Large new clinical study launched to study. . .niacin


Oxford University has issued a press release announcing plans for a new clinical trial to raise HDL cholesterol and reduce heart attack risk. 20,000 participants will be enrolled in this substantial effort. The agent? Niacin.

How is that new? Well, this time niacin comes with a new spin.

Dr. Jane Armitage, formerly with the Heart Protection Study that showed that simvastatin (Zocor) reduced heart attack risk regardless of starting LDL, is lead investigator. She hopes to prove that niacin raises HDL cholesterol and thereby reduces heart attack risk. But, this time, niacin will be combined with an inhibitor of prostaglandins that blocks the notorious "flushing" effect of niacin.

The majority of Track Your Plaque participants hoping to control or reverse coronary plaque take niacin. Recall that niacin (vitamin B3)is an extremely effect agent that raises HDL, dramatically reduces small LDL, shifts HDL particles into the effective large fraction, reduces triglycerides and triglyceride-containing particles like IDL and VLDL. Several studies have shown that niacin dramatically reduces heart attack. The HATS Study showed that niacin combined with Zocor yielded an 85-90% reduction in heart attack risk and achieved regression of coronary plaque in many participants.

In our experience, approximately 1 in 20 people will really struggle using niacin. Flushes for these occasional people will be difficult or even intolerable. Should Dr. Armitage's study demonstrate that this new combination agent does provide advantages in minimizing the hot flush effect, that will be a boon for the occasional Track Your Plaque participant who finds conventional niacin intolerable.

But you already have access to niacin, an agent with an impressive track record even without this new study. And you have a reasonably effective prostaglandin inhibitor, as well: aspirin. Good old aspirin is very useful, particularly in the first few months of your niacin initiation to blunt the flush.

Although this study is likely to further popularize niacin and allow its broader use, it's also a method for the drug companies to profit from an agent they know works but is cheap and available.

You don't have to wait. You already have niacin and aspirin available to you.

The dark side of CT heart scans

"I just got a heart scan!" declared Eric to his doctor. He handed the report to him.

"Oh my. Your score is 154." The doctor paused, then looked at Eric with a serious look on his face. "If we're going to understand whether or not you're in danger, you'll need a heart catheterization."


I've seen this happen countless times. How can I say this diplomatically? THIS IS WRONG!! In my view, it's absolutely criminal for this to happen. Physician ignorance, profiteering, whatever--it is wrong.

There's very few reasons why someone who has no symptoms should go directly to the cath lab for a procedure. (A rare exception might be an exceptional quantity of plaque in the left mainstem artery, e.g., >100. This is highly unusual.)

Even a nuclear stress test (e.g., thallium) at this level of scoring is only 10-15% likely to be abnormal. That means 85-90% likelihood of being normal. There's rare reasons to perform a heart catheterization in a person with no symptoms and an entirely normal stress test. The vast majority of people like Eric do not need a heart catheterization to discern risk.

If Eric's doctor had been up-to-date on the published literature on the prognostic value of heart scans, he could have advised Eric what the risks were--without a catheterization. Many doctors simply don't want to be bothered. Or, they opt for the more profitable method--a hospital procedure.

Always discuss your heart scan with your doctor--but be armed with information in case your doctor is uninformed or unscrupulous. Unfortunately, that's not uncommon. The Track Your Plaque program is your advocate, a source for unbiased information.

The dirty little secret about aneurysms

Jake had an abdominal aneurysm identified--by accident.

While getting a CT scan of his abdomen for unexplained abdominal pain, a 4.4 cm aneurysm was discovered. Jake's abdominal pain eventually passed without explanation, but he was left with this aneurysm.

Jake's primary care doctor referred him to a surgeon. "It's too small to require surgery right now. Wait a few years and it'll probably get bigger. When it gets to around 5.5 cm, that'll be the time to operate. Let's schedule an abdominal ultrasound or CT scan every 6 months."

Jake then got himself a heart scan. His high score of 879 then led him to my office. Lipoprotein testing, a stress test, correction of his lipoprotein patterns, changes in lifestyle followed. One year later, Jake's heart scan score was unchanged.

How about his abdominal aneurysm? 4.2 cm--a modest quantity of regression. When Jake's surgeon learned of the change, he just shrugged. "Okay, we'll just watch it from here."

Shockingly, the conversation surrounding aneurysms is just like the one Jake received: Let's just watch it grow until you need surgery.

If you've every seen anyone have abdominal aneurysm surgery, you know it is an awful, painful, barbaric process with high risk for major complications like kidney failure and loss of the legs. Waiting for an aneurysm to grow is a lousy solution. Surgeons point out that, although surgery is imperfect, it's better than the alternative: rupture, which is catastrophic with a 50% chance of dying.

But what about stopping the growth of the aneurysm? Or even reversing, or shrinking, it?

Surgeons say it can't be done. Yet we've done it--many times. And it's not that difficult.

The steps to take are very similar to that in the Track Your Plaque program for coronary plaque regression, with a few different strategies. Suppression of inflammation, for instance, plays a more important role and blood pressure must be abolutely normal, even during exercise.

More to come on this important topic in the future, including an upcoming Special Report on the www.cureality.com membership website.

Heart scan scores dropping like stones!!

I saw two instances of dramatic coronary plaque regression today.

John, a 53-years old mechanical lift operator, dropped his heart scan score from 479 to 323--a 32% regression of coronary plaque volume!

Eric, a 50-year consulting engineer, dropped his heart scan score from 668 to 580--a 13% reduction.

Both men did nothing special beyond the principles advocated in the Track Your Plaque program. Recall that, without preventive efforts, your heart scan score is expected to increase by 30% per year. Both men are well on their way to freedom from risk of coronary "events".

Two less people to feed the revenue-hungry hospital procedure system! We need many more like them.

Pre-diabetes: An explanation for explosive coronary plaque growth

Art's first CT heart scan in March, 2006 yielded a concerning score of 1336. He felt fine--no chest discomfort, no breathlessness, etc.

Art agreed to take the statin cholesterol drug his primary care doctor prescribed. He also agreed to take the fish oil, niacin, and some of the nutritional supplements that we advised. But Art just couldn't bring himself to make the commitment to lose weight.

At the start of his program, Art--at 5 ft. 8 inches--was 40 lbs overweight (212 lb). This was important since his blood sugar wavered in the pre-diabetic range, going as high as 130 mg. (The American Diabetes Assn. defines diabetes as a blood glucose of 126 mg or greater.)

One year later, Art's lipid and lipoprotein values were corrected to perfection. But he still weighed in at a hefty 209 lbs--essentially no change. His blood sugar likewise hovered in the 120's.

I felt Art need to be prodded, so I asked him to undergo another heart scan. His score: 1935--a 600 point increase, or 45%!

Only now has Art begun to comprehend to power of diabetes and pre-diabetes to fan the flames of plaque growth. Recent published data, in fact, show that the majority of recently diagnosed diabetics already have well-established coronary artery disease.

Don't let this happen to you. Do not dismiss diabetic patterns as they will catch up to you. If Art can lose the 30-40 lbs in the abdominal weight that is creating the diabetic pattern, he will likely succeed in stopping plaque growth. Otherwise, it's just a matter of time before his heart attack, stent, or bypass.

Who cares if you're pre-diabetic?

Marta is a smart lady. She's worked in hospital laboratories for the last 23 years and knows many of the ins and outs of lab tests and their implications.

After years of being told that her cholesterol was acceptable, she needed to undergo urgent bypass surgery after experiencing severe breathlessness that proved to be a small warning heart attack at age 57. But this made Marta skeptical of relying on cholesterol to identify heart disease risk.

I met Marta two years after her bypass surgery when she was seeking better answers. And, indeed, she proved to have several concealed sources of heart disease: small LDL particles, Lipoprotein(a), intermediate-density lipoprotein (IDL--a very important abnormality that means she is unable to clear dietary fats from her blood), among others. But she was also mildly diabetic with a blood sugar of 131 mg (normal < or = 100 mg). This had not been previously recognized.

As I'm a cardiologist and our program focuses on reversal and control of coronary plaque, I asked Marta to return to her primary care doctor to continue the conversation about diabetes. She was a bit frightened but followed through.

"Well, you're not urinating excessively. And your long-term measure of blood sugar, hemoglobin A1C, is still normal. I wouldn't worry about it. We'll just watch it."

I guess I should know better. What the poor primary care doctor doesn't know is that pre-diabetes and mild diabetes are potent risks for heart disease. In fact, some of the most explosive rates of plaque growth occur when these patterns are present. It's well established that risk for heart attack in a diabetic is the same as that of someone who's already suffered a prior heart attack--very high risk, in other words.

Marta's primary care doctor's advice would be like inquiring about cancer and the doctor says "Let's just wait until it's metastatic--then we'll start to worry." Of course, this is insane.

Pre-diabetes and mild diabetes should not be ignored or just "watched". Even though the blood sugar itself may not be high enough to endanger you, the hidden patterns underlying your body's unresponsiveness to insulin creates a torrent of hidden coronary risk.

For better answers, Track Your Plaque members can read "Shutting Off Metabolic Syndrome" at http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_dp001metabolic.asp on the www.cureality.com website. ("Metabolic syndrome" is the name commonly given to the constellation of abnormalities associated with pre-diabetes and diabetes.)

Don't get smug!

It may sound silly, but after someone succeeds in stopping their heart scan score from increasing or reduces their score, I warn them to not get smug. Let me explain.

I'll tell you about Jack. I met Jack a few years ago after he had a heart scan at age 39. His score: 1441! A score this high at his age obviously puts him in the 99th percentile. Also recall that a score >1000 carries a 25% annual risk for heart attack.

This captured Jack's attention. At the start, his lipoproteins were disastrous with numerous abnormal patterns. Jack committed to the program. After one year, his lipoproteins were around 80-90% corrected towards perfection. He'd lost 27 lbs, was exercising six days a week, and felt great.

Jack's repeat score one year later: 1107--over a 300 point drop! A huge success. He was ecstatic.

Unfortunately, work and life in general distracted him. Jack allowed himself to drift back to old habits, indulging in fast food 2 or 3 times a week, slacking on exercise such that it became sporadic, half-hearted efforts, and regained 15 lbs. He even failed to show up for appointments and we lost contact for two years.

One day, Jack simply decided to see where he stood, so he got himself another heart scan. The score: 2473--over a doubling from his reduced score.

