What are "normal" triglycerides?

Among the most neglected yet enormously helpful values on any standard cholesterol panel is the triglyceride value.

Triglycerides traverse the bloodstream by hitching a ride on water (serum)-soluble lipoproteins, or lipid-carrying proteins. We measure triglycerides as an indirect index of triglyceride-containing lipoproteins.

Triglycerides are a basic currency of energy. While the average American ingests around 300 mg of cholesterol per day, he or she also ingests 60,000-120,000 mg (60-120 grams) of triglycerides, i.e., 200 to 400 times greater amounts, from fat intake. Zero triglycerides in the diet or in the bloodstream is not an option.

But what represents too much triglycerides in the bloodstream? There are several observations to help us make this determination:

1) When fasting triglycerides are 133 mg/dl or greater, 80% of people will show show at least some degree of small LDL particles.

2) When fasting triglycerides are 60 mg/dl or less, most (though not all, since genetic factors enter into the picture) people will show little to no small LDL particles.

3) When fasting triglycerides are 200 mg/dl or greater, small LDL particles will dominate and large LDL particles will be in the minority or be gone entirely.

4) When triglycerides are 88 mg/dl or greater after eating, then risk for heart attack is doubled. Non-fasting triglycerides in the 400+ mg/dl range are associated with 17-fold greater risk for heart attack.



From Austin et al 1990. "Phenotype A" means that large LDL particles dominate; "phenotype B" means that small LDL particles dominate.

Note that conventional "wisdom" (i.e., NCEP ATP-3 guidelines) is that triglycerides of up to 150 mg/dl are okay, a level that virtually guarantees expression of small LDL particles and increased cardiovascular risk.

Based on observations like these, in the Track Your Plaque program we aim for fasting triglycerides of no higher than 60 mg/dl and postprandial (after-meal) triglycerides of no more than 90 mg/dl.

Curiously, while fat intake (i.e., triglyceride intake) plays a role in determining postprandial triglyceride blood levels, it's carbohydrate intake that plays a much larger role. That will be an issue for another day.

Comments (67) -

  • Stephan Guyenet

    4/11/2011 6:58:50 PM |

    Hi Dr. Davis,

    I searched for that reference but I wasn't able to find it.  I found two papers from Austin et al. in 2000 but neither contained that graph.  Would you mind giving a more detailed reference for it?  I'd like to have that paper as a reference.  Thanks!

  • Anonymous

    4/11/2011 7:14:14 PM |

    HI Dr. Davis--

    Since I have been having my cholesterol levels checked, my triglyceride level has always been on the very low side...ave. around mid 30's.  My hdl  and ldl are generally around low to mid 80's.

    Could you say something about the people who have low triglycerides...is this healthy or a concern?

    My doctors usually think this is great , but I wonder.
    Thank you.

  • Dr. William Davis

    4/11/2011 9:40:20 PM |

    Hi, Stephan--

    Here's the URL for the abstract on Pubmed: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2372896

    I also see that I got the year wrong: It was 1990. (Now corrected.)


    Anon--

    Low triglycerides are wonderful. Your values are at the biologically perfect range.

  • Anonymous

    4/11/2011 10:07:10 PM |

    This is from Anon , who wrote you about my very low triglycerides-in the 30's.  Thank you so much for responding--I had been concerned there was something wrong with me!  
      
    I do not think my levels are due to genetics as my siblings have cholesterol issues. I think it is my diet and ex.

    Do you see many people with tri's in the 30's?  
    Thanks again!

  • Frank Hagan

    4/11/2011 10:13:07 PM |

    I must be doomed; even with vlc diet (less than 30g per day), fish oil and niacin, my triglycerides have never been under 103. They started at 440, so that's progress, but I suspect I have familial hypertriglyceridemia, as I can't get them to budge lower after two years.

    I tried going off niacin at one point, and they rose to 140 again. So I continue with the fish oil (1200mg of EPA and 900mg of DHA), niacin (1500mg 1x day) and vlc diet.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/11/2011 10:36:00 PM |

    Triglyceride (Trig.)clearing relys on the enzyme lipo-protein lipase being able to function at the capillary endothelium. If a Trig can get into a cell it is not taken out of circulation.

