic performance on bike-ergometers and forearm muscle strength. They found that UV radiation induced a significant improvement in both muscle strength and athletic performance.



Hettinger T, Seidl E. [Ultraviolet irradiation and trainability of musculature.] Internationale Zeitschrift für angewandte Physiologie, einschliesslich Arbeitsphysiologie 1956; 16: 177-83. [In German]


Another German researcher, at the Institute for Medical Physics and Biophysics at the University of Gottiingen, studied reaction times (the time needed to recognize a light and switch it off) during October and November in a series of controlled experiments on 16 children and an unspecified number of adults. He first controlled for practice effects (getting better by practicing) and then administered nine full-body UV radiation treatments over three weeks to the two treatment groups, using placebo radiation in the two control groups. UV radiation improved choice reaction time by 25% in children and 20% in adults while reaction time worsened in controls. The improvements in the irradiated groups peaked at the end of the three weeks of UV treatments and reverted to baseline levels three weeks later. In the two control groups, he found distinctly improved reaction times in the sunnier months.


Sigmund R. [Effect of ultraviolet rays on reaction time in man.] Strahlentherapie. 1956; 101: 623-9. [In German]


The next study threw me because it was very well conducted, meticulously designed, and completely negative. In 1963, Berven reported on the effects of ultraviolet irradiation and vitamin D supplementation in a group of 30 Stockholm schoolchildren, aged 10 -11, comparing them to appropriate controls. He found no seasonality of fitness in the control group and no effect from either irradiation or two different vitamin D supplementation protocols (1500 IU of cholecalciferol daily for two months and a single dose of 400,000 IU of ergocalciferol) on performance on a bike ergometer.


Berven H. The physical working capacity of healthy children; seasonal variations and effect of ultraviolet irradiation and vitamin-D supply. Acta paediatrica. Supplementum 1963; 148: 1-22.


However, two things were not right and got me thinking. One, Berven found no seasonality of physical fitness and was the only author who found no such seasonal variations in athletic performance. Second, he found no effect from irradiation, again, the only author. Then I realized he was working with Swedish children in the late 1950's. Supplementation of children with high doses of vitamin D - often as cod liver oil - was routine in Scandinavia in the past, particularly in children. For example, in neighboring Finland, the official recommended daily dose of vitamin D for children - including infants - was 4,000 IU per day until 1964, when authorities reduced it to 2,000 IU/day. (That's right, you read that correctly, 4,000 IU per day for infants, which is too much by the way.)



In 1975, Finnish authorities reduced it to 1,000 IU per day, and, in 1992, to 400 IU per day. I emailed Professor Elina Hypponen who confirmed that the Swedish recommendations were similar to the Finnish ones. Therefore, it seems highly unlikely that many of Berven's Swedish children, studied in 1958 and 1959, all from "families with a good standard of living," were vitamin D deficient. Therefore, this study showed that vitamin D will not improve athletic ability in vitamin D replete people. That's very important because it indicates more is not necessarily better. More is only better if you are not taking enough.

Hypponen E, et al. Intake of vitamin D and risk of type 1 diabetes: a birth-cohort study. Lancet. 2001 Nov 3;358(9292):1500-3.

In the 1960's, three American researchers conducted experiments with university students. Rosentswieg studied the effects of a single six-minute dose of UV light on each side of the trunk in 23 college women, recording changes in various tests of muscle strength at one and five hours. He found a trend towards significance after five hours in white but not African American students. In 1968, Cheatum found that a six-minute administration of UV light, on each side of the trunk, increased the speed of 15 college women in the 30-yard dash. In 1969, Rosentswieg found a six-minute dose of UV light, on each side of the trunk, finding improved performance on a bicycle ergometer in college women. However, unlike the Germans and Russians, I could find no evidence that any of these American findings interested any American professionals involved in the care or training of athletes.


Rosentsweig J. The effect of a single suberythemic biodose of ultraviolet radiation upon the strength of college women. J Assoc Phys Ment Rehabil. 1967 Jul-Aug;21(4):131-3.

Cheatum BA. Effects of a single biodose of ultraviolet radiation upon the speed of college women. Res Q. 1968 Oct;39(3):482-5.

Rosentswieg J. The effect of a single suberythemic biodose of ultraviolet radiation upon the endurance of college women. J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1969 Jun;9(2):104-6.


2. Athletic performance peaks in the summer when vitamin D levels peak, and is at its lowest in the winter when vitamin D levels are at their lowest.

A. True
B. False


True. The studies below - all I could find in the literature - show tests of physical performance peak in the summer, when vitamin D levels peak, start to decline in early autumn, as vitamin D levels decline, and athletic performance reaches its lowest point in late winter, when vitamin D levels bottom out. However, it is reasonable to assume that any associations between athletic performance and summer season may be due to "reverse causation." That is, improved athletic performance in the summer might be secondary to increased outdoor physical and recreational activity in the warmer weather with an indoor sedentary lifestyle during the colder months. Maybe people have better athletic ability in the summer because they exercise more. If that is true - and using the same logic - athletic performance should not begin to decline until late autumn, because at most temperate latitudes early fall weather is ideal for outdoor physical activities.


However, some of the studies below controlled for seasonal variations in time spent exercising. Furthermore, besides a consistent positive association of summer season with improved athletic performance, the below studies found an abrupt - and unexplained - reduction in athletic performance beginning in the early fall - when vitamin D levels decline - but when the weather is ideal for outdoor activities.


For example, in 1956, German researchers found a distinct seasonal variation in the trainability of musculature, studying wrist flexor strength in 21 German subjects undergoing daily training. They found highly significant seasonal differences with peak performance during the later part of the summer, nadirs in the winter, and an unexplained sharp autumn decline beginning in October.


Hettinger T, Muller EA. Seasonal course of trainability of musculature. Int Z Angew Physiol. 1956;16(2):90-4.

A study of Polish pilots and crew found physical fitness and tolerance to hypoxia were highest in the late summer with an unexplained sharp decline starting in September. The authors hypothesized that seasonal variations in an unidentified hormone best explained their results.


Kwarecki K, Golec L, Klossowski M, Zuzewicz K. Circannual rhythms of physical fitness and tolerance of hypoxic hypoxia. Acta Physiol Pol. 1981 Nov-Dec;32(6):629-36.


Cumulative work ability among 1,835 mainly sedentary Norwegian men during bicycle exercise tests showed an August peak, a sharp decline starting in the autumn, and a wintertime nadir. There were no seasonal changes in body weights, as might be expected if more caloric-demanding recreational activity during the sunnier months explained their results.


Erikssen J, Rodahl K. Seasonal variation in work performance and heart rate response to exercise. A study of 1,835 middle-aged men. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol. 1979 Oct;42(2):133-40.


Koch and Raschka reviewed the mostly German literature on the seasonality of physical performance, discussing studies indicating that muscle strength and stamina peak in the late summer. The authors then attempted to control for seasonal variations in the time spent exercising by instituting a controlled yearlong training regimen, beginning in December. The training regimen consisted of at least 20 push-ups per day and 2 or 3 long-distances races per week for the entire year. They found the both the number of push-ups and muscle strength peaked in late summer followed by a rapid decline in the fall, and a nadir in the winter, despite continued training. They concluded that seasonal variations in an unidentified hormone best explained their results. In addition, by now we all know that vitamin D is a seasonal hormone, and a steroid hormone precursor to boot.


Koch H, Raschka C. Circannual period of physical performance analysed by means of standard cosinor analysis: a case report. Rom J Physiol. 2000 Jan-Dec;37(1-4):51-8.

3. Vitamin D has direct muscle-building (anabolic) effects.


A. True
B. False

True, but only in vitamin D deficient subjects. Both animal and human studies have found that vitamin D directly affects muscle. That is, vitamin D increases muscle mass.



For example, Birge and Haddad found that vitamin D caused new protein synthesis in rat muscle.


Birge SJ, Haddad JG. 25-hydroxycholecalciferol stimulation of muscle metabolism. J Clin Invest. 1975 Nov;56(5):1100-7.


What about humans? In 1981, Young performed muscle biopsies on 12 severely vitamin D deficient patients before and after vitamin D treatment. They found type-II (fast-twitch) muscle fibers were small before treatment and significantly enlarged after treatment. Sorensen performed muscle biopsies on eleven older patients with osteoporosis before and after treatment with vitamin D. The percentage and area of fast twitch fibers increased significantly after treatment, despite the lack of any physical training.


Young A, Edwards R, Jones D, Brenton D. Quadriceps muscle strength and fibre size during treatment of osteomalacia. In: Stokes IAF (ed) Mechanical factors and the skeleton. 1981. pp 137-145.

Sorensen OH, Lund B, Saltin B, Lund B, Andersen RB, Hjorth L, Melsen F, Mosekilde L. Myopathy in bone loss of ageing: improvement by treatment with 1 alpha-hydroxycholecalciferol and calcium. Clin Sci (Lond). 1979 Feb;56(2):157-61.


Sato reported that two years of treatment with 1,000 IU of vitamin D per day significantly increased muscle strength, doubled the mean diameter, and tripled the percentage of fast-twitch muscle fibers, in the functional limbs of 48 severely vitamin D deficient elderly stroke patients. The placebo control group suffered declines in muscle strength, and in the size and percentage of fast-twitch muscle fibers.


Sato Y, Iwamoto J, Kanoko T, Satoh K. Low-Dose Vitamin D Prevents Muscular Atrophy and Reduces Falls and Hip Fractures in Women after Stroke: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2005 Jul 27;20(3):187-192 [Epub ahead of print]

These studies clearly show that vitamin D when administered to vitamin D deficient people stimulates the growth and number of those muscle fibers critical to athletic ability, type-2, or "fast twitch," muscle fibers.

4. Many studies have found direct associations between physical performance and vitamin D levels. That is, the higher your vitamin D level, the better your athletic performance.

A. True
B. False

True. I found 13 positive studies of associations between vitamin D levels and various parameters of neuromuscular performance. However, they were all in old people. Of course, old people can be athletes too. Furthermore, age differences in physiology and pharmacology are quantitative, not qualitative. That is, what is true in old people will be true in young people, although the magnitude might be different. Higher vitamin D levels are associated with a wide variety of athletic performance but appear to have the strongest associations with balance, timing, and timed tests of physical performance.

The three largest studies had more than 7,000 elderly subjects. All found evidence of a vitamin D threshold of between 30 - 50 ng/ml, above which further improvements in athletic performance were not seen. Wicherts and her colleagues found a linear correlation between vitamin D and neuromuscular performance; scores were 78% better for those with vitamin D levels greater than 30 ng/ml compared to those with levels less than10 ng/ml.


Bischoff-Ferrari HA, Dietrich T, Orav EJ, Hu FB, Zhang Y, Karlson EW, Dawson-Hughes B. Higher 25-hydroxyvitamin D concentrations are associated with better lower-extremity function in both active and inactive persons aged > or =60 y. Am J Clin Nutr. 2004 Sep;80(3):752-8.

Gerdhem P, Ringsberg KA, Obrant KJ, Akesson K. Association between 25-hydroxy vitamin D levels, physical activity, muscle strength and fractures in the prospective population-based OPRA Study of Elderly Women. Osteoporos Int. 2005 Nov;16(11):1425-31.


Wicherts IS, et al. Vitamin D status predicts physical performance and its decline in older persons. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2007 Mar 6; [Epub ahead of print]

Professor Heike Bischoff-Ferrari, now in Switzerland, did the largest study. She and her colleagues found a strong positive correlation and suggestion of a U-shaped curve with athletic performance on one test peaking with vitamin D levels of 50 ng/ml but deteriorating at higher levels. It is interesting to speculate that levels around 50 ng/ml may be optimal for athletic performance as such levels are common in humans living in a "natural" state of sun-exposure, such as lifeguards or tropical farmers.


Bischoff HA, Stahelin HB, Urscheler N, Ehrsam R, Vonthein R, Perrig-Chiello P, Tyndall A, Theiler R. Muscle strength in the elderly: its relation to vitamin D metabolites. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1999 Jan;80(1):54-8.


Interestingly, all three studies that looked for an association between mental abilities and vitamin D levels found one. A fourth study, unrelated to athletic function, also found an association. The obvious explanation for these findings is that cognitively impaired patients do not go outdoors as often as higher functioning patients and thus have lower vitamin D levels. However, Dhesi found the association after excluding all but mildly demented patients, making such an explanation more difficult. Flicker and - more recently - Przybelski and Binkley, found the association after controlling for outdoor activities, raising the possibility that the association of vitamin D levels with cognitive abilities is casual. Both the vitamin D receptor and the enzyme necessary to activate vitamin D are present in a wide-variety of human brain tissue. If vitamin D deficiency impairs cognitive abilities, it is likely that such deficiencies will also impair the brain's ability to process the complex circuits needed for peak athletic performance.


Dhesi JK, Bearne LM, Moniz C, Hurley MV, Jackson SH, Swift CG, Allain TJ. Neuromuscular and psychomotor function in elderly subjects who fall and the relationship with vitamin D status. J Bone Miner Res. 2002 May;17(5):891-7.

Kenny AM, Biskup B, Robbins B, Marcella G, Burleson JA. Effects of vitamin D supplementation on strength, physical function, and health perception in older, community-dwelling men. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2003 Dec;51(12):1762-7.

Flicker L, Mead K, MacInnis RJ, Nowson C, Scherer S, Stein MS, Thomasx J, Hopper JL, Wark JD. Serum vitamin D and falls in older women in residential care in Australia. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2003 Nov;51(11):1533-8.

Przybelski RJ, Binkley NC. Is vitamin D important for preserving cognition? A positive correlation of serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D concentration with cognitive function. Arch Biochem Biophys. 2007 Jan 8;

There can be no doubt that higher vitamin D levels are associated with improved athletic performance in the elderly. From what we know of physiology and pharmacology, the same associations should hold true in young people, including young athletes.

5. Numerous studies have found that vitamin D improves physical performance.

A. True
B. False.

True, but, again, most all the studies are in old persons, not young ones, and none of the studies are in world-class athletes. However, there is no medical reason why vitamin D would improve the athletic performance of vitamin D deficient old people but not vitamin D deficient young ones. Eleven studies found vitamin D improved physical performance, mainly on measures of balance and reaction time. The one study of younger subjects showed dramatic physical performance effects in 55 severely vitamin D deficient women.


Sorensen OH, Lund B, Saltin B, Lund B, Andersen RB, Hjorth L, Melsen F, Mosekilde L. Myopathy in bone loss of ageing: improvement by treatment with 1 alpha-hydroxycholecalciferol and calcium. Clin Sci (Lond). 1979 Feb;56(2):157-61.

Gloth FM 3rd, Smith CE, Hollis BW, Tobin JD. Functional improvement with vitamin D replenishment in a cohort of frail, vitamin D-deficient older people. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1995 Nov;43(11):1269-71.

Glerup H, Mikkelsen K, Poulsen L, Hass E, Overbeck S, Andersen H, Charles P, Eriksen EF. Hypovitaminosis D myopathy without biochemical signs of osteomalacic bone involvement. Calcif Tissue Int. 2000 Jun;66(6):419-24.

Prabhala A, Garg R, Dandona P. Severe myopathy associated with vitamin D deficiency in western New York. Arch Intern Med. 2000 Apr 24;160(8):1199-203.

Verhaar HJ, Samson MM, Jansen PA, de Vreede PL, Manten JW, Duursma SA. Muscle strength, functional mobility and vitamin D in older women. Aging (Milano). 2000 Dec;12(6):455-60.

Pfeifer M, Begerow B, Minne HW, Abrams C, Nachtigall D, Hansen C. Effects of a short-term vitamin D and calcium supplementation on body sway and secondary hyperparathyroidism in elderly women. J Bone Miner Res. 2000 Jun;15(6):1113-8.

Bischoff HA, Stahelin HB, Dick W, Akos R, Knecht M, Salis C, Nebiker M, Theiler R, Pfeifer M, Begerow B, Lew RA, Conzelmann M. Effects of vitamin D and calcium supplementation on falls: a randomized controlled trial. J Bone Miner Res. 2003 Feb;18(2):343-51.

Dhesi JK, Jackson SH, Bearne LM, Moniz C, Hurley MV, Swift CG, Allain TJ. Vitamin D supplementation improves neuromuscular function in older people who fall. Age Ageing. 2004 Nov;33(6):589-95.

Sato Y, Iwamoto J, Kanoko T, Satoh K. Low-Dose Vitamin D Prevents Muscular Atrophy and Reduces Falls and Hip Fractures in Women after Stroke: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2005 Jul 27;20(3):187-192 [Epub ahead of print]



In summary, five converging - but totally separate - lines of scientific evidence leave little doubt that vitamin D improves athletic performance. (I actually left out a sixth line of evidence, something a little more complicated, studies of muscle strength and vitamin D receptor polymorphisms; the two studies I could find were both positive.) Anyway, the scientific evidence that UVB radiation, either from the sun or from sunbeds, will improve athletic performance is overwhelming and the mechanism is almost certainly vitamin D production. Peak athletic performance will probably occur with 25(OH)D levels of about 50 ng/ml, whether from sun, sunbeds, or supplements.


All that is missing is a big-time professional or college team identifying and then treating their elite athletes who are vitamin D deficient. Can you imagine what such performance-enhancing effects would do for basketball players, most of who are African American and who practice and play indoors all winter? Or gymnasts? Or weight lifters?


However, a word of caution. The above studies suggest that taking too much vitamin D (more than 5,000 IU per day) may actually worsen athletic performance. Take the right amount, not all you can swallow. Take enough to keep your 25(OH)D levels around 50 ng/ml, year round. Easier yet, regularly use the sun in the summer and sunbeds in the winter - with care not to burn. Once a week should be about right.


When you think about it, none of this should surprise anyone. Every body builder knows that steroid hormones can improve athletic performance, certainly increase muscle mass. Barry Bonds knows they increase timing and power. Moreover, activated vitamin D is as potent a steroid hormone as exists in the human body. However, unlike other steroids, levels of activated vitamin D in muscle and nerve tissue are primarily regulated by sun exposure. That's right, the rate-limiting step for the cellular function (autocrine) of activated vitamin D is under your control. It depends on how much you put in your both or go into the sun. It's ironic that many athletes now avoid the sun, organized baseball is even promoting sun avoidance and sunblocks. The ancient Greeks knew better; they had there elite athletes train on the beach and in the nude.



The medical literature indicates vitamin D levels of about 50 ng/ml are associated with peak athletic performance. Of course, recent studies show such levels are ideal for preventing cancer, diabetes, hypertension, influenza, multiple sclerosis, major depression, cognitive impairments, etc. But who cares about all that disease stuff old people get, we're talking about something really important: speed, balance, reaction time, muscle mass, muscle strength, squats, reps, etc. And guess who's now taking 4,000 IU/day? Yes he is, and he tells me his timing is better, he can jump a little higher, run a little faster, and the ball feels "sweeter," whatever that means.

John Cannell, MD

This is a periodic newsletter from the Vitamin D Council, a non-profit trying to end the epidemic of vitamin D deficiency. If you don't want to get the newsletter, please hit reply and let us know. We don't copyright this newsletter. Please feel free to reproduce it and post it on Internet sites and blogs. Remember, we are a non-profit educational organization. Our pathetic finances are available for public inspection. We rely on donations to publish our newsletter and maintain our website. Send your tax-deductible contributions to:


The Vitamin D Council (www.vitamindcouncil.com)
9100 San Gregorio Road
Atascadero, CA 93422

Watch your groin

The reason why I've been blogging lightly these past few days is because, as a favor, I'm covering the practice for some colleagues who I'm (very) loosely affiliated with. The time demands have been great.

Nonetheless, it is a good reminder to me just how far wrong conventional cardiology remains. Judging by what I see around me, there is a startling lack of restraint in proceeding to the catheterization laboratory. Curiously, the internists and family practitioners have been brainwashed into accepting this path. I suppose that all it takes is an occasional real "save" for these physicians to develop a fear of ever missing real disease.

What I'm seeing is just how many people presenting with chest pain or similar symptoms end up going to the cath lab. I would crudely estimate 80%. That is, once you make it past the emergency room, there's a four out of five chance that you'll end up with a heart catheterization to "be sure your heart is okay", "make certain you're not going to die of heart disease", "see if there's a ticking time bomb in your chest". You've heard all the clever, scary phrases that get tossed around to scare the pants off you and justify putting catheters in your groin.

Despite the fact that tools for heart disease prevention have improved dramatically, the volume of heart catheterizations continues to grow nationwide.

I find it shocking and unacceptable. We're currently working behind the scenes to help change this situation through education of the public. Persuade a $1 million a year cardiologist that he is overdoing procedures? Unlikely in my experience. Educate the public about the shocking over-reliance on high-revenue procedures? Perhaps more practical.

Garlic and cholesterol--Does everyone now need Lipitor?

Garlic May Not Lower Cholesterol
Study Shows No Improvement in Cholesterol Levels From Raw Garlic or Garlic Supplements

Lots of reports continue to hit the press about a small study that hoped to determine whether garlic as whole cloves (4 to 6), an aqueous extract of garlic called Kyolic, or an oil extract called Garlicin (high in allicin), or placebo. No differences in lipid numbers including LDL cholesterol were observed.

(Full text at WebMD at http://www.webmd.com/cholesterol-management/news/20070226/garlic-may-not-lower-cholesterol?ecd=wnl_chl_030507. You may be required to log in or register.)

I believe that the researchers were sincere in their effort to follow an honest, scientfically sound clinical trial design. I'm personally not that surprised. The effect in prior studies has been modest, sometimes none. Does that mean that we should ignore the other studies that suggest there may be modest blood-thinning, anti-inflammatory, blood pressure-reducing, and cancer-preventing properties? No, it does not. Dr. Matt Budoff at UCLA even published a very small study in about 20 people that suggested a slowing of plaque growth by using Kyolic in persons tracked by CT heart scans.

Nonetheless, garlic is, at best, probably no more than a source of small benefits. The biggest fallout from this kind of report, however, is not the neutral results from garlic, but from the open door the drug companies sense when this happens.

If you read the WebMD report, you'll notice all sorts of advertisements from drug companies for statin cholesterol drugs ("Cholesterol health center"; "Understanding Cholesterol Numbers"; "There are two sources of cholesterol: food and family"), Niaspan (which I used to support but have been discouraged by the Kos companies excessively profiteering methods and recent big Wall Street sellout).

It doesn't follow. The failure of one nutritional strategy to reduce LDL does nothave to trigger a run to the drugs. Don't fall for it. Drugs have their place. So do supplements and food choices, which can be very powerful. Drug manufacturers and their marketing people salivate when something like this comes along, an open invitation to say, "If garlic doesn't work, _____ sure does."

Diet Coke saves father's life

Jason came to the office because of chest pain. At 34 years old, he works as manager of a (non-fast food) restaurant, but indulges in lots of the odds and ends. Among his indulgences: Diet Coke. Every time he'd have a diet Coke, he'd have chest pain. Not drinking diet Coke--no chest pain. If Jason drank coffee, no chest pain. Other foods, no chest pain. Anyway, just eliminating the diet Coke seemed to do the trick. (Aspartame?)

Anyway, that's not why I tell you Jason's story. In the midst of his evaluation, an echocardiogram showed a mildly enlarged aorta, measuring 4.0 cm in diameter. So we obtained lipoproteins. Jason showed lipoprotein(a) and small LDL particles, the dreaded duo. We talked about how to correct this pattern. Among the strategies we discussed was niacin.

But what bothered me was that neither of Jason's parents had a diagnosis of heart disease. Jason had to have gotten Lp(a) from either his mother or father, since you obtain the gene from one or the other parent. You cannot acquire Lp(a). So one of Jason's parents was sitting on a genetic time bomb of unrecognized Lp(a) and hidden heart disease.

Because Jason's paternal grandfather had a heart attack at age 62, only Jason's Dad had the heart scan (though I urged both to get one). Score: 1483. Recall that heart scan scores >1000 carry a risk of death or heart attack of 25% per year if no preventive action is taken. Now, of course, we have to persuade Jason's Dad that a program of prevention--intensive prevention is in order, including a measure of Lp(a).

So that's the curious story of how Diet Coke probably saved Jason's Dad's life. The lesson is that if you or someone you know has Lp(a), think about their children as well as their parents, each of whom carry a 50% chance of having the pattern.
All posts by william-davis

Large new clinical study launched to study. . .niacin


Oxford University has issued a press release announcing plans for a new clinical trial to raise HDL cholesterol and reduce heart attack risk. 20,000 participants will be enrolled in this substantial effort. The agent? Niacin.

How is that new? Well, this time niacin comes with a new spin.

Dr. Jane Armitage, formerly with the Heart Protection Study that showed that simvastatin (Zocor) reduced heart attack risk regardless of starting LDL, is lead investigator. She hopes to prove that niacin raises HDL cholesterol and thereby reduces heart attack risk. But, this time, niacin will be combined with an inhibitor of prostaglandins that blocks the notorious "flushing" effect of niacin.

The majority of Track Your Plaque participants hoping to control or reverse coronary plaque take niacin. Recall that niacin (vitamin B3)is an extremely effect agent that raises HDL, dramatically reduces small LDL, shifts HDL particles into the effective large fraction, reduces triglycerides and triglyceride-containing particles like IDL and VLDL. Several studies have shown that niacin dramatically reduces heart attack. The HATS Study showed that niacin combined with Zocor yielded an 85-90% reduction in heart attack risk and achieved regression of coronary plaque in many participants.

In our experience, approximately 1 in 20 people will really struggle using niacin. Flushes for these occasional people will be difficult or even intolerable. Should Dr. Armitage's study demonstrate that this new combination agent does provide advantages in minimizing the hot flush effect, that will be a boon for the occasional Track Your Plaque participant who finds conventional niacin intolerable.

But you already have access to niacin, an agent with an impressive track record even without this new study. And you have a reasonably effective prostaglandin inhibitor, as well: aspirin. Good old aspirin is very useful, particularly in the first few months of your niacin initiation to blunt the flush.

Although this study is likely to further popularize niacin and allow its broader use, it's also a method for the drug companies to profit from an agent they know works but is cheap and available.