The message: Long-term consistency is key, even after you've achieved control over your score. Stick with your program--and don't get smug!

Holidays are dangerous!

If you're on holiday from work today, make sure you're not on holiday from your health, too.

Too often, people come back to the office telling me that the holidays simply got out of hand--cookouts, picnics, family gatherings, etc.--and they simply couldn't avoid overeating, overdrinking, sitting around--and gaining 3-5 lbs in a weekend. (Our record is 10 lbs in a weekend!)

I don't want to harp on this issue and ruin your holiday, but I can't stress how important it is that you don't allow this to happen to you. Weight gained in a brief space of time has exceptionally destructive effects. Ever see the movie "Super Size Me"? It's an entertaining and well-done yet graphic portrayal of the damaging effects of rapid weight gain.

Enjoy your time off. Relax, enjoy your family and friends--but continue to pay attention to choosing the right foods, don't overeat, take time out to do something (or several things) physical. It'll pay off hugely in the long run.

More on carotid plaque...

Although not a perfect test, carotid ultrasound is an exceptionally easy and accessible test. Using high-frequency sound, clear images are available for most people.

I say it's not perfect because the way it's done in 2006 makes it a non-quantitative test. It is a qualitative test. In other words, you may find out that there's a 30% blockage ("stenosis"), at the far end of the common carotid artery on the right side. Unfortunately, this gives you an isolated measure of diameter of the plaque compared to the artery. What it does not tell you is what the volume of the entire plaque is. That's a far more accurate measure (and one that is incorporated into your heart scan score, by the way).

Nonetheless, carotid ultrasound is easy, very safe, and available in most hospitals and many clinics. One difficulty: most insurance companies will not allow you to go through a carotid ultrasound scan as a "screening" procedure, i.e., a test just to see if you have a carotid plaque. They will generally pay if you're having symptoms of a stroke or "mini-stroke" (transient ischemic attack, or "TIA"), have an abnormal sound in your carotid ultrasound detected by your doctor (a carotid "bruit"), or some other unusual indications. Sometimes, a resourceful physician will muster up a diagnosis based on something in your history (e.g., left arm numbness, a common and often benign complaint that can also signal stroke).

Another option are the mobile scanners or some hospital services that offer carotid screening, usually for a very modest price. Drawback: Sporadic availability, difficulty in obtaining serial scans, and imprecise reporting since it's viewed as a screening test. But it's better than nothing.

My hope is that, as screening services using safe imaging techniques like ultrasound propagate and increase in direct availability to the public, you'll be able to circumvent the obstacles imposed by your insurance company and even, sometimes, your doctor. But try your doctor first.

Carotid plaque can be shrunk

Rose, a 64-year old woman, just had a 70% carotid blockage identified by a screening ultrasound. When the result was given to her doctor, he prescribed Lipitor and told Rose that an ultrasound would be required every year. She would need carotid surgery, an "endarterectomy", if the blockage worsened.

"Can't I reduce the amount of blockage I have?" asked Rose.

"No. Once you've got it, it doesn't get any better."


Is this true? Once you've got carotid plaque, you can only expect it to get worse and it can't be reduced?

This is absolutely not true. In fact, compared to coronary plaque, carotid plaque is easier to reduce!

Of course, the Track Your Plaque program is designed to help you control or reduce coronary plaque. But, in our experience, people who have both coronary and carotid plaque will show far greater and faster reduction of carotid plaque. Dramatic reductions are sometimes seen. I've personally seen 50-70% blockages reduced to <30% on many occasions.

The requirements to achieve reduction of carotid plaque are very similar to the approach we use to reduce coronary plaque. One difference is that hypertension may play a more important role with carotid plaque and needs to be reduced confidently to the normal range before carotid plaque is controlled.

I find it shocking that the attitude like the one provided by this physician continue to prevail. Unlike coronary plaque, which has a relatively small body of scientific literature documenting how it can be reduced, carotid plaque actually enjoys a substantial clinical literature. Part of the reason is that the carotids are more easily imaged using ultrasound. (Heart structures can be seen with ultrasound, but not the coronary arteries.)

Numerous agents have been shown to contribute to reduction of carotid plaque: statin drugs, niacin, fish oil, the anti-diabetic "TZD" drugs (Actos, Avandia), several anti-hypertensive drugs, vitamin E, pomegranate juice, and several others.

It outrages me to hear stories like this. Rose is not the only one.

Don't accept the flip dismissals or the over-enthusiastic referral for carotid procedures. Insist on a conversation about plaque regression.


Note: Although I am a vigorous advocate of atherosclerotic plaque regression, this does not mean that if you have a severe (70% blockage or greater), or if there are symptoms from your carotid disease, that you should engage in a program of reversal. You must always take the advice of your doctor if your safety is in question.
All posts by william-davis

Heart disease reversal is getting easier and easier

I've recently observed that more and more of our patients on the Track Your Plaque program seem to be stopping or reducing their heart scan scores. And they're doing it faster, in less time, and with larger drops in score.

I'm not entirely sure why the sudden surge in success. However, I do wonder if adding therapeutic levels of vitamin D--at least in our generally sun-deprived Wisconsin participants--is responsible. However, we've also gotten a lot smarter on how to correct the parameters that seems to have outsized effects on plaque growth, especially small LDL.

Yesterday alone, we had two people we added to our list of successes. One, an attorney, stopped his score in one year, with no change (compared to the expected increase of 30%). Another, a woman from the northeast, dropped her score 10% in one year. Her story is remarkable for beginning at a score >1000. In general, the higher your starting score, the longer it takes to stop or reduce it.

These are just two examples. It seems to be happening at an accelerating pace.

I can only hope that our surge in success (not 100%--yet!) will continue. But, every week, we're adding more and more people to our list of success stories.

A used car lot on every street corner

Imagine that, every day, a parade of used-car salesmen knock on your front door to sell you a special "deal". Day in, day out they knock, expecting you to hear about their offers openly.

Is there any doubt about their intentions or motives? Of course not. They're just trying to profit from selling you a car.

That's how it is in a medical office nowadays. Drug representatives, 5, 6, or more each and every day, promoting drugs. Except that the profits from drugs are far greater than a used automobile, and there's a third party involved in the transaction: you.

Today, a pushy representative came to my office. My staff and I tried to tell him that I was not interested in speaking to him. But he proved such a nuisance that I finally came out to tell him that I objected to the idea of drug reps just hanging around trying to hawk their wares.

He blurted, "Doctor, do you have patients with angina? Our new drug, ranolazine, is perfect. Forget about nitroglycerin, beta blockers, and all that. Here's the latest study proving it's better." He tried to shove a reprint of the study at me.

Getting to the bottom line, I asked, "What does it cost the patient?"

"Well, the co-pay is between $40 and $60. We're not yet well covered by insurance, so it'll cost patients around $200 a month."

Need I say more? Here's a drug that does little more than help relieve anginal chest pains. It doesn't reverse coronary plaque. It won't avoid heart attack, death, or procedures. It just modestly cuts back on the frequency of chest pain. And all for the cost of a single heart scan--a heart scan that could have prevented the entire cascade of symptoms/procedures/medication/hospitalization etc.

Hospitals, drug companies, medical device manufacturers. They're all businesses that thrive on your doctor's failure to detect and control your coronary plaque. Sometimes, even your doctor is part of this conspiracy to squeeze dollars out of human disease. Don't fall for it.

Heart disease reversal at age 77

I met Agnes 18 months ago after she underwent a heart scan that revealed a scary score of over 1100. Although in her mid-70s, this was still a very high score. (Recall that a score this high carries a risk for heart attack and death of 25% per year.) Poor Agnes was a wreck over this unexpected result. "I can't sleep, I can't stop thinking about it!"

She'd undergone the scan because her 44-year old son had a heart scan score of 2200! Unfortunately, he ended up with a bypass operation for very severe disease.

Despite having been seeing a cardiologist in Boston for the last 8 years for a murmur, we uncovered multiple hidden lipoprotein patterns, many of which she shared with her son. Her most notable abnormalities were a low HDL and small LDL. Nearly 100% of all LDL particles were, in fact, small. This pattern also caused her LDL cholesterol to be underestimated by over 40%.

18 months on the Track Your Plaque program and Agnes came into town to get a repeat scan. Her score was 10.2% lower. She'd learned to live with the idea that she had hidden heart disease missed by her doctor and cardiologist for many years. But knowledge of the substantial reversal she'd achieved in the 18 months on the program gave Agnes tremendous peace of mind.

Agnes left the office with a big smile.

If you need a reason to quit smoking...

If you've read Track Your Plaque, you already know my feelings about smoking and coronary plaque. Smoke, and you will lose the battle for control over coronary plaque growth--it will grow and grow until catastrophe strikes.

Nonetheless, this is not sufficiently motivating for some people.

If you need more motivation to quit smoking, just take a look at your heart scan sometime, accompanied by either one of the doctors or technicians at the scan center you choose. After you've had an opportunity to look at your coronary arteries, take a look at the lungs. The heart is in the middle and the lungs are the two large black areas on either side of the heart. (They're not really black; that's just the way the images are color-coded.)

Smokers will see large cavities in their lungs--literally, half-inch to one-inch wide holes that contain only air. Many of them. These represent remnants of lung tissue, digested away and now useless from the damage incurred through smoking.

Non-smokers should see uniform lung tissue without such cavities.

What surprised me early on in my heart scan experience was how little smoking exposure was required to generate these cavities. A 40-year old, for instance, who smoked a half-pack per day for 10 years would have them. Heavier smokers, of course, showed far more extensive cavities.

Officially, these cavities are called "emphysematous blebs", meaning the scars of the lung disease, emphysema.

When I've pointed out these cavities or emphysematous blebs to patients, 9 out of 10 times they immediately become non-smokers. Commonly, they'd exclaim, "I had no idea I was really damaging my lungs!" Most admitted that they were awaiting some bona fide evidence that they were truly doing some harm to their bodies. Well, that's it.

Give it a try if you're struggling.

Vitamin D for winter blues?

Winter is now over and spring is in the air, even in Wisconsin.

In this part of the country, winter blues are commonplace. Sometimes called Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) when it's severe enough to cause functional impairment, feelings of fatigue, lack of motivation, or the blues are very frequent when days are short and sunlight is in short supply.

I've been seeing many people in the last several weeks who were advised to add vitamin D to their program last fall. Christopher's experience was typical.