    Trigs move around in the circulation bound to lipo-proteins, and one natural component (among several components) of the lipo-protein molecules that carry Trigs is identified as Appoliprotein (Apo) C III. When there is an un-naturally high proportion  of Apo C III involved  this inhibits the working of the enzyme lipo-protein lipase, which is an essential enzyme for clearing Trigs from the blood stream (note: this is not discussing how Trigs get formed).

    Apo C III blocks the lipo-protein lipase enzyme from functioning at the capillary endothelium; Apo C III doesn't actually bind to the lipo-protein lipase enzyme.  It (the enzyme) can't get to work at that capillary inter-face when Apo C III over-abundant; so, there is less lypo-lysis (ie: Trig cleaving off) done to the Trig carrying lipid molecules (ie: VLDL, IDL and chylomicron lipids burdened with Trigs).

    So, what complicates the natural process when there is no underlying genetic cause obstructing Trig clearing from the blood stream ? If you said "insulin" you are correct; insulin signaling has a distinct regulatory affect on the APOC3 gene expression, which encodes for Apo C III.

    Docs interventions keep Trigs down in the obvious manner of setting up less substrate for Trig formation. What contiues to intrigue me is how insulin is involved in metabolic signalling beyond text book role of "driving" glucose into cells.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/11/2011 10:39:55 PM |

    edit last comment (mine) 1st paragraph, 2nd sentence to read:
    " If a Trig can NOT get into ...."

  • Anonymous

    4/11/2011 11:05:37 PM |

    When I had my last lipid analysis, I had been fasting for about 36 hours.  I frequently do intermittant fasting. My numbers were very contradictory and I wonder if my LDL levels were artificially increased due to the extended fast. My triglycerides were 69, VLDL were too few to be measured, but the number of small LDL particles was very high.  Thank you for addressing this issue.

  • Harry

    4/11/2011 11:21:54 PM |

    might, as I understand it, as VLDL loses trigs, it becomes IDL, and after further loss of trigs and all apolipoproteins except ApoB, it becomes LDL. I have been wondering if receptors in the LDL family are part of the process whereby VLDL and IDL and LDL lose trigs to cells throughout the body. Is this the way it works, or are receptors of the LDL family all or  mostly in the liver?

  • Adam Michael

    4/11/2011 11:35:42 PM |

    Anonymous, would you mind sharing your typical diet and lifestyle practices, including exercise?  I'm sure all curious minds could benefit!  Thank you.

  • Anonymous

    4/12/2011 1:11:53 AM |

    Adam M--In response to your question about my regimen. There really is nothing extreme about it so I have been baffled for years with my cholesterol results esp. the tri's in the 30's.

    For the past 20 yrs. I have almost totally avoided processed foods.Basically no junk food at all. Most of that time I ate no red meat. I have probably not eaten enough food...I  have always been a light eater and on the thin side. Lowish bmi but def. not anorexic or any eating disorder . I haven't eaten butter, though I do drink no-fat, or low fat milk and eat yogurt  daily as well. I use olive oil as much as I care to have, and eat walnuts and almond butter.I don't drink alcohol except on the very rare occassion--maybe a few times a yr.

    No special supplements...but fish oil over the past 8yrs. and a good level vit d. for the past few years. I was probably vit d deficient most of my life before supplementing vit d.


    For the past 10 years, I have walked briskly at least 6 days a week 4-6mi. I lift weights  (dumbbells #15-3-4 days a week. Do some tai chi.

    So you can see ...nothing too special but I do think vastly different than most Americans.

    My guess is that I am reaping the benefits of some good habits from the past 20 plus years. As I said my siblings take bp meds and statins....I don't take either. I think they have bad eating habits, don't exercise consistently and drink alcohol . Though 2 siblings have fairly decent diets, don't drink much and still need a statin and bp meds.

    I am female in my late 50's and siblings a bit older and a bit younger, male and female.

    Hope this helps. Anon.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/12/2011 1:12:10 AM |

    Hi Harry,
    The liver exports most Trigs bound to VLDL; when measuring fasting Trigs these are mostly complexed to VLDL. IDL (intermediate density lipo-protein) is really a spin off phase of a VLDL remnant, and is itself short lived (ie: IDL degrades quickly).