You don't have to wait. You already have niacin and aspirin available to you.

The dark side of CT heart scans

"I just got a heart scan!" declared Eric to his doctor. He handed the report to him.

"Oh my. Your score is 154." The doctor paused, then looked at Eric with a serious look on his face. "If we're going to understand whether or not you're in danger, you'll need a heart catheterization."


I've seen this happen countless times. How can I say this diplomatically? THIS IS WRONG!! In my view, it's absolutely criminal for this to happen. Physician ignorance, profiteering, whatever--it is wrong.

There's very few reasons why someone who has no symptoms should go directly to the cath lab for a procedure. (A rare exception might be an exceptional quantity of plaque in the left mainstem artery, e.g., >100. This is highly unusual.)

Even a nuclear stress test (e.g., thallium) at this level of scoring is only 10-15% likely to be abnormal. That means 85-90% likelihood of being normal. There's rare reasons to perform a heart catheterization in a person with no symptoms and an entirely normal stress test. The vast majority of people like Eric do not need a heart catheterization to discern risk.

If Eric's doctor had been up-to-date on the published literature on the prognostic value of heart scans, he could have advised Eric what the risks were--without a catheterization. Many doctors simply don't want to be bothered. Or, they opt for the more profitable method--a hospital procedure.

Always discuss your heart scan with your doctor--but be armed with information in case your doctor is uninformed or unscrupulous. Unfortunately, that's not uncommon. The Track Your Plaque program is your advocate, a source for unbiased information.

The dirty little secret about aneurysms

Jake had an abdominal aneurysm identified--by accident.

While getting a CT scan of his abdomen for unexplained abdominal pain, a 4.4 cm aneurysm was discovered. Jake's abdominal pain eventually passed without explanation, but he was left with this aneurysm.

Jake's primary care doctor referred him to a surgeon. "It's too small to require surgery right now. Wait a few years and it'll probably get bigger. When it gets to around 5.5 cm, that'll be the time to operate. Let's schedule an abdominal ultrasound or CT scan every 6 months."

Jake then got himself a heart scan. His high score of 879 then led him to my office. Lipoprotein testing, a stress test, correction of his lipoprotein patterns, changes in lifestyle followed. One year later, Jake's heart scan score was unchanged.

How about his abdominal aneurysm? 4.2 cm--a modest quantity of regression. When Jake's surgeon learned of the change, he just shrugged. "Okay, we'll just watch it from here."

Shockingly, the conversation surrounding aneurysms is just like the one Jake received: Let's just watch it grow until you need surgery.

If you've every seen anyone have abdominal aneurysm surgery, you know it is an awful, painful, barbaric process with high risk for major complications like kidney failure and loss of the legs. Waiting for an aneurysm to grow is a lousy solution. Surgeons point out that, although surgery is imperfect, it's better than the alternative: rupture, which is catastrophic with a 50% chance of dying.

But what about stopping the growth of the aneurysm? Or even reversing, or shrinking, it?

Surgeons say it can't be done. Yet we've done it--many times. And it's not that difficult.

The steps to take are very similar to that in the Track Your Plaque program for coronary plaque regression, with a few different strategies. Suppression of inflammation, for instance, plays a more important role and blood pressure must be abolutely normal, even during exercise.

More to come on this important topic in the future, including an upcoming Special Report on the www.cureality.com membership website.

Heart scan scores dropping like stones!!

I saw two instances of dramatic coronary plaque regression today.

John, a 53-years old mechanical lift operator, dropped his heart scan score from 479 to 323--a 32% regression of coronary plaque volume!

Eric, a 50-year consulting engineer, dropped his heart scan score from 668 to 580--a 13% reduction.

Both men did nothing special beyond the principles advocated in the Track Your Plaque program. Recall that, without preventive efforts, your heart scan score is expected to increase by 30% per year. Both men are well on their way to freedom from risk of coronary "events".

Two less people to feed the revenue-hungry hospital procedure system! We need many more like them.

Pre-diabetes: An explanation for explosive coronary plaque growth

Art's first CT heart scan in March, 2006 yielded a concerning score of 1336. He felt fine--no chest discomfort, no breathlessness, etc.

Art agreed to take the statin cholesterol drug his primary care doctor prescribed. He also agreed to take the fish oil, niacin, and some of the nutritional supplements that we advised. But Art just couldn't bring himself to make the commitment to lose weight.

At the start of his program, Art--at 5 ft. 8 inches--was 40 lbs overweight (212 lb). This was important since his blood sugar wavered in the pre-diabetic range, going as high as 130 mg. (The American Diabetes Assn. defines diabetes as a blood glucose of 126 mg or greater.)

One year later, Art's lipid and lipoprotein values were corrected to perfection. But he still weighed in at a hefty 209 lbs--essentially no change. His blood sugar likewise hovered in the 120's.

I felt Art need to be prodded, so I asked him to undergo another heart scan. His score: 1935--a 600 point increase, or 45%!

Only now has Art begun to comprehend to power of diabetes and pre-diabetes to fan the flames of plaque growth. Recent published data, in fact, show that the majority of recently diagnosed diabetics already have well-established coronary artery disease.

Don't let this happen to you. Do not dismiss diabetic patterns as they will catch up to you. If Art can lose the 30-40 lbs in the abdominal weight that is creating the diabetic pattern, he will likely succeed in stopping plaque growth. Otherwise, it's just a matter of time before his heart attack, stent, or bypass.

Who cares if you're pre-diabetic?

Marta is a smart lady. She's worked in hospital laboratories for the last 23 years and knows many of the ins and outs of lab tests and their implications.

After years of being told that her cholesterol was acceptable, she needed to undergo urgent bypass surgery after experiencing severe breathlessness that proved to be a small warning heart attack at age 57. But this made Marta skeptical of relying on cholesterol to identify heart disease risk.

I met Marta two years after her bypass surgery when she was seeking better answers. And, indeed, she proved to have several concealed sources of heart disease: small LDL particles, Lipoprotein(a), intermediate-density lipoprotein (IDL--a very important abnormality that means she is unable to clear dietary fats from her blood), among others. But she was also mildly diabetic with a blood sugar of 131 mg (normal < or = 100 mg). This had not been previously recognized.

As I'm a cardiologist and our program focuses on reversal and control of coronary plaque, I asked Marta to return to her primary care doctor to continue the conversation about diabetes. She was a bit frightened but followed through.

"Well, you're not urinating excessively. And your long-term measure of blood sugar, hemoglobin A1C, is still normal. I wouldn't worry about it. We'll just watch it."

I guess I should know better. What the poor primary care doctor doesn't know is that pre-diabetes and mild diabetes are potent risks for heart disease. In fact, some of the most explosive rates of plaque growth occur when these patterns are present. It's well established that risk for heart attack in a diabetic is the same as that of someone who's already suffered a prior heart attack--very high risk, in other words.

Marta's primary care doctor's advice would be like inquiring about cancer and the doctor says "Let's just wait until it's metastatic--then we'll start to worry." Of course, this is insane.

Pre-diabetes and mild diabetes should not be ignored or just "watched". Even though the blood sugar itself may not be high enough to endanger you, the hidden patterns underlying your body's unresponsiveness to insulin creates a torrent of hidden coronary risk.

For better answers, Track Your Plaque members can read "Shutting Off Metabolic Syndrome" at http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_dp001metabolic.asp on the www.cureality.com website. ("Metabolic syndrome" is the name commonly given to the constellation of abnormalities associated with pre-diabetes and diabetes.)

Don't get smug!

It may sound silly, but after someone succeeds in stopping their heart scan score from increasing or reduces their score, I warn them to not get smug. Let me explain.

I'll tell you about Jack. I met Jack a few years ago after he had a heart scan at age 39. His score: 1441! A score this high at his age obviously puts him in the 99th percentile. Also recall that a score >1000 carries a 25% annual risk for heart attack.

This captured Jack's attention. At the start, his lipoproteins were disastrous with numerous abnormal patterns. Jack committed to the program. After one year, his lipoproteins were around 80-90% corrected towards perfection. He'd lost 27 lbs, was exercising six days a week, and felt great.

Jack's repeat score one year later: 1107--over a 300 point drop! A huge success. He was ecstatic.

Unfortunately, work and life in general distracted him. Jack allowed himself to drift back to old habits, indulging in fast food 2 or 3 times a week, slacking on exercise such that it became sporadic, half-hearted efforts, and regained 15 lbs. He even failed to show up for appointments and we lost contact for two years.

One day, Jack simply decided to see where he stood, so he got himself another heart scan. The score: 2473--over a doubling from his reduced score.

The message: Long-term consistency is key, even after you've achieved control over your score. Stick with your program--and don't get smug!

Holidays are dangerous!

If you're on holiday from work today, make sure you're not on holiday from your health, too.

Too often, people come back to the office telling me that the holidays simply got out of hand--cookouts, picnics, family gatherings, etc.--and they simply couldn't avoid overeating, overdrinking, sitting around--and gaining 3-5 lbs in a weekend. (Our record is 10 lbs in a weekend!)

I don't want to harp on this issue and ruin your holiday, but I can't stress how important it is that you don't allow this to happen to you. Weight gained in a brief space of time has exceptionally destructive effects. Ever see the movie "Super Size Me"? It's an entertaining and well-done yet graphic portrayal of the damaging effects of rapid weight gain.

Enjoy your time off. Relax, enjoy your family and friends--but continue to pay attention to choosing the right foods, don't overeat, take time out to do something (or several things) physical. It'll pay off hugely in the long run.

More on carotid plaque...

Although not a perfect test, carotid ultrasound is an exceptionally easy and accessible test. Using high-frequency sound, clear images are available for most people.

I say it's not perfect because the way it's done in 2006 makes it a non-quantitative test. It is a qualitative test. In other words, you may find out that there's a 30% blockage ("stenosis"), at the far end of the common carotid artery on the right side. Unfortunately, this gives you an isolated measure of diameter of the plaque compared to the artery. What it does not tell you is what the volume of the entire plaque is. That's a far more accurate measure (and one that is incorporated into your heart scan score, by the way).

Nonetheless, carotid ultrasound is easy, very safe, and available in most hospitals and many clinics. One difficulty: most insurance companies will not allow you to go through a carotid ultrasound scan as a "screening" procedure, i.e., a test just to see if you have a carotid plaque. They will generally pay if you're having symptoms of a stroke or "mini-stroke" (transient ischemic attack, or "TIA"), have an abnormal sound in your carotid ultrasound detected by your doctor (a carotid "bruit"), or some other unusual indications. Sometimes, a resourceful physician will muster up a diagnosis based on something in your history (e.g., left arm numbness, a common and often benign complaint that can also signal stroke).

Another option are the mobile scanners or some hospital services that offer carotid screening, usually for a very modest price. Drawback: Sporadic availability, difficulty in obtaining serial scans, and imprecise reporting since it's viewed as a screening test. But it's better than nothing.

My hope is that, as screening services using safe imaging techniques like ultrasound propagate and increase in direct availability to the public, you'll be able to circumvent the obstacles imposed by your insurance company and even, sometimes, your doctor. But try your doctor first.

Carotid plaque can be shrunk

Rose, a 64-year old woman, just had a 70% carotid blockage identified by a screening ultrasound. When the result was given to her doctor, he prescribed Lipitor and told Rose that an ultrasound would be required every year. She would need carotid surgery, an "endarterectomy", if the blockage worsened.

"Can't I reduce the amount of blockage I have?" asked Rose.

"No. Once you've got it, it doesn't get any better."


Is this true? Once you've got carotid plaque, you can only expect it to get worse and it can't be reduced?

This is absolutely not true. In fact, compared to coronary plaque, carotid plaque is easier to reduce!

Of course, the Track Your Plaque program is designed to help you control or reduce coronary plaque. But, in our experience, people who have both coronary and carotid plaque will show far greater and faster reduction of carotid plaque. Dramatic reductions are sometimes seen. I've personally seen 50-70% blockages reduced to <30% on many occasions.

The requirements to achieve reduction of carotid plaque are very similar to the approach we use to reduce coronary plaque. One difference is that hypertension may play a more important role with carotid plaque and needs to be reduced confidently to the normal range before carotid plaque is controlled.

I find it shocking that the attitude like the one provided by this physician continue to prevail. Unlike coronary plaque, which has a relatively small body of scientific literature documenting how it can be reduced, carotid plaque actually enjoys a substantial clinical literature. Part of the reason is that the carotids are more easily imaged using ultrasound. (Heart structures can be seen with ultrasound, but not the coronary arteries.)

Numerous agents have been shown to contribute to reduction of carotid plaque: statin drugs, niacin, fish oil, the anti-diabetic "TZD" drugs (Actos, Avandia), several anti-hypertensive drugs, vitamin E, pomegranate juice, and several others.

It outrages me to hear stories like this. Rose is not the only one.

Don't accept the flip dismissals or the over-enthusiastic referral for carotid procedures. Insist on a conversation about plaque regression.


Note: Although I am a vigorous advocate of atherosclerotic plaque regression, this does not mean that if you have a severe (70% blockage or greater), or if there are symptoms from your carotid disease, that you should engage in a program of reversal. You must always take the advice of your doctor if your safety is in question.
The nattokinase scam

The nattokinase scam

A conversation about vitamin K2 commonly leads to confusion. Several people have asked about something called nattokinase.

The scientific data on the potential role of vitamin K2 deficiency in causing both osteoporosis and vascular calcification is fascinating. Along with vitamin D3, vitamin K2 may be an important factor in regulation of calcium metabolism. Supplementation may prove to be a major strategy for inhibition of vascular calcification.

Obtaining K2 in the diet is tricky, since it's present in just a handful of foods: egg yolks, liver, traditional cheeses, and natto. This is where the confusion starts.

Natto is a Japanese fermented soy product. I've had it and it's quite disgusting. Nonetheless, Japanese who eat natto experience less fracture. (A parallel study in heart disease has not been performed.) Natto is also a source of another substance called nattokinase.

Advocates (otherwise often known as supplement distributors) claim that nattokinase is a "fibrinolytic", or blood clot-dissolving, preparation that "improves blood flow, protects from blood clots, and prevents heart attacks and strokes."

Don't you believe it. This is patent nonsense. There are several problems with this rationale:

--Any oral fibrinolytic agent is promptly degraded in the highly acid environment of the stomach. That's why all medically used fibrinolytics are given intravenously. Drug companies have struggled for years to encapsulate, modify, or somehow protect protein (or polypeptide) products taken orally from degrading this way. They've never succeeded. That's why, for instance, growth hormone (a polypeptide) remains an injection, not an oral agent. An oral growth hormone, by the way, would sell like mad, so the drug companies would very much like to figure out how to bypass the degradative effects of stomach acid. One of the "researchers" behind the nattokinase claims boasts that he has single-handedly figured out how to protect the nattokinase molecule in the gastrointestinal tract. However, he won't tell anybody how he does it. Right.

--Fibrinolytic agents are extremely dangerous. In years past, we used to treat heart attacks with intravenous fibrinolytic agents like tissue plasminogen activator, urokinase, streptokinase, and others. They have fallen by the wayside, for the most part, because of limited effectiveness and the unavoidable dangers of their use. Fibrinolytics are "dumb": they dissolve blood clots in both good places and bad. While they might dissolve the blood clot causing your heart attack, they also degrade the tiny clot in your cerebral (brain) circulation that was protective. That's why fatal brain hemorrhages, bleeding stomach ulcers, and blood oozing from strange places can also occur with fibrinolytic administration. Believe me, I've seen it happen, and I've watched people die from them.

The idea that a small dose taken orally is healthy is ridiculous. Even if nattokinase worked, why the heck would you take an agent that has known dangerous and very real consequences?

Don't let this idiocy reflect poorly on the K2 conversation, which, I believe, holds real merit and is backed by legitimate science. This is symptomatic of a larger difficulty with the supplement industry: Insane and unfounded claims about one supplement erodes credibility for the entire industry. It gives regulation-crazed people like the FDA ammunition to go after supplements, something none of us need. You and I have to sift through the nonsense to uncover the real gems in this rockpile, real gems like vitamin D3, omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil, and, perhaps, vitamin K2. But not nattokinase.

Comments (179) -

  • Anonymous

    6/2/2007 6:49:00 PM |

    Before you dismiss Nattokinase, please check out research done by Hiroyuki Sumi from 1987 (original discovery) and 1990, and subsequent research on how the compound has an effect on plasmin and other clot-dissolving agents.

  • Dr. Davis

    6/2/2007 10:12:00 PM |

    I have read his research. I stand by my opinion: Nattokinase is a scam. It is an utterly ridiculous notion that anyone should take oral thrombolytic agents to "prevent blood clots". Thrombolysis is a dangerous strategy, even if it worked in humans by the oral route. An agent that, if it worked, poses serious potential for severe side effects and death needs to be tested thoroughly first. It is plain idiocy to use this agent. It is not fish  oil, it is not a vitamin, it is something entirely different that has no basis for use as a preventive. You're throwing your money away.

  • Anonymous

    9/2/2007 5:33:00 AM |

    I actually don't find natto disgusting at all -- I think I am one of the few non-Japanese who like it.  I didn't realize it was so healthy for you.  Should I consciously add it to my diet?

  • Dr. Davis

    9/2/2007 1:29:00 PM |

    No kidding?

    Natto is an abundant source of vitamin K2, which may have a role in regulating calcium metabolism. Although not as crucial as vit D3, K2 is emerging as a potential addition to our program. See our full Special Report on vitamin K2 on the www.trackyourplaque.com website.

  • Anonymous

    12/18/2007 11:07:00 PM |

    "Fibrinolytics are "dumb": they dissolve blood clots in both good places and bad."

    That's true of anything taken orally, and is not much of a criticism. And there is little difference in risk between fish oils or aspirin, and typical nattokinase intakes. So the only point you're making that makes any sense to me is that nattokinase does not survive stomach acidity, but that is contradicted by studies where nattokinase taken orally did have an effect.

  • Anonymous

    12/19/2007 6:04:00 AM |

    "I believe you are failing to appreciate what fibrinolytics accomplish if they were truly being absorbed through the stomach: They are deadly. You have to be nuts to take an agent like this chronically if it worked."

    Problem is that it's even nuttier to be taking warfarin chronically, considering it's _known_ interaction with vitamin K - but that's exactly what is currently pushed. See www.vitamink2.org for discussion of the evils of warfarin - the surest route to osteoporosis and blood vessel calcification.

    Personally, I take K2-7, fish oil, etc., but am open to the idea that nattokinase may be able to offset the decline in plasmin production that occurs with age. Of course, it would be best if we had a (convenient) blood value to monitor to check dosage (something as simple as a blood glucose or INR meter). Certainly more research is needed.

    If not nattokinase, then how do you suggest that we address the increased risk of clotting with age? And how should the amounts of these alternatives be adapted to individual differences? (As exemplified by the issue of how much fish oil to consume.)

  • Dr. Davis

    12/19/2007 1:32:00 PM |

    I agree with you on the vitmamin K2 issue and certainly with omega-3. However, the whole lytic issue is truly nutty. Lytics are destructive. While warfarin (I'm no fan, either, and I put all interested warfarin-taking patients on K1 and K2 supplements if the warfarin can't be avoided, e.g., chronic pulmonary emboli, left ventricular thrombi, prosthetic heart valve--these people have no choice) prevents propagation of blood clot, it is NOT a blood clot dissolver. Lytic agents ARE. In other words, the little protective blood clot in the tiny defect in your middle cerebral artery that would have healed itself without consequence becomes a cerebral bleed. I know--I've seen it happen several times in the "old days" when lytics were popular. It even happens with the smaller doses used for localized clot dissolution introduced via specific delivery into the thrombus.

    Unfortunately, I don't have an answer on how to manage the acquired disorder of blood coagulation that accompanies aging. However, omega-3s are a big part of the solution.

  • Anonymous

    12/19/2007 2:49:00 PM |

    For the record, here's a summary of the argument for nattokinase, as promoted by Holsworth. If all of this turns out to be true, would you still be against use of nattokinase?

    Dr. Holsworth describes the actions of nattokinase as “Nurturing Nature”. The most therapeutic perspective property of NK is the indirect effect.
    1) inhibits PAI-1 (plasminogen activation inhibitor-1)
    2) upregulates individual’s own tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) anti-clotting mechanism
    3) converts endogenous pro-urokinase to urokinase
    4) has small anti-platelet activity – similar to garlic or onions
    Lyses cross-linked or dysfunctional fibrin. NK is 6 times more efficient than our own plasmin, but does not compete with cleavage of fibrinogen, so doesn’t attack anything that isn’t dysfunctional. Fibrin is the single-most causative agent that makes blood thick.
    -No direct tPA activity – no direct competition in clotting
    -No degradation of albumin by NK
    -Said to act like an Angiotensin Converting Enzyme inhibitor ACEi). Keeps angiotensin II down and in rat studies, thins the neo-intimal layer of inflamed blood vessels. He is not impressed with the clinical studies suggesting the ACEi effect; but clinically, it works as an anti-hypertensive medicine . He does find that people on antihypertensives decrease the amount of high blood pressure medication or eliminate them all together in 7 – 14 days.
    Dr Holsworth cautions that individuals on high blood pressure medicines, closely monitor their blood pressure and notify their primary care physician about any lowering of their blood pressure.
    Dr. Holsworth has seen significant decreases of 10-20 points of systolic and diastolic blood pressures within 7 days of starting nattokinase.
    -Linked to circadian rhythm. PAI-1 inhibits the ability to create plasmin. Clots occur early in the a.m. predominantly and, therefore, increase the stroke or heart attack incidence.
    Breaking down existing clots…
    NK has only slight or limited Pac Man capabilities to “eat away” directlyat existing clots, but rather “nurtures nature” by enhancing our own endogenous pro-fibrinolytic system. Small direct effect of less than 10% efficacy similar to plasmin where it works directly on a clot – Pac Man style. It will not break loose a clot.

    What is an ideal thyrombolyic agent?
    • Rapid – NK is effective within 4 hours PO (oral) administration and has significant fibrinolytic activity in blood vs. tPA which has that 3-hour grace period to initiate…so there is only one hour differential in ischemia situation. Additionally, tPA has short duration of effectiveness and must be taken intravenously..
    • Duration – maintain patency of vasculature – no early reclusions.
    • Sustained duration of action - half-life of NK is 8 – 12 hours. After tPA administration, patients are at an increased risk for the next 14 – 48 hours where patients are susceptible and have an increased thrombophilic state secondary to tPA IV (as in rebound effect).
    • Specific - no shotgun effect of cleaving any and all fibrin in the body… Specific or targeted…that’s what NK does with cross-linked fibrin.
    • Thrombosis–specific…doesn’t adversely affect coagulation factors or the coagulation cascade
    • Upregulates body’s own plasminogen system.
    • Low risk of hemorrhage - isolated cases of epistaxis (nose bleeds) – compounded by 4 – 5 other anti-platelet agents…garlic ginkgo, fish oil. Reduce intake.
    • Absence of systemic side effects.
    • Caution – if on antihypertensives, check blood pressure in 7 – 10 days. NK can quickly correct the body’s Hemorheology. Blood pressure medicines may have to be titrated down so individual is not over-medicated or discontinue use.
    • -Low cost
    • Per oral (P.O.) convenience (as opposed to IV).

  • Anonymous

    12/22/2007 3:24:00 PM |

    I should have mentioned that the above Holsworth summary is from Jackie on the www.afibbers.net forum.

    I guess I'm also interested in what Dr. Davis has to say about the use of nattokinase to treat fibroids, as exemplified by Fibrovan (www.fibrovan.com). Are all the testimonies faked? Or will all the patients soon die of some sort of internal bleeding?

  • Dr. Davis

    12/23/2007 12:31:00 AM |

    The data I've looked at re: nattokinase has been proprietary, generated clearly by a manufacturer. Until some real science emerges, even modest, to support this otherwise counterintuitive strategy, it remains something that has no value for our plaque reducing focus. The disease is not thrombus or clot; the disease is atherosclerosis. Clot develops when heart attack occurs. It makes no sense to take a lytic agent that dissolves clotes continuously. Unless I am missing something here, nattokinase remains squarely in the nonsense column.

  • Anonymous

    2/24/2008 2:38:00 PM |

    My wife has enometriosis with disabling pain and the treaments that the doctors have been giving seems to only make it wrose. I found aFibrovan on the internet stating that it would reduce the symptoms within in weeks with no side effects.

    Is this fibrovan similar to the scams in which you speak or does it have merit for endo an treatment?

  • Anonymous

    3/2/2008 2:33:00 PM |

    Thank you Dr. Davis for your comments re:  nattokinase.  As you know, the testimonials (at the product sites) are pretty amazing.  As my holistic MD is suggesting UFE or myomectomy, I'm thinking about trying one of the fibrovan, neprinol "fibroid dissolvers"!  I'm also taking codliver oil, turmeric and a pile of herbs to support liver function.  are all those testimonials lies?  maybe if we had an economic system based on love and caring instead of profit, we wouldn't be asking this question.  thank you again for your knowledge and care-it's clear that you do. lynn

  • Anonymous

    3/9/2008 12:18:00 AM |

    I don't have a heart problem.  I have had debilitating muculoskeletal pain for over 8 years.  Last week Friday, 3/7/08, I began taking a large dose of nattokinase.  Results were evident in fewer than 4 hours and continue today, 8 days later.  I am able to function without my usual pain medication and the adhesions and hypertone in my muscle tissue continue to decrease daily.  Do you have any ideas why?

    Thanks.

  • Anonymous

    3/19/2008 3:24:00 PM |

    I have spoken with my doctor who states that NK is being used currently in Germany to treat DVT's, clots, etc., and two of her heart patients also take it, one for over two years now (from Germany himself) and another woman for the past six months, both have improved health.  I also have many friends who have used NK to dissolve their DVT's who no issues what so ever, and with doctors involvement watching the progress.  Why is none of this ever talked about?  I haven't heard one report of a person dying from NK.  SH

  • Rett

    4/15/2008 3:31:00 PM |

    I an interested to know why you think, that if nattokinase were dangerous in that it may dissolve clots too quickly or inappropriately, how come users of natto do not report excessive bruising?