"You know, since you told me to take vitamin D, I didn't get sad and tired like I do every winter. This is the first time I can remember that happening. I didn't sleep as much and I didn't get that feeling of always being overwhelmed."

I've felt it myself this past winter. I think there's some real truth to this effect.

Dr. Bruce Hollis has published a small experience in treating people with SAD with vitamin D and showed measurable improvement in depression. (One recent study in older women failed to show any effect, however, when small doses of vitamin D of 800 units were administered. In my experience, this dose doesn't even come close to normalizing blood vitamin D levels.)

The best source for in-depth information on vitamin D is Dr. John Cannell's website, www.vitaminDcouncil.com. If you've read Dr. Cannell's discussion on the Track Your Plaque website, you know that he is an articulate spokesman for the benefits of vitamin D replacement. He also persuasively argues that vitamin D deficiency is rampant in northern climates and in people who don't get frequent sun exposure. Interestingly, we now have two studies of populations in Florida and one in Hawaii, both of which showed substantial percentages of people even in these tropical climates to be deficient in vitamin D (around 50% in Hawaii and 30% in Florida).

The dose we've used with much success is 2000 units per day in females, 3000 units per day in males. This yields normal blood levels of around 50 ng/dl in around 80-90% of people. Occasional people will require more, some less. The best way to do it is to check a baseline blood level and a level on therapy to determine the adequacy of your dose.

Dr. Cannell will tell you that it's very important to have your doctor check the right test: 25-OH-vitamin D3, not 1,25-diOH-vitamin D3. These are two very different tests of two different compounds.

In the Track Your Plaque program, we use vitamin D to reduce pre-diabetic tendencies, reduce blood pressure (vitamin D is an inhibitor of the pressure-raising hormone renin), shut down inflammation, and gain better control over coronary plaque (mechanism uncertain). In the process, you will sharply reduce risk of osteoporosis, colon and prostate cancer.

And maybe you'll be brighter when the winter blues come around again.

$4 per gallon gas is good for your health!

Gasoline is now approaching $4 per gallon in some parts of the U.S. But there's a silver lining in this dark cloud. In fact, I see this as a positive for your health.

How can higher gas prices possbily be good for health?

Imagine this trend continues: Fuel prices climb higher and higher. Driving your car will become increasingly more costly. What will be the fall-out?

Well, there will be a number of implications. But among the developments will be a broad impetus towards rejecting fuel-based sources of transportation. This may come as a shock to you, but humans legs were meant for walking!

Remember way back when, Mom would say "We need some milk"? In 1953, you wouldn't get in your car and zip to and from the supermarket. Instead, you would walk a quarter-mile, half-mile or more to the store. And you would carry your bags back. You might walk a mile or two to school and back. In 2006, this seems incomprehensible.

Higher fuel prices will prompt a gradual return to 1953--As transportation costs climb, your town may try and make it easier to walk as an alternative means of getting places.
Imagine that it was easy to walk three blocks to the grocery store, produce stand, work or school, walk along pleasant paths on the weekend, stroll to the home of friends. Drive or walk? Leave the car in the garage and save you and your family hundreds of dollars a month in gas bills.

In a few years, given the current fuel cost trends, there won't be a choice. But it will be in your favor for health.

Another Ornish casualty

Barry's lipoproteins were nearly all corrected to perfection: LDL 64 mg, HDL 57 mg, triglycerides 45 mg. He was approaching the Track Your Plaque goal of 60/60/60, the levels we find tip the scales heavily in your favor for achieving plaque reversal.

But one problem still prominently persisted: small LDL. Of Barry's 64 mg of total LSL, 90% of his LDL were small.

Barry was already on niacin (Slo-Niacin; Upsher Smith)1000 mg per day and fish oil, 4000 mg per day, both of which contribute to correction of this pattern. He had added occasional raw almonds and oat bran to his daily habits, both of which also help suppress small LDL. "I thought you told me that small LDL should go away if I did all this!" he lamented in frustration.

We probed Barry's diet choices more closely. "I eat really healthy foods, just like an Ornish program." Uh oh.

"What do you mean?" I asked.

"For breakfast, I have two slices of whole wheat toast--no butter or margarine, of course! I'll have Shredded Wheat with skim milk. That's it. My typical lunch is low-fat turkey--no mayonnaise!--on whole wheat. I'll add some low-fat whole wheat crackers or pretzels. That's pretty much my habit."

"How about dinner?"

"Dinner varies a lot. I'll usually have a low-fat meat like chicken or turkey, never beef, a vegetable, and a potato. I love rolls but I try to make them whole wheat. I don't use gravy. I love ice cream, so I've been having low-fat frozen yogurt instead. I guess that's about it."

Barry had indeed been counseled on how we approach nutrition. We, of course, do not endorse the low-fat approach of the Ornish program. Low saturated and hydrogenated fat, yes, but not the super-strict low-fat, "all fat is bad" approach of Dr. Dean Ornish.

Barry's diet is typical of someone on a low-fat restriction. When I asked him why he was eating this way, he admitted that he'd seen Dr. Ornish on a TV program in which he persuasively proclaimed that he reversed heart disease in his patients over the past nearly 20 years using this low-fat approach.

That explained it. Barry's nearly pure carbohydrate diet was triggering high blood sugar responses after meals, causing his insulin to skyrocket and magnifying the small LDL pattern.

I advised Barry to dramatically reduce his carbohydates like breads, pretzels, low-fat yogurt, crackers, etc. Instead, he could increase his lean proteins like eggs, egg whites, Egg Beaters, raw nuts and seeds, low-fat (yes, low-fat!) dairy products like yogurt and cottage cheese (both high protein), and healthy oils.

I've seen this happen with many people over the years: A severe low-fat restriction becomes a high-carbohydate diet. It's not uncommon for many people to have more than 70% of calories from carbohydrates on these programs.

The low-fat approach worked in the era of high-fat diets in the 1980s. In 2006, where convenience foods made with carbohydrates, especially wheat, predominate and pack 80% of supermarket shelves, low-fat is now a distorted nutritional mistake that leads to problems like Barry's uncontrolled small LDL, and often pre-diabetic or overt diabetes.

Should you take Plavix?

A question I get fairly frequently nowadays is, "Should I take Plavix?"

For the few of you who've managed to miss the mass advertising campaign for this drug on TV, USA Today, etc., Plavix is a platelet-blocking drug, known chemically as clopidogrel, that "thins" the blood and helps prevent blood clot formation in coronary arteries and carotid arteries, thus potentially reducing heart attack and stroke risk.

What if you have a heart scan score of, say, 450--should you take Plavix?

In general, no. First of all, aspirin and Plavix (generally taken together, since the effect of Plavix is incremental to that of aspirin) only block blood clot formation. They have no effect whatsoever on the rate of plaque growth. Aspirin and Plavix will neither slow it or increase it.

What they do is when a plaque ruptures like a little volcano and exposes its internal contents (inflammatory cells, fat, etc.--like a raw wound), a blood clot forms on top of the ruptured surface. If the clot is big enough, it can occlude the vessel and causes heart attack. Or, if it's a carotid artery, debris from the clot can break off and find its way headward to the artery controlling your speech or memory center. Aspirin and Plavix simply help inhibit clot formation once a plaque ruptures. That's it.

Interestingly, if you view any of Sanofi Aventis' commercials for Plavix, you'd think they came up with a cure for heart disease. It ain't true.

When is Plavix helpful? It's clearly an advantage after someone receives a coronary stent, drug-coated or uncoated;, after coronary bypass, particularly if certain metal punch devices are used to create the grafts in the aorta; and during and after heart attack. These are all situations in which blood clot formation is a forceful process. Blocking it helps.

In general, in asymptomatic people with positive heart scan scores at any level, we do not recommend taking Plavix. The Plavix people are extremely aggressive pushing their drug (hang around any medical office and see!) and, I believe, have gone overboard in promoting its benefits. Rarely, in someone with a very high heart scan score, say 2000 or more, we'll use Plavix for a period of a few months until lipids/lipoproteins and other risk measures are addressed, just as an added safety measure. But, in general, the great majority of people with some heart scan score or another do not receive it and I don't believe that they should.

As always, look beyond the marketing. The purpose of marketing is to increase profits, not to educate.

Dr. Ornish goofed

"I don't think I need the Track Your Plaque program. I've been doing the Ornish program, so I think that my plaque has already regressed."

So proclaimed Bruce, a recent patient I saw in consultation. Having suffered a heart attack three years earlier, he was thoroughly convinced that he was now cured following the Ornish program.


Indeed, back in the 1980s, many of us existed on greasy, high-fat diets of cheeseburgers, French fries, fried chicken, plenty of butter or margarine, mayonnaise, and the like.

Along came Dr. Dean Ornish, who wrote a book called "Dr. Dean Ornish's Program for Reversing Heart Disease: The Only System Scientifically Proven to Reverse Heart Disease Without Drugs or Surgery". This book struck a chord during this era and has been a hot-seller ever since it was published.

Does it work? In my experience, no, it does not.

Dr. Ornish claimed that sharply curtailing fat intake reverses heart disease. Closer to the truth is that, in people who start with high fat intakes, a low-fat restriction is indeed an improvement. This will lead to a modest improvement in blood flow in the coronary arteries due to a phenomenon called "endothelial dysfunction." This means that arteries will dilate modestly when specific changes are made. Thus, you will see minimal improvements in the measures he used (stress testing with nuclear imaging.)

What it does not mean is that plaque has regressed, certainly not "reversed".

In fact, our experience (over 10 years ago, when we first used the Ornish approach) was that the majaority of people did worse on this low-fat program: HDL dropped, triglycerides increased, blood sugar increased, inflammatory measures like C-reactive protein increased. Some people even magnified diabetic or pre-diabetic patterns.

It's almost certain that Bruce has not reversed his coronary plaque. In fact, I would bet that his plaque has grown substantially. Bruce started three years earlier from a diet high in unhealthy fats. If the expected rate of coronary plaque growth is 30% per year, perhaps he slowed it--to 20% or so. Since he didn't have a heart scan score at the time of his heart attack, we'll never know if he truly did reduce the quantity of coronary plaque he had.

But when I met him on his Ornish program, Bruce showed disturbing patterns that included an HDL cholesterol of 38 mg, 70% of all LDL particles were small, triglycerides measured 209 mg, and C-reactive protein was high at 2.8 mg/l. In other words, Bruce's plaque causes were far from corrected. Perhaps they were worse.