    When measuring fed (post-prandial) Trigs these are some appearing in VLDL (ie: liver exported) and some Trigs the chylo-microns carry (ie: from the intestine, a different source of Trigs); a relatively minor amount would be Trigs carried by IDL. When fasting (ex: overnight) there are very sparse amounts of Trigs associating with chylo-microns and IDL would be neglibible.

    HDL also has to carry Trigs; it (HDL) brings them back to the liver, which hydrolizes (cleaves) those Trigs for the liver to "play" with again. The HDL Trigs are not scavenged from the long enduring VLDL lipo-protein; but are Trigs HDL had picked up (ie: from the peripheraly circulating short lived IDL & chylo-microns).

    My understanding is that it is not the LDL receptors that are key to how & when Trigs physically get "off" of any molecule that is carrying a Trig. The Apo C III (detailed previously) is one of several proteins ( Apo C molecules exist in different iso-forms, do so simultaneously and sometimes as mutations); a lot of sub-groups get "bundled" to the Apo B complex.

    Apo C III component having excessive expression is what interfers with the enzyme  (lipoprotein lipase) involved in cleaving off Trigs. LDL receptor dynamics only add mitigating circumstances to how/where/when a circulating Trig is coming to be (or not be) presented for cleaving off.

  • Paul

    4/12/2011 3:00:41 AM |

    At least 50% of my caloric intake consists of fat, mostly saturated and monounsaturated from grass-fed tallow, ghee, butter, cheese, coconut, olive oil, almonds, avocados, and one tsp. fish oil... I get plenty from organ meats, wild salmon, free-range eggs, chicken, and beef too.  Not to mention I avoid grains, starch, and sugar as though they are poison.

    I'm a 50 y.o. male, and try to perform at least three apposing compound weight resistant exercises every day (bench-presses, pull-ups, squats, military-presses, rows, lunges, dead-lifts, power-cleans, or clean-&-jerks.)

    I've been doing this for a couple years.

    Along with very (visibly) favorable body comp muscle/fat ratios, my last 12 hr. triglyceride measurement came in at 52 mg/dl.  I think I'll stick with what I'm doing.

  • Rick

    4/12/2011 3:15:34 AM |

    Dr Davis,

    I'm a bit confused about number 4. You suggest that a postprandial value of greater than 88 is dangerous, but accept levels of up to 90 in your program. Are you sure the figures are correct?

    Also, are the 4 points in the order you intended?: you move from fasting triglycerides being too high (1), to being low (2), then to being too high again (3), then you move to non-fasting triglycerides in 4, starting with quite a very low figure (88), and suddenly jumping to 400+. How about more typical non-fasting figures in the 100+ or 200+ ranges?

  • Anonymous

    4/12/2011 5:35:26 AM |

    I must really be screwed. Even on six fish oil caps a day and a gram of niacin, I'm at 292.. my all time low was 157. I'm on even more fish oil and cut out breakfast cereal and other sources of high fructose corn syrup. What I need is a whole new genotype....

  • Alex

    4/12/2011 6:00:44 AM |

    Dr. Davis,

    While I understand that your target audience are probably Americans, as a European, I would be very grateful if you would also post values of the tests you speak of in the measurements used on the other side of the Atlantic. Here we speak of triglycerides in mmol/L, not in mg/dl, so whenever I read your posts I have to sit here with a conversion sheet and calculator, and considering that I can't make notes on other people's websites, I have to do so EVERY time I read your posts, even for the second or third time. It would be very helpful (and probably not too much work for you) if you could post values in both measurement systems, so I can put down the calculator and conversion sheet in the future and put all my attention to the contents.

    Thanks for listening.

  • LifeCoachAndy

    4/12/2011 7:38:17 AM |

    To ' I must be screwed up, VLC diet may be working for , so you  may want to try a different approach, eg. low fat plant based diet, do some fasting, also may need some attention to your liver.

  • Anonymous

    4/12/2011 8:44:10 AM |

    @Alex: +1

    Australia uses mmol/L also as it's the SI standard.