  • Anonymous

    4/17/2008 8:04:00 PM |

    As if conventional medicine is so great.  The United States spends more on health care than any other nation, yet as a recent study revealed we are dead last in outcomes.  I went to FIVE (5) physicians (PCP, ortho, GYN, etc.) over a 3.5-month period with left leg pain and swelling, and stated several times with these symptoms and the fact I'm on estrogen I think this is a DVT.  Response?  "Oh, no that's normal as we age.  Our veins become less efficient" (oh, please...what a crock)  The sixth physician, a pulmonologist, ordered an ultrasound that revealed an extensive proximal DVT.  If conventional medicine is so charming, please explain to me why it is so d*** incompetent.  A friend of mine went for a mammogram.  "We see something suspicious."  Pathology after biopsy-indeterminate x3, then "you've got lymphoma".  An oncologist was wanting to start chemo right away.  A PET scan and numerous labs were all NORMAL!!!  No cancer.  How pathetic.  How many people are receiving chemotherapy who never had cancer in the first place?  Perhaps Dr. Davis you need to open your mind!!  Most sincerely!

  • Anonymous

    4/18/2008 1:33:00 PM |

    I started taking Nattokinase for a DVT.  I was initially taking 2,000 FU per day then bumped it to 6,000.  Recent labs and ultrasound show IT IS WORKING!!  Fibrin degradation products are high and the ultrasound shows a resolving clot just weeks after diagnosis.  (Natto was started in the past 3 weeks; the higher dose within the last week.)  We've been using rat poison (Coumadin) since the early 1950s.  The hair thinning/loss, bloating, headache, etc. that accompanies Coumadin are known side effects though most doctors will tell patients they are not.  Are we to believe that in 60 years we can't come up with anything better to offer than Coumadin?  Studies have undeniably shown that after one year of "treatment" with Coumadin, more than 24 percent of people STILL HAVE residual clot.  Coumadin, of course, does not dissolve clots.  It only prevents new ones from forming and impacts the clotting cascade to enable the body to absorb the clot.  Nattokinase is a viable, effective alternative.  The real reason it is not studied in America is because it is a naturally-occurring substance that cannot be patented,i.e., no drug company can profit.  The Japanese people are the healthiest people on the face of the earth.  How thoughtful of Japan Air Lines to include natto in their snacks on their LONG-HAUL flights.  Obviously, they are proactive in their healthcare and attempts to prevent clots.  Just as American medical practitioners laugh at Nattokinase, I recall a time when we laughed at those cars called Toyotas.  No one is laughing now at the quality and high integrity of this company.  Now as then, perhaps we should stop criticizing and start emulating.

  • Anonymous

    4/18/2008 1:37:00 PM |

    Dr. Davis-you should be upfront about the fact that Coumadin is one of the top 10 reasons for emergency room visits in the United States.

  • Anonymous

    6/21/2008 2:39:00 AM |

    I like the saying "If all you have is a hammer, everyting you see is a nail".  I have seen many doctors on various occasions, lost a tooth because the dentist only had a hammer.  Now I have s second tooth that feels funny, and it will not be treated by a dentist.

    I started taking nattokinase a few days ago, 5000FU per pill once a day.  I do feel something different happening, but can't quite put my finger on it.  But it's not a feeling of being better.  As of now, I am feeling a bit numbness in both arms, and a location between the shoulder blades hurts a bit and changes in area now and then.

  • Dr. William Davis

    7/8/2008 3:47:00 AM |

    Looking back over these posts accumulating over the past several months, I note that some readers have interpreted my criticisms of the junk science behind nattokinase as an indirect endorsement of warfarin.

    That is plain wrong.

    I criticize nattokinase for making extravagant claims with virtually no real data in humans. If fibrinolysis truly developed with nattokinase, we would expect several deaths for every 100 people who take it, because that is the experience with any agent causing lysis of clots.

    If I advocate anything, it is truth. Be aware that, whether it's a drug manufacturer, a food manufacturer, or a supplement manufacturer, they are willing takers of your money.

    There are truly effective, powerful supplements out there. Nattokinase is not one of them.

  • Oswald

    7/12/2008 3:04:00 PM |

    This is an interesting debate on a couple of levels:

    (1) The assertion that "all" fibrolytic substances are broken down by the stomach environment. That should be all *known* substances. Just because you have always seen only white swans doesn't mean there aren't any black swans (see the philosopher Karl Popper to learn about being a real scientist).

    (2) Anecdotal evidence from myself. I try to be objective. I can't say anything about the anticoagulant effects of Nattokinase, but so far as I can tell it has some anti-inflammatory effect. I have monitored this in my own health.

    Of course we all need to proceed carefully when new substances are touted as having fabulous effects.
    Snake oil is ever present. We should also remember that most Doctors are not trained to be scientists, they seldom understand how science should proceed. So very often they retreat into dogma and blanket assertions. It wasn't so long ago that saying stomach ulcers were caused by bacteria would have caused a Doctor to be derided as a fool. Science and knowledge proceeds by conjecture and refutation, and while we do have to be careful of Snake oil, we also have to be aware that accepted dogma is often wrong.

  • Anonymous

    8/4/2008 6:07:00 AM |

    "If fibrinolysis truly developed with nattokinase, we would expect several deaths for every 100 people who take it, because that is the experience with any agent causing lysis of clots." - Dr. Davis

    Makes perfect sense, that as a oral thrombolytic agent, nattokinase very likely is a "scam."

    But, nattokinase's efficacy as an oral anticoagulant is not out of the question by the limited empirical evidence that exists.  Nattokinase begs to be studied in that regard, and should be before being totally declared a "scam."

    Would not nattokinase qualify as an important part of the TYP protocol if it does indeed prove to be an effective alternative for all thoughs people taking warfarin?

  • Gene

    8/22/2008 8:50:00 PM |

    I take it you disapprove of NK.
    Thank you for your insights.  It may or may not be that your paradigm colored your opinion, as it does with all of us, I suppose.  
    NK is an over-the-counter substance and, if taken on its face value, according to your analysis, it should be removed from the stores, as it is monkeying with primal forces.
    Therefore, either someone is asleep at the switch or the risk is not as purported (the risk of being ripped off is another department.)
    I think the scientific method is over-used as a sword and shield, yet doctors rely on their own experience all the time, even disagreeing with reports. My view there is no report not telling me to not eat wood screws.
    More real information is needed, but the drug companies, unlike what is suggested, will not be happy to find a cheap, generic solution to anything. though the president may use the solution. It is just the way reality has been organized.
    What is needed is a useful government, but we all know that is a wasted thought.
    Foreign research should not be put aside, not because to do so is some sort of racism, but because it may be balanced.
    Clearly, NK does something. We can't just throw our hands up and deny anecdotal experience, often quoted by intrigued doctors, and call people nuts. That may be sort of true, but it is a meaningless as blatant advocacy. Thus, we must wait and look for research, probably out of Japan.
    In the meantime, natto is OK if you add cinnamon. Forget that soy stuff.  Do this, and it is anti-inflammatory, too.
    Me, I am a fan of Serrapeptase and have not found much to dissuade me.

  • Anonymous

    9/8/2008 6:31:00 PM |

    Hello Dr. Davis

    While your credentials speak for themselves, I would submit that you simply do not have the nutritional background to support many of your claims re: Nattokinase. I base this on the typical Medical curriculum that includes on average a whopping equivalent of a weekend course at best... I suggest you look at the coagulation pathways that Nattokinase acts within and then you might be entitled to having an opinion that comes from reality and not your personal dogma.

  • Ryan W.

    10/5/2008 8:02:00 AM |

    Another fibrinolytic enzyme, serrapeptase, (which is also a serine protease) which is larger than nattokinase and also absorbed by the gut (if coated to pass through the stomach) is capable of breaking up bacterial biofilms, enhancing the effectiveness of antibiotics, and removing persistent bacterial infections.

    Serrapeptase is also used commonly as a painkiller and anti-inflammatory in Germany with no marked ill effects. The fact that it has fibrinolytic activity, is absorbed gastrointestinaly and still is safe makes me question your catagorical statements about nattokinase.

    I don't suppose you can cite any peer reviewed in vitro research that actually supports your view?

    The safety of natto aside for a moment, personally what I wonder is whether Natto's beneficial effects are from nattokinase or from a different serine protease found in natto.

    ----
    Because the control of the invasion of host cells by Listeria could potentially hinder its spread in the infected host, we have examined the effects of a protease treatment on the ability of L. monocytogenes to form biofilms and to invade tissues. We have chosen serratiopeptidase (SPEP), an extracellular metalloprotease produced by Serratia marcescens that is already widely used as an anti-inflammatory agent, and has been shown to modulate adhesin expression and to induce antibiotic sensitivity in other bacteria. Treatment of L. monocytogenes with sublethal concentrations of SPEP reduced their ability to form biofilms and to invade host cells.

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18479885?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

    CONCLUSIONS: Serratiopeptidase was effective for eradicating infection caused by biofilm-forming bacteria in this experimental animal model. The antibiofilm property of the enzyme may enhance antibiotic efficacy in the treatment of staphylococcal infections.

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16757752?ordinalpos=2&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

    Among the different mechanisms of bacterial resistance to antimicrobial agents that have been studied, biofilm formation is one of the most widespread. This mechanism is frequently the cause of failure in the treatment of prosthetic device infections, and several attempts have been made to develop molecules and protocols that are able to inhibit biofilm-embedded bacteria. We present data suggesting the possibility that proteolytic enzymes could significantly enhance the activities of antibiotics against biofilms. Antibiotic susceptibility tests on both planktonic and sessile cultures, studies on the dynamics of colonization of 10 biofilm-forming isolates, and then bioluminescence and scanning electron microscopy under seven different experimental conditions showed that serratiopeptidase greatly enhances the activity of ofloxacin on sessile cultures and can inhibit biofilm formation.


    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8109925?ordinalpos=3&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum


    These results indicated QK-1 was a plasmin-like serine protease and QK-2 a subtilisin family serine protease.

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14984705?ordinalpos=13&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

  • Dan

    10/8/2008 2:45:00 PM |

    "I don't have a heart problem. I have had debilitating muculoskeletal pain for over 8 years. Last week Friday, 3/7/08, I began taking a large dose of nattokinase. Results were evident in fewer than 4 hours and continue today, 8 days later. I am able to function without my usual pain medication and the adhesions and hypertone in my muscle tissue continue to decrease daily. Do you have any ideas why?"

    Dr. Davis,

    I have been taking NK since I wrote the quote, above.  In the past 6 months I have continued to experience improvement in my condition.

    I am a massage therapist, having worked on 1000's of clients, many with similar, but less severe, symptoms as mine.  I have never seen, nor experienced such a dramatic improvement in tissue health except with one client who began treatment with quinolin(many years ago), an anomoly to me at that time.

    I was a mechanical engineer, before head injury led to my physical dysfunction.  It is common, in every field of knowledge, for us to limit our options for problem solutions due to unfounded beliefs, often out of convenience, fear or ignorance.

    NK has allowed me to end my slow slide into physical pain and oblivion after more than 8 years of extensive, and intensive treatment(s) that had only succeeded in slowing my slide.  It has allowed me to return to massage practice, part time, to begin reconnecting with my family after years of isolation, and has given me reason to think that a return to engineering practice may one day be possible, too.

    That is a big claim, I realize, but it represents a careful evaluation of objective evidence of the beneficial action of NK in the human body, something I haven't found anywhere, to date. I don't know what makes NK work, but for people with hardened myofacsia, it improves their response to therapy, resulting in reduced pain and improved function in a much shorter time than is typical.  It's effects are obvious to palpation in less than 4hours.

    You have reason to question NK for lack of solid evidence. I don't expect my claim to change your position.  But I can tell you that my claim is solidly objective, the results are more repeatable than most medical claims, rising very near the level of empirical certainty.

    I hope this discussion leads others to unexpected solutions, as it has me.

  • Anonymous

    10/14/2008 5:59:00 PM |

    What the good Doctor unfortunately overlooks, is that most serious Nattokinase supplements are enteric coated tablets, and quite easily pass the acid barrier of the stomach, he also fails to mention that not all of Nattokinase, even in a non enteric protected form, is destroyed by stomach acid. For example , a diet rich in Natto, isn't suffering 100% lost to stomach acid, but rather a mere percentage, as with most any strict exclusive diet of one particular thing.

  • rudy

    11/19/2008 8:43:00 PM |

    i am taking natto 100mg primarily to make blood harder to clot, i have observed three things; 1) it is pretty potent, even with 100mg (2000FU), i had a bleeding in the gum is harder to clot, 2) my blood pressure have dropped about 8 points both high and low side, 3) like DAN, my myfascial pain is lessen ever since taking natto, at first i thought it was because of MSM, but actually it was natto that reduced my pain

    however, my father died from cerebal bleeding after he was given thrombolytic in ER for his heart attack, so i certainly do appreciate Dr.Davis point of view that sometimes clots are useful, and if you overdo it and use too much anticongulate agent (such as natto) it may have negative side effects one has to be careful

  • Anonymous

    12/3/2008 11:05:00 AM |

    By calling Nattokinase a "scam", one implies that current medical treatment is superior or less dangerous.  It encourages people on Coumadin to continue this dangerous drug, which has led to untold morbidity and mortality--and we won't go into the manufacturing debacles from China.  We really should not be comparing Coumadin/Warfarin (a product of the laboratory) with Nattokinase.  Coumadin and Warfarin do NOT dissolve blood clots. They simply prevent them from enlarging/prevent new clots, while the clots (hopefully) stabilize and do not embolize.  After stabilization of a clot against the vessel wall, one must exercise to increase plasmin in the blood in order to significantly affect breakdown.  Doctors DO NOT inform patients that Coumadin is not a fibrinolytic.  Most patients on Coumadin believe that Coumadin is breaking down their clots. Nattokinase supports the plasmin realm, working the way the body naturally does, to gradually break down clot constituents--no emboli are created.  ("-ase" indicates enzyme)  Some other enzymes and enzyme products can have anti-inflammatory properties, such as those naturally occuring in foods, those in the famous Wobenzym, and those in a number of digestive enzyme products absorbed through the gut.  Inflammation is a key factor in preventing aberrant clots.  But taking laboratory products, rather than foods or food derivatives, is what gets us in trouble.  We do not have the full knowledge of synergy in foods and conventional doctors tend to dismiss, rather than respect, what is unknown.  Synergy is why eating "live" food is so important.  I will stand by Hippocrates--"Let your food be your medicine and your medicine your food."  Treatments derived from foods (which have been alive) are safer than and, in the long term, superior to isolated, fractionated, or synthetic drugs.  Enzymes decrease inflammation because they allow it to resolve--breaking down the barriers in the circulatory and interstitial spaces, so that waste products can leave and nutrition can enter.  This may be why folks report effects on fibroids, muscle pain, and fatigue with enzymes such as Nattokinase and Wobenzym.  It supports the normal, continuous break-down/re-build process at work in the body.  Synthetic drugs target isolated effects (clots) from a bigger problem (inflammation) and fail to address root causes.  Enzymes have a more comprehensive effect--they also aid digestion, so that food does not putrefy, ferment, become rancid--absorption of which also causes inflammation and other undesirable effects on health.  We have 3 paths in the body that cause blood to clot and just one (plasmin) to break down clots. That speaks to the wisdom of the Creator--given a good, low inflammation diet of fresh foods with enzymes, clotting would not occur abnormally.  Bleeding (from injury), not aberrant clotting, would be the primary concern for us if we followed a healthy lifestyle.  With aging, there is more tendency to clotting--this parallels digestive problems (stomach, liver, gall bladder, pancreas, intestinal tract).  Conventional Doctors give acid preventer drugs, such as the purple pill, and antacids.  Natural doctors address healing of ulcers and leaky gut, if necessary, and give enzymes and hydrochloric acid supplements (HCl production declines by 1/2 by the time we reach 50--it's the lactic acid from food fermentation that typically causes heartburn).  One cannot   knowledgeably discuss whole foods or whole food derived supplements with a medical-style mindset--foods/phytonutrients are far more complex than synthetic drugs, and have  synergistic, protective effects that haven't been duplicated in the laboratory. Nattokinase is currently being researched for use in atrial fibrillation.

  • Anonymous

    12/10/2008 3:20:00 AM |

    I know someone who has essential thrombocytosis and her platelets were on a steady path upward until she started taking nattokinase with doctor supervision of her platelets.  They are now on a steady path downward and have already dropped by almost 400 in the last 2 months.  I'm not sure the risks are any moreso than taking a chemotherapy drug for the rest of your life which was the alternative. Anecdotal evidence should not be ignored.

  • lmontgom

    1/12/2009 4:11:00 AM |

    Nattokinase has been a miracle for me. I could barely walk or sleep because of chronic, pervasive pain in both my legs. My doctor x-rayed hips and knees, recommended replacements. She sent me to an orthopedist who asked if my knees and hips hurt. My "No" caused him to send me away. I asked for physical therapy. That helped little. Reading on the vitacost site, I found a comment on natto kinase that caused me to drive to my local health food store, buy some and take it immediately. By Day 2, my legs hurt much less. by Day 4, they stopped hurting. That was about 2 months ago, and the experience continues. In addition, occasional numbesses in my hands ceased. I urge Dr. Davis to look at the effects we are experiencing and find research telling him why it works. I know nothing about thrombolytics but am grateful that I have nattokinase and can walk!

  • Red Beard

    1/29/2009 5:35:00 PM |

    Everyone seems to be missing the most important argument against the effectiveness of nattokinase:  it is a protein enzyme, and there is not a single protein in this universe that can be taken up by our GI tract in its whole and active form.  Look at it this way:  there are a few rare diseases in which a person is unable to make some important enzyme on their own.  If enzyme replacement therapy is an option, this is always done intravenously, because we've known for a long time that you cannot introduce an enzyme in pill form and have it be functional in the blood stream.  If you could, enzyme replacement pills would be a multi-billion dollar industry!

    Yes, nattokinase may have all the effects that have been described vs. clotting, but this is only if you add it DIRECTLY to the blood.  The research that has been done that everyone quotes was not done by having people take this enzyme orally then examining their clotting function.  They either took blood out of a person and added it, or gave it to animals intravenously.  

    Secondly, even IF it was true that an enzyme like nattokinase could be orally active--which is impossible--its fibrinolytic properties would make it MORE DANGEROUS than aspirin in terms of serious side effects.

  • Karen

    2/10/2009 3:09:00 PM |

    and the alternative is coumadan (warfarin) WHICH IS RAT POISON. You are so wrong doctor.

  • Anonymous

    2/15/2009 1:50:00 PM |

    Nattokinase taken orally works, yoiu can find a lot of research on pubmed.
    Maybe stomach environment transforms it in something different, but what if that something is active against blood clotting?

  • Anonymous

    2/23/2009 6:41:00 PM |

    I have noted that NattoKinase as an oral blood thinner is asserted to be a scam here and the rationalisation for this is that there was no reliable research done to back it for what it is purported to do, right?.

    If I advocate anything, it is truth. Be aware that, whether it's a drug manufacturer, a food manufacturer, or a supplement manufacturer, they are willing takers of your money.

    Quote:
    "There are truly effective, powerful supplements out there. Nattokinase is not one of them."
    Dr.Davis

    Well what do you call asserting a negative (its a scam) without empirical research to back the assertion? Do we have the pot calling the kettle black?

    Apparently the research has proceeded to an empirical stage.
    A research summary can be seen here:
    http://www.xymogen.com/drr/RR-012-1104-07.pdf

    Excerpt from link;

    Research
    Two human trials and 17 other studies have been done
    on nattokinase. In a placebo-controlled study done by
    Dr. Sumi in which dogs were induced to have blood
    clots, oral administration of nattokinase (1 gm nattokinase
    as four 250 mg capsules) resulted in angiograms
    showing normal circulation and dissolution of the clot
    within five hours of treatment. In contrast, blood clots
    in the dogs receiving only a placebo did not show any
    signs of dissolution during the 18 hours following treatment.4
    Japanese researchers who studied nattokinase's ability
    to dissolve a thrombus in the carotid arteries of rats
    found that those given nattokinase regained 62% of
    blood flow, whereas those treated with plasmin regained only 15.8%.5
    Researchers from Oklahoma State University,Miyazaki Medical College and JCR Pharmaceuticals
    conducted a human study on 12 healthy volunteers (6 men and 6 women; ages 21-55 years). Before breakfast,each of the volunteers was given 200 grams of the food natto. Then, through a series of blood tests, the researchers tracked the fibrinolytic activity. On average, the volunteers' ELT (a measure of how long it takes to dissolve a blood clot) dropped by 48% within two hours of treatment. This heightened ability to dissolve blood clots was retained for 2 to 8 hours. In order to provide
    a control for the study, the same amount of boiled soybeans
    (non-fermented)was consumed by
    the volunteers. The same tests for fibrinolytic activity did
    not show any significant changes.6

    In recent years, several clinical trials on animals and humans have confirmed this action. A Wister rat study demonstrated on average a 12.7% decline in systolic blood pressure within two hours of a single administration of test extract directly into the
    peritoneum of the rats. These same researchers also confirmed the presence of angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors within the test extract of natto.7 The same extract was then tested on hypertensive human volunteers who took 30 grams of the extract for four consecutive days. In four out of five volunteers, the systolic blood pressure dropped an average of 10.9% and the diastolic dropped 9.7%.7,8

  • Anonymous

    3/2/2009 8:16:00 PM |

    During my last blood test, my C-Reactive Protein Test came out high (3.6) My doctor suggested nattokinase to see if that would reduce the inflammation.  After taking the nattokinase for a month I retested my CRP and the reading was 1.4.  Also, as a side note, I had continuous problems with a hemmroid which has disappeared.  I don't know if this was the nattokinase or not, but I wasn't taking anything else at the time.

  • FunkOdyssey

    3/3/2009 9:23:00 PM |

    You are incorrect in your assertion that nattokinase cannot be absorbed intact across the gut mucosa, and this is supported by published data in contrast to your opinion.  Its effects in humans after oral administration include a reduction of blood pressure:

    Hypertens Res. 2008 Aug;31(8):1583-8.

        Effects of nattokinase on blood pressure: a randomized, controlled trial.
        Kim JY, Gum SN, Paik JK, Lim HH, Kim KC, Ogasawara K, Inoue K, Park S, Jang Y, Lee JH.

        Yonsei University Research Institute of Science for Aging, Department of Food and Nutrition, College of Human Ecology, Yonsei University, and Department of Family Medicine, Mizmedi Hospital, Seoul, Korea.

        The objective of this study was to examine the effects of nattokinase supplementation on blood pressure in subjects with pre-hypertension or stage 1 hypertension. In a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, 86 participants ranging from 20 to 80 years of age with an initial untreated systolic blood pressure (SBP) of 130 to 159 mmHg received nattokinase (2,000 FU/capsule) or a placebo capsule for 8 weeks. Seventy-three subjects completed the protocol. Compared with the control group, the net changes in SBP and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) were -5.55 mmHg (95% confidence interval [CI], -10.5 to -0.57 mmHg; p<0.05) and -2.84 mmHg (CI, -5.33 to -0.33 mmHg; p<0.05), respectively, after the 8-week intervention. The corresponding net change in renin activity was -1.17 ng/mL/h for the nattokinase group compared with the control group (p<0.05). In conclusion, nattokinase supplementation resulted in a reduction in SBP and DBP. These findings suggest that increased intake of nattokinase may play an important role in preventing and treating hypertension.

        PMID: 18971533

    Some evidence of the fact that nattokinase is an orally effective fibrinolytic agent in humans that can be dangerous when used improperly:

    Intern Med. 2008;47(5):467-9. Epub 2008 Mar 3.
        Cerebellar hemorrhage provoked by combined use of nattokinase and aspirin in a patient with cerebral microbleeds.
        Chang YY, Liu JS, Lai SL, Wu HS, Lan MY.

        Department of Neurology, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital-Kaohsiung Medical Center, Chang Gung University College of Medicine, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.

        Nattokinase is used as a health-promoting medicine for preventing thrombosis due to its fibrinolytic activity. Cerebral microbleed is remnant of blood extravasations from the damaged vessels related to cerebral microangiopathies. We report a patient, having used aspirin for secondary stroke prevention, who had an acute cerebellar hemorrhage after taking nattokinase 400 mg daily for 7 consecutive days. In addition to the hemorrhagic lesion, multiple microbleeds were demonstrated on brain MR images. We suggest that nattokinase may increase risk of intracerebral hemorrhage in patients who have bleeding-prone cerebral microangiopathy and are receiving other antithrombotic agent at the same time.

        PMID: 18310985

    It seems nattokinase should be contraindicated in certain high risk populations and should not be combined with other antithrombotic agents.

  • Anonymous

    3/9/2009 9:58:00 PM |

    I am curious about your blanket statement that fibrinolytics are dangerous. Many plants contain significant amounts of proteases that are fibrinolytic; these survive the acid of the stomach, and a portion is absorbed into the blood. Bromelain from pineapple is one prominent example; kiwis also contain a similar protease. These have been used in large doses for decades with few side effects.

  • DVT research

    3/20/2009 8:25:00 PM |

    Sumi's work was a great start, but now there is some momentum and the recent human trials are very interesting.

    Dr. Davis seems to have been a bit prejudicial. Some clinical MDs are very linear thinkers. Dr. Davis, I hope will open his mind.

  • Anonymous

    3/23/2009 5:05:00 PM |

    The nattokinase bottle states not to take it with any type of blood thinning medication or anticoagulant.  Aspirin of itself can cause a brain bleed

  • Jonathan Byron

    4/3/2009 12:59:00 PM |

    Blanket assumptions that proteolytic enzymes simply cannot be absorbed should be reconsidered.

    Here a study that found that orally administered bromelain enzyme is absorbed into the blood intact.

    Intestinal absorption of undegraded proteins in men: presence of bromelain in plasma after oral intake.


    Here are the conclusions of another review on bromelain:
    Bromelain, a standardized complex of proteases from the pineapple plant, is absorbed unchanged from the intestine of animals at a rate of 40%; in animal experiments it was found to have primarily anti-edema, antiinflammatory, and coagulation-inhibiting effects. These effects are due to an enhancement of the serum fibrinolytic activity and inhibition of the fibrinogen synthesis, as well as a direct degradation of fibrin and fibrinogen."