The Ornish program, despite it's ambitious claims, has outlived its usefulness. In 2006, it is an antiquated relic of a time past when lifestyle habits and technology were different.

Warning: This product may contain wheat!

Jerry experienced a peculiar sensation in his chest one evening while watching TV with his wife and kids. He squirmed in his chair and experienced a little breathelessness. But he kept it to himself and didn't say anything to his wife.

Fortunately, the feeling passed. But it concerned Jerry enough that he called a local heart scan center and scheduled a CT heart scan.* Minutes later, Jerry had a heart scan score of 112. At 46 years old, this placed him in the 90th percentile compared to other men in his age group.

Jerry came to my office for consultation. Among the first steps we took was to perform lipoprotein testing. Jerry showed striking abnormalities that included an HDL cholesterol of 38 mg, triglycerides of 210 mg, an unimpressive LDL of 133 mg but comprised of 99% small LDL, and excessive IDL (meaning that he was unable to clear dietary fats after eating).

At 5 feet 10 inches, Jerry weighed 190 lbs. He showed a slight excess bulge at the tummy, but hardly obese.

Jerry's history was remarkable, however, for the amount of carbohydrates he ate. "I'm addicted to bread. I love it! If I smell a loaf of fresh baked bread, I sometimes eat the whole loaf!"

Jerry also admitted to over-indulging in bagels (whole wheat), pretzels, low-fat snack chips, Raisin Bran cereal, Cheerios, and noodles. In fact, many days he'd have 5 or 6 servings of any of these foods. He also complained of an extraordinary amount of bowel gas and cramping. "Sometimes, I'm afraid to go to a group function. I might embarass myself."

I suggested an experiment: For a 4 week period, completely eliminate wheat-containing products--breads, pretzels, breakfast cereals, pasta, etc. In their place, increase intake of protein foods like eggs, raw almonds and walnuts, low-fat yogurt, cottage cheese, chicken, fish, and use healthy oils (olive, canola, grapeseed, flaxseed) more liberally.

Just four weeks later, Jerry came to the office a new man: 8 lbs lighter, brighter, with bursts of energy he hadn't had in years. And no gas!

Lesson: Wheat-based carbohydrates can be the culprit behind many lipoprotein patterns, especially low HDL, high triglycerides, small LDL, and others. Wheat can also be responsible for a myriad of abdominal symptoms, even joint pains and rashes. In its most extreme form, it's called "celiac disease". But experiences like Jerry's are quite common--not as obvious and dramatic as full-blown celliac disease, but smouldering and destructive, nonetheless.

Track Your Plaque expert, Dr. Loren Cordain of Colorado State University, tells us that, in his reconstruction of the history of human illness, there was an extraodinary surge in disease just about the time when humans began cultivating wheat around 8000 B.C. (Track Your Plaque members: Read Dr. Cordain's fascinating interview at http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_04-005cordaininterview.asp.)

Do you need to eliminate wheat products entirely from your diet? It's something to think about, particularly if you share any of the difficulties that Jerry had.


*In general, I do not recommend heart scanning as a self-prescribed tool for chest pain or other symptoms. Symptoms should always be discussed with your doctor.
To get low-carb right, you need to check blood sugars

To get low-carb right, you need to check blood sugars

Reducing your carbohydrate exposure, particularly to wheat, cornstarch, and sucrose (table sugar), helps with weight loss; reduction of triglycerides, small LDL, and c-reactive protein; increases HDL; reduces blood pressure. There should be no remaining doubt on these effects.

However, I am going to propose that you cannot truly get your low-carb diet right without checking blood sugars. Let me explain.

Carbohydrates are the dominant driver of blood sugar (glucose) after eating. But it's clear that we also obtain some wonderfully healthy nutrients from carbohydrate sources: Think anthocyanins from blueberries and pomegranates, vitamin C from citrus, and soluble fiber from beans. There are many good things in carbohydrate foods.

How do we weigh the need to reduce carbohydrates with their benefits?

Blood sugar after eating ("postprandial") is the best index of carbohydrate metabolism we have (not fasting blood sugar). It also provides an indirect gauge of small LDL. Checking your blood sugar (glucose) has become an easy and relatively inexpensive tool that just about anybody can incorporate into health habits. More often than not, it can also provide you with some unexpected insights about your response to diet.

If you’re not a diabetic, why bother checking blood sugar? New studies have documented the increased likelihood of cardiovascular events with increased postprandial blood sugars well below the ranges regarded as diabetic. A blood sugar level of 140 mg/dl after a meal carries 30-60% increased (relative) risk for heart attack and other events. The increase in risk begins at even lower levels, perhaps 110 mg/dl or lower after-eating.

We use a one-hour after eating blood sugar to gauge the effects of a meal. If, for instance, your dinner of baked chicken, asparagus brushed with olive oil, sauteed mushrooms, mashed potatoes, and a piece of Italian bread yields a one-hour blood sugar of 155 mg/dl, you know that something is wrong. (This is far more common than most people think.)

Doing this myself, I have been shocked at the times I've had an unexpectedly high blood sugar from seemingly "safe' foods, or when a store- or restaurant-bought meal had some concealed source of sugar or carbohydrate. (I recently had a restaurant meal of a turkey burger with cheese, mixed salad with balsamic vinegar dressing, along with a few bites of my wife's veggie omelet. Blood sugar one hour later: 127 mg/dl. I believe sugar added to the salad dressing was the culprit.)

You can now purchase your own blood glucose monitor at stores like Walmart and Walgreens for $10-20. You will also need to purchase the fingerstick lancets and test strips; the test strips are the most costly part of the picture, usually running $0.50 to $1.00 per test strip. But since people without diabetes check their blood sugar only occasionally, the cost of the test strips is, over time, modest. I've had several devices over the years, but my current favorite for ease-of-use is the LifeScan OneTouch UltraMini that cost me $18.99 at Walgreens.

Checking after-meal blood sugars is, in my view, a powerful means of managing diet when reducing carbohydrate exposure is your goal. It provides immediate feedback on the carbohydrate aspect of your diet, allowing you to adjust and tweak carbohydrate intake to your individual metabolism.

Comments (60) -

  • Anne

    1/19/2010 3:29:13 PM |

    I can attest to the fact that doctors ignore what happens to blood glucose after eating. My fasting BG has always been normal but my glucose tolerance tests have always been high. My last glucose tolerance test a few yrs ago went to 201. My doctors told me I had some insulin resistance but assured me that I did not have to do anything about it because my fasting was OK.

    About 1 year ago, after reading this blog and others, I bought a glucometer. Yes, my fasting was "normal" but I could easily push it up to 200 by eating. I did just what Dr. Davis recommends. I used the glucometer to figure out what I can eat and how much I can eat. I am able to keep my blood glucose below 120 now. The glucometer is a powerful tool.

    Is it possible my ignored elevated post meal blood sugars did damage? Well, lets see, I have peripheral neuropathy and have had cardiac bypass. Giving up gluten 6 yrs ago greatly improved my PN and relieved my of shortness of breath and pitting edema. Getting my blood glucose down will make a difference too.

    I recommend Blood Sugar 101 http://www.phlaunt.com/diabetes/

  • sdkidsbooks

    1/19/2010 5:09:59 PM |

    Going to get a glucose meter today and start checking.  Is there a desirable number or range for glucose before and after or is it about how much or how little it rises without regard to the number?
    Seems like somewhere around a 100 is what you are advocating.  

    If a person is not diabetic, is it helpful at all to know your A1C when getting routine blood work done?  Just wondering...

    Thanks.

    Jan

  • Anonymous

    1/19/2010 6:38:43 PM |

    You can get Wavesense Keynote test strips from Amazon for about 35 cents per strip -- the best deal I've ever seen.  (The meter is about $35 there.)  

    I am curious about the right time to test.  If blood sugar goes to 160 at 30 minutes, but is down to, say, 100 at one hour, is that ok? Why is one hour (not 30 mins or 2 hours) the key number?

  • Gretchen

    1/19/2010 7:02:35 PM |

    Ground meat is often cut with breadcrumbs. I won't eat ground meat or meatloaf at a restaurant or potluck supper.

    Balsamic vinegar contains up to 3 g of glucose per tablespoon. And most people do add sugar to salad dressings. One restaurant I went to boiled down cider vinegar until it was sweet.

    You can use those urine glucose test strips to test foods for the presence of glucose before you eat them. If it's starch, you have to chew the food a bit first to break down the starch. See Richard Bernstein's "Diabetes Solution."

  • Anonymous

    1/19/2010 7:16:36 PM |

    When exactly do you take the measurement?  One hour after the start of a meal or one hour after the end?  Sometimes when we eat out, a meal can take an hour or more to finish.

  • DrStrange

    1/19/2010 7:48:44 PM |

    One caution is that blood sugar meters are only accurate to plus or minus 20% which is a huge variance.  Also, many (probably worst w/ the Walmart Relion or similar budget meters) are not very consistent so you can't just compare to a lab test and calibrate.  

    What I generally do is take 3 (or even 4) readings within a few seconds of each other, toss any wild outliers, then average what is left.  If you try this a few times, depending on your meter, you may be shocked at how much difference there is between the readings.

  • Calvin

    1/19/2010 7:51:01 PM |

    Dr. Davis--Great post--I totally agree. Even if someone isn't diabetic or prediabetic (myself),  investing in a glucose meter, then self-testing (especially post postprandial) has got to be one of the absolute best investments one can make in personal health.

    I once read that if most diabetics (and I'll add prediabetics too) had invested in a meter years before their diagnosis, mostly likely they could have/would have avoided many of their accompanying negative health conditions today.  

    That said, there is still a lot of "cognitive dissonance" with regards to diet and health--I think the meter really helps to reinforce the cognition portion of that phrase thereby reducing the dissonance half.  

    And using a glucose meter can actually be fun!

  • Future Primitive

    1/19/2010 10:33:28 PM |

    Here's an example of carbo loading on yam and plantain - there was a 7 hour "fast" prior to eating and then taking the measurements.

    http://tinyurl.com/bg-set-001

    mg/dL is marked at a few key points on the right hand side.

    What I don't get is how to interpret the second rise and fall after the two hour mark ... though it is still inside the post-absorptive window (which closes 3-5 hours after eating, IIRC).

    I'm pretty certain a glass of red wine explains the initial drop to 65 mg/dL, btw.

    Also, for those that would like to make their own graph, it's easy to grab the url and fill in your own data (it's a google charts thing).