    Perhaps a converter on your site or quick reference table?

  • majkinetor

    4/12/2011 11:20:59 AM |

    "I must really be screwed. Even on six fish oil caps a day and a gram of niacin, I'm at 292.. "
    If you didn't do this, you may try exercising, sesame butter and soy lecithin.

    @Alex:
      +1
    We need M measure too. I have to convert each read, too.

  • Medicomp INC.

    4/12/2011 3:58:11 PM |

    Curiously, while fat intake (i.e., triglyceride intake) plays a role in determining postprandial triglyceride blood levels, it's carbohydrate intake that plays a much larger role. That will be an issue for another day.

    Interesting point. Many people think that fat is the most important part of a diet to assess, other factors definitely play a role in heart complications.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/12/2011 4:43:59 PM |

    Exertion (ex: manual work, breathing harder exercising, endurance training, etc.) improves insulin resistance; the
    sedentary, overweight, obese and Type II diabetics are told to actively exercise. Less insulin lingering in circulation means less insulin signals to ratchet up the Apo C III level; Trigs can clear out of circulation (as detailed above).

    Lipo-protein lipase enzyme can then robustly cleave of circulating Trigs for then getting into cells. In the cell the Trig must be processed into a "droplet" molecule for storing inside the cell; up to 1% of our genome is suspected to be involved in the biochemistry of achieving fat "droplet", which reflects it's importance.

    Fat Storage-Inducing Transmembrane Protein (FITM) in the cell's endoplamic reticulum make this conversion of Trigs into droplets (again note: this is not how Trigs are initially assembled). FITM uses the enzyme di-acyl-glycerol O-transfer-ase
    to do the job; then the droplet is rendered into the storage form called di-acyl-glycerol.

    FITM 1 is what exists in skeletal muscle endoplasmic reticulum to make muscle stores of di-acy-glycerol. When we exert ourselves and run out of glucose to burn the muscle takes back off the acyl-CoA fractions
    from stored di-acyl-glycerol; then it cobbles back together tri-acyl-glycerol molecules (note: this is the same molecule as a tri-glyceride, the more commonly used term just skips mentioning the acyl group) to burn and meet the demand for energy.

    Quite conveniently, for those who exert themselves, sustained activity also induces more di-acyl-glycerol transferase enzyme production; it is positive feed back augmenting the rate at which muscles can access their stored "fat" to burn (ie: training increases endurance).

    With muscle fitness burning up the on site reserves of di-acyl-glyceride the muscle can then take up more Trigs from the blood stream. Thus Trigs readings are lower for most geno-type individuals who regularly exert themselves (there are a few instances, mostly disease related, where low circulating Trigs are due to the liver holding on to too many Trigs).

    Our fat (adipose) cells' endoplasmic reticulum are the other site of a lot of lipid droplet processing for storage; there the adipose cells use FITM 2. When there is no exertion (ie: muscle cells have made no room for more stored di-acyl-glycerides) the Trigs slowly  get into the adipose cells(and some other tissues); so for the sedentary individual burning off that fat "reserve" is extremely difficult.

  • Harry

    4/12/2011 5:40:24 PM |

    Might, have you seen Mendivil's paper "Metabolism of VLDL and LDL containing apolipoprotein C-III and not other small apolipoproteins" It's at

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2818784/

    It seems to me that there must be some docking involved when a VLDL or LDL particle sheds trigs either in the liver or elsewhere in the body. Maybe it's not receptors of the LDL family that do the docking, but as I understand it, lipoprotein lipase isn't carried by the ApoB containing lipoprotein, but rather, is a component of the receiving cell that facilitates transporting the trigs through the receiving cell wall. The process may not involve full endocytosis, where the whole ApoB-containing particle is engulfed by the cell, but it seems to me that there must be some sort of adhesive or attractive region on the cell to trap the VLDL or LDL at least for a while so that the trig can be unloaded. Any idea how this works?

    From what I've read, it appears that the longer half-life of LDL in the circulation, vs that of VLDL and IDL, is due to ApoE being contained in VLDL and IDL, but not LDL. Since ApoE can attach to LDL receptors as well as or better than ApoB can, this results in more rapid clearance of VLDL and IDL than LDL.  