    On the pharmacology of bromelain

  • joker247

    4/5/2009 6:34:00 PM |

    just a comment on surviving stomach acid - I have UC, so I don't take blood thinners (if I started bleeding internally, where would you put the tourniquet?)
    However I do take an anti-inflammatory called ASACOL which has a polymeric coating that only dissolves in an alkaline environment so that the active ingredient gets where it needs to go, the colon. Unless this coating process is patented, it seems that it IS possible to have an active ingredient survive stomach acid. I'm not one to jump on the bandwagon of sensationalized products - as a former chemist I have a bit of wisdom in that regard - but if you really want to get something past the upper digestive tract it seems quite possible.

  • Anonymous

    4/8/2009 6:20:00 PM |

    My opinion is its all about the money  If you are protecting the Drug Companies,than only 3 people know about it. You,.the Drug Companies, and GOD. Every drug made has killed more people than it has cured. Eternity is a very long time I wish you the best

  • Anonymous

    4/14/2009 4:25:00 PM |

    April 14, 2009 Tues. I am 80 year of age, I have been eating fresh made Natto every day for the past 6 years.  My neuclear stress test has shown that I have a 52% blood flow thru my left ventricle of my heart, which I have been told by my doctor is very exceptional and good. Blood pressure rarely above 120/80 Natto is good for you, eat it.  These scientific guys are wrong quite often????

  • Anonymous

    5/3/2009 7:31:00 AM |

    I spent 25 years in medicine. I used to be somewhat close-minded or skeptical to some things so far as natural supplements were concerned.

    I feel that Dr. Davis is obviously close minded and speaks more like someone who is backed by Big Pharma.

    Dr. Davis -- There IS research out there and proven studies advocating the use and effectiveness of nattokinase. You just do not want to hear it for whatever reason.

    Here is a brief article written by pharmacist Dave Foreman who is an RPh, ND and well known author, lecturer and radio host:

    "In 1980, Doctor Hiroyuki Sumi was in the middle of searching for a natural agent that had thrombolytic effects (able to break up blood clots). The enzyme he was looking for would be able to dissolve the clots associated with heart attacks and stroke. After testing over 100 natural foods as potential clot busters, Dr Sumi accidentally found what he was looking for when Natto was dropped onto artificial thrombus (fibrin) in a Petri dish. The thrombus around the Natto dissolved gradually and had completely dissolved within 18 hours. Dr Sumi named the newly discovered enzyme "nattokinase", which means "enzyme in natto".

    To understand the importance of this discovery, let's go back to biology class for a second. Blood clots form when strands of protein called fibrin accumulate in a blood vessel. In the heart, blood clots cause blockage of blood flow to muscle tissue. If blood flow is blocked, the oxygen supply to that tissue is cut off and it eventually dies. This can result in angina and heart attacks. Clots in chambers of the heart can mobilize to the brain. In the brain, blood clots also block blood and oxygen from reaching necessary areas, which can result in senility and/or stroke.

    For many, Nattokinase may be the biggest discovery for natural approaches to cardiovascular health. But what is Nattokinase? Nattokinase is a potent fibrinolytic (breaks down fibrin) enzyme extracted and purified from a traditional Japanese food called Natto. Natto is a cheese-like food and is produced by a specific fermentation process of soybeans. Natto has been used in Japan for over 1,000 years for cardiovascular support and to lower blood pressure. Natto is the only preparation that contains the remarkable nattokinase enzyme with fibrin-dissolving properties.

    Why is Nattokinase so important? The enzyme is capable of breaking down and dissolving blood clots formed in a vessel or heart chamber and can enhance the body's natural ability to fight clotting of the blood. Unlike the class of medications called antithrombin, Nattokinase produces a prolonged action (lasting from 8 - 12 hours) in preventing coagulation of blood and dissolving existing clots.

    As a pharmacist and ND, I think that this discovery is and should be considered a major discovery for those concerned with cardiovascular health issues and general overall health. I come from a family history of cardiovascular disease and have started using Nattokinase personally to help prevent circulatory episodes in the future.

    Beyond the more obvious uses mentioned above, Nattokinase has shown to provide other health benefits. Here is a small list of some of the other potential health benefits of Nattokinase:

    Hemorrhoids and varicose veins
    Diabetes (caused by pancreatic dysfunction)
    Senile dementia
    Fibromyalgia
    Muscle spasms
    Poor healing
    Chronic inflammation

    I believe in using Nattokinase in combination with other enzymes. I believe in using balance and enzymes are no exception to this philosophy. Enzymes support many different facets of health and in this case, Nattokinase is the one to use for cardiovascular health. Regretfully, for those of us who are healthy, it is hard to notice any changes, but with the science behind Nattokinase, you can get piece of mind knowing that you are doing something proactive to help your cardiovascular health.

    Nattokinase is extremely important for circulation and circulatory disorders. If you look at the physiology of the body and understand how Nattokinase works, you can easily understand why this may be a supplement that even the healthiest of people would want to use.

    Finally, the one concern many natural health enthusiasts have is about safety. When looking for a quality Nattokinase, you need to look for one with the vitamin K removed. Natto contains the highest concentration of Vitamin K known in food. Significant amounts of Vitamin K2 are produced during the fermentation process of Nattokinase. By removing most or all of the Vitamin K2 you will eliminate any potential adverse drug interactions with warfarin (Coumadin), a Vitamin K antagonist pharmacological agent typically used an anticoagulant."

    I seriously hope that Dr. Davis will drop the attitude towards nattokinase and open his mind to the PROOF that IS out there supporting the use and  effectiveness of nattokinase.

    Making false statements such as calling nattokinase "a scam" makes people even more leery of doctors in this day and age. Rightfully so.

    Big Pharma has so many Dr's. blinded (or in their hip pockets) in this day and age and I feel that this may also be the case with Dr. Davis.

    I too made mistakes in putting too much faith in alopathic medicine and my own training. That all changed when I developed many significant health issues and was at one time on a dozen different prescription meds daily.

    No longer. I take natural supplements and my health is greatly improved. I'm on only 2 or 3 medications per day. Modern pharmaceutical agents almost cost me my life!

    Let's wake up people. Prescription medications and ignorance are the real killers!

  • Anonymous

    5/3/2009 7:39:00 AM |

    Dr. Davis - I encourage you to do some research on Dr. Stephen Sinatra. He is a board certified Cardiologist and nationally known speaker and best selling author.

    Dr. Sinatra advocates the use of Nattokinase and has switched many of his patients to taking it as opposed to harmful pharmaceuticals.

    Yes, there is the need for coumadin in some cases - but Dr. Sinatra has wondeful success with patients taking nattokinase!

    You owe it to yourself to check out Dr. Sinatra and what he has to say about Natto. There are enough documented studies that promote the safety and effectiveness of nattokinase.

    I hope you too will come to the realization that Nattokinase is not a scam and does in fact work!

  • Anonymous

    5/5/2009 12:10:00 AM |

    I have fibroids and a cyst on my only ovary-I have never had children and I want to. Can Nattokinase help me? What affect will 100 mg 2000 FU do for me or to me? I want real help because I am running out of options that will keep my fertility intact and rid some of these fibroids so they don't take over my uterus. PLEASE HELP!

  • Anonymous

    5/7/2009 5:04:00 PM |

    Anyone wondering if nattokinase can survive the gut and enter the bloodstream has only to search PubMed. Dr. Davis is incorrect in his assertion that nattokinase is rendered ineffective by transit through the gut. There are interesting studies suggesting that nattokinase can lower blood pressure and inhibit restenosis after angioplasty.

  • Anonymous

    5/21/2009 9:40:29 PM |

    Does anyone know, if when taking Nattokinase, a person can remain active in contact sports or does it thin the blood too much?

  • KRyan

    5/22/2009 5:12:44 PM |

    If your worried about stomach acid destroying nattokinase or any other acid sensitive supplement, just make sure your stomach acid is low. Take them on an empty stomach when there is no need for stomach acid. Take them with water to dilute the acid. I think you'll be surprised at how high the ph will go just from the water alone. (I wonder if people drink to many fluids with their meals and it hinders digestion or puts stress on the body to produce greater loads of acid) More info on stomach acid and reactions with food, supplements,enzymes etc http://www.care2.com/news/member/956805373/322081

  • terraoutwest

    5/28/2009 10:25:06 PM |

    Factor Five Leiden is my main problem, not the usual plaque and cholesterol type issues with blood clots. I recently had a minor heart attack where the blood clot developed in the heart itself (they think) and now I'm on warfarin 5mg. I'm an athlete and although I don't intend to "hurt myself, (who does?)the opportunity for bumps, bruises and scrapes is there. I really don't like the other side effects of warfarin either. I would really like to get away from the pharmaceuticals and on to something more natural with less (or no) side effects. Surely there is some other way to manage Factor Five patients who are otherwise quite healthy. And... I miss my leafy greens!  Any research out there on management of Factor Five without Coumadin?

  • Carla B

    6/4/2009 4:52:48 AM |

    To the person who posted anonymously on december 9, 2008. I am desperately looking for a natural way to treat my escalating thrombocytosis. Would love to talk to your friend. If you're still tuned into this post, please reach me at purpledots at pacbell dott net. I would be forever grateful.

  • Anonymous

    6/4/2009 5:18:50 AM |

    To the anonymous person who left the comment on December 9, 2008 with the friend who's thrombocytosis was improved with nattokinase: I'm desperately trying to find something natural to treat mine. If you're still tuned in to this post, please drop me a line at purpledots at pacbell dott net. I would be forever grateful.

  • Anonymous

    6/10/2009 2:39:19 PM |

    I have various fibroids - the biggest is the size of a canteloupe - or was - since taking Natto for 2 weeks - it is shrunk. I cannot say that it was the Natto for sure, but I changed nothing else.  

    Natto was easier for me to find that Nattokinase.  I have heard that Natto is not popular amongst Westerners but I have no problem with it.

    If it helps those willing to try - its texture is like a tin of baked beans mixed into a tablespoon of a beaten egg. While at the Asian supermarket - where I bought the Natto in the chilled storage section - I also bought a bottle of Chili Soy Sauce (from the Chinese section) and the Chili Soy Sauce is yummy with the Natto.  But then I do like Chili Soy Sauce.  Its worth trying. The Natto that is - add a sauce flavor you like, if it makes it more palatable to you.  The real Natto is way cheaper than the supplement, and in my view it is the supplement manufacturer's that are putting us off eating the cheaper, natural Natto by saying things like it is disgusting - but then some people don't like beaten egg.  PS there are many different types of Natto and I am working my way through.  I can't read Japanese - so all I can tell you is so far I like the ones in the Green wrapper and also the ones in the yellow wrapper.  They are stacked as three small trays each and I eat half a tray every 2 days.

  • Anonymous

    6/14/2009 4:33:21 PM |

    My father had a DVT 2 years ago.  He was started on heparin and then switched to coumadin and had complete resolution of his clots.  He didn't like the idea of being on warfarin for the rest of his life and switched to natto instead.  He had not been feeling well over the course of the past 3 weeks but didn't want to see his doctor until he collapsed at home and was rushed to the ED via ambulance.  He had numerous pumlmonary emboli as well as large clots in his pulmonary artery and the veins of both legs.  The doctors told him that he had probably been throwing clots for weeks if not months.  He is set to be released today and is already talking about when he can get off the warfarin and back on the natto.  I think this is clearly a failure of the natto to prevent and/or treat the clots.  I do not know if the warfarin would have prevented them or not, but due to the number of clots in multiple vessels I am pushing for him to continue the warfarin.  Warfarin certainly has side effects but it is the gold standard for preventing blood clots.  Unless there is a study natto is superior to warfarin then I wouldn't recommend using it.  BTW he had been taking natto for several years prior to his first DVT, so it didn't prevent that one either.

  • terraoutwest

    6/15/2009 2:46:58 PM |

    What about the earthworm based lumbrokinase? Anyone out there tried this?

    It sounds more disgusting than Natto, but I believe there have been more/better studies on it and has accepted as a better alternative (at least) by the Naturopathic doctors.

  • Anonymous

    7/6/2009 2:15:22 AM |

    Anonymous, June 14, 2009 :

    What brand name of Nattokinase did your father take? Be assured there are REPUTABLE brands out there, but also MANY FAKES!

    Just because a brand is cheap does not mean it is reputable. Many of the fakes out there claim to be reputable, and even provide you with a 'certificate', but in reality they have no active ingredients!

    A reputable brand would be (as an example) Allergy Research.

  • Anonymous

    7/6/2009 2:22:54 AM |

    terraoutwest  May 28, 2009

    Nattokinase might just be your ticket. It has virtually no side effect;, the 'real' stuff has no vitamin K in it, so it can be used with warfarin, but if you do it w/o warfarin, then you can eat and drink whatever you want to and however much you want to. The only thing you should not do is to take nattokinase together with other enzymes. Wait a couple hours between each.
    I have factor v leiden, and am on nattokinase since about eight years now. No clots.
    Cannot overdose on it either. Make sure you get a reputable brand.

  • Anonymous

    7/11/2009 4:00:19 AM |

    RE:"Everyone seems to be missing the most important argument against the effectiveness of nattokinase: it is a protein enzyme, and there is not a single protein in this universe that can be taken up by our GI tract in its whole and active form."

    Never say never, or should I regret having just violated that rule by saying never.

    Prions are a class of proteins that modify other proteins.  If taken orally, it will cause illness like mad cow disease.  It is believed that the prion modifies other proteins in the brain in a cascading fashion, eventually causing total cns dysfunction by converting increasing number of proteins into more prions.

    My point, saying all proteins can not survive low pH in the stomach is too broad of a statement to make.  I am afraid modern sciences is not yet able to explain all events that can take place in the body.

    Saying one should be skeptical of nattokinase is justifiable, but declaring nattokinase to be a scam is a claim that calls for more evidence, in my opinion.

    If I witness first hand cases in which natto proves to be effective, I will then become skeptical of the claim that nattokinase is a scam.

    I hope the same will be true for Dr. Davis.

  • Anonymous

    7/19/2009 11:49:43 PM |

    Nearly a year ago I could barely function due to endometriosis. I was working from home only a few hours a week because the pain was so bad. I just wanted to lay around and have someone put me out of my misery.

    I then began purchasing Fibrovan which has nattokinase in it. It didn't take long before I started noticing positive results. Little by little I started improving. The pain began lessening. My blood pressure improved.My energy improved. I was able to go for long walks and I'm back working full time outside the home, doing a very physically demanding job working in a hospital.

    A scam is something that is  fraudulent or deceptive. I in no way feel like I have been scammed. My health has improved and for that I am thankful.

  • citizen alan

    7/20/2009 5:08:10 PM |

    I think the work of Linus Pauling definitely indicates that EVERYONE on ANY sort of anti-coagulant should be supplementing with Vitamin C. My dad was taking aspirin (as a preventative) without letting me know and wound up with blood collecting in his eyes.  Permanently half-blind, a condition that I believe would have been totally avoidable had he also supplemented with at least 500 mg/day of Vitamin C.

  • Anonymous

    7/24/2009 6:30:18 PM |

    My husband and I eat natto, and while not Japanese, I have come to like it. We buy several packs and freeze them.

    We think natto tastes good with chopped green onions or chives, and/or some grated daikon radish, along with a bit of soy sauce.

    Sometimes we also mix natto with a bit of soy sauce, a very small amount of grated ginger, finely shredded radish leaves (leaves of the familiar small, red-skinned-white-inside radishes), and some of the dried fish flakes called "katsuobushi," which is available in small packets at Japanese food stores.

    If you eat natto along with rice, it will probably be easier to get down.

  • Anonymous

    8/5/2009 10:33:31 PM |

    Dr. Davis,

    I don't know if you are right or not on this matter.  If the stomach destroys Nattokinase, how then is there any effect, good or bad?  My wife has fibrosis in her bone marrow and we just discovered today that this substance may stop or reverse this activity.  The alternative is a steady downgrade and finally death.  I am concerned that she is on a baby aspirin along with her chemo as that might not be a good thing to take with this; we will be seeing the oncologist next week again and ask.  

    In any case, I appreciate your attempt to warn, and hope that whoever does not agree would be kind in their remarks and suggestions.  Thank you.

  • Anonymous

    8/12/2009 8:01:50 PM |

    My experience is only anecdotal. After going through a triple by-pass I was put on Plavix, aspirin, etc.  I din't experience the blotches (internal bleeding) that a co-worker who had a stent put in did.  

    But when I added NK about 5 months in I did experience them and consequently cut the Plavix rather than the NK.

    That was a couple years ago and still continue the NK. Wouldn't mind trying the Natto though I would have to go up to Tucson to get it.

    So it could have been just a coincidence but as an engineer I don't really believe in them or half the crap the medical community tries to foist off as fact.  No offense, Doc.  Smile

  • lmontgom

    8/19/2009 8:51:51 PM |

    Dr. Davis:
    Why have you been silent on nattokinase for so long?  I continue to derive great benefit from it.  I would not be walking today because of muscle weakness and pain were it not for nattokinase, which I buy from vitacost.com.

  • Anonymous

    9/8/2009 6:58:32 PM |

    VERY TELLING how Dr. Davis has disappeared, stopped replying when confronted with the double-blind studies that show he's wrong.

    I'm disappointed.  I was considering signing up for the Track Your Plaque program, but forget it.

    This guy has shown that if he's not selling it, he's not buying it either.

  • Fran

    9/22/2009 4:13:25 AM |

    I searched your blog for "serrapeptase", another supplement that claims to be a natural Chelation-Anti-Inflammatory. From serrapeptase info website: "Serrapeptase digests non-living tissue, blood clots, cysts, and arterial plaque and inflammation in all forms." Have you written any blogs about this product?

  • Anonymous

    9/26/2009 3:24:59 PM |

    lmontgom said...
    Dr. Davis:
    Why have you been silent on nattokinase for so long? I continue to derive great benefit from it. I would not be walking today because of muscle weakness and pain were it not for nattokinase, which I buy from vitacost.com

    Please tell me what brand name you bought, I want to be sure to get one that someone has experienced success with! i have always experienced heavy bleeding during menstration but 2 yrs ago it got worse, now I have been bleeding for 3 weeks VERY heavy, hemoglobin down (will need blood transfusion soon), i have fibroids and i have an ultra sound scheduled to see if the fibroids have increased in size, but the treatments that my dr has suggested are ablation or hysterectomy (have 2 children and although I don't currently want any more, not sure if i am ready to close that door, still in my 30s).  I've spoke to many women who have experienced this and am just appalled that some dr's i have seen sit so nonchalant while i explain what is happening as if flowing quarts of blood out of you is completly acceptable!!  Although I have read reviews where nattokinase has not worked for some people, I have not read any reviews where people have experienced negative side effects.  I will try nattokinase and post again, but again, what brand do you buy, I want a reputable brand?

  • Anonymous

    9/28/2009 3:54:08 PM |

    I am interested in NK. This forum has been on for over two years initiated by valid criticisms from Dr. Davis. The respondents are all intelligently fluid in their arguments. There is one thing missing.

    Dr. Davies mentioned side affects of good blood clots dissolving. I imagine anyone with these symptoms would be very miserable or dead and the diagnosis of cause very, very difficult. Of the previous respondents how many have suffered these symptoms? How would we ever know? Could everyone who is PRO NK assign a close relative to update this forum if something happens?

  • Anonymous

    10/1/2009 5:03:44 AM |

    As a mother of 3 adult sons, I have a dilemma! My youngest son (25 yrs) was recently diagnosed with a DVT in his leg. While my oldest son (today 34 yrs) had a blood cloth in his brain 6 yrs ago. Doctors then declared to be a "very rare" case and not to worry that it would happen again. Last Sept, he developed a DVT in his leg. He is now on Coumadin for life.

    I had contacted a Naturopath earlier (Feb 09) who told me that he has helped many patients with similar conditions with Nattokinase.
    As my boys are very young in age (tests do not show genes as both parents have no problems) I would really appreciate some feedback.

  • Tom

    10/19/2009 5:46:32 AM |

    To many people with so little grasp of basic physiology.

    1. Proteins are denatured in the stomach, not degraded. Degradation occurs in the small intestine and can not be avoided because this is also the purported  site of absorbtion.

    2. Intact proteins can not be absorbed. If intact proteins could be absorbed, pretty much all food would be 100% fatal.

    3. If Nattokinase did even half of what is claimed, Dr. Davis is quite right, it would kill you.


    I think most of the miracle cures being claimed by other commentors are either placebo, or missattributed. (I might point out that, in most cases described, the symptoms alleviated could have resulted from a severe vitamin K deficiency, and might be alleviated by the fact that these crude isolates of natto CONTAIN VITAMIN K)




    Nattokinase is produced and market heavily by the same guys who sell you trypsin and chymotrypsin pills in the form of wobenzyme with the claim that those enzymes are able to have a systemic effect.  Clearly the naturally occurring enzyme trypsin (which functions to lyse proteins in the small intestine) could not possibly leave the small intestine without killing you.


    I had a dog once that had a intestinal defect that did allow intact proteins be absorbed from its intestine. Obviously this dog didn't live very long. Think massive fluid imbalances and kidney failure.

  • Dr. William Davis

    10/19/2009 10:04:18 PM |

    Hi, Tom--

    Excellent points.

    The fanaticism that surrounds this absurd approach continues to astound.

  • Anonymous

    10/20/2009 10:52:51 PM |

    From one who has taken nattokinase for a couple of years I find your comments while logically consistent - wrong.

    Nattokinase blew out my arteriosclerosis as evidenced by the elasticity of my blood vessels, reduced my BP. and appears to have cleared out my blood debris. It doesn't replace fish oil, so I will take both - intemittently.

  • Anonymous

    10/22/2009 2:51:32 PM |

    So, how do you research the companies, marketing Nattokinase, to know if the ingredients are real or not?

  • Anonymous

    10/26/2009 1:02:17 AM |

    There is research the supports the concept that the human GI tract can absorb intact proteins:

    http://ajpgi.physiology.org/cgi/content/abstract/273/1/G139

    http://arjournals.annualreviews.org/doi/abs/10.1146%2Fannurev.nu.08.070188.001553

  • Tom

    10/26/2009 6:06:40 AM |

    That first link is only pseudo science done on a small scale by scientific guns for hire, (note that the institute La Fey specializing in being contracted by private R&D entities, and also observe that each author has published about 1 dubious article in just about every field).

    The second only involves trace absorption of 2-3 residue peptides, with some exceptions due to the role of erythrocytes as antigen presenting cells.  It is possible that this mechanism would allow an ingested peptide to be presented intact or in fragments to the immune system with immunomodulating effects(as is clearly the case with certain foodborne allergies and conditions). It is possible that these enzyme products might produce a beneficial effect through that or other unknown mechanisms, but the makers of these products do not make that claim, perhaps due to its complexity. Rather, they invariably make simple, easily marketed claims.


    But that is besides the point,
    those who market and promote Nattokinase and other "enzyme" healing products deceptively make claims that are unsupported, contradictory, and physiologically unfeasible.   One should always be wary of any product, natural or otherwise that makes broad unsupported claims as to how and what it does.

  • lmontgom

    10/26/2009 7:15:16 PM |

    Everyone -- users, researchers, docs -- should remember that each human body is unique.  For those of us who have used nattokinase and say it works (meaning it stops the pain, in my case), who are you to say that we should discontinue it?  I will order natto itself just to be sure nothing has happened in the processing of nattokinase that changes its impact in the body.  Until then, I will use what works for me and trust that Dr. Davis and the rest of the nay-sayers would do the same.

  • Anonymous

    10/29/2009 5:30:58 PM |

    Dear Doc -
    if NK is a scam like you say, then how can it be dangerous?  since a scam is afterall a fake.    yet you say the people who eat the food get some kind of benefit and no ill effects?    

    this does not make any sense.

  • Anonymous

    10/29/2009 11:14:55 PM |

    Not sure what you mean by "pseudoscience" in terms of bromelain absorption (the protein in question my posting of 10/25).  

    This would no doubt come as a surprise to Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, who states:  "Orally administered bromelain is absorbed intact through the intestine. Because of its proteolytic activity, about 50% of bromelain is rapidly complexed with an antiproteinase, namely alpha-2-macroglobulin (AMG). Proteolytic activity is maintained within this protective molecule, but reduced. In a recent human study, plasma half-life was determined to be 6-9 hours. Orally administered bromelain is absorbed at a rate of 40% in animal studies."

    I would also remind you that cyclosporine is an 11 polypeptide molecule that is administered orally.


    Thrombolysis is a natural occuring event.  All blood clots secrete thrombolysins. The question is now much, how its mediated, etc.  It's like saying no one should take Coumadin or Lovenox, because they would all become hemophiliacs and bleed to death.

    I would agree that the story on nattokinase is not complete.  But calling it a "scam" is merely the obverse of calling it a "miracle drug."

  • Tom

    10/30/2009 4:09:16 AM |

    Seriously? You refute me refuting your paper by citing a source which cites the same fake research paper? It is pseudoscience because all the names associated with the paper are people are hired to write whatever paper/conclusion you want. BTW, the paper only goes so far as to say that over a 48 hour period 10.8 micrograms were in the ENTIRE plasma. May I offer you a book titled "How To Lie With Statistics"?


    For a much more in depth study of bromelian absorption look for a 1971 study published in the Japanese Journal of Pharmacology titled Gastrointestinal Absorption And Anti Inflammatory Effect of Bromelian. That study was done in dogs, but they found the half life of intravenous bromelian was only about one hour. They also found that less than .052% of a intraduodenal dose of labeled bromelian was absorbed "intact" based on the assumption that radioactive proteins of similar mass and isoelectric point found in the plasma were in fact bromelian. Their immunological assays detected that the actual amount of bromelian was MUCH less.  The absorption you quote, 40%, is absurd.

    Also, cyclosporine is only 11 residues long, cyclic, and composed of D-amino acids not normally encountered in nature.  11 is much smaller than 275 for nattokinase.  Yes some proteins can be absorbed, like botulin toxin (on a nanogram scale), but not the huge amounts claimed by the natto guys.