  • notrace

    1/20/2010 12:04:01 AM |

    Will there still be production of small LDL from excess blood glucose even if there is ample available glycogen storage space? That is, will the liver simultaneously manufacture LDL and glycogen?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 2:37:04 AM |

    When do you start to count your one hour.  From the time of your first bite of food, or when you have  finished your last bite.  Since it takes about 20-30 minutes to finish eating, when to start the one hour count down is important.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 2:58:57 AM |

    Hi, Anne--

    What a perfect example of the power of postprandial testing!

    Yes, Jenny Ruhl at http://diabetesupdate.blogspot.com  provides a wealth of insight into blood sugar issues. We will also be releasing an in-depth Special Report on this issue on the www.trackyourplaque.com website.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 3:00:50 AM |

    In answer to the questions on timing of blood sugar checks:

    I am guilty of oversimplification. The peak timing of blood sugar varies on the foods consumed and the mix of foods consumed. It will also vary from individual to individual. I believe a reasonable way to start out is to check 60 minutes from the completion of a meal. Even better, you might occasionally perform your own time-course study: Check blood sugars every 30 minutes to determine when you tend to peak.

  • Coach Jeff

    1/20/2010 12:58:55 PM |

    Since an LC diet causes insulin resistance, (Actually a GOOD and protective thing within the context of an LC diet)wouldn't a long-term low carber get a sort of "false positive" reading of high blood sugar from ANY high carb meal?

    Also, what do you think of the theory (that seems to really be gathering momentum lately) that fructose is the actual cause of insulin resistance, while on a "high carb" diet, and that glucose/starch is relatively benign?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 1:12:53 PM |

    I got a blood glucose monitor after I starting taking niacin for HDL (had read that niacin could raise blood glucose) and it was an eye opener. Now I know what foods to avoid.

    Jeanne

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 1:43:47 PM |

    Gretchen--

    Great thoughts. I forgot about the bread crumbs in ground meat issue.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/20/2010 1:45:17 PM |

    Coach--

    I think it's a matter of degree: While fructose is clearly a very bad player, glucose/starch are not benign, just less bad. Look at the responses we can generate with glucose tolerance testing using 75 grams of glucose.

  • Peter

    1/20/2010 2:55:25 PM |

    Since a simple way to reduce after-meal glucose readings is to eat smaller meals and eat more often, I don't quite understand why you think it's a bad idea.

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 3:27:43 PM |

    Bloodsugar101 suggests timing from the start of the meal. I always set a timer anyway, and it is easier to do before beginning to eat than at the end of the meal. This can feel awkward at first in restaurants, but I look at it as a way to get the word out.

    The occasional checks every 30 minutes is an excellent suggestion. Anytime you go over 140, you're causing damage. Even if it is only for brief periods, you want to be sure this is not one of your staple foods!

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 8:07:02 PM |

    What has happended to your trackyourplaque forum? I can't reach it anymore? Server crash without any backups? :-(

  • P

    1/20/2010 9:26:25 PM |

    hmmm. How painful is it to check the blood sugar that often?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 10:13:42 PM |

    I'm curious to know how to interpret blood sugar readings on the background of a healthy weight and a low-carb diet, with no known diabetes.  

    My fasting sugar is the same as it was before going low-carb (mid-70s).  However, it now takes a lot fewer carbs to spike my postprandial sugars.  

    An example: after 25 grams of carb in the form of a small serving of sweet potato with butter, my 45 minute postprandial reading, measured in triplicate, was 135.  I'm guessing the peak was even higher.  In case it matters, I'm a 36yo woman with a BMI of 18.9.  

    Should I be unconcerned by this kind of spike as long as my typical meals don't spike my sugar?  Is this just the normal insulin resistance caused by a low-carb diet, as Coach Jeff mentioned in his comment?

  • Anonymous

    1/20/2010 11:06:20 PM |

    Dr. Davis, you said, "While fructose is clearly a very bad player, glucose/starch are not benign, just less bad. Look at the responses we can generate with glucose tolerance testing using 75 grams of glucose."

    This does not prove anything about what causes insulin resistance in the first place though.  The person having a response to glucose during a tolerance test may have originally gotten their insulin resistance from fructose.  You can't use fructose in the test since it doesn't raise blood sugar, you can only use glucose.  

    To put it another way, people who don't have insulin resistance don't have abnormal responses to glucose during glucose tolerance tests.  Does that exonerate glucose?  Not really.  

    What I'm saying is you can't indict glucose OR fructose based solely on what is seen in a glucose tolerance test.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/21/2010 11:59:56 AM |

    Anon--

    Blood sugars are too high. Either too much carbohydrate in the diet or something has caused an abnormal insulin response. While the dangers are not acute, there are long-term consequences of blood sugars this high.

  • frogfarm

    1/21/2010 3:02:19 PM |

    Dr. Davis, if you can spare a moment I hope you would comment on this:

    http://fanaticcook.blogspot.com/2010/01/should-you-take-vitamin-d2-or-vitamin.html

    where Dr. Michael Holick (Mr. Vitamin D, from the look of his pedigree) claims D2 is equally as effective as D3 in raising and maintaining 25OHD levels?

  • DrStrange

    1/21/2010 3:43:05 PM |

    There are two main causes of insulin resistance, dietary fat and possibly fructose.  Fructose is not a cause for many as they can eat a mostly fruit diet without issues but for some it is a big factor.  There are "must have" essential fatty acids needed in proper amounts and ratio, perhaps a bit more fat is needed.  Beyond that minimum amount, any additional adds to insulin resistance. The amounts and ratios are all present in an all plant diet without the addition of any add oils or fats and that w/ minimal nuts/seeds (maybe an ounce of flax).

    After being on strict McDougall diet (total dietary fat approx 10% and no refined carbs, no animal products, no junk) for about 18 months, I did a 75 gm glucose tolerance test and had them do an extra point at 30 minutes just in case. My highest peak was 114.  Previously, on low carb diet I would go to 185 or higher. [I am 5'3" and 110 pounds so small body mass; lbs body per gm glucose if that makes any difference]

  • TedHutchinson

    1/21/2010 8:49:40 PM |

    @ frogfarm said...
    I find it very strange people take this particular study seriously.

    At the end of the trial none of the participants had 25(OH)D levels above 30ng/ml, so they all remained vitamin D insufficient.
    IMO it is unacceptable medical practice to knowingly give people an amount of a supplement that leaves them at such a low 25(OH)D level they remain unable to properly absorb calcium and well below the 58.8ng/ml level at which human breast milk flows replete with D3.
    So too little vitamin D of any kind leaves you vitamin D deficient.
    Is that such a remarkable finding?

    BUY DISCOUNT Ostoforte 50,000 IU (also called Drisdol) ONLINE 50,000 IU (100 capsules)  $168.99 USD
    or you can choose
    Vitamin D3 $26.95 for 100 X 50,000iu capsules.
    Who, but a fool, chooses to pay $169 when there's a better, cheaper alternative costing only $27?
    Or choosing an oilbased gelcap still saves loads of money.
    Healthy Origins, Vitamin D3, 10,000 IU, 360 Softgels $23.95

    I'm not sure of the point or the common sense, involved in trying to prove a synthetic drug, humans have to convert to D3 anyway, may, in trivial amounts too low to get anybody out of insufficiency, may be as good as a natural, cheaper, product or that equivalence seen in a few persons at a very low dose level, also applies at the sensible, natural levels, desirable for optimum health outcomes.

    While there are cases like this listed in Pubmed it is clear some people do not absorb nor are able to use Vitamin D2.
    We report a case of a 56-year-old woman who received supratherapeutic doses of ergocalciferol (150,000 IU orally daily) for 28 years without toxicity.

    A small trial of just 68 people is unlikely to pick up cases like the above.

    Grassrootshealth Banner Graph shows the amounts people have been taking and the 25(OH)D levels they have achieved.
    6000~8000iu approx 1000iu/daily for each 25lbs you weigh generally produces a natural level at which the body is able to store a sufficient reserve of D3 to be effective at times of crisis.
    This LEF study is another example showing 5000iu/d is not sufficient to get most people above 50ng/ml.

    As Holick knows perfectly well human skin naturally makes 10,000iu/daily given a few minutes full body UVB exposure. It does that for a purpose. Only when researchers start using equivalent EFFECTIVE amounts of the same NATURAL Vitamin D3 biologically identical to the form human skin NATURALLY makes, will we see an improvement rates of chronic illness.

  • Anonymous

    1/21/2010 9:13:05 PM |

    Dr Strange, if you're eating low carb, you have to prep for a GTT by carb-loading for 3-5 days beforehand.  Your pancreas won't be prepared to handle 75g of carb unless you give it a few days to rev up insulin production first.

    The reason that you had no problem with the GTT while McDougalling was that your body was used to high-carb loads, and so the test posed no challenge to your pancreas.

  • TedHutchinson

    1/21/2010 9:33:39 PM |

    Testing in Pairs
    Although this idea is for diabetics I feel it may also be useful for others wanting to see how particular food/exercise choices affect their numbers.
    There is also a short video, a downloadable record form and an example to consider.

  • Anonymous

    1/22/2010 5:22:55 AM |

    I can support what others are saying: before I went low carb, I could eat carbs and my blood glucose would never go above 120; now I eat pretty low carb and a single sweet potato can take me to 150.  I guess one should either eat extremely low carb or extremely high carb to avoid glucose spikes.

  • Dr. William Davis

    1/22/2010 3:04:13 PM |

    I worry that chronically eating high-carbohydrate, while generating an "accommodation" response that blunts postprandial blood sugars, will generate pancreatic BURNOUT by constantly challenging the pancreas to overproduce insulin.

  • Vladimir

    1/22/2010 3:47:56 PM |

    I too find that my post-meal glucose goes up much more after I do have carbs, if I'm eating low carb than high carb.  It's kind of amazing, and a little worry-some.

    However, if I eat very low carb, my fasting glucose is in the low 80s, while if I have more carbs, it's in the high 90s the next morning.  For example, I have (following the blog's advice) had absolutely no wheat and minimal sugar since Dec 27.  My fasting glucose had fallen into the low to mid 80s.  Two days ago, I had a large cookie after lunch --  My first wheat/sugar in 3 weeks.  The next morning, my fasting glucose was 98.