    As a result of this discussion and some references like Mendivil's paper, it appears that ApoC is involved also. Since LDL carries only ApoB, maybe that also contributes to the longer half-life of LDL.

    Might, have you considered joining Dr. Davis' Track Your Plaque (TYP) forum? I'm a member, and we have many interesting discussions of CHD issues. There is a small fee involved, but we discuss many things before they make it into the Heart Scan Blog. For example, we discussed the subject of this blog thread about a year ago, and as a result, I purchased a cardiochek meter and did a postprandial trig test. My fasting trig level was 57, and I then drank 6 oz of heavy cream. My trigs peaked 4 hours later at 69, which showed that my low-carb diet (30 g/day) had acclimated me to rapid removal of trigs. We learn a lot from each other's experiences.

    Anyway, your knowledge of cellular and molecular processes would make a great addition to the TYP forum. There are a number of ApoE3/4, E2/4, and E4/4 people there as well as E3/3's, and We sometimes discuss posts you have made in other fora. I hope you will consider joining us. And by the way, I'm not connected in any way with the TYP forum other than being a member who likes to get into the nitty gritty of CHD issues.

  • Renfrew

    4/12/2011 6:40:45 PM |

    Might o'chondria:

    I am enjoying your posts, though they are quite technical and mostly go over my head. It seems you are a very knowledgeable contributor here.
    I have one request: You'd be of service for many, if you could add some "behavioral" recommendations or at least sensible things to do/to avoid after you analyze/report/explain physiological parameters and biochemical findings.

    A simple sentence, like: Because of this, it would make sense to do this... or that.... or avoid this...would be much appreciated.
    Thanks.

    Renfrew

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/12/2011 7:47:20 PM |

    Hi Renfrew,
    This is Dr. Davis' blog so it is my feeling that specific health
    recommendations be his; and he does make them (some here & apparently more specifics  elsewhere). I am not a medical doctor, and do not follow
    all his recommendations (as I know them)for that matter.

    The fancy words I use are there because contemporary science has coined them to describe the complex details researchers keep finding. A lot of the hyphens (ex: "...-...-...") in words are inserted by me; this breaks up technical words into their component parts. I chose to do this so readers might identify some of the key parts  researchers coined that word from and not just tune out because of the jargon.

  • Brent

    4/12/2011 8:26:47 PM |

    To Frank Hagan (I Must Be Doomed) and Anon (I Must Be Screwed) - It does not seem like either of you take enough fish oil.  I visited Doc a month ago and he moved me from 2,400 mg DHA & EPA per day up to 3,000 mg per day - and I my Trigs were in the upper 70's.  Have not tested since.

    My understanding of TYP dosages is that you start around 3000 mg per day (DHA & EPA) and you go up from there, as high as 6,000 mg per day until your triglycerides are under 60.

  • Renfrew

    4/12/2011 8:53:45 PM |

    Whatever happened to KRILL OIL ? Has it been forgotten?

    I have read that KRILL oil is far more bioavailable than fishoil and chemically more stable, thus less prone to go rancid. Also because we are talking about phospholipids here which are absorbed much btter than ordinary fishoil, I would assume KRILL is the better choice.
    Unfortunately there does not seem to be much science on this. Probably because big pharma cannot make a buck out of this.
    I'vew been taking Krill oil for a year now and my trigs went from 250 to 56 in about 1 month. Stable since then. Unfortunately it does not seem to reduce LDL or raise HDL.
    Any experience, comments or details on KRILL?
    Renfrew

  • Ensues

    4/12/2011 9:58:35 PM |

    Hi Frank-

    I am exactly the same way.  Mine started over 1000 then to 769.  On fish oil, VLC, and Tricor (200mg) the lowest I have been able to achieve is 229.  My HDL is very low <25.  Neither of my parents have issues.  Very frustrating.  I am hoping my body/metabolism is healing and it my tri's will come down with time.

  • Ellen

    4/12/2011 10:06:13 PM |

    Hey Anon-- you ain't the only one! my triglycerides are always around 31. I always thought they were too low as well because they flag low for the lab range.