  • Anonymous

    11/4/2009 1:24:26 PM |

    Why would someone buy supplements? The whole supplement industry kinda' confuses me over all. Nattou is delicious... just eat nattou. There are lots of foods that have vitamins and nutritional value that you can receive if you just eat a varied diet. As long as you're eating a variety of healthy foods, taking supplements is a big fat waste of money!

  • Chris33780

    11/11/2009 9:29:45 AM |

    Dr Davis said: "The data I've looked at re: nattokinase has been proprietary, generated clearly by a manufacturer. Until some real science emerges, even modest, to support this otherwise counterintuitive strategy, it remains something that has no value for our plaque reducing focus."

    Why would the FDA bother with producing real science on something they cannot patent and gain a return on their investment? I am not going to fall for criticism of the effectiveness of a substance just because money cannot be made by the FDA. The people I hear putting nattokinase down want proof by FDA approval, and this would only happen if it could be patentable, which a natural substance cannot be.

  • Dr. William Davis

    11/11/2009 1:07:21 PM |

    Earth to Chris:

    The FDA does NOT generate data to support or refute any drug or supplement. They are only a regulating agency.

  • Anonymous

    11/22/2009 2:39:06 AM |

    I am just starting to look into this issue having recently been diagnosed with a DVT.

    I appreciate that Dr. Davis has taken the time to explain why he refutes certain natto claims.  I am squarely in the camp of proof via empirical evidence; even more so when people stand to profit from a mere suggestion that something benefits you in a particular way.

  • Anonymous

    12/1/2009 4:48:30 AM |

    Here's the problem with blasting nattokinase based on stomach acid acidity or fear of indiscriminate breakdown of "good" clots as an unwanted side effect: this kind of Western, Descartian thinking when applied to the complex human body so often proves to be simply wrong. There are studies that show vitamin B2 promotes cancer growth, for example, but others that show increased vitamin C counteracts that effect. Perhaps the Japanese who ingest more nattokinase and have fewer fractures benefit from it in ways that are similar to users of whole herbs who do better than those who use just the "active ingredient" isolated from the same herbs. "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio..." I eat Natto miso and LOVE it. It tastes great in soup or rice and veggies. I've gone out of my way to find it via internet/mail order after our co-op stopped carrying it. I feel great after I eat it. I also tried buying a bottle of nattokinase and found that my trigeminal neuralgia gets worse after taking it, or seems to. I've only tried it a very few times so perhaps it was coincidental. (When you have something this painful you don't play around with trying things that seem to make it worse.) I also notice bromelain makes it worse, and from what I've read that, too, is fibrinolytic, right? And that one has a lot of research showing it somehow survives the stomach acid, doesn't it? I'm going from memory of quickly scanned articles, there, so may be all wrong. A final thought: I've heard that vegans have substantially less stomach acid than meat eaters. Have there been any studies on this? My intuition is there is probably something to this, and the difference may be quite significant. My wife and I often think our desire for sugar after protein is out of a need to generate more acid than we tend to produce normally. Just some thoughts to encourage a less "know-it-all" attitude so common among doctors trained in the USA and other Western cultures. I almost think sometimes it is a personality trait that is a prerequisite for getting through Med schools here, having a mind that quickly closes.

  • Trey

    12/5/2009 7:41:22 PM |

    Dr. Davis...isn't it true that you as a physician are bound by the laws of the medical community and face a severe fine or possibly loss of license for recommending anything out of conventional treatment? The same treatments such as the same thing we have done tirelessly for years for cancer treatment (Chemotherapy) amd that also as a doctor going through medical school Doctors are taught very little about nutrition?

  • Anonymous

    12/14/2009 10:08:31 PM |

    Could the proliferation of various electromagnetic-radiation-producing technologies within the last century (electricity/electrical power lines, radio, radar, cell phone and wifi towers and antennas) be the underlying mechanism behind the increased risk of heart attacks and strokes in industrialized nations, more so than diet?

    I ask because I've read several articles which seem to indicate that calcium metabolism is affected by these exposures to electromagnetic/radiofreqency/microwave radiation. Specifically, calcium's 'efflux' - its movement into and out of cells - is affected by these exposures.

    http://electromagnetichealth.org/electromagnetic-health-blog/the-cell-phone-and-the-role-of-calcium/

  • ron

    12/30/2009 2:49:14 PM |

    I have had two heart attacks, the last one after a quintuple bypass. Unfortunately, no tests are done as to the bodies rejection factor of sutures used in bypass surgery, resulting in two of the bypass grafts failing (disintegrating) and the remaining grafts heavily crusted by the bodies rejection mechanisms. I am still strong and active, plavix and aspirin daily with BP meds. During a recent angiogram, the Dr. tore the saphenous vein graft to my rt. cor. art. causing a large thrombus. Hence the present meds. Anyone used NK in this instance.
    I know it sounds scary, but I have no chest pain, exercise daily BP 120/60 HR 60. Any other input would be appreciated.
    Ron

  • Anonymous

    12/30/2009 6:42:47 PM |

    The real scam is American medicine that has for years led people to believe it is about "health" and "care".  In reality, it is about money.  Follow the money, you'll always find the answer.  Big Pharma is big business, plain and simple.  Most doctors don't give a hoot about their patients.  With Big Pharma rewarding doctors for prescribing their drugs, doctors have lost credibility in favor of montary persuasion.  It's no longer what's best for the patient, but what profits the practitioner.

  • Anonymous

    1/4/2010 2:09:54 AM |

    Dr. Davis, by not publishing one's comments you likely think nattokinase will lose credibility.  Regardless of what Big Pharma-rewarded MDs think in this country, nattokinase works.  However, I understand the tenacles of Big Pharma reach far and wide and why you would be afraid to publish my comment clearly showing NK worked.  U.S. medicine is gravely lacking in many ways.  I dare you to publish my prior comment regarding how four (count 'em 4) MDs couldn't diagnose the obvious >2 ft. clot in my left leg despite my emphatically telling them it was a clot.  Indeed and in fact, many practitioners have egos that arrive 20 minutes before they do!  I suppose you think the American people should have confidence in a system controlled by drug companies.  You have immensely increased my respect for the Japanese where research is not sponsored by Big Pharma.  Instead of criticizing the Japanese and Nattokinase, perhaps you should start emulating!!

  • Holly

    1/10/2010 4:24:46 AM |

    I am a patient who has antiphospholipid syndrome.  I also have low factor VIII levels. Before this was diagnosed, in 2008, I suffered over 5 strokes (only 1 left me with some small permanent damage, luckily) and countless tia's (am in my 50's and there was no other medical reason for me to be having stroke/tia).
    Because of the low factor VIII levels, my hematologist explained I was not a candidate for warfarin, however we tried heparin injections for 4 months.  My body could not tolerate them, it was explained to me that there was nothing which could be done for me.  (yes, I did have a second opinion).  
    Several months later I was introduced to nattokinase at Allergy Research Group.  After much research, started taking 400 mg. daily, divided.  This was 2 years ago.  Since that time I have had one tia.  My hematologist is familiar with nattokinase, but will not support it, so I have had to leave her.  However I am working with my internist who does support it and gives me the proper blood tests; everything is in order.
    Allergy Research Group addresses the question of stomach acid you bring up; they have printed much with the limited research which has been able to be done.  Before closing your book completely on this subject, perhaps you might look a bit further - many people are being helped by this where no other help is available.  
    Natto is not a scam.  It IS important to get quality product and there ARE inferior products out there.  It is always vital to study carefully when one is venturing into any alternative health remedy and remember that someone is ready to take your money all too easily.  It is just as vital to remember that western medicine, as marvelous as it is, does not have all the answers.  All too often doctors can be very closed minded without doing proper research.

  • Anonymous

    1/29/2010 3:39:51 AM |

    A very interesting thread for sure.

    I had Massive PE last year.  It stemmed from walking pneumonia (treated as adult onset asthma)
    PE never showed up on scans as no contrast was used.  
    They even did a heart cath on me while I had massive PE and could hardly breath (they thought I was nervous)  Major Pulmonary HTN and Massive PE found a week later at a University clinic via spiral CT.
    I could not walk 10 feet, they just said "You out of shape" hehe I'm 40 and play singles comp. tennis.  

    I did have very high CRP >10 and high D-dimer but they failed to connect the dots.  

    Anyway after IV abs, heparin then later coumadin (I declined surgery
    ) My CRP went down to near normal levels.   My clots were thought to be from chronic infection and resulting inflammation.

    I don't take natto (yet) but there seems to be quite a bit of anecdotal and some scientific evidence (Airline study)

    The problem I see is
    1. How does it interact with ASA?
    2. How does it interact with warfarin?
    3. How much is enough?
    4. How often?

    I agree with the good Dr. Davis on most of the points.  But its very difficult to call anything "Snake Oil" without knowing the true mechanism of action.  

    There are many medications that have been studied and are currently being prescribed in which the mechanism of actions is "unknown".  The studies show that it had a repeatable effect and that it improved the condition being tested for but the "how it works" is not known.  These are not snake oil because we do not know how it works.  Its because they have been found to show a positive response above what is found with placebo.


    There is enough anecdotal evidence on Natto for scientific studies to be done.  This is how many drugs are finally tested.  Where do you think we got antibiotics?  People have been taking natural things way before we had science.  Many of these have been tested.

    Natto is one that has not been.

    I would love to see some real studies on it.  

    A more interesting question is not if it is or not is snake oil but why has this not been studied?

    The assumption of its destruction in the stomach implies that one knows its mechanism.  After studies are done we will know.  It may be it works but in a totally different way than DR. Davis envisioned.  

    So I am not sure why he is so quick to label it as a scam when he simply does not have enough information to say one way or another.

    It may be true that the drug companies can't make a profit on it but why can't some of these well to do Vitamin companies fund the research?  The money has to come from somewhere.  I don't expect big pharm to foot the bill but someone should.

    From what evidence is available it all points to something more than a placebo effect.  Animal studies and one human study point to something real happening.
    I have yet to read any studies stating that there is no effect.

    Without seeing studies to the contrary I think Dr. Davis is just using his intuition.  Not saying his educated guess is wrong just saying its just a guess with some holes in it.

  • Anonymous

    1/31/2010 3:59:26 AM |

    I've had many a spirited discussion with MDs and PhDs about whether enzymes taken orally can go systemic.  All I can say is that there are a lot of MDs and PhDs who believe that enzymes cannot and do not go systemic.  HOWEVER, there are other MDs and PhDs who vehemently disagree and there are studies from reputable investigators that support the belief that enzymes can enter the blood stream intact or at least in some fashion where they can can be proteolytic or fibrolytic.  

    So, it's easy to stop all argument about the efficacy of an enzyme like nattokinase if you believe it can't work because it can't get into the blood.  I mean, honestly, there is nothing left to discuss, right?  And that seems to be Dr. Davis's basic position and Dr. Davis is clearly with the majority of doctors who hold this position.  

    However, if you accept the possibility that some enzymes CAN enter the blood stream, then you must then discuss what they might accomplish, for good or for bad, while in the blood.  And that leads to a discussion of WHICH enzymes might work best, and WHAT they might accomplish, and WHAT dosages work . . . a whole host of follow on questions that, presently, have few answers.

    That leaves all of us who'd like to know real answers sort of in the dark.  We are left with anecdotal testimonials, some who had good experiences and some who had adverse reactions.  That still doesn't give intellectual warm fuzzies.  However, if does suggest that if something MIGHT work and has few contraindications, that one might want to give it a try.

    As Dr. Davis clearly knows, logic is not controlling in science.  Science is complete with theories that are logically sound and later completely discredited as simply wrong despite the logic.  

    Logically, one has to allow that enzymes may be able to enter the blood system and may have curative effects -- until the theory is totally discredited -- even if you don't really know how it works.

  • stevensgarethb

    2/8/2010 11:57:22 PM |

    300 years ago if you were ill you would go to the local barbers where they would take some blood with an unclean instrument and infect you with a nasty disease. They would then send you home with some medication which did not work and was highly dangerous causing other medical conditions to arise. It is different today. Now the only thing that has changed is that you go to a nice new hospital to get infected and given medication that is dangerous and does not work and causes other medical conditionsSmile

    I am taking Neprinol which contains Nattokinase and Serrapeptase and it worked within several hours taken orally. I  use Neprinol as a replacement for Fragmin which I had already been taking for 6 months.  The alternative would have been Coumadin (Warfarin). It is all very well knocking Nattokinase but what alternative is there?
    I tried to stop taking fragmin but within half a day my symptoms came back.  Since taking Neprinol my symptoms have not returned and I am  experiencing no side effects apart from increased energy. I am cycling uphill 8 gears higher than before and not getting tired. Previously I had been admitted to hospital 5 times with chest pain, the first time I had an MI and the other times were at a different hospital who did not have a clue.  I did not appreciate being given a drug which made my condition worse.  I am from a highly technical background and could tell that the cardiac department had no expertise in understanding how the body works. It is obvious to me that medical staff are "non technical" so they can never work out what is wrong with someone.
    I decided to self diagnose and self prescribe and that was the best decision I ever made. I understand my condition now and how to treat it which is great.  I have also discovered a rare genetic link in my family and hope to connect with a University who are researching this subject.  I hope to start golf again when the weather improves and cycle along some mountain routes to improve my fitness.


    If doctors were paid by results... we would save an awful lot of money!

  • Anonymous

    2/18/2010 10:40:33 PM |

    I had a documented >2 foot long blood clot.  There is no denying the existence of this clot.  (THERE IS ALSO NO DENYING THE RESOLUTION OF THIS CLOT BY CURRENT ULTRASOUND!)  I went on one week of Lovenox and had serial ultrasounds on my left leg for  months.  The clot remained.  I started Nattokinase 15,000 FUs per capsule (4x/day).  Eighteen months later when another ultrasound was done, I was called back to the facility because they thought they had done the wrong leg or the test was done incorrectly by the tech.  Why?  BECAUSE THERE WAS NO CLOT FOUND.  The radiologist repeatedly stated I had to be incorrect in what I was taking, that it had to be Coumadin [note:  Coumadin prevents additional clots--it does not lyse clots].  HE WAS INCORRECT.  I definitely know what I take--it was, is and continues to be Nattokinase.  Nattokinase got rid of my clot, plain and simple.  If conventional providers do not want to believe it, I don't care.  If it can work for a >2 foot long clot, it likely works for other clots.  That said, I am a healthcare professional and fact is conventional medicine cares about nothing other than money.  Healthcare is "sick" care because that's where the money is made.  An epidemic of good health is the last thing Big Pharma wants!  If something can be effective without requiring frequent labs and doctor visits, obviously it would cut into the "take" on the part of MDs and other providers.  The system itself is sick!  Just as we laughed at those "funny-looking" Japanese cars in the 1970s and 1980s, it was those "funny" cars that gained the majority market share.  The Japanese healthcare system is much more efficient than the U.S. system.  Since it is care-driven versus our money-driven system, I believe it has more credibility.  I believe Dr. Sumi's research and will not have confidence in our system until such time research is objective and not controlled by big pharma.

  • Anonymous

    2/21/2010 3:02:13 AM |

    I just read this from Tom's post and found he countradicts himself:
    Tom said:
    It is possible that these enzyme products might produce a beneficial effect through that or other unknown mechanisms, but the makers of these products do not make that claim, perhaps due to its complexity. Rather, they invariably make simple, easily marketed claims.

    One should always be wary of any product, natural or otherwise that makes broad unsupported claims as to how and what it does." end quote

    Does this apply to Avandia too?

    I stated taking NK a month ago because I was having heart pain, nothing terribly serious as doctors never find any problems with my heart. After a few weeks I have not had any heart pains, and feel better, sleep better, etc.  I attribute it to the NK, and will continue to take it. My dad had heart problems so I am aware that I must prevent the same.  Taking anything else would be contrary to what works.  It is clear that Dr. Davis doesn't have a cure for heart disease and therefore can make no claims that NK does not work.  You can't have it both ways chum.
    The scam is the drug cartels, not natural products that work.

  • Dottie

    2/23/2010 10:46:17 PM |

    I haven't seen anything about Nattokinase being used to dissolve scar tissue in the stomach, for which I was referred.  Anyone heard of this?

  • Anonymous

    3/1/2010 12:39:41 AM |

    Please, people, stop falling into the trap of thinking that every study abstracted in PubMed is of good quality, let alone "proof."  I have to constantly caution myself against this, especially when all I am looking at is an abstract (and I would venture to say that less than 1% of the abstract readers bother to obtain the full article, and even if they do they probably don't rally understand much of what they are reading).

    And remember that the "pro supplement" research is just as prone to bias (often economically-motivated) as the pharma studies, and MORE prone to low quality.  Big Pharma and the Supplement industry BOTH have the almighty dollar as their primary motivator, and your health as -- perhaps -- a secondary motivator.  Neither should be demonized any more than the other.

    I use multiple supplements, including some herbs, and multiple drugs.  And I know there are potential risks and benefits (including unknown properties and unknown interactions) with both.  I also knwo that just because something "works" for me and *seems* safe, that it won't necessarily work for everyone, and isn't necessarily safe for everyone.  And that long-term hidden unknown detriments or benefits (again, for both supplements and drugs) may lurk.

    I know this has been rambling, but the main takeaways are:
    (1) Drug vs. "natural" partisans, please wise up
    (2) Don't assume everything you read is accurate (even the relatively unbiased stuff) just because "there are some studies,"  and
    (3) For very serious consitions such as cardiovascular disease, cerebrovascular disease, and cancer, realize that you NEED a doctor.  That doesn't mean you can't shop around for a better one, or that you can't question everything they say.

    Let me finish by saying that I found a "5 star" customer review of nattokinase on a well-known supplement site chilling.  It was to the effect of, "My Dad died of an aneuryism and no one can explain why, so I'm taking nattokinase to make sure the same thing doesn't happen to me!  It's great!"  That's SCARY!!

    (sorry, no time to check for typos right now... -- gotta run)

  • Anonymous

    3/22/2010 9:10:18 PM |

    Dr. Davis. You say Nattokinase supplementation is a scam? Someone with your professional credentials ought to be a little more informed on the subject as well as sensitive to the needs of others.

    Capsules, pills and tablets can't be made to protect their contents in the stomach? Have you ever herd of enteric coated, time release, or sustained release meds and supplements?

    You've personally witnessed bleed out and death that you attribute to use of nattokinase and other such enzymes. Is this due to product abuse by users? Was it because of a combination of other medical factors resulting in complications? Where is the documentation of your findings? Where is the open mindedness and balance in your personal and professional position? I see scare tactics and ignorance in a condecending spirit.

    I have had 5 DVT's and 3 PE's in recent years with no diagnosis for the cause. I have been seen by dozens of doctors, had 4 trips to the emergency room, and racked up enough medical bills to put me in bankruptcy. I've been on a steady diet of low dose rat poisin (warfarin) and am reminded to flex my calves when standing or sitting. Yes, I just have to live with it, I'm told.

    What ar you going to do for me? You all had your shot. I'm saying to you - Don't be afraid to learn something new or investgate the untraditional. Do your homework first. Then maybe there will be more to your position on this subject than emotional reasoning and unsubstantiated events.

    To all those out there exploring the new wave of enzyme therapies, I say carry on. It is an amazing science and a very viable alternative.

  • Anonymous

    3/26/2010 5:28:54 PM |

    Dr. Davis, I am seriously disappointed in your comments that nattokinase is a scam.  You seem to be very misinformed or have not done your research.

    Any scam you mention does not have to do with Nattokinase itself but the way supplement companies are marketing NK as well as how they are packaging and encapsulating NK with other ingredients to make it seem like a multivitamin.  The supplement versions of NK are diluted considerably by supplement companies. I know this first hand as I have personally seen and taken probably the most purest and concentrated form of NK available.

    "Clot develops when heart attack occurs. It makes no sense to take a lytic agent that dissolves clotes continuously. Unless I am missing something here, nattokinase remains squarely in the nonsense column."

    You are definitely misinformed.  It's really sad that you feel this way seeing that many people will now be misinformed about the truth of NK and how it improves human health.  NK does not have to be taken as a hard capsule.  It does survive stomach acid. That being said, I can understand that you may not have access to all of the information or the pure form of Nattokinase as it is not readily available anywhere other than Japan and China.

    I would suggest that you refrain from calling NK a scam until you yourself have definitive proof.  Otherwise your opinion remains squarely in the nonsense-column.

  • Dr. Dawn

    3/29/2010 1:35:15 PM |

    Dr. Davis,
    This reminds me of the initial skepticism about fish oil--you reference it as if it was always accepted and promoted in the medical community. Now there is Lovasa-- $200/mo. vs. $20/mo. for fish oil. (I actually recommend Krill oil.)
    Enzymes, when used against inflammation instead of digestive purposes, are taken on an empty stomach and are  absorbed into the blood stream. The thrombolytic effect is not sudden and works peripheral to central on the clot, posing no risk of embolism. I introduced fish oil to the cardiology department at  University Hospital (Michigan) in 1993 following a patient's M.I.-- at that time they hadn't heard of using omega 3s, but at least they were open to functional foods, eventually making fish oil part of their cardiac protocol. The early days of introducing most functional foods to the medical community is like turning around a locomotive-- until the pharmaceutical companies find a way to patent them-- we can thank them for the high cost of "sickness mgt" instead of health care. Coumadin counters K2, so while people have been guided to prevent clots (it does not break down clots, only prevents new ones and enlargement of those  established), they've also been engineering hypertension and atherosclerosis in their bodies--not to mention the organ repercussions of Coumadin. Humility in the medical community with respect to historical wisdom would be a refreshing change-- and might have gone a long way to prevent the gradual replacement of health care with our costly system of "sickness management", as well as the recent push for a governmental takeover plan. Research continues: Nutrition Research. Volume 29, Issue 3, March 2009, Pages 190-196. The older article by Milner explains the clotting mechanism for laymen. Research shows that Nattokinase can suppress thickening of the intima following damage to the inside of a blood vessel. Nutrition. 2003 Mar;19(3):261-4
    Remember, many doctors have created many health problems over the years   because they made assumptions..... After all, K2 is in egg yolks and helps calcium reach the bones instead of depositing in arteries-- yet for years doctors advised patients to avoid eggs if they had cardiovascular disease-- more mythology debunked. Those same eggs provide choline, key to brain, liver, and who-knows-what-else. Tanning (sun or bed) has been decried, yet Hollick showed women who tan regularly have 25% higher bone density--and not the inferior bone resulting from so-called osteoporosis drugs-- check out the NY Times article from March 25th.   Vitamin D3 deficiency, due to seriously flawed advice, has contributed to untold diseases-- diabetes, MS, cardiovascular disease,  breast, prostate, and colon cancer--to name just a few. Let's remain humble about non-drug methods and not attribute  characteristics and side effects of synthetic pharmaceutical drugs to functional foods. We are still identifying the beneficial synergistic relationships within these foods that do not exist in synthetic, isolated chemical constituents of drugs.

  • Inquisitive

    4/7/2010 5:00:46 PM |

    I am a 49 year old white male with a high stress life.  I am overweight, have sleep apnea, an asymptomatic irregular heartbeat, bouts with depression and anxiety (for which I was prescribed Prozac), supposedly "pre-diabetic" and I have, what a shock, high blood pressure.  I am interested in the potential benefits of Nattokinase as a possible enhancement to or replacement for the precription meds I am taking for hypertension.  I have recently started taking some other supplements such as Vitamins D3, K2, Fish Oil, Resveratrol, CoQ10 etc.  Does anyone out there with an open mind and the intellect to back it up have any personal experience, reccomendations or advice for me?  Please respond if so!  Thank you!  I am intelligent and I spend lots of time reading and researching from various sources on the internet and frankly, I just don't know who to believe anymore.  I just want to be healthier!

  • Anonymous

    4/9/2010 6:15:01 AM |

    I just want to chime in here - I have been on nattokinase for the last 8 years.
    Before that, I was on Coumadin for over two years for a clot that went all the way from my calf to my belly button. I have Factor V Leiden, a genetic clotting condition.
    While on Coumadin, I had numerous side effects, including Post Phlebitic Syndrome (PPS).
    Since starting on nattokinase, I have not been bothered with ANY of the side effects I had with Coumadin. No more Ultram for PPS, no more worrying about (not) eating my greens, no more INRs - NOTHING! My blood pressure is a healthy 115/75 (I am around 60y/o).

    I swear by Nattokinase, but I also know that there are many 'fakes' out there that claim to be nattokinase, but in reality have no active ingredients. Buyer beware!
    Check out reputable brands like Allergy Research, or Pure Prescriptions, or check out Dr. Holsworth, the researcher of nattokinase. Contact him for other reputable brands.

  • madanthony

    4/10/2010 7:04:09 PM |

    There ARE studies showing oral nattokinase IS fibrinolytic (so obviously was absorbed despite stomach acid!).  Here's one.  (I am limitted by your size restrictions)

    Sumi, H. et al. "Enhancement of the fibrinolytic activity in plasma by oral administration of nattokinase." Acta haematol 1990, 84: 139-43.
    Abstract
    The existence of a potent fibrinolytic enzyme (nattokinase, NK) in the traditional fermented food called 'natto', was reported by us previously. It was confirmed that oral administration of NK (or natto) produced a mild and frequent enhancement of the fibrinolytic activity in the plasma, as indicated by the fibrinolytic parameters, and the production of tissue plasminogen activator. NK capsules were also administered orally to dogs with experimentally induced thrombosis, and lysis of the thrombi was observed by angiography. The results obtained suggest that NK represents a possible drug for use not only in the treatment of embolism but also in the prevention of the disease, since NK has a proven safety and can be massproduced.