  • DrStrange

    1/22/2010 3:57:49 PM |

    Insulin resistance is the key here and dietary fat is a major contributor to IR.  I simultaneously took insulin levels w/ the blood sugar readings in the 75 gm glucose tolerance test above, and they were consistently low normal to slightly below normal, starting w/ undetectable level at fasting. Readings were:

    fasting < 2
    30 minutes = 3
    60 minutes = 5
    120 minutes = 14
    180 minutes = 8


    reference ranges given on lab report:
    fasting  < 17
    30 minutes = 6-86
    60 minutes = 8-112
    120 minutes = 5-55
    180 minutes = 3-20


    Doesn't seem like too much risk of burn out there!  And again, the reason for the low insulin output generating a fairly flat and low sugar curve was that without excess dietary fat (7-10% of total calories), there is dramatically reduced insulin resistance.

  • Matt Stone

    1/22/2010 6:47:00 PM |

    Thanks for bringing up the importance of blood sugar levels. I've done the same thing with my followers in my recent eBook on type 2 Diabetes, Metabolic Syndrome, and Prediabetes.

    What I have done is take it a step further. Instead of noting what my blood sugar reaction is to a large meal full of high GI starch and trying to avoid it, my focus has been finding ways to improve my glucose tolerance to such a meal.

    My glucose response to food is now far better than any single person following the advice of this blog. That much I can guarantee. It is not luck. It is not genetics. I watched my numbers fall as I followed insights that I gained from several years of intense investigation on the subject.

    The big thing that low-carb authors are missing is that unrefined carbohydrates can improve glucose response to food, even if they cause a larger rise in blood sugar in the short-term.

    My blood sugar now peaks at levels below 80 mg/dl after meals, something that the medical and nutrition-sphere probably considers to be impossible. But it's not. It's glucose metabolism perfection, but it's not achieved through limiting glucose intake. In fact, that can make your response to glucose worse, not better.

  • I Pull 400 Watts

    1/22/2010 9:58:30 PM |

    When you say low carb, what percentage of your calories are coming from carbs? Talking under 30% here?

  • Ateronon

    1/23/2010 6:43:30 AM |

    Off topic here but wish you would discuss salt and its effect on heart disease. There has just been a well publicized news story on it:

    http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/01/21/salt.intake/

    Do you recommend cutting salt intake to your patients?

    Great blog!

  • DrStrange

    1/23/2010 9:38:02 PM |

    "...if I eat very low carb, my fasting glucose is in the low 80s...  Two days ago, I had a large cookie after lunch -- My first wheat/sugar in 3 weeks. The next morning, my fasting glucose was 98."

    Yes, the high fat content of low-carb diet causes insulin resistance!  If you ate low fat (around 10% total calories max) for a couple weeks then you would maintain the lower fasting sugar after a carb load. Though if that cookie had a lot of fat in it, that could be enough to kick up the insulin resistance again.  One other possibility is if you are gluten intolerant, the stress to your system of eating wheat cookie could make fasting bg higher.

  • Vladimir

    1/24/2010 3:28:38 AM |

    Dr. Strange, Do you have any evidence that a diet high in healthy fats -- I'm a vegetarian, so I get little saturated fat -- causes insulin resistance?  I've never seen that theory propounded, and the mechanism seems implausible to me.

  • Matt Stone

    1/24/2010 5:57:21 PM |

    Dr. Strange-

    Interesting thoughts and you are right to question low-carb dogma as well as to show that insulin resistance is the core problem - and that a very high-fat, low-carb diet worsens the core problem.

    Anyone questioning this has not researched the issue thoroughly enough.


    However, you are making the same mistake. Eating a high-carb, low-fat diet for an extended period of time, while lowering your fasting glucose and insulin levels, also makes your glucose tolerance worse.

    Let me explain...

    If you have a basline meal, let's say, a slab of baby back ribs with cornbread and baked beans, and your 1-hour pp is 140 mg/dl, fasting the next day is 100, then you have good base numbers to track improvement.

    Eat low-carb, high-fat for 10 weeks, eat that same meal (ribs), and both your fasting and pp glucose levels will be higher than they were before you went low-carb. This means you're in worse shape than before the experiment.

    If you eat low-fat, high-carb for 10 weeks, and you eat a slab of ribs, cornbread, and baked beans...
    You're pp and FG will measure into the stratosphere (my 1-hour pp actually hit 173 mg/dl breaking a low-fat escapade...nutritarian).

    Both diets made your glucose metabolism worse in response to your baseline meal.  In other words, both strategies give you better numbers in the interim while making you fundamentally unhealthier (not to mention eating low-fat will make you crave more fat and low-carb will make you crave more carbs).

    What I've found is how to improve your glucose levels and insulin sensitivity in response to normal mixed food ratios. That's where real healing is achieved. A low-carber or a "low-fatter" will never get to a point where he or she can eat a large mixed meal with lots of fat, carbohdyrates, protein, and calories without having high postprandial spikes and high fasting glucose levels. Only someone who can eat 2 baked potatoes with 2T of butter and an 8-ounce untrimmed ribeye with fasting levels in the 70's and pp's in the 70-90 range is truly healthy and free of insulin resistance. I've found the secret to achieving that, and it is not low-fat, low-carb, or low-calorie.

    If such a meal sends your blood sugar half way to Mars, then you need to fix that!  Not avoid it!

  • Anonymous

    1/24/2010 11:32:13 PM |

    @ Matt Stone:

    Stop spamming! Yes, "everyone is wrong but I have figured it all out but for won't tell you what it is unless you go to my web site and pay me" is a spam, plain and simple. Please stop it.

  • DrStrange

    1/25/2010 12:42:19 AM |

    MattStone said: "Only someone who can eat 2 baked potatoes with 2T of butter and an 8-ounce untrimmed ribeye with fasting levels in the 70's and pp's in the 70-90 range is truly healthy and free of insulin resistance."

    That is somewhat how I used to eat and my fasting sugar level was creeping skyward.  Switched to low carb and felt gradually worse and worse for the 9 months I did it.  Switched to low-fat/starch based diet and have been feeling very well and not craving fat at all.  I do eat a little over an ounce per day of flax and pumpkin seeds for EFA boost.

    On 4 different occasions over the past couple years I have sent my blood sugar way up from one meal of moderate fat intake.  One was from eating all the seeds in a medium sized Delicata squash in one meal, maybe 1/2 cup or a bit more.

    Admittedly my liver is not in the best of shape due to much solvent exposure working in surfboard industry years ago and this my contribute...

    Don't have evidence handy but my understanding is that saturated fat is the biggest contributor to IR, much more so than unsaturated. There is some saturated fat in veg foods, some are very high in fact like coconut.

  • DrStrange

    1/25/2010 1:53:35 AM |

    Matt, Have read some on your blog site and think I get the overall picture of what you are doing but...

    What about the demographic data showing increasing cancer rates w/ increasing consumption of animal protein?  And the at least transient damage from meals high in sat. fat?:

    http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/short/48/4/715
    Consumption of Saturated Fat Impairs the Anti-Inflammatory Properties of High-Density Lipoproteins and Endothelial Function
    CONCLUSIONS: Consumption of a saturated fat reduces the anti-inflammatory potential of HDL and impairs arterial endothelial function. In contrast, the anti-inflammatory activity of HDL improves after consumption of polyunsaturated fat. These findings highlight novel mechanisms by which different dietary fatty acids may influence key atherogenic processes.

    And this one is a little concerning (its title tells the tale):
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18263705
    Glucose and leptin induce apoptosis in human beta-cells and impair glucose-stimulated insulin secretion through activation of c-Jun N-terminal kinases.

    More on low fat diet and atherosclerosis:

    http://www.heartattackproof.com/resolving_cade.htm

    It is a fascinating concept that increasing leptin dramatically reduces insulin resistance.  Leptin secretion seems to be induced by increasing glucose level, so eating starch (unrefined carbs like potatoes, whole grains, etc)which converts directly to glucose, should raise leptin level.  What I do not understand is the need for high fat and saturated fat in the diet, nor the need for "overfeeding."  We do need a certain amount of fat in our diets, but a plant based diet, with the addition of an ounce or so of selected seeds/nuts does seem to cover the 10-15% calories from fat we need without the increased disease risks of higher fat intake, and the risks from intake of large amounts of animal protein.

  • billye

    1/25/2010 5:03:20 PM |

    All 42 comments are amazing,

    Lots of varied comments here.  How do you suppose we all arrived here in the first place?  Our genes traveled through the ages,  without the benefit of all of this information.  How did they do this you might ask?  Simple, our ancient ancestors ate what their genes required for survival, full fat wild animal product, supplemented by a few wild not very starchy roots pulled from the ground, and seasonal wild not very sweet tree fruit.  This progressed throughout the last 2.5 million years.  That is how we got here.  Where we went wrong is when agriculture and farming started about 10,000 years ago followed by industry.  Our genes did not change much in the last 2.5 million years of eating high saturated fat including all high fat organs and marrow from the bones, with limited seasonal veggies and fruit.  They did not have the benefit of the sage advice of modern traditional medicine, or electronic devices to guide them, relative to the easy to treat by lifestyle change metabolic syndrome diseases.  Weren't they lucky?  Lest you think I am disparaging all doctors, I am not.  G-d forbid you have a broken leg or a disease that is congenital or inherited  that is difficult or near impossible to treat and need a physician, this group of dedicated highly trained professionals are  a life raft, and much appreciated.  I practice what I preach.  I went from a very ill patient to one that has reversed many of the metabolic syndrome illness that I suffered.  I trust the wisdom of my ancient ancestors and my doctors who practice out of the box evolutionary medicine to guide me.

    Billy E

  • Jared

    1/25/2010 5:04:46 PM |

    The information and anecdotes you provide about various heart disease issues is very interesting and useful. There is a registered dietitian in the Kansas City Area that has produced a series of informational videos about weight loss, nutrition and healthy living that you may be interested in. Here is her latest Nutrition 101 Video Series: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KZCjcCTCOE&feature=related

    Thank you and happy heart month!

  • TedHutchinson

    1/25/2010 5:44:47 PM |

    @ Dr Strange
    Nutrition and Metabolism  Dietary fat research
    Perhaps you haven't yet read the Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease Patty W Siri-Tarino, Qi Sun, Frank B Hu, and Ronald M Krauss, Jan. 2010
    showing there is no significant evidence for concluding that dietary saturated fat is associated with an increased risk of CHD or CVD.