  • Paul Mcgrath

    4/12/2011 10:14:34 PM |

    @Renfrew

    No offense, but Might-o's valuable contributions here are clear to me on what specific behavior would be a healthy one.

    It can be summed up in one word... move. Well, maybe two more words would be clearer... lift something.  You would literally have to be blind and deaf not to notice all the effective programs  to help reach your goals. I particularly love Erwin Le Corre's Movnat - http://movnat.com/

    Our distant ancestors didn't have cars, automated climate controlled houses, refrigerators, cooking stoves, grocery stores, TV's, computers, game consoles, or various other modern conveniences that relieved or distracted them from having to go do physical work... just to survive.

    Combine that with today's widely available, tasty, cheap high carb food sources, you have a perfect synergistic formula for diseases of western civilization.

  • Anonymous

    4/12/2011 10:55:41 PM |

    MCA:

    You are my bochemistry reference guide and I really appreciate your posts. Please keep posting because you have the ability to answer why.
    Moving ones body has got to be one of the best investments in physical and mental health. I would rather do that then obsess or stress-out about numbers on a lab test. Get out in the woods and mountains and cover a lot of miles. I am fortunate because I live in Montana and have the wilderness in my backyard.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/12/2011 11:33:19 PM |

    10 mg/dl  =    0.555 mmol/L
    10 mmol/L =  180.0   mg/dl

    Maybe this scale of 10s will help those who need to do quick conversions.

  • Anonymous

    4/13/2011 2:08:11 AM |

    Put me in the genetically hopeless camp.  Tri's are 150 despite vegetables being my only source of carbs and intense activity 3 x's per week (about 1.5 hrs total), body fat and natural musculature that could have me as a paleo-bod model.  I feel hopeless on the blood lipid front.

  • michael goroncy

    4/13/2011 5:43:17 AM |

    Easy to confuse....
    Chol.LDL&HDL are on a different scale than TRIGS.
    To convert mmol/l to mg/dl multiply by 39 for cholesterol.
    For TRIGS multiply by 89.

  • Anonymous

    4/13/2011 12:34:20 PM |

    @Might-o'chondri-AL said...
    " 10 mg/dl = 0.555 mmol/L
    10 mmol/L = 180.0 mg/dl"

    When you are doing molar conversions there is a different factor for every chemical. Glucose, triglycerides, ...whatever. All have VERY different figues.

  • Anonymous

    4/13/2011 12:46:46 PM |

    Since removing bread and starch from my life my values have never been so good.  I do *very* occasionally have some rice or soaked beans or lentils...but my fasting triglycerides were 33, my total cholesterol 221, my HDL was 94 and LDL 121.  Just posting in case you are collecting data Smile

  • Anonymous

    4/13/2011 1:15:52 PM |

    My fasting triglyceride level fell from 81 to 46 over a 9 month period.  During this time, I doubled my exercise from 30 mins a day to 60 mins a day (every day of the week).  I believe that this is the cause.  For those trying to cut out animal fat, I have to report that I eat chicken skin and pork fat and this does not affect my cholesterol levels.

  • Stargazey

    4/13/2011 2:07:01 PM |

    I think Might-o'chondri-AL was giving us the conversion factors for glucose.

    My triglycerides went from 118 pre-Atkins to 43 after a few years on it. No change in exercise; I just cut out the carbs.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/13/2011 3:10:33 PM |

    Thanks M. Goroncy & Stargazey,
    for correcting my mistake; I do make them, so anytime welcome errors being pointed out.

  • Geoffrey Levens

    4/13/2011 4:13:21 PM |

    "Curiously, while fat intake (i.e., triglyceride intake) plays a role in determining postprandial triglyceride blood levels, it's carbohydrate intake that plays a much larger role."

    I exercise moderately daily, HIIT and resistance. Eat Fuhrman's ETL diet so I get about 30% calories from fat (raw nuts and seeds)and get about 250-300 grams carbs per day (zero refined carbs though).  My fasting trigs just read at 56.  High dose fish oil can elevate trigs, refined carbs also. Not so much apparently for whole foods, unrefined carbs.

  • Eric

    4/13/2011 4:38:58 PM |

    Well stated Paul Mcgrath!