  • Ara

    4/13/2010 6:37:58 PM |

    So if nattokinnasse works for you. You are dismissed as a crazy -fanatic- person. So here I'm another "fanatic" person that has been taking fibrovan for over a year. My horrendous pelvic (menstrual) pain has improved more than half.
    So I guess it is over 12 months of the placebo effect.
    I read somewhere: First they ignore you then the ridicule you and finally they join you!
    Thank you Dr for at least not deleting the "freaks" posts.
    Anna

  • Anonymous

    4/25/2010 2:14:52 PM |

    I am 54 years old and have suffered from multiple fibroids and dangerous haeavy non-stop bleeding with clots in excess of 1 oz each. I started bleeding last July and by November 15 was close to hemmoraging. I was dangerously anemic for months. They wanted to give me a transfusion in the ER but I refused. I ended up with 10 days of fibrovera which did little except the clots decreased in size. My obgyn wanted to do a hysterectomy but I said no. He gave me 14 days more of fibrovera. Still bleeding I went online and ordered Fibrovan. I had previously taken a fibrinolytic mix with a lot of improvement but had stopped due to feeling better and the cost. After a week on Fibrovan I stopped bleeding for 4 months. I am now having  light manageable flow and will continue the Fibrovan. I would not be able to function otherwise. There are many more testimnials of the help it has been to other women who did not want to be cut on.
    Gail age 54 Texas

  • Tom

    4/25/2010 7:32:17 PM |

    That is ridiculous. Fibroids have nothing to do with fibrin, the words just sound similar. Nor would a purported fibrinolytic help to reduce uterine bleeding. In fact, if it did have fibrinolytic properties, it would increase bleeding.

    The makers of fibrovan and fibrovera (which are both practically identical) both make the absurd claim that nattokinase reduces fibroid size. Fibroids are a benign tumor and are effected by hormone levels. It is absurd to add the unsupported claim that nattokinase is able to shrink tumors and reduce bleeding because this would contradict the other unsupported claims made by pronattokinase commenters.


    It is shameful that supplement manufactures will create entire product lines simply because fibroid sounds like fibrin. I suggest we name this new fake medicine Homonymopathy.

  • Anonymous

    5/17/2010 2:56:11 AM |

    Nattokinase worked for me and I am living proof via ultrasounds.  Wake up folks!  If conventional medicine is so blasted great, then why are there currently mass tort actions regarding Avandia, Bextra, Vioxx, pain pumps used after shoulder surgery, Fleet's Phosphosoda used as a prep before colonoscopies that has put a number of people across our nation in renal failure requiring dialysis and transplants, nephrogenic fibrosing dermopathy as a result of gadolinium used for MRIs, etc., etc., etc.  I could go on and list at least 50 actions rights now for products made by Big Pharma and pushed by those who call themselve doctors (aka glorified drug pushers).  Our system is so broken, I wouldn't trust it to take care of a fruitfly!

  • Tom

    5/18/2010 9:39:02 AM |

    Supplements are just big pharm unregulated. That really turned out well for Europe and thalidomide.

    Also, natural does not equal non toxic. I'm acquainted with a patient who absolutely destroyed his liver on vitamin A and E to the point where he required a transplant.

  • ron

    5/18/2010 12:51:42 PM |

    I had bypass surgery 3 years ago after a heart attack. Five bypass grafts were performed. A year ago, I had another heart attack, the cause as indicated on the angiogram was that my body rejected the sutures used. Two of the bypass grafts fell off, and the others are full of crap at the suture that my body has deposited to counter what it feels is a foreign object. The point of this is that if a bypass is necessary, make sure the sutures used are compatible to your body and will not be rejected. there are several suture materials available from silk to propylene and many others. Question if they will work for you.
    All the best
    RB

  • Dave

    5/21/2010 2:51:10 AM |

    Dr. Davis and Tom,

    Fact: Clinical trials support the fact that oral NK mildly, but significantly, increases fibrnolytic activity in humans. I've personally witnessed this with myself.

    Fact: Clinical trials support the fact that NK lowers BP. I've personally witnessed this myself.

    Fact: Nattokinase lowers CRP levels. I've personally witnessed this myself.

    I realize that if any protease enzyme were directly injected into our blood stream, it would turn our veins and arteries into mush. Obviously, very little oral NK is absorbed, but enough to have an affect.

  • Anonymous

    6/1/2010 6:50:30 PM |

    Does anyone know if NK can be helpful in case of Protein C deficiency?
    I have 2 sons who have been diagnosed with 0.62 ratio of Protein C deficiency (genetically predisposed). It should read 0.70 to be normal range.

    In their case, they have to take Coumadin 10mg for life. Trying to avoid by all means.

    Please help.

  • Anonymous

    6/5/2010 11:38:56 AM |

    While barefoot on a ladder I slipped and fell to the next metal step. By the next day the entire arch of my foot was a deep purple with bruise. As witnessed in the office I showed my bruise, ate 100gm of fermented natto food and we watched as the next two days the bruise had cleared entirely. The only remnant was a small wound under the skin that was the source of the bruise/bleeding. It healed in what I would consider a normal period of time.

    Think of all the people on coumadin that would not be walking around with bruised arms or legs...etc

    Someone please explain if a bruise is a form of clotting or not.

    Perhaps in this economy of forced health care the government could spend some of that money on non pharmaceutical research as it might apply to the health of its citizens from eating food.

    I make my own natto, have been eating it weekly for the last 7 years. Soy sauce makes it better so does yogurt...I now am accustomed to eating it by itself. Thank you mother nature.

    A 52 year old believer.

  • Anonymous

    6/5/2010 11:57:24 AM |

    Same 52 year old believer from recent post.

    My wife was hit by an automobile while on her bicycle very recently. The ER sent her home with clean X-Rays for broken bones but advise on future possibility of finding damaged ligaments and or tendons in her leg where the bike frame contacted her.

    The folks at the ER said that day two would have more pain but day three would be the worse. They also advised that she should expect bruising on here entire leg area along with other areas that she was not aware of yet. (she used her arms when falling to protect her head)

    Within a few hours the large area of a bruise was showing. Again, roughly 100g of natto-the food, and the bruising has cleared the same evening. We are on day 4 and still no bruises. We can see an area under the skin where the tissue has been injured, perhaps a tear.....we are not medically trained. Her healing is progressing ahead of schedule as day two and three where better than day one.
    She was struck hard enough for the SUV to have a flat tire from the bicycle.
    I share these experiences to help show that...yes, there is an active ingredient in the natto and yes it gets past the stomach and does have an effect, if only in clearing a bruised area of the body.
    When I have a paper cut or small skin cut the blood is bright red, like I remember when I was very young. The blood also seems to be thinner but will coagulate easily when I apply pressure...as I always have done pre-natto. This from an ongoing, once a week usage.

  • Anonymous

    7/15/2010 4:36:01 PM |

    If what you say is true about stomache acid, then Plavix does not work either, nor does Asprin.

  • Anonymous

    7/17/2010 6:29:52 AM |

    1. If nattokinase worked as argued, then it should increase bruising, not decrease it.

    2. Plavix and asprin are both not enzymes.

  • Anonymous

    7/28/2010 5:09:52 AM |

    from pubmed.gov

    "Effects of nattokinase on blood pressure: a randomized, controlled trial.

    Kim JY, Gum SN, Paik JK, Lim HH, Kim KC, Ogasawara K, Inoue K, Park S, Jang Y, Lee JH.

    Yonsei University Research Institute of Science for Aging, Department of Food and Nutrition, College of Human Ecology, Yonsei University, and Department of Family Medicine, Mizmedi Hospital, Seoul, Korea.
    Abstract

    The objective of this study was to examine the effects of nattokinase supplementation on blood pressure in subjects with pre-hypertension or stage 1 hypertension. In a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, 86 participants ranging from 20 to 80 years of age with an initial untreated systolic blood pressure (SBP) of 130 to 159 mmHg received nattokinase (2,000 FU/capsule) or a placebo capsule for 8 weeks. Seventy-three subjects completed the protocol. Compared with the control group, the net changes in SBP and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) were -5.55 mmHg (95% confidence interval [CI], -10.5 to -0.57 mmHg; p<0.05) and -2.84 mmHg (CI, -5.33 to -0.33 mmHg; p<0.05), respectively, after the 8-week intervention. The corresponding net change in renin activity was -1.17 ng/mL/h for the nattokinase group compared with the control group (p<0.05). In conclusion, nattokinase supplementation resulted in a reduction in SBP and DBP. These findings suggest that increased intake of nattokinase may play an important role in preventing and treating hypertension."

    PMID: 18971533 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]"

  • Robert

    8/5/2010 5:43:33 AM |

    Dr. David, check http://www.houston-enzymes.com/learn/articles/doctor-may-not-know.php which says that plant and microbe based enzymes do survive the stomach acid, it is  the animal based or pancreatic enzymes that do not. So please retract your statement on enzymes.

  • Robert

    8/5/2010 6:17:29 AM |

    The bruising anecdotes are interesting, hopefully some medical researchers will look into it. Natto the food supposedly contains vitamin K2 which helps with clotting and may help reduce additional bleeding.  It is not clear what the interplay is between Nattokinase and K2.

  • Knox

    8/7/2010 3:24:15 PM |

    Dr. Davis -
    I would be very interested in your thoughts on SOD and it's action on fibrosis.  Note the following study:
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11134893

  • Anonymous

    8/8/2010 3:10:03 AM |

    I am thoroughly enjoying the debate on Nattokinase on this site, but one thing bothers me about Dr. Davis' claim that it is a scam.  Firstly, and foremost he claims that there is no way that it can survive the acidity of the stomach, even if it is enteric coated.  Secondly, he claims that it's anti-thrombolic properties are dangerous and can cause aneurysms in the brain.  I think he needs to pick a topic and stick with it.  If indeed, this product is a scam and does not survive the digestive process, then how can it be dangerous. Seems there needs to be more medically based research done on this enzyme before the word "scam" can be wholeheartedly used.

  • Anonymous

    8/10/2010 2:32:40 PM |

    I've been taking Nattokinase for 4 days now, I'm only 35 years old, but I can literally feel how it dramatically improves blood circulation in my body. The best way to prove or disprove something is to try. I have undiagnosed headaches which nobody can figure out for 13 years, I have chronic pain for 13 years daily non stop. My own theory (not supported by healthcare proffessionals) is that I had some kind on tiny aneurysm rupture or other kind of minor brain bleeding not big enough to show up in MRI but enough to somehow cause me this terrible chronic pain. It started as sudden worst headache you could possibly imagine, I almost lost consciousness. Something terrible must have happened. In any case if Nattokinase can help me it will be pretty major proof. It seems that it started to improve things already. The pain is not going away completely, but it started to disappear for like half a day ...

  • knox

    8/12/2010 4:27:33 PM |

    Anonymous from Aug 10 -

    I'm curious if you drink diet soft drinks or consume aspartame.  I used to have daily headaches and they stopped instantly when I stopped consuming aspartame.  It's a neurotoxin and it's deadly.

  • Anonymous

    8/30/2010 9:43:04 PM |

    I.m also interested into Nattokinase and fully agree with comment posted last August 10 by Anonimous:

    "... one thing bothers me about Dr. Davis' claim that [Nattokinase]is a scam. Firstly, and foremost he claims that there is no way that it can survive the acidity of the stomach, even if it is enteric coated. Secondly, he claims that it's anti-thrombolic properties are dangerous and can cause aneurysms in the brain. I think he needs to pick a topic and stick with it. If indeed, this product is a scam and does not survive the digestive process, then how can it be dangerous. Seems there needs to be more medically based research done on this enzyme before the word "scam" can be wholeheartedly used."

    Would like to know Dr.Davis answer

  • Anonymous

    9/1/2010 12:11:25 AM |

    Part 1
    For those who are searching for an answer to dissolving blood clots, I would love 2 share my success story.  In Oct 2009 I developed a freak blood clot after knee surgery.  I exercise almost every day and part of the regimen is cardio 5-7 days a week for 40 minutes @ a time. For a 40 year old male I was in peak condition.  My resting heart rate is excellent, blood pressure, cholesterol, weight, & BMI all perfect.  The week before my surgery I developed the H1N1 flu which put me in bed for a week and they had to push my knee surgery back.  So I went from super active to lying in bed for a week then having surgery and lying in bed again 2 recover.  Doctors tested for all diseases and genetic causes of blood clots and I had none of them.  They finally came to a conclusion that going from extreme activity to nothing could have been the only cause.  If I knew then what I know now I would have moved around more etc. but I had no clue?  I actually self diagnosed my own blood clot using web md and called my doctor.  He didn’t believe me so he said take an aspirin and come see him in the morning (3-4 days after surgery)  They put a Doppler on my leg found the blood clots & immediately rushed me to surgery to have a filter placed in my groin 2 prevent the clot from traveling 2 my heart.  They started giving me Heparin and then warfarin (coumidan) when I left the hospital.  They kept increasing my dose of warfarin since they could not get my PT level above 2 (they wanted it between 2-3) my level was 1.5-1.8.  I started getting terrible headaches, pain behind my eyes and after 6 weeks of this I developed horrible heartburn (I never was sensitive to ANY spicy food for my whole life) they wanted me to take 12mg of warfarin “rat poison” a day and I had enough.  None of my doctors wanted to discuss garlic, fish oil, or any of the other natural blood thinning methods.  They just wanted to give me one drug to cover the side effects of the other.  Since I normally eat mostly organic foods and am ultra healthy I had enough and decided to do my own research.  I read that Nattokinase would not only thin my blood, but unlike the “rat poison” it would actually dissolve the clot.  My doctor had told me that I would always have scars from blood clots and thus would need to take a baby aspirin for the rest of my life and go on warfarin whenever I had surgery in the future, because the “rat poison” only prevented future clots, but would not dissolve the clot.  So I found the best pharmaceutical grade Natto made by Allergy Research Group (I believe it is made in Japan) but was able to find in on Amazon.  I started taking 100mg a day and reduced my warfarin to 5mg & added 1 eight hour time released garlic pill.  Since my doctor could not measure my blood level (his devise only measured the amount of warfarin in my blood) I had to do this on my own and lied to my doctor about how much warfarin I was taking.  I had to judge my blood thickness by bruising and blood flow when pricked ( I know this sounds crazy but where I live I could not find a doctor that was willing to help me)  I knew that I had the filter in my leg as a back up, so that took some of the danger out of the equation.  After about a month of this I went to 200mg of Natto (one pill every 12 hours) and three eight hour time released garlic pills and stopped taking warfarin all together.  I did this for another 3 months.  PLEASE NOTE I UNDERSTAND WHAT I DID WAS DANGEROUS, SO I HOPE YOU CAN FIND A DOCTOR TO HELP WITH THIS PROCESS.
    to be continued...

  • Anonymous

    9/1/2010 12:12:50 AM |

    Part 1
    For those who are searching for an answer to dissolving blood clots, I would love 2 share my success story.  In Oct 2009 I developed a freak blood clot after knee surgery.  I exercise almost every day and part of the regimen is cardio 5-7 days a week for 40 minutes @ a time. For a 40 year old male I was in peak condition.  My resting heart rate is excellent, blood pressure, cholesterol, weight, & BMI all perfect.  The week before my surgery I developed the H1N1 flu which put me in bed for a week and they had to push my knee surgery back.  So I went from super active to lying in bed for a week then having surgery and lying in bed again 2 recover.  Doctors tested for all diseases and genetic causes of blood clots and I had none of them.  They finally came to a conclusion that going from extreme activity to nothing could have been the only cause.  If I knew then what I know now I would have moved around more etc. but I had no clue?  I actually self diagnosed my own blood clot using web md and called my doctor.  He didn’t believe me so he said take an aspirin and come see him in the morning (3-4 days after surgery)  They put a Doppler on my leg found the blood clots & immediately rushed me to surgery to have a filter placed in my groin 2 prevent the clot from traveling 2 my heart.  They started giving me Heparin and then warfarin (coumidan) when I left the hospital.  They kept increasing my dose of warfarin since they could not get my PT level above 2 (they wanted it between 2-3) my level was 1.5-1.8.  I started getting terrible headaches, pain behind my eyes and after 6 weeks of this I developed horrible heartburn (I never was sensitive to ANY spicy food for my whole life) they wanted me to take 12mg of warfarin “rat poison” a day and I had enough.  None of my doctors wanted to discuss garlic, fish oil, or any of the other natural blood thinning methods.  They just wanted to give me one drug to cover the side effects of the other.  Since I normally eat mostly organic foods and am ultra healthy I had enough and decided to do my own research.  I read that Nattokinase would not only thin my blood, but unlike the “rat poison” it would actually dissolve the clot.  My doctor had told me that I would always have scars from blood clots and thus would need to take a baby aspirin for the rest of my life and go on warfarin whenever I had surgery in the future, because the “rat poison” only prevented future clots, but would not dissolve the clot.  So I found the best pharmaceutical grade Natto made by Allergy Research Group (I believe it is made in Japan) but was able to find in on Amazon.  I started taking 100mg a day and reduced my warfarin to 5mg & added 1 eight hour time released garlic pill.  Since my doctor could not measure my blood level (his devise only measured the amount of warfarin in my blood) I had to do this on my own and lied to my doctor about how much warfarin I was taking.  I had to judge my blood thickness by bruising and blood flow when pricked ( I know this sounds crazy but where I live I could not find a doctor that was willing to help me)  I knew that I had the filter in my leg as a back up, so that took some of the danger out of the equation.  After about a month of this I went to 200mg of Natto (one pill every 12 hours) and three eight hour time released garlic pills and stopped taking warfarin all together.  I did this for another 3 months.  PLEASE NOTE I UNDERSTAND WHAT I DID WAS DANGEROUS, SO I HOPE YOU CAN FIND A DOCTOR TO HELP WITH THIS PROCESS.
    to be continued...

  • Anonymous

    9/1/2010 12:14:57 AM |

    Part 1
    For those who are searching for an answer to dissolving blood clots, I would love 2 share my success story.  In Oct 2009 I developed a freak blood clot after knee surgery.  I exercise almost every day and part of the regimen is cardio 5-7 days a week for 40 minutes @ a time. For a 40 year old male I was in peak condition.  My resting heart rate is excellent, blood pressure, cholesterol, weight, & BMI all perfect.  The week before my surgery I developed the H1N1 flu which put me in bed for a week and they had to push my knee surgery back.  So I went from super active to lying in bed for a week then having surgery and lying in bed again 2 recover.  Doctors tested for all diseases and genetic causes of blood clots and I had none of them.  They finally came to a conclusion that going from extreme activity to nothing could have been the only cause.  If I knew then what I know now I would have moved around more etc. but I had no clue?  I actually self diagnosed my own blood clot using web md and called my doctor.  He didn’t believe me so he said take an aspirin and come see him in the morning (3-4 days after surgery)  They put a Doppler on my leg found the blood clots & immediately rushed me to surgery to have a filter placed in my groin 2 prevent the clot from traveling 2 my heart.  They started giving me Heparin and then warfarin (coumidan) when I left the hospital.  They kept increasing my dose of warfarin since they could not get my PT level above 2 (they wanted it between 2-3) my level was 1.5-1.8.  I started getting terrible headaches, pain behind my eyes and after 6 weeks of this I developed horrible heartburn (I never was sensitive to ANY spicy food for my whole life) they wanted me to take 12mg of warfarin “rat poison” a day and I had enough.  None of my doctors wanted to discuss garlic, fish oil, or any of the other natural blood thinning methods.  They just wanted to give me one drug to cover the side effects of the other.  Since I normally eat mostly organic foods and am ultra healthy I had enough and decided to do my own research.  I read that Nattokinase would not only thin my blood, but unlike the “rat poison” it would actually dissolve the clot.  My doctor had told me that I would always have scars from blood clots and thus would need to take a baby aspirin for the rest of my life and go on warfarin whenever I had surgery in the future, because the “rat poison” only prevented future clots, but would not dissolve the clot.  So I found the best pharmaceutical grade Natto made by Allergy Research Group (I believe it is made in Japan) but was able to find in on Amazon.  I started taking 100mg a day and reduced my warfarin to 5mg & added 1 eight hour time released garlic pill.  Since my doctor could not measure my blood level (his devise only measured the amount of warfarin in my blood) I had to do this on my own and lied to my doctor about how much warfarin I was taking.  to be continued...

  • Anonymous

    9/1/2010 12:16:39 AM |

    Part 1
    For those who are searching for an answer to dissolving blood clots, I would love 2 share my success story.  In Oct 2009 I developed a freak blood clot after knee surgery.  I exercise almost every day and part of the regimen is cardio 5-7 days a week for 40 minutes @ a time. For a 40 year old male I was in peak condition.  My resting heart rate is excellent, blood pressure, cholesterol, weight, & BMI all perfect.  The week before my surgery I developed the H1N1 flu which put me in bed for a week and they had to push my knee surgery back.  So I went from super active to lying in bed for a week then having surgery and lying in bed again 2 recover.  Doctors tested for all diseases and genetic causes of blood clots and I had none of them.  They finally came to a conclusion that going from extreme activity to nothing could have been the only cause.  If I knew then what I know now I would have moved around more etc. but I had no clue?  I actually self diagnosed my own blood clot using web md and called my doctor.  He didn’t believe me so he said take an aspirin and come see him in the morning (3-4 days after surgery)  They put a Doppler on my leg found the blood clots & immediately rushed me to surgery to have a filter placed in my groin 2 prevent the clot from traveling 2 my heart.  They started giving me Heparin and then warfarin (coumidan) when I left the hospital.  They kept increasing my dose of warfarin since they could not get my PT level above 2 (they wanted it between 2-3) my level was 1.5-1.8.  I started getting terrible headaches, pain behind my eyes and after 6 weeks of this I developed horrible heartburn (I never was sensitive to ANY spicy food for my whole life) they wanted me to take 12mg of warfarin “rat poison” a day and I had enough.  None of my doctors wanted to discuss garlic, fish oil, or any of the other natural blood thinning methods.  They just wanted to give me one drug to cover the side effects of the other.  Since I normally eat mostly organic foods and am ultra healthy I had enough and decided to do my own research.  I read that Nattokinase would not only thin my blood, but unlike the “rat poison” it would actually dissolve the clot.  My doctor had told me that I would always have scars from blood clots and thus would need to take a baby aspirin for the rest of my life and go on warfarin whenever I had surgery in the future, because the “rat poison” only prevented future clots, but would not dissolve the clot.  So I found the best pharmaceutical grade Natto made by Allergy Research Group (I believe it is made in Japan) but was able to find in on Amazon.
    to be continued...

  • Anonymous

    9/1/2010 12:18:58 AM |

    Part 1
    For those who are searching for an answer to dissolving blood clots, I would love 2 share my success story.  In Oct 2009 I developed a freak blood clot after knee surgery.  I exercise almost every day and part of the regimen is cardio 5-7 days a week for 40 minutes @ a time. For a 40 year old male I was in peak condition.  My resting heart rate is excellent, blood pressure, cholesterol, weight, & BMI all perfect.  The week before my surgery I developed the H1N1 flu which put me in bed for a week and they had to push my knee surgery back.  So I went from super active to lying in bed for a week then having surgery and lying in bed again 2 recover.  Doctors tested for all diseases and genetic causes of blood clots and I had none of them.  They finally came to a conclusion that going from extreme activity to nothing could have been the only cause.  If I knew then what I know now I would have moved around more etc. but I had no clue?  I actually self diagnosed my own blood clot using web md and called my doctor.  He didn’t believe me so he said take an aspirin and come see him in the morning (3-4 days after surgery)  They put a Doppler on my leg found the blood clots & immediately rushed me to surgery to have a filter placed in my groin 2 prevent the clot from traveling 2 my heart.  They started giving me Heparin and then warfarin (coumidan) when I left the hospital.  They kept increasing my dose of warfarin since they could not get my PT level above 2 (they wanted it between 2-3) my level was 1.5-1.8.  I started getting terrible headaches, pain behind my eyes and after 6 weeks of this I developed horrible heartburn (I never was sensitive to ANY spicy food for my whole life) they wanted me to take 12mg of warfarin “rat poison” a day and I had enough.  None of my doctors wanted to discuss garlic, fish oil, or any of the other natural blood thinning methods.  They just wanted to give me one drug to cover the side effects of the other.  Since I normally eat mostly organic foods and am ultra healthy I had enough and decided to do my own research.
    to be continued...

    All posts by william-davis

    Tell me your wheat elimination story and receive a copy of my new book, Wheat Belly

    I'm looking for interesting wheat-free experiences.

    For the past year, I have been writing my new book, Wheat Belly . After many, many late nights and soccer games missed, it's now finished. The book will be out in fall, 2011, to be published by Rodale, the Prevention Magazine people.

    Wheat Belly will provide, in excruciating detail, the discussion of how wheat was transformed from innocent wild grass to incredible genetically-altered Frankengrain and why it has become such a health nuisance.

    I am looking for interesting stories of wheat elimination for the online and special editions of the book. If you have an interesting tale of wheat-elimination successes, woes, or drama, I'd like to hear about it. Even better, if you would agree to be interviewed by phone (not for live use, just for comments and detail), the editors at Rodale will help tell your story.

    If we use your story, I will have a free copy of the new Wheat Belly sent to you when it becomes available.

    Please post your story in the comments here. I will then need to obtain your contact info, which we will do privately.

     

    Real men don't eat carbs

    Real men don't eat carbs. At least they don't eat them without eventually paying the price.

    How do carbohydrates, especially those contained in "healthy whole grains," impair maleness? Several ways:

    --Consume carbohydrates, especially the exceptional glucose-increasing amylopectin A from wheat, and visceral fat grows. Visceral fat increases estrogen levels; estrogen, in effect, opposes the masculinizing effects of testosterone. Overweight males typically have low testosterone and high estrogen, a cause for depression, emotionality, weight gain, and low libido.

    --Sugar-provoking carbohydrates like wheat cause visceral fat to accumulate which, in turn, triggers prolactin to be released. Increased prolactin in a male causes growth of breasts: "man boobs,""man cans," "moobs," etc. This is why male breast reduction surgery is booming at double-digit growth rates. In cities like LA, you can see billboards advertising male breast reduction surgery.

    --Carbohydrates increase visceral fat that sets the stage for postprandial abnormalities, i.e., markedly increased and persistent lipoproteins, like chylomicron remnants and VLDL particles, that impair endothelial function literally within minutes to hours of ingestion. Impaired endothelial function underlies erectile dysfunction. This is why Internet spammers so enthusiastically send you offers for discounted Viagra.