    With reference to Consumption of Saturated Fat Impairs the Anti-Inflammatory Properties
    The mitochondria of people new to consuming coconut oil will not be  adjusted to it. It takes time to acquire appropriate gut flora. A single ingestion of an unfamiliar dietary substance will have different effects from long term use of the same substance.

    Any single trial comparing an omega 6 frequently consumed with a type of saturated fat the general public are not generally accustomed to will fail to spot the long term benefits of MCT (coconut oil, saturated fat) consumption.
    MCTs suppress fat deposition through enhanced thermogenesis and fat oxidation. MCT's preserve insulin sensitivity. MCTs regulate production of adipocytokines (e.g., adiponectin.

  • DrStrange

    1/26/2010 12:37:51 AM |

    Billye, you might want to read these.  It is true that ancestors ate full fat wild game, which is very very lean.  Also, 100% of it ate its natural diet and not corn, soy, and synthetic supplements and drugs.  Also, they most likely ate primarily a lot of starchy roots, leaves, flowers, insects, whatever they could collect and some meat when they could get that.  The meaty, beefy, caveman is a romantic fantasy.  They also did not live very long so degenerative diseases of aging were not an issue

    http://diabetesupdate.blogspot.com/2009/09/lets-not-twist-history-to-support-our.html

    http://diabetesupdate.blogspot.com/2009/11/saying-something-over-and-over-doesnt.html

  • billye

    1/26/2010 2:06:40 PM |

    Dr. Strange,

    The reasons that ancient peoples expired at a relatively young age was because diseases that are cured today through the use of antibiotics such as malaria along with the many natural disasters that occurred throughout the ages account for this fact.  However, what they did not die from were the diseases of the metabolic syndrome that you attribute inaccurately to degenerative diseases of old age. They are brought on by the standard American diet.  The degenerative diseases that you mention are first found in ancient egyptians from about 12,000 years ago after the advent of agriculture.  The patients can do their own trials under the watchful eye and monitored by their doctors.  The plain fact is that when switching to an ancient evolutionary lifestyle most of the diseases of the metabolic syndrome  reverse themselves.  This is being accomplished by thousands of people all over the world today, including my self.  You might read the well documented by clinical trials, Good Calories Bad Calories by G. Taubes, and Trick and Treat by B. Groves.  

    Billy E

  • billye

    1/26/2010 3:30:08 PM |

    DR.Strange,

    This is a P.S.  Archaeologists have found many human bones that had cut marks inflicted by other waring clans, along with the fact that the population of those times was very small compared to today's populations.  This is in contrast to the huge carnivore animal populations that walked the earth devouring humans who were in their food chain.  Also of note was the proven fact that ancient populations prized the fattest parts of the animal, brains, organs, and marrow from the bones etc.

    Billy E

  • donny

    1/26/2010 4:33:37 PM |

    Dr Richard Bernstein is in his mid-70s, and has type I diabetes. His diet is around 30 grams of carbohydrate a day, and he has no fear of saturated fat. It beggars the imagination that a man like him, whose pancreas hasn't produced any of it's own insulin in over half a century, should live to a ripe old age (as a male type one diabetic, he's already done this, and he ain't done yet.), but that the same diet should be deadly to the non-diabetic. Maybe he's lucky; but, before he learned to tightly control his own blood sugars, (and with as little insulin as possible), he suffered all kinds of complications, hardening of the arteries, high triglycerides, low hdl, early kidney disease, etc. I think Dr Bernstein and his patients provide proof of concept for what Dr Davis is trying to accomplish here for those suffering insulin resistance, whether they happen to be diabetic or not.
    Matt, you can't test insulin levels with a glucose meter. You also can't test any possibly progressive damage to glucose homeostasis that *might* be caused by a high everything diet over the course of years or even decades in a matter of weeks or months. Nor can you say flat out that your metabolism has been "healed" by such a diet. Has your system healed, or was it just healthy enough in the first place that over time it was capable of making the hormonal adjustments necessary to function well on a mixed diet? Can everybody make that leap?
    The thing about leptin and insulin resistance... one of the effects of leptin is to decrease the appetite for carbohydrate. (Maybe by increasing ketosis? or at least lipolysis.) It's almost like carbohydrate restriction is built right into the system.;)

  • DrStrange

    1/27/2010 12:22:58 AM |

    "...of note was the proven fact that ancient populations prized the fattest parts of the animal, brains, organs, and marrow from the bones..."

    Proven?  How they do that?

  • Anna

    1/27/2010 5:12:13 AM |

    FYI, a few tips I have picked up in the years I have been testing my BG,

    For the least amount of pain sensation when lancing my finger, I take the blood sample from the *side* of my finger tip, *not* on the pad or the tip.    

    If you have chronially cold hands it can be hard to get a good enough sample.  Wash hands with warm water first, dry well.  Swing arm in a big arc few times if necessary, to force more blood to the hands.  Sometimes my house is a bitt chilly but my car is warm from the sun in the driveway.  A few minutes sitting in the sunny car warms up my hands considerably, making a blood drop easy to get.

    It's ok to slightly "milk" the finger from the palm to the tip once, but with warm hands and a few pre-lancing "swings" (described above), that shouldn't be necessary.  It shouldn't take a lot of "milking" to get a good enough sample.

    There's no need to change the lancet tip for each test sample if you are the only one using the lancet (with clean hands, of course).  In fact, the lancet tips become more comfortable with use.  I change the tip only when it becomes dull and uncomfortable.  It goes without saying the lancet tip should always be changed if it is used to get a blood sample for another person.

    Speaking of clean hands, be sure there is no sugar on your hands or it can affect your results.  Wink

  • TedHutchinson

    1/27/2010 1:04:07 PM |

    @ Anna
    Thanks for tips. I've just started testing (following Dr D's suggestion)
    Bit surprised at some of the numbers.
    5.7=102mg/dl premeal
    8.1=146mg/dl 1hr after meal
    Chicken portion in curry sauce + carrots
    Probably tikka sauce (bought ready meal sugar listed 3rd in marinade and in sauce. Won't buy that again.
    Generally between 6.1 and 6.9 110mg/dl~125mg/dl

  • billye

    1/27/2010 2:20:12 PM |

    Dr. Strange,

    There is so much Paleolithic archaeological proof that ancient populations prized brains, organs, and marrow from bones, that it boggles the mind.  Have you not read about the thousands of bones along with tools found in ancient caves? They were smashed to get at the brains and marrow.  I call your attention to the Quarterly Review Of Biology, Vol 79, No1 March 2004, one of the many studies and reports out there.  Meat eating - dietary shift to increased regular consumption of fatty animal tissues in the course of hominid evolution as mediated by selection for "meat adaptive" genes.  This selection conferred resistance to disease risks associated with meat eating also in life expectancy.  The data was produced at the University of southern California, Los Angeles California.  This argument is long over, unless you wish to ignore all of the indisputable archaeological proof available.  Lets get on with out of the box medicine which supports health.  

    Billy E, nephropal.com

  • The Accidental Farmer

    1/29/2010 12:30:13 PM |

    Coach Jeff said: Since an LC diet causes insulin resistance, (Actually a GOOD and protective thing within the context of an LC diet) . . .

    I am new to this blog, got the link from the Taubes Talk yahoogroups board, and I am curious about this statement.  Why is IR good and protective?  I eat a very high fat diet, as well as low carb, as that is what seems to control my hypoglycemia the best, and so this statement seems counter-intuitive.  Or am I mistaken in thinking that hypoglycemia is a sign that one is developing insulin resistance?  If so, then it would seem that if something relieves the symptoms of hypoglycemia, then it is not leading to further insulin resistance.

  • TedHutchinson

    2/9/2010 3:09:04 PM |

    Following Dr Davis's suggestion I bought a Lifescan Onetouch Ultraeasy from Ebay.
    With too many readings higher than I expected, I needed a better way of recording numbers.
    All posts by william-davis

    Honey: More fructose than high-fructose corn syrup

    Honey: It’s natural. Mom probably gave it to you, either straight or in tea for a sore throat when you were a kid. Even today, honey is touted as possessing almost supernatural qualities for promoting health.

    Honey contains B vitamins, minerals, and a handful of antioxidants. It also contains . . . fructose. 60% of honey, in fact, is fructose.

    While the average per capita intake of honey is only a modest 1.29 lb per year (National Honey Board; 2008) and therefore contributes only 0.77 lb of fructose per year, there are people who, believing honey to be healthy, use it to excess and use far more than 1.29 lb per year.

    How does that compare to table sugar, or sucrose?

    Sucrose is 50:50 glucose to fructose. How about high-fructose corn syrup, the sweetener found in virtually all processed foods that has replaced sucrose as the most common sweetener? Depending on the variety, high-fructose corn syrup is generally 42-55% fructose. Many of us (including me) believe that the proliferation of high-fructose corn syrup in processed foods is a big part of the reason Americans are fat and diabetic.

    Yes: Judged by its fructose content, honey is worse than high-fructose corn syrup. It is also worse than sucrose.

    It means that honey can also contribute to the adverse health effects of fructose, as detailed in this prior Heart Scan Blog post.

    Sun, fish, and seaweed

    Extraordinary heart health springs from three basic sources in our environment:

    Sun, fish, and seaweed.

    Sun: Sunlight exposure is nature's intended source of vitamin D. Humans were meant to run naked, or at least scantily clad, in tropical or sub-tropical climates. The large surface area of skin ensured plenty of skin activation of vitamin D, along with long days of intense sun (unlike the seasonal variation of day length and less intense sun further north).

    Fish: Fish are the principal source of omega-3 fatty acids, as are, to a lesser degree, wild land animals. Humans as hunter-gatherers tracked, captured, and slaughtered fish and wild game, eaten immediately, since there was no means of storage. Omega-3-rich game was the principal source of fat for primitive cultures.

    Seaweed: Seaweed is the world’s most concentrated source of iodine. While seafood like fish and shellfish also contain iodine, seaweed contains, on average, a thousand-fold greater quantity. Seaweed, like plants found on land, are also rich in phytonutrients.

    The healthiest cultures on earth follow this simple recipe for health. The unhealthiest population on earth-meaning Americans (i.e., without benefit of bail-out medications and procedures that keep us alive, or vaccinations that protect us from infectious diseases)--neglect all three. Witness the Okinawans, whose daily meals nearly always contain some form of fish and seaweed, and whose sub-tropical climate provides greater sun exposure. It is not unusual for Okinawans to live to 100 years of age, not as an exception, but the rule. Heart disease was virtually unknown except in 90-year olds and older-that is, until the recent adoption of Western practices like fast food and snacks.