  • Travis

    4/13/2011 9:43:17 PM |

    Dr. Davis,

    2) When fasting triglycerides are 60 mg/dl or less, most (though not all, since genetic factors enter into the picture) people will show little to no small LDL particles.

    I have lower fasting triglycerides since going on a low carb, higher protein and fat diet similar to what you suggest (they dropped from about 100-120 to 60-90). Yet, when I've had an NMR Lipoprofile done, it shows that I have high amounts of small LDL particles (in particular 850 nmol/L of small LDL-P and 1720 nmol/L LDL-P). I'm disappointed both that my triglyercides don't seem to be consistently low and that my small LDL-P is high. I'm otherwise healthy, not obese, no signs of insulin resistance, and eat primarily meat, eggs, dairy, and leafy green vegetables (with some starchy vegetables and fruit).
    I recognize you suggest this may be partly genetic, but what does this mean for me and is there anything I can do about it? Have you written about this elsewhere that I can't find? Thanks!

  • Eric

    4/13/2011 10:25:49 PM |

    Travis- This might help ApoE.

    ApoE 4/4 have to be more selective in their fat selections and amounts than an Apo 3/3.

    This may be just 1 genetic marker that can account for your numbers.

  • Adam

    4/14/2011 1:07:53 PM |

    2 years ago, when I had a case of the flu, and it didn't go away for 3 months, my doc ordered me a blood panel. My fasting triglycerides were 240mg/dL.

    Of course, i also suffered from the typical symptoms of metabolic syndrome: high BP, high cholesterol, obesity (40" waist), diabetic level of fasting blood glucose, low HDL... He told me to eat more "healthy whole grains" and cut out all fat and eat no red meat, to which I answered "that is exactly how I have been eating for decades!"

    Google then revealed to me Marks Daily Apple, I cut out all forms of sugar, grains, legumes, partially hydrogenated oils, and most dairy. Added in more grassfed beef, wild fish, coconut. Exercise sessions are short but as intense as physically possible.

    2 years later, I'm 40kg (88lbs) lighter, my waist is now 29" (smaller than my mom and I'm a man!), no more high BP, no more high cholesterol, HDL is 90+mg/dL.

    Triglycerides? 38mg/dL.

    Good thing I didn't listen to my doctor and take a heap of pills which he said I have to take for the rest of my life.

  • Steve

    4/14/2011 1:59:16 PM |

    Fascinating NYTimes article (4/13): "Is Sugar Toxic" by Gary Taubes. LINK

  • Frank Hagan

    4/14/2011 2:00:02 PM |

    Brent, thanks for the comment re: fish oil dosage. I am at 3,900mg of EPA&DHA combined (specifically 2400mg of EPA and 1500mg of DHA).

    I have a blood test coming up in June; I may increase to 5,200 mg to see if that has more effect.

  • Frank Hagan

    4/14/2011 2:07:07 PM |

    Ensues, you might check with your doctor about using niacin (not sure if there's an issue taking it with Tricor so I would check with him; I couldn't continue on Tricor due to an allergic reaction to it).

    My lowest triglyceride reading was when I was combining VLC, fish oil at 3,900mg EPA & DHA daily and 1,500mg of niacin.

    Dr. Davis has a lot of info here on niacin, including recommendations for using SloNiacin (over the counter) instead of the prescription version (Niaspan, I think) to save money. And he has some tips to avoid the flusing most of us get (what works for me is a regular aspirin 30 minutes before taking the niacin, and drinking plenty of water.)

  • Anonymous

    4/14/2011 7:35:37 PM |

    I notice some comments about large doses of fish oil (3+ grams daily) in order to reduce triglycerides.

    Any concerns over immune suppression at these doses? Or even 1-2g doses?

    I recall one pubmed study showing close to a 50% reduction in NK activity at a rather paltry EPA dose of 720mg/daily.

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11237929

    3+gm of fish oil might scare me a bit, longterm, if that study is correct.

  • Tim Tom

    4/14/2011 8:44:56 PM |

    I agree with your last statement that carbohydrates are a much bigger culprit to high triglyceride levels than fat intake. Looking forward to that post.

  • Dash