    --Carbohydrates increase blood sugar which provokes the process of glycation, glucose modification of proteins, that also contributes to endothelial dysfunction followed by erectile dysfunction.

    Real men therefore avoid carbs.

    Real men don't eat carbs

    Real men don't eat carbs. At least they don't eat them without eventually paying the price.

    How do carbohydrates, especially those contained in "healthy whole grains," impair maleness? Several ways:

    --Consume carbohydrates, especially the exceptional glucose-increasing amylopectin A from wheat, and visceral fat grows. Visceral fat increases estrogen; estrogen, in effect, opposes the masculinizing effects of testosterone. Overweight males typically have low testosterone, high estrogen, a cause for depressions, emotionality, and weight gain.

    --Consume carbohydrates like wheat and visceral fat causes prolactin to be released. Increased prolactin in a male causes growth of breasts: "man boobs,""man cans," "moobs," etc. This is why male breast reduction surgery is booming at double-digit growth rates. In cities like LA, you can see billboards advertising male breast reduction surgery.

    --Carbohydrates increase visceral fat that sets the stage for postprandial abnormalities, i.e., markedly increased and prolonged lipoproteins like chylomicron remnants and VLDL particles that impair endothelial function. Impaired endothelial function underlies erectile dysfunction. Eat a bagel, become impotent.

    Why do the Japanese have less heart disease?

    We should look to the Japanese to teach us a few lessons about preventing heart disease. A Japanese male has only 65% of the risk of an American male (despite 40% of Japanese men being smokers), while a Japanese woman has 80% less risk than an American woman. While the U.S. is near the top of the list of nations with highest cardiovascular risk, Japan is the lowest.

    What are they doing right?

    There is no one explanation, but several. Genetics probably does not play a substantial role, by the way, as demonstrated by observations of Japanese people who emigrate to Western cultures. People of Japanese heritage living in Hawaii, for instance, develop the same cardiovascular risk as non-Japanese living in Hawaii. They also develop obesity and diabetes.

    Among the factors that likely contribute to reduced risk in Japanese people:

    --A style of eating that does not include a lot of sweet foods. No breakfast cereal or donuts for breakfast, for instance, but miso soup with tofu, fish, green onions, and daikon (as takuan, or pickled radish).
    --Seaweed--It's probably a combination of the green phytonutrients and iodine. Typical daily iodine intake is in the neighborhood of 5000 mcg per day from nori, kombu, wakame, and other seaweed forms. (The average American obtains 125 mcg per day of iodine from diet.)
    --Seafood--Fish in many forms not seen in the U.S. are popular.
    --Green tea--Consumption of green tea has been confidently linked to reduced cardiovascular risk, probably via visceral fat-reducing, anti-oxidative, and anti-inflammatory effects. Although tea in Japan is often the less flavonoid-rich oolong tea, softer benefits from this form are likely.
    --Soy--Tofu, miso, and soy sauce are staples. It's not clear to me whether soy is intrinsically beneficial or whether it is beneficial because it serves to replace unhealthy alternatives. (Genetic modification may change this effect.)
    --Reduced exposure to cooked animal products (except seafood). This is not a saturated fat issue, but probably an advanced glycation end-product/lipoxidation issue that result from cooking.
    --The lack of a "eat more healthy whole grain" mentality, the advice that has plunged the entire U.S. into the depths of a diabetes and obesity crisis (along with high-fructose corn syrup and sugar). Noodles like udon and ramen do have a place in their diet, as do some dessert foods. But the overall wheat exposure is less--no bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast cereals.
    --Less overweight and obesity--The above eating style leads to less weight gain.

    Japanese foods have a unique taste, consistency, and mouth-feel that go well with saltiness, thus the downside of their diet: salt consumption. On a broad scale, high salt consumption has been associated with hypertension and gastric cancer. But the tradeoff has, on the whole, been a favorable one.


    One study trying to find some answers:

    Dietary patterns and cardiovascular disease mortality in Japan: a prospective cohort study.

    Shimazu T, Kuriyama S, Hozawa A et al.
    Division of Epidemiology, Department of Public Health and Forensic Medicine, Tohoku University Graduate School of Medicine, Japan.


    We prospectively assessed the association between dietary patterns among the Japanese and CVD mortality. Dietary information was collected from 40 547 Japanese men and women aged 40-79 years without a history of diabetes, stroke, myocardial infarction or cancer at the baseline in 1994.
    During 7 years of follow-up, 801 participants died of CVD.

    Factor analysis (principal component) based on a validated food frequency questionnaire identified three dietary patterns: (i) a Japanese dietary pattern highly correlated with soybean products, fish, seaweeds, vegetables, fruits and green tea, (ii) an 'animal food' dietary pattern and (iii) a high-dairy, high-fruit-and-vegetable, low-alcohol (DFA) dietary pattern. The Japanese dietary pattern was related to high sodium intake and high prevalence of hypertension. After adjustment for potential confounders, the Japanese dietary pattern score was associated with a lower risk of CVD mortality (hazard ratio of the highest quartile vs the lowest, 0.73; 95% confidence interval: 0.59-0.90; P for trend = 0.003). The 'animal food' dietary pattern was associated with an increased risk of CVD, but the DFA dietary pattern was not.

    The Japanese dietary pattern was associated with a decreased risk of CVD mortality, despite its relation to sodium intake and hypertension.

    Niacin: What forms are safe?

    Niacin, or vitamin B3, remains a confusing issue for many people. It shouldn't be.

    It doesn't help that most physicians and many pharmacists also do not understand the basic issues surrounding niacin. The only reason why there is any level of prevailing knowledge about niacin is that Kos Pharmaceuticals managed to "pharmaceuticalize" a niacin preparation, prescription Niaspan, that provided the revenue to fund professional "education."

    Niacin can be helpful to increase HDL, reduce small LDL particles and shift them towards the more benign large particles, reduce triglycerides, and reduce lipoprotein(a).

    So here's a brief description of the various forms that you will find niacin:

    Immediate-release niacin--Also called crystalline niacin or just niacin. This is the original niacin that releases within minutes of ingestion. Because it releases rapidly, it triggers the most intense "hot flush." While this form of niacin works wonderfully well, is the safest, and is dirt cheap, the majority of people are simply unable to tolerate the intense flush. It also works best taken twice a day, generating two intolerable flushes per day.

    Slow-release niacin--These preparations were popular in the 1980s, since the slow 12 to 24 hour pattern of release minimized the annoying hot flush. But, with prolonged use, it also became apparent that an unnaceptable frequency of liver toxicity developed. Unfortunately, this means that any niacin preparation that trickles niacin out over an extended period, including many of the slow-release preparations now sold in health food stores and pharmacies, have potential for liver toxicity. These preparations should be avoided.

    6-hour release niacin--Releasing niacin more slowly than immediate-release niacin but more rapidly than slow-release niacin, 6-hour release (or what the Niaspan people call "extended-release" niacin) is nearly as effective as immediate-release niacin with approximately the same low potential for liver toxicity. It is far less liver toxic than slow-release niacin. 6-hour release niacin therefore offers the best balance between effectiveness and safety. Preparations that show this pattern of release include Niaspan ($180 per month), the poorly-named Sloniacin (about $8 per month), and Enduracin (about $7 per month) for 1000 mg per day. (Some Track Your Plaque Members have also determined that several other over-the-counter preparations have been demonstrated to share a similar pattern of release.)

    Then there are the scam products that have no useful effect at all:

    Flush-free or no-flush niacin--Inositol hexaniacinate, or 6 niacin molecules bound to the sugar, inositol, has no effect in humans, at least not with the dozen or so preparations that I've seen used. Nor are there any data to document the effectiveness of flush-free niacin. It's also more expensive.

    Nicotinamide--This niacin derivative likewise has no effect on the usual targets for niacin treatment.

    While I used to prescribe Niaspan, the ridiculous pricing and aggressive marketing really turned me off. I now advise my patients and our online followers to use only Sloniacin or Enduracin, unless you can tolerate immediate-release niacin.

    Introduction to the New Track Your Plaque book, version 2.0


    Out with the old,
    in with the new  



    “I believe that you are suffering from what is called a fatty degeneration of the heart.”

    Dr. Tertius Lydgate to Mr. Casaubon on making a diagnosis with the new medical device, the stethoscope.

    George Elliot
    Middlemarch, 1871





    Old notions in medicine have a peculiar way of lingering.

    In 1882, Dr. Robert Koch discovered the tubercle bacillus in tissues of people with “consumption.” By connecting a bacterium with the disease, he usurped the long held notion that tuberculosis was a degenerative disease caused by lack of fresh air. But, for decades after Dr. Koch’s revelation, the “bad air” belief persisted. Surgical collapse of the lung, a painful and barbaric treatment for tuberculosis, persisted well into the 1960s, years after effective antibiotics were discovered in 1947.

    The medical community of the 19th century viewed mental illness as the hereditary end-product of ancestral nervousness, alcoholism, prostitution and criminal behavior, a bias that remained widespread well into the mid-20th century. Nazi physicians invoked the theory of heritable “mental degeneration” to justify wholesale extermination of schizophrenics. Electro-convulsive therapy (ECT, or “electroshock therapy”) was widely applied to treat schizophrenia, depression, homosexuality, and criminal behavior for over 30 years, gradually abandoned (at least in its original form) after years of abusive application to subdue patients, demonized in the 1975 movie, “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest,” depicting the author’s real-life experience with ECT.

    Long after a theory or practice has been discredited, it can persist, refusing to die. The new and improved may not be adopted into mainstream practice for years, even decades.

    Back to the 21st century: What if you realized that, by quirks of human nature and the uneven adoption of health information, your doctor practiced medicine appropriate for 1985? 1975?

    While digital information nowadays is transmitted at the speed of light, disseminating as fast as it takes the next juicy tidbit to be “virally” reproduced via social networking websites, it’s the human factor that still operates with the inertia of human behavior. Habits and attitudes slow the adoption of new information in time measured not in seconds, but in years or decades.

    A century ago, 20 years were required for the new technology of blood pressure measurement to be adopted after its introduction in the U.S. in 1910, since physicians were long comfortable with the practice of “pulse palpation” (feeling the pulse). (The arcane language of pulse palpation persists to this day, terms like “pulsus parvus et tardus,” the slow rising pulse of a stiff aortic valve; and the "water-hammer" pulse of a leaking aortic valve.)

    The discovery of new, health-changing information today in the 21st century disseminates through the ranks of modern healthcare providers at much the same pace as measuring blood pressure did in the early 20th century.

    It’s also tempting to paint American medicine as a fiefdom intent on maintaining exclusive rein over health information. Look back over the hierarchical relationship of medicine over nursing in the past century: When blood pressure measurement was adopted on a broad scale in the 1930s, it was practiced only by physicians, since nurses were deemed incapable. (Modern-day nurses should surely have a hearty laugh over this.) Stethoscopes, around even longer than blood pressure cuffs, weren’t permitted to fall into the hands of nurses until the 1960s, since the medical community feared that nurses might command too much control over patient care. Even after nurses were permitted to have their own stethoscopes, great pains were taken to be certain the nurses’ version was readily distinguishable from the “real” tool wielded by physicians; nurses’ stethoscopes were therefore labeled “nurse-o-scopes,” or “assistoscopes,” and were required to be smaller and flimsier.

    Old and ineffective doesn’t always give way to new and better at once; it is slowed by habit as well as an unwillingness to relinquish control.

    Somehow technology marches on. But it does so unevenly, sweeping some along in its first wave, others in its wake, some never at all.

    Just as effective antibiotics to cure tuberculosis were available for 20 years while surgeons continued to remove patients’ lungs, so better solutions to heart disease are already available but not yet employed by your neighborhood physician. The primary care physician may have heard about some of the newest means to prevent heart disease, but is too overwhelmed with the day-to-day of sore throats, diarrhea, and rashes. Cardiologists, intent on inserting the next best stent or defibrillator, have little but passing interest in strategies that might halt or reverse the heart disease that can be “managed,” no matter how imperfectly, with procedural solutions like angioplasty and bypass surgery. We should bear these flawed human tendencies in mind as we explore the world of heart disease prevention.

    We need look no farther than the front page of the newspaper to find evidence of the failure of present-day heart disease detection and management. Over the past several years, headlines have carried the likes of Tim Russert, Bill Clinton, Larry King, Dick Cheney, David Letterman, Tommy Lasorda, Ed Bradley, Mike Ditka, Walter Cronkite, Alberto Salazar, all heart disease sufferers. Some, like talk show host David Letterman, survived their brush with heart catastrophe and underwent successful bypass surgery. Others, like marathoners Fixx and Salazar, raised none of the conventional red flags for heart disease. All received standard, “modern” medical care . . . all the way up to their heart attack, bypass surgery, or untimely death.

    Like the sphygnomanometer (blood pressure) cuffs of 1910, Track Your Plaque represents an example of the new. But, unlike the simple practice of taking blood pressure in the early 20th century, Track Your Plaque represents an entirely new way to look at coronary heart disease: a new way to measure it, a new way to identify its causes, and a new way to seize control over it, often to the point of achieving reversal of the process. It also puts control over much of this process into your hands and away from hospitals, cardiologists, and heart procedures. 

    I could speak of revealing “secrets,” but that’s not true. In Track Your Plaque, I simply convey information about heart disease that you were likely unaware existed, strategies that doctors fail to discuss. I assemble them into a “package” that, together, create an enormously empowering unique approach to prevent heart disease and heart attack.

    Track Your Plaque also challenges the high-tech status quo, practices that occupy exalted places in the enormous cardiovascular healthcare machine that has dominated American healthcare for the past 40 years. I propose that high-tech hospital procedures should join the practice of ECT for homosexuality and insanity¾and become yet another relic of the past.

    What are "normal" triglycerides?

    Among the most neglected yet enormously helpful values on any standard cholesterol panel is the triglyceride value.

    Triglycerides traverse the bloodstream by hitching a ride on water (serum)-soluble lipoproteins, or lipid-carrying proteins. We measure triglycerides as an indirect index of triglyceride-containing lipoproteins.

    Triglycerides are a basic currency of energy. While the average American ingests around 300 mg of cholesterol per day, he or she also ingests 60,000-120,000 mg (60-120 grams) of triglycerides, i.e., 200 to 400 times greater amounts, from fat intake. Zero triglycerides in the diet or in the bloodstream is not an option.

    But what represents too much triglycerides in the bloodstream? There are several observations to help us make this determination:

    1) When fasting triglycerides are 133 mg/dl or greater, 80% of people will show show at least some degree of small LDL particles.

    2) When fasting triglycerides are 60 mg/dl or less, most (though not all, since genetic factors enter into the picture) people will show little to no small LDL particles.

    3) When fasting triglycerides are 200 mg/dl or greater, small LDL particles will dominate and large LDL particles will be in the minority or be gone entirely.

    4) When triglycerides are 88 mg/dl or greater after eating, then risk for heart attack is doubled. Non-fasting triglycerides in the 400+ mg/dl range are associated with 17-fold greater risk for heart attack.



    From Austin et al 1990. "Phenotype A" means that large LDL particles dominate; "phenotype B" means that small LDL particles dominate.

    Note that conventional "wisdom" (i.e., NCEP ATP-3 guidelines) is that triglycerides of up to 150 mg/dl are okay, a level that virtually guarantees expression of small LDL particles and increased cardiovascular risk.

    Based on observations like these, in the Track Your Plaque program we aim for fasting triglycerides of no higher than 60 mg/dl and postprandial (after-meal) triglycerides of no more than 90 mg/dl.

    Curiously, while fat intake (i.e., triglyceride intake) plays a role in determining postprandial triglyceride blood levels, it's carbohydrate intake that plays a much larger role. That will be an issue for another day.

    1985: The Year of Whole Grains

    In 1985, the National Cholesterol Education Panel delivered its Adult Treatment Panel guidelines to Americans, advice to cut cholesterol intake, reduce saturated fat, and increase "healthy whole grains" to reduce the incidence of heart attack and other cardiovascular events.

    Per capita wheat consumption increased accordingly. Wheat consumption today is 26 lbs per year greater than in 1970 and now totals 133 lbs per person per year. (Because infants and children are lumped together with adults, average adult consumption is likely greater than 200 lbs per year, or the equivalent of approximately 300 loaves of bread per year.) Another twist: The mid- and late-1980s also marks the widespread adoption of the genetically-altered dwarf variants of wheat to replace standard-height wheat.

    In 1985, the Centers for Disease Control also began to track multiple health conditions, including diabetes. Here is the curve for diabetes:


    Note that, from 1958 until 1985, the curve was climbing slowly. After 1985, the curve shifted sharply upward. (Not shown is the data point for 2010, an even steeper upward ascent.) Now diabetes is skyrocketing, projected to afflict 1 in 3 adults in the coming decades.

    You think there's a relationship?

    Have some more

    Wheat, via exorphin effects, is an appetite stimulant. Eat a whole wheat bagel or bran muffin, you want another. You also want more of other foods. You also want something to eat every two hours due to widely-swinging insulin-glucose responses: blood sugar high followed by a sharp downturn that triggers a powerful impulse to eat (thus the cravings for a snack at 9 and 11 a.m. after a 7 a.m. breakfast).

    If wheat is a stimulant of appetite, then removing it should yield reduced appetite and reduced calorie intake. That is precisely what happens.

    When wheat products are removed from the diet--without calorie restriction, without counting fat or carbohydrate grams, no exercise program, no cleansing regimen, no skipping meals . . . nothing--calorie intake drops 350 to 400 calories per day. This calorie figure remains curiously consistent across multiple studies in which wheat was eliminated.

    400 calories per day results in 21 lbs lost over 6 months, based just on calories. (3500 calories per pound lost.) That is what happens in wheat elimination diets: 21-26 lbs lost over 6 months.

    Wheat is the processed food industry's nicotine, a means of ensuring repeat food purchases. It's also low-cost (subsidized by the U.S. government), high-yield, an ingredient that even has its very own withdrawal syndrome should you miss a "hit."

    Copyright © 2026 Cureality.com

    NY Times Jane Brody misses the mark



    NY Times' health columnist, Jane Brody, recently wrote a bit of fluff for her paper:

    "CT Scans of the Heart Come With Trade-Offs


    In her report, she says:

    Coronary CT scans are being sold directly to the public, and they have found a market in health-conscious people who can afford them. But screening exams can have downsides. They can cause needless worry, and they sometimes reveal other potential conditions that require invasive procedures like biopsies to diagnose.

    I soon learned that among the strongest proponents of CT scans of coronary arteries were physicians with financial ties to drug companies that make statins and others connected to imaging centers that would profit directly from widespread CT screenings.



    She then goes on to discuss how the Framingham scoring calculation can tell you whether or not you are at low-, intermediate-, or high-risk for heart disease. She therefore concludes that heart scans are therefore irrelevant for the majority of people. She then proceeds to take a statin agent.

    This sort of nonsense continues to get published, despite the clear lack of real "digging" for the truth. She clearly fell for the conventional arguments that continue to mis-guide the majority of people, myths like:

    --the Framingham scoring system is reliable--Reliable it is NOT; it is susceptible to substantial "misclassification" bias, meaning people who appear low risk can actually be high risk, and people at high risk can actually be low risk. Among the latest studies that question the scoring system is Family history of premature coronary heart disease and coronary artery calcification: Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA). This study pointed out how the Framingham scoring system, which leaves out family history, can cause people classified as low risk to actually have substantial heart scan scores. This is crucial. A heart scan gets beyond the uncertainties and shows with >95% certainty whether or not hidden coronary atherosclerotic plaque is present.

    --"Coronary risk" is a dynammic phenomenon, subject to changes in a person's life. What if, for instance, a person smoked for 20 years, quit 10 years ago, lost 30 lbs, dropped their blood pressure as a result of the weight loss, then relied on the Framingham Risk Calculator to determine risk. They would likely be classified as low- risk, since risk factors now appear favorable. This person could easily have a heart scan score of 500, or 700, or 1000, levels that carry a cardiovascular event risk of 5-25% per year, hardly low-risk, because much of their risk accumulated earlier in life and is no longer revealed by an assessment of risk factors.

    --There are sources of risk that have nothing to do with Framingham, such as lipoprotein(a), which is often revealed by family history; the presence of small LDL, which co-varies with HDL and triglycerides, but can behave independently also; and, my favorite, deficiency of vitamin D. This would explain part of the 60-70% of people who are typically mis-classified by Framingham.


    Where did Ms. Brody get the idea that proponents of heart scans had ties to drug companies? I think she's barking up the wrong tree on that one. Of course, she ends up on a statin drug. For my part, I am a critic of statin drugs. Yes, they play a role, but they are miserably misused and abused by practicing physicians, based on the endless onslaught of drug company-sponsored trials that have served to distort their usefulness.

    If I were Ms. Brody, I would be quaking in my shoes, not knowing what my true risk for heart disease was, relying on the--at best--30% reduction in heart attack risk of Lipitor or other statin drug. Ms. Brody: You are not cured, you're simply wearing a superficial Band-Aid. If you want to know your true risk for heart attack, and you want a precise value that you can track over time, the answer is simple: Reject the conventional notion and get a heart scan.

    "There must be a mistake"

    Neal is our current male record holder for greatest reduction in heart scan score. (Yes, the ladies have the lead!)

    You may remember that this 40-year old man reduced his heart scan score from 339 to 161--a 51% drop. If you haven't yet read his story, go to

    http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_07-001nealt51.asp


    Neal reminded me of the experience he had when he underwent his second heart scan. Both scans had been performed at the same scanning center. At this center, the radiologists provide the added service of sitting down with people and actually going over the images and results.

    After the scan, the radiologist pulled up the result from Neal's first scan for comparison. "There must be a mistake! This score is lower. Scores never drop."

    The radiologist was apparently stumped, unable to provide an explanation. However, Neal then proceeded to tell the radiologist that we had warned Neal that this could happen and that he might even be told that it was due to error of some sort. This yielded a puzzled look on the radiologist but no further comment.

    Of course it's not a mistake. It's something we achieve on purpose. Curiously, I still get comments that this is impossible, heart scan scores never drop, etc. Of course, those of you following this conversation know this is completely untrue. Heart scan scores DO drop, and sometimes drop enormous amounts, as it did for Neal.

    I would have liked the radiologist to have had the lightbulb of understanding go off in his head when he realized that a reduction in heart scan score is a cause for celebration. Unfortunately, this radiologist's reaction is all too common: disbelief, confusion, dismissal.

    Heart disease reversal is simply not in the realm of understanding of most doctors, radiologists and cardiologists alike. By conventional thought, if you have it, it just gets worse. "Maybe some high-dose Lipitor might help."

    Ironically, when they see it right in front of their eyes, plain as day on the computer screen, they don't understand what has happened. It's Greek to them.

    Should this happen to you, don't be surprised. Just bite your tongue, because you know better.

    Jimmy Moore Interview: Is saturated fat the villain we thought?

    Enter "weight loss" or "low carb" in your web search and you can't help but stumble across the prolific and widely-connected Jimmy Moore.

    On his Blog, Livin' la Vida Lo Carb , Jimmy conducts a wide-ranging and informative discussion of the benefits of a low carbohydrate diet, a la Atkins. Though his initial claim to fame was the 180 lbs he lost in his first year of dieting on this approach, Jimmy has extended the conversation and built a considerable community of like-minded individuals, all of whom are participating in this grand "experiment."

    Anybody who looks at lipoproteins and associated factors in health will quickly come to the conclusion that processed carbohydrates are the culprits in much of heart disease, diabetes, and heart disease. But I have had a hard time dismissing the ill-effects of saturated fat. After all, we've all been taught--drilled--with the idea that saturated fats cause LDL cholesterol to go higher, cause arterial constriction, growth of atherosclerotic plaque, inflammation, even cancer.

    But there does indeed seem to be a growing sentinment that this long-held dogma may not be true. So I went to the ever-entertaining and informative Jimmy Moore, an able spokesman for these concepts.




    TYP: It's certainly impossible to argue with the success you had in weight loss and the health you've regained on your program.

    I think that the approach we use in diet in the Track Your Plaque program and the nutrition approach you advocate overlap to a great extent. We both emphasize plenty of vegetables, fruits, healthy oils, nuts, etc. The major point of difference seems to lie in saturated fat: We say restrict it, you say don't restrict it. Could you elaborate?





    JM: Thank you for inviting me to your blog today, Dr. Davis. I have nothing but deep respect and admiration for the work you are doing to help educate others about how to keep their heart health in tip-top shape. Keep fighting the good fight, my friend.

    While we do agree on probably 99% of the basic tenets of what I describe as
    "livin' la vida low-carb," the issue of saturated fat to me is one where we
    indeed do not. It's not a deal breaker regarding my support for what you do
    just as I'm sure you would say the same regarding your backing of what I do. If
    we all agreed on everything, then what a boring world this would be!

    My thinking on saturated fat has evolved since I started eating this way nearly
    four years ago. Like most people, I was terrified to eat ANY fat at all because
    of the abject fear that people like Dr. Dean Ornish and other so-called health
    "experts" instilled in me about how dangerously unhealthy it is to consume it.
    This fat phobia is arguably the single biggest contributor to the ongoing
    obesity crisis our world faces today.

    With that said, you and I both know fat consumption is a part of a healthy
    lifestyle. There are just too many benefits to the body that come from the
    consumption of fats and even saturated fats such as coconut oil, butter, lard,
    nuts, seeds, and animal fat when it is combined with a restricted carbohydrate
    intake.

    An intriguing study was presented at a scientific conference in November 2006 by two highly-respected researchers--Dr. Stephen Phinney from the University of California at Davis and Dr. Jeff Volek from the University of Connecticut--who conducted a side-by-side comparison of the amount of saturated fat in the blood of people on a low-carb diet with those following those highly-touted low-fat diets. What they found was the low-carb study participants had "significantly less" saturated fat in their blood than the low-fatties did.