    It's pretty incredible when you think about it: Simple practices can markedly reduce your likelihood of heart attack and developing heart disease.

    Perhaps you’d rather not run naked along a semi-tropical beach, spear fish, and gather seaweed. You could always do the modern equivalents and achieve similar benefits.

    Fructose is a coronary risk factor

    As discussed in a previous Heart Scan Blog post, Say Goodbye to Fructose, a carefully-conducted University of California study demonstrated that, compared to glucose, fructose induces:

    1) Four-fold greater intra-abdominal fat accumulation

    2) 13.9% increase in LDL cholesterol, doubled Apoprotein B

    3) 44.9% increase in small LDL, 3-fold more than glucose

    4) Increased postprandial triglycerides 99.2%.


    Other studies have shown that fructose:

    --Increases uric acid--No longer is red meat the cause for increased uric acid; fructose has taken its place. Uric acid may act as an independent coronary risk factor and increases high blood pressure and kidney disease.

    --Induces insulin resistance, the situation that creates diabetes

    --Increases glycation (fructose linked to proteins) and protein cross-linking, processes that underlie atherosclerosis, liver disease, and cataracts.


    Make no mistake: Fructose is a powerful coronary risk factor.
    There is no doubt whatsoever that a diet rich in fructose from fruit drinks, honey, raisins and other dried fruit like cranberries, sucrose (table sugar), and high-fructose corn syrup is a high-risk path to heart disease.

    Also note that many foods labeled "heart healthy" because of low-fat, low saturated fat, addition of sterol esters, or fiber, also contain fructose sources, especially high-fructose corn syrup.

    Who lost weight?

    The results of the latest Heart Scan Blog poll are in.


    I went wheat-free and I . . .


    Gained weight 6 (3%)

    Lost no weight 41 (21%)

    Lost less than 10 lbs 28 (14%)

    Lost more than 10 lbs 34 (17%)

    Lost more than 20 lbs 22 (11%)

    Lost more than 30 lbs 28 (14%)

    I'm still losing weight! 30 (15%)

    (189 respondents)


    This means that, by eliminating wheat:

    24% had no success

    31% had moderate success (less than 10 lbs or more than 10 lbs)

    25% had extravagant results with 20 lbs or more lost


    It would be interesting to know where along the weight-loss spectrum the last category, "I'm still losing weight," group falls. (Anyone with a good story please speak up!)

    I believe we can conclude from this casual exercise that, as a simple strategy, wheat elimination is surprisingly effective.

    Why would 3% gain weight? Well, without knowing the details, there are several possible explanations:

    1) Weight gain developed through other foods. For instance, I've had people eliminate wheat only to replace it with fattening gluten-free alternatives. Remember: wheat-free is not gluten-free. Others load up on the wrong foods, e.g., Craisins and other dried fruit; overdo dairy; or snack on wheat-free but unhealthy foods like ice cream and chips.

    2) Too much alcohol

    3) Hypothyroidism--A lot more common than you'd think. In fact, this has been the case with a majority of people who have done everything right, yet either failed to lose weight or gained weight.

    Those are the biggies.

    I'd like to hear your personal stories of wheat elimination--the ups and downs, your success or failure, how you felt during the process, how easy or difficult, your eventual results. Just post them as a response to this blog post.

    A niacin primer

    A reader of Life Extension reminded me of a piece I wrote about niacin a couple of years back.

    Anyone desiring a primer on how and why to use niacin to correct lipid and lipoprotein patterns might find this useful.

    While some people, no matter what they do, cannot tolerate niacin (about 10% of people), many others enjoy spectacular benefits.


    Q: I recently had a cholesterol profile blood test and learned that I may be at risk of heart disease because my levels of beneficial HDL (high-density lipoprotein) are too low. I read that niacin could help increase my HDL, but my doctor said niacin is dangerous. Whom should I believe?

    A: Your doctor would be right—if we were still living in 1985. Since then, however, we have learned how to use niacin (vitamin B3) safely and effectively. Unfortunately, many physicians have not yet caught up, or are still trapped by the idea that cholesterol-lowering statin drugs are the only way to decrease cardiovascular disease risk. I have personally prescribed niacin for thousands of patients as part of our program to reverse coronary disease. In fact, niacin is the closest thing we have available to a perfect treatment that corrects most of the causes of coronary heart disease.

    Continued here.

    What would life be like . . . ?

    What if coronary heart disease could be prevented--no eliminated--applying methods that were accessible, easy, and cheap?

    What if coronary heart disease and, thereby, angina, heart attack, sudden cardiac death, ventricular tachycardia, heart failure, and the cerebrovascular equivalent, stroke, could be eliminated using readily available tools available to virtually everyone in the U.S.? And, over a year, it cost less than a once-a-week latte at Starbucks?

    How would the healthcare landscape change? What would become of hospitals, manufacturers of the billions of dollars of hospital equipment necessary to supply the cardiovascular hospital industry (e.g., stent manufacturers, catheter manufacturers, defibrillator and pacemaker manufacturers, pharmaceutical manufacturers who no longer have to produce the volume of antiplatelet agents, inotropic drugs, antiarrhythmic agents, etc.)?

    How would our lives change? What would the end of life look like if people stopped dying of heart attack, sudden cardiac death, congestive heart failure at age 55, 65, or 75, but lived out their lives to die of something unrelated?

    What if the solution had little or nothing to do with drugs but evolved from simple nutritional strategies, supplements meant to correct the deficiencies that accompany modern lifestyles, and a few unique strategies targeted towards the genetic predispositions that lead to heart disease?

    What if all this were possible at a cost of a few hundred dollars per year?

    It would certainly be a cataclysmic change. Hospitals would shrink to a small remnant of their current gargantuan, dozens-per-city presence. The need for hospital staff would be slashed by over half. The rare cardiologist would tend to congenital heart disease sufferers and other unusual forms of heart disease and he or she might have a colleague or two in all of a major city.

    Healthcare costs would plummet, no longer having to sustain the enormous cardiovascular healthcare machine of hospitals, staff, industry, and long-term care. Health insurance, private or public, would drop by 50%.

    It would free up nearly a trillion dollars that could be redirected towards other pursuits, like schools and research. Extraordinary leaps forward in quality of life and science would emerge, given that magnitude of funding.

    It's not as grand a thought experiment as Alan Weisman's The World Without Us, in which he imagines what the world would be like without humans altogether.

    How long would it take to recover lost ground and restore Eden to the way it must have gleamed and smelled the day before Adam, or Homo habilis, appeared? Could nature ever obliterate all our traces? How would it undo our monumental cities and public works, and reduce our myriad plastics and toxic synthetics back to benign, basic elements?

    But I believe this thought experiment--what would life be like without heart disease because it was eliminated using inexpensive tools-- is more plausible, more likely to occur. In fact, it has already begun to occur.

    See those vines growing up the side of the hospital?

    Are jelly beans heart healthy?

    Total Fat

    3 g or less

    Less than 6.5 g





    Saturated Fat



    1 g or less

    1 g or less





    Cholesterol

    20 mg or less

    20 mg or less





    Sodium

    480 mg or less per RACC* & labeled serving

    480 mg or less per RACC* & labeled serving





    Nutrients

    Contain 10 percent or more of the daily value of 1 of 6 nutrients; vitamin A, vitamin C, iron, calcium, protein or dietary fiber



    Contain 10 percent or more of the daily value of 1of 6 nutrients; vitamin A, vitamin C, iron, calcium, protein or dietary fiber





    Trans fat

    Less than 0.5 g per RACC* and labeled serving



    Less than 0.5 g per RACC* and labeled serving





    Whole Grain

    N/A



    51 percent by weight/RACC*







    Minimum Dietary Fiber



    N/A

    1.7 g/RACC of 30 g

    2.5 g/RACC of 45 g

    2.8 g/RACC of 50 g

    3.0 g/RACC of 55 g





    (RACC=Reference Amount Customarily Consumed)

    Thyroid correction: The woeful prevailing standard

    Rich has been taking Synthroid or levothyroxine for many years.

    When Rich came to my office for continuing management 10 years after his bypass surgery, I checked his thyroid panel:

    TSH 7.44 uIU/L

    Free T4 1.88 ng/dl (Ref range 0.80-1.90 ng/dl)

    Free T3 2.0 pg/ml (Ref range 2.3-4.2 pg/ml)


    Rich's thyroid hormone distortions--high TSH, low T3--are sufficient to account for a tripling of heart attack risk long-term.

    As Richs' thyroid was being managed by his primary care physician, I notified this doctor of Rich's panel. He therefore increased Rich's levothyroxine from 75 mcg per day to 100 mcg per day. Another thyroid panel several months later showed:

    TSH 0.98 uIU/L

    Free T4 2.38 ng/dl

    Free T3 2.0 pg/ml



    As you would expect, increasing the intake of the T4 hormone (levothyroxine) increased free T4 and suppressed TSH.

    But what about T3? It's unchanged.

    Indeed, Rich says that he feels no better and, in fact, wakes up in the morning foggy and requires a nap in the afternoon.

    In my experience, the majority (approximately 70%, but not 100%) experience subjective improvement when T3 is added in some form and the free T3 level is increased. While the data (summarized here) are conflicted on whether there is objective benefit to T3 management and supplementation, there seems to be a poorly-quantified subjective improvement.

    Rich's increased levothyroxine dose decreased (calculated) LDL cholesterol by 10 mg/dl. Based on my experience, I'll bet that his lipid panel would likely be further improved with T3 correction.

    What I find incredible is the absolutely rabid resistance waged by primary care physicians and endocrinologists against this notion of T3, mostly due to fears of the remote likelihood of inducing atrial fibrillation and osteoporosis, while they are ready to prescribe lifelong statin drugs without a moment's hesitation.

    Launch of new Track Your Plaque newsletter: Cardiac Confidential

    Track Your Plaque has just launched a new version of our newsletter. We call it Cardiac Confidential.

    Cardiac Confidential is meant to be a no-holds-barred, go-for-the-throat exposé of the world of heart disease. We will expose the dishonest, reveal what we view as the underlying truth. We'll even have an occasional "undercover" report of what goes on in hospitals and the go-for-the-money world of heart procedures.

    Read the first issue here (open to everyone) in which "Laurie" describes her encounter with a sleazy, profiteering cardiologist. She survives, but not without paying a dear price.

    Copyright © 2026 Cureality.com