    Here are the actual numbers from the study:

    - LOW-FAT/HIGH-CARB DIETERS: lowered saturated fat by 24%
    - LOW-CARB/HIGH-FAT DIETERS: lowered saturated fat by 57%
    - Eating 3X the saturated fat cut the amount in the blood in half

    In an interview I conducted at my blog with Dr. Volek last year (here's the
    link: http://livinlavidalocarb.blogspot.com/2006/09/volek-high-carb-low-fat-diet-useless-to.html),
    he said the conventional wisdom regarding fat, especially saturate fat, is dead
    wrong while the significance of carbs is all but ignored by those who claim to
    understand the metabolic response mechanism.

    Here's what Dr. Volek said in my interview:

    "Eating fat does not make you fat, storing fat makes you fat. And carbohydrates play a major role in storing fat. So the level of dietary carbohydrate is really the most important factor to control because it dictates what happens to fat. Carbs are dominant and fat is passive. When carbohydrates are low, fat tends to be burned, and when carbohydrates are high dietary fat tends to be stored. The same holds true for the atherogenic effects of saturated fat. The body handles saturated fat better when carbohydrates are low."

    Long-time low-carb practitioner and current President of the American Society of Bariatric Physicians (ASBP) Dr. Mary C. Vernon from Lawrence, Kansas confirms the findings of Dr. Volek and Dr. Phinney in a succinct recap of what their research showed.

    Here's what she said:

    "Eating fat (whatever kind) does not make you fat. It does not increase blood
    stream saturated fat. Eating carbs does make you fat. Eating carbs does put
    saturated fat in your blood stream."

    To me, as a simple layperson with no medical background, it's all a matter of who you believe. Do we continue to buy into the low-fat propaganda machine and assume that what they are telling us about saturated fat is true? Or do we instead start paying closer attention to the latest research that is coming out about saturated fat that doesn't exactly line up with the edicts of the last three decades? The choice for me is a simple one.

    And if you haven't read the brand new Gary Taubes book entitled GOOD CALORIES, BAD CALORIES yet, then it is REQUIRED reading to arm yourself with the research studies about fat. After you read that book, it will be almost impossible for ANYONE to believe fat, including saturated fat, is unhealthy.



    TYP: In our program, we advocate a wheat-free approach for many people, because of the addictive potential of wheat products, as well as the flagrant creation of the small LDL pattern that wheat products create, thereby adding to atherosclerotic plaque growth. However, many people express a concern over a lack of fiber in their diets if they eliminate whole wheat bread, pasta, Fiber One, Raisin Bran cereal, etc.

    Have you encountered any phenomena of low-fiber on your approach?

    JM: What an excellent question and I even wrote a humorous blog post about the importance of fiber intake called "Allow Your Bowel To Shake, Rattle, And Roll" (http://livinlavidalocarb.blogspot.com/2006/06/allow-your-bowel-to-shake-rattle-and.html).

    Fiber consumption is another one of those issues that not everyone who advocates
    a controlled-carb approach agrees is necessary. I'm on the side that it IS a healthy part of your diet and should be consumed in high enough quantities to keep you regular...something many people think is impossible on a low-carb diet.
    Not true! I take a fiber supplement like FiberCon, eat plenty of high-fiber vegetables, drink lots of water, and even consume high-fiber, low-carb products that help me maintain high levels of fiber in my diet (see my favorite ones in this post: http://livinlavidalocarb.blogspot.com/2007/04/there-are-plenty-of-low-carb-fiber.html).

    As for consuming the highly-touted "healthy whole grain" cereals that you
    mentioned, what a travesty that would be for people trying to manage their
    weight and health. While the cereal manufacturers have had a heyday in their
    marketing efforts promoting their whole grain content, it's all just a big fat
    ruse on the public trying to convince them that these cereals are somehow healthy for their bodies. Sure, they're better than the sugary cereals, but all those grains are metabolized as sugar inside the body, so you might as well be eating Lucky Charms and Fruit Loops!

    Many of these "healthy" cereals contain as many carbohydrates in a single bowl
    without the milk as I would eat in an entire day. Raisin Bran, for example, which used to be my favorite cereal before my low-carb lifestye, has a whopping 47 grams of carbohydrates. Needless to say, I don't touch that with a ten-foot pole nowadays because I would surely gain weight and get back on the blood sugar rollercoaster ride that I was on prior to beginning the Atkins diet on January 1, 2004. Plus, all those carbs just make you hungrier sooner, so it's better just to eat some delicious eggs cooked in butter, a couple of slices of sausage, and tomato slices to start your day off right. You'll get enough fiber in your body the rest of your day.



    TYP: 180 lbs of weight loss in your first year is absolutely astounding.

    I take it that you've continued this trend and have lost more weight since your early success. What role did exercise play during your first year and subsequently?
    How are your food choices today different from that first year?

    JM: Yes, that weight loss was indeed one of the greatest accomplishments I have ever experienced in my life. It was a hard-fought battle that even included a 10-week period where I was stalled with no weight loss. But I knew my chosen diet was the right one for me because I felt better than I ever had on a diet, was never hungry because I ate every 2-3 hours, and could see myself doing this for the rest of my life. So far, so good!

    It has been close to four years since I began this journey and I am indeed continuing this pathway to better health. My low weight in 2004 was 230 pounds and I currently weigh 225 pounds. As long as I keep my carbs reduced, I am able to maintain my weight right where it is. I've had minor fluctuations in both directions where I got down to as low as 215 pounds at one point (but didn't feel good at that weight) and as high as 252 pounds (when I was allowing myself one too many high-carb foods here and there).

    There's a balance that people need to find for themselves and it's different for
    all of us. I am one of the unlucky people who has to keep his carbohydrate
    intake below 50g daily or I gain. It's just a fact of life that I've come to
    grips with and realize is a necessity in order to manage my weight for the rest
    of my life. But I wouldn't have it any other way!

    Exercise was indeed a part of my low-carb weight loss success in 2004 as I
    forced myself to do cardio every single day as a commitment to this journey. In
    hindsight, that was probably not the best thing for me to do since the body has
    a rather peculiar way of telling you it needs to wiggle and move spontaneously
    on its own rather than forcing the issue. But I consider the exercise I did to
    be such an integral part of my success that I dedicated an entire chapter of my
    book to the subject.

    Today, my daily cardio routine is out the window and I choose instead to engage
    in activities outside the gym that let me burn calories and have some fun in the
    process. I regularly play volleyball, basketball, and referee flag football at
    my church which all give me quite a workout. I'm very physically active and fit
    on my 6'3" body and just enjoy burning off all this excess energy that I have
    been given since losing nearly have my weight! I do want to get into a little
    more organized resistance training routine soon to try to shape and tone some
    areas of my body that still show signs of that 410-pound man I used to be
    (although the loose, hanging skin in my abdomen and inner thighs isn't going to
    get any better with exercise since the elasticity has been ruined from being
    stretched out so far). Here is a link to some posts and pictures I have written
    about this subject:
    http://lowcarblinks.blogspot.com/2007/04/theme-based-low-carb-links-loose-skin.html

    As for my food choices today compared to my weight loss year in 2004, they
    haven't really changed a whole lot. This was a lifestyle change in every sense
    of the phrase and I've learned to implement this way of eating into a permanent
    and healthy diet that I can and will gladly live with forever and ever amen. I
    probably eat more berries, melons, and nuts today than I did then, but otherwise
    it's the identical diet.



    TYP: I'm sure that you are as impressed as I am that much of the wisdom in healthy eating doesn't always come from doctors or clinical studies, but from the collective wisdom that emerges from this national experiment (inadvertent, for the most part) in eating. Your Livin' La Vida Low-Carb is, in my view, a perfect example of the sort of wisdom that is helping all of us understand what happened to our health over the last 20 years.

    Does the approach you advocate today differ in any substantial way from the diet as originally articulated by Dr. Atkins?

    JM: Actually, my personal diet is precisely based on the teaching of the late great Dr. Robert C. Atkins in his classic bestseller DR. ATKINS' NEW DIET REVOLUTION (DANDR) book. But most people are surprised when they learn I do not necessarily advocate the Atkins diet as the nutritional approach for everyone.

    Nope, I sure don't!

    Instead, my philosophy is simple: Find the diet plan that will work for YOU, read and research everything you can about that chosen plan, follow that plan exactly as prescribed by the author of that book, and then KEEP doing that plan for the rest of your life. If you do that, then there's no reason why you can't succeed just like I did.

    Anyone interested in doing the low-carb lifestyle and needs help finding which
    plan is right for them, let me HIGHLY encourage you to pick up a copy of Dr. Jonny Bowden's LIVING THE LOW-CARB LIFE (read my review: http://livinlavidalocarb.blogspot.com/2005/05/must-have-book-for-everybody-doing-low.html).
    It's the perfect overview of low-carb living with a comparison and recap of the
    major plans.

    THANK YOU again for allowing me to share my story with you and your readers, Dr.
    Davis!

    TYP: And thanks to you, Jimmy!



    For more on Jimmy Moore's lively and informative discussion of these issues, go to

    Livin' la Vida Lo Carb

    Also, watch "Livin' La Vida Low-Carb on YouTube"

    Join the conversation at Jimmy's new low-carb forum called "Livin' La Vida
    Low-Carb Discussion
    " at LowCarbDiscussion.com


    Also, Jimmy's 2005 book on his weight loss experience:
    "Livin' La Vida Low-Carb: My Journey From Flabby Fat To
    Sensationally Skinny In One Year"

    Mammogram of the heart

    Some people have called CT heart scans the "mammogram of the heart." The analogy contains a lot of wisdom.

    First of all, both--mammograms and CT heart scans--are screening tests, one for cancer, of course, the other for coronary atherosclerotic plaque. Both are performed in specific age groups, mammograms in women 40 years and over (generally), heart scans in women 50 years and over (generally).


















    Mammograms: Left, normal; right, a small mass. (Courtesy Nat'l Institutes of Health and Wikipedia.)



    Both are also meant to be repeated periodically when normal as a surveillance process.

    Both use low quantities of radiation of about 0.3-0.4 mSv (the most real-life measure of total body exposure), a modest quantity of radiation.

    Both are good for their purposes, though not perfect. Can a mammogram performed properly miss a small cancerous mass? Sure it can, but it's still unusual. Can a CT heart scan miss the non-calcified plaque prone to rupture? Sure it can, but this is also unlikely (<5% probability).

    Given the exorbitant costs of medical tests, both are quite inexpensive. On the flip side, they are both also quite unprofitable for the centers providing the tests. Unfortunately, this means that mammography centers and heart scan centers come and go because of the difficulties of the profit-side of these services.

    Both tests initially struggled to gain acceptance among the medical community. In 1960, for instance, mammograms were performed on standard x-ray devices, the same as that used to perform chest x-rays--low precision, high radiation back then. In 1969, dedicated mammography devices made the scene. However, it took over 10 years for even these new dedicated devices to become widely used. Use of mammograms has gradually increased over the ensuing 20 years. In other words, 47 years have passed since the introduction of mammography.

    CT heart scans, of course, have had a shorter history of approximately 20 years, since engineer, Dr. Douglas Boyd, first invented the "ultra-fast" EBT devices, the first devices with sufficient scanning speed to scan the heart and coronary arteries.

    One interesting difference between the two: In a woman between the age of 50 and 60, the likelihood of detecting cancer is 1 in 237. The likelihood of detecting coronary atherosclerotic plaque? About 1 in 4. Coronary disease eventually kills 1 in 3 females, hugely overshadowing breast cancer in frequency.


    Progress on both fronts, one in cancer detection, the other in atherosclerotic coronary plaque detection. But still lots more progress to go.

    Dr. Susie Rockway on conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)

    I’m fascinated by the perspectives that nutritionists (free-thinking ones, at least), food scientists, and biochemists bring on nutrition and nutritional supplements.

    A few months ago, I met a fascinating nutritionist/biochemist named Susie Rockway, PhD. Dr. Rockway brings a world of experience in the world of nutritional supplements, clinical trials with supplements, and their development. She has special expertise in conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), having been among the scientists who initially developed CLA as a supplement. We are also exploring CLA as a possible addition to the Track Your Plaque program and wanted to get Dr. Rockway’s perspectives.

    So I asked Dr. Rockway if she’d answer a few questions for us.






    TYP: Dr. Rockway, we understand that you are particularly excited about the prospects of CLA for FAT loss and perhaps for regression of atherosclerosis. Can you tell us about the origins of your interest in CLA and why you're so enthusiastic?

    Dr. Rockway: I have been fascinated with this unique fatty acid since the early 1990’s when CLA was first being discussed as nature’s most potent anti-carcinogen. I was then working in the granting/funding section of the National Dairy Council and saw this molecule as truly one of the future functional fats that would likely benefit people (next to omega-3’s!)

    I think the benefits of CLA have just begun to be investigated—animal studies are extraordinary for showing fat reduction, lean mass (muscle) increases, immune enhancements, blood glucose normalization, anti-inflammatory properties and plaque reduction!

    Human data to date is very encouraging for fat reduction. As a nutritionist seeing the massive increase in abdominal fat (stomach fat) in the world population and the direct relationship to cardiovascular disease, I see CLA as a great supplement to take to help this. Of course eating lots of vegetables, fruit, lean protein and whole grain products is also a must for maximizing good health.

    I am studying the impact of CLA in reducing muscle loss in aging women—a condition known as sarcopenia. As we lose muscle with age, we lose strength, falls increase, we become frailer, and eventually many of us lose our independence. Along with the muscle atrophy, most people gain fat—never a good thing! So, if CLA can reduce fat and increase muscle, our bodies are more likely to withstand the hurdles that life throws at us much more efficiently.

    So, how can you not be excited about this very bioactive molecule?




    TYP: What are your specific areas of interest in nutrition and health?

    Dr. Rockway: I strive to understand the role of bioactive molecules that can be taken to improve the aging process and enhance health.

    As a trained nutritional biochemist, we tend to look at cell metabolism in a very ideal sense: what we learned in our biochemistry texts years ago where all substrates, proteins, enzymes, etc. are made exactly when we need them, where all cells behave as they should.

    Unfortunately, little research has been devoted to understanding the changes in metabolism as we age. Do we still produce everything as efficiently as when we were 20? I suspect not. So, I think we need a little help, and supplements are a key to getting there.

    Two nutrients that I think are emerging as “super nutrients” are the fatty acids found in fish oil (EPA and DHA) and vitamin D. Where we know these two nutrients are essential for life, we are seeing that they play a huge role in the QUALITY of life. Mood, depression, PMS, wound healing, bone growth, atherosclerosis, and arthritis are clinical areas where we see a direct benefit with doses of omega-3 and Vitamin D that are probably much greater than the RDA. Our current requirements for nutrients are really based on fixing deficiencies and not maximizing health, and maximizing health is where I’m at.

    Thus, I am very interested molecules like CLA as mentioned above, and other bioactive ingredients such as plant derived ingredients (phytochemicals) called flavonoids that may well help explain why people who have diets high in fruits and vegetables are less likely to have certain cancers and heart disease. Reducing oxidative stress through foods that provide these active molecules (think colored fruits and veggies) is a new and exciting area of research.



    TYP:The big "diet experiment" in America has clearly steered people in the wrong direction, usually by 50 or more pounds. As a scientist in nutrition, what are your thoughts?

    Dr. Rockway: The American Heart Association was keen 20 years ago to promote the low-fat diet for all Americans as the key way to reduce cholesterol levels and decrease chance of heart disease, the number one killer of men and women. However, I must admit the nutritional community bought into this one, too. Unfortunately, the general public took this message to reduce percent fat in their diet (and they did a bit), but increased overall calories instead—and a large portion of the increased calories was from simple carbohydrates. I’m convinced that this in itself has been part of the huge rise in obesity…we simply eat more food and it’s not the healthy kind of food either.

    When you increase sugar intake beyond what you burn off, you will store some of it as glycogen in the liver and muscles, but you will convert most of the excess into fat—and that we can store very efficiently! The fat that is made in the liver is sent to the blood as VLDL’s which are the precursor to the class of lipids called low density lipoproteins (LDL) that are the “lethal” type of cholesterol circulating in our blood.

    So, Americans now have to listen to a new message that they need to eat more fruits and vegetables in hopes they will cut down on fast foods—tending to be high in fat (saturated particularly), low in fiber and low in nutrients and other high calorie dense foods. We nutritionists have our work cut out for us, that’s for sure.



    TYP: We are especially excited that nutritionists are assuming a leading role in shining light on the confusion in diet and nutrition that has characterized the last 40 years. Do you have a sense for the emerging important issues for the next 10 years?

    Dr. Rockway: Certainly, the scientists in the nutritional field are well aware of the problems facing this nation—it’s in fixing them that we fall short!

    We aren’t very well coordinated to get a single message out, nor do we all agree on what that message should be. I feel that people need to eat healthy MOST OF THE TIME, exercise all of the time, and take supplements that have clear evidence of benefit. Lots of my colleagues would not concur with supplement use. Our bodies were designed to move a lot and eat a lot…we just do the latter now and are paying the price!

    One emerging and very exciting area that we have to teach Americans is that all fat is not bad. The different types of fat—omega-6 vs. omega-3, are where we need to focus our education.

    Decreasing the corn oil we pour on everything needs to go out the window! Consume olive oil and eat fish or take fish oil supplements—we simply have tons and tons of research showing the benefits of reducing the ratio of omega-6 to omega-3. Did you know that cattle that are grass fed actually have less omega-6 in their tissues and more CLA? But most cattle are fed corn-based diets, so we have perturbed their natural selection of food and their fat composition.

    See, it all comes back to CLA!


    TYP: Thanks, Susie!




    Susie Rockway, Ph.D., C.N.S.

    Dr. Susie Rockway is an experienced scientist with accomplishments in both the academic and food and supplement industry business directing science/technology research. Her background includes faculty appointments at the graduate level in teaching and research at Rush University Medical Center and industrial experience managing basic and applied research studies.

    Dr. Rockway received her Ph.D. in Nutritional Sciences, Biochemistry from the University of Arizona. Dr. Rockway has authored several publications in journals such as the Physiological Genomics, Journal of Nutrition, the Journal of Food Science, International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health and has published chapters on nutrition on inflammatory bowel diseases. She is a member of the American Society for Nutrition, American Oil Chemists Society, the Institute of Food Technology, American College of Nutrition and is a Certified Nutrition Specialist.

    We're also proud to add Dr. Rockway to our panel of Track Your Plaque Experts.

    Which is better?

    If you have the common pattern of high LDL particle number (NMR) with small LDL--a pattern highly related to coronary plaque--which is better:




    Lipitor or a combination of fish oil, vitamin D, and elimination of wheat?


    Lipitor quite effectively reduces LDL particle number, usually on the order of 40% or so. Effect on LDL particle size: None. Side-effects: plenty, including muscle aches (inevitable in my experience, not the ridiculous 2% they claim) and occasionally mental effects such as impaired short-term memory.

    Lipitor does seem to exert a modest effect on reduction of C-reactive protein, around 30%. It also reduces cardiovascular events by 30%.



    A combination of fish oil, vitamin D, and elimination of wheat:

    Reduces LDL particle number commonly by a similar 40% (though variable, depending on body weight). There is substantial improvement in LDL particle size, a large drop in C-reactive protein, often >50%, a 30% or more reduction in cardiovacular events.



    On this combination, however, you also:

    --Lose weight, often substantially.

    --Improve bone health, esp. osteoporosis and arthritis.

    --Reduce cancer risk from the vit D supplementation.

    --Reduce risk of stroke.

    --Reduce postprandial (after-eating) abnormalities like intermediate-density lipoprotein.

    --Reduce winter blues.

    --Experience more energy.

    --Obtain increased clarity of thought (from elimination of wheat).

    --Reduce blood pressure.


    Oh, and there's no muscle aches.

    Heart health for stupid people

    I'm kidding.

    What I'm referring to is the incredibly lame information I come across that passes as "heart health" on the internet, magazines, and other media. Just to keep abreast of what is being said, I subscribe to multiple newsletters and magazines and I witness the sorts of advice offered to the reading public.

    A recent long-winded article on a popular website listed the "exciting" strategies available for a healthy heart:

    Eat healthy--by eating a "balanced" diet low in saturated fat

    Don't smoke

    Exercise

    Don't ignore chest pain symptoms or breathlessness

    Know your numbers! meaning your cholesterol numbers. "If your cholesterol is high, you may need to speak to your doctor about medication to reduce it."


    Surely they must all believe we're stupid. Otherwise, why would they repeat the same obvious information over and over again? Quit smoking? Gee, you think so?

    How about some real heart healthy advice:

    Get a heart scan--since we have to accept that cholesterol values are a miserable failure in detecting hidden heart disease. So is waiting for symptoms to appear.

    If you have any measure of coronary plaque, ask your doctor to assess lipoproteins, not lipids (cholesterol).

    Take fish oil for omega-3 fatty acids--At a dose of 1000 mg or more of EPA + DHA, heart attack risk is reduced by at least 28%.

    Eliminate wheat and other processed carbohydrates --Small LDL has emerged as the number one cause of coronary plaque, not high cholesterol from saturated fat.

    Get vitamin D assessed--The effects are huge--HUGE. There's already a study in a kidney disease population that showed a substantial reduction in mortality with vitamin D supplementation. More data are coming, including our own.


    That's a start--truly effective, practical heart healthy strategies that go way beyond the conventional bland advice.


    Copyright 2007 William Davis, MD

    Money, money, money, money

    I've been asked the question numerous times:

    Why aren't heart scans more popular?

    First, let me qualify by saying that heart scan have indeed grown in popularity over the past decade. I think the real question is:

    Given the enormous usefulness of CT heart scanning to detect hidden, asymptomatic coronary atherosclerotic plaque, why haven't they more readily been incorporated into conventional medical practice?

    That's easy: There's no money in it.


    Say, for instance, your doctor orders a heart scan and somehow receives a $1000 for the test. Scan centers would be scanning 100 people a day, falling over themselves to do scans.

    This would be similar to a heart catheterization. Order a catheterization, do 30 minutes of work, and get $1000. Or, order a nuclear stress test. Depending on how its done and where, $1800-4000 is paid by the insurer.

    Order a CT heart scan and how much is paid to the doctor? Usually nothing. At most, a nominal fee might be paid if the doctor reads the scan.

    With heart scans, there simply is no big payoff.

    We learned the implications of this situation 10 years ago when I was trying to help my friend, Steve Burlingame, the owner of Milwaukee Heart Scan. (I am NOT and NEVER WAS an owner.) Steve was trying to let everybody know about this great new $2 million dollar heart scan device in the Milwaukee area.

    The first few years were tough for Steve: Carrying the substantial expense of this device while doctors essentially gave the technology the cold shoulder. It simply did not fit into the financial equation. Why change the way things were, particularly when there was virtually no financial reason to do so? To counter this, Milwaukee Heart Scan followed the model many other scan centers have followed and marketed directly to the public.

    I see this as yet another example of why people need to take control of health care away from doctors and hospitals, the current controllers of the system who are providing a disservice to the public they are supposed to be serving. These institutions, for the most part, serve their self-serving financial interests, not your health interests. It's the same equation that drives food manufacturers to make more and more processed carbohydrate foods that they sell for substantial markups, not green peppers and cucumbers that make little money.

    I regard heart scans as among the greatest self-empowering tools in health ever conceived. It was that way in 1997; it remains that way in 2007.

    The many faces of LDL

    Ginnie came in for an opinion about her heart scan score of 393. At age 57, this put her in the 99th percentile, a high score.

    As usual, we did a lipoprotein analysis by NMR (Liposcience). Some numbers:

    LDL cholesterol: 96 mg/dl
    This value puts Ginnie's LDL in the most favorable 25% in the country.


    LDL particle number: 2140 nmol/l
    This value is in the worst 25% of the country and is the equivalent of an LDL cholesterol of 214 mg/dl (take off the zero).

    In addition, over 90% of Ginnie's LDL particles fell into the small class.

    Had we run some other values, how would they have turned out? These are my estimates (since we didn't actually run them in Ginnie), but having run side-by-side numbers in past, reasonable estimates would have put:

    Apoprotein B somewhere in the 120 to 140 mg/dl range

    Direct LDL 100-130 mg/dl range.


    In other words, conventional calculated LDL is the least reliable of all the ways of examining low-density lipoprotein.

    It can also go the other way: High calculated LDL, low LDL particle number or ApoB or direct LDL. And, indeed, these other measures have proven superior in their ability to predict "events" like heart attack over conventional calculated LDL.

    Unfortunately, relying on conventional LDL is like a broken speedometer on your car. You really can't gauge accurately how fast you're going; sometimes you could be way off. While insurance companies and many physicians still continue to balk at this argument, the data have already been generated that show that lipoprotein analysis (my bias is NMR) is not just superior, but enormously superior for accuracy and event prediction.

    In addition, lipoprotein analysis has proven a crucial tool that accounts for our extraordinary success in reducing and controlling CT heart scan scores in the Track Your Plaque program. I doubt that we could have achieved the same level of success using conventional lipids.

    I'm also aware of the logistical difficulties obtaining lipoprotein testing in a world enthusiastically supportive of hospital procedures and smugly ignorant of superior prevention tools like lipoprotein analysis. I've learned just how difficult it can be in our Track Your Plaque Member Forum; I've also learned about some strategies for obtaining these tests that I hadn't been aware of, thanks to the resourcefulness of our Members.

    We will be working on some solutions in the coming months.


    Copyright 2007 William Davis, MD

    What does "Success" mean in the Track Your Plaque program?

    Say you begin with a CT heart scan score of 400.

    You correct your lipoprotein pattterns, take fish oil, correct 25-OH-vitamin D3 to 50 ng/ml, correct your other hidden patterns, follow a diet suited to your patterns.

    One year later, you get another heart scan. What score would constitute "success"?

    With all of our recent talk about record-setting reductions in heart scan scores, is it really necessary to drop your score that much to succeed?

    For instance, is our latest record-setting 63% drop in score better than "only" a 10% drop in score? Both represent reversal of coronary plaque. Both signify huge reductions in risk for plaque rupture, or heart attack.

    You can read about how we view the various forms of success in the program by reading our latest Track Your Plaque Special Report, Winning Your Personal War with Heart Disease: The Track Your Plaque 5 Stages of Success.

    We are making the Report available to everyone. Just go to the www.cureality.com homepage.

    Copyright © 2026 Cureality.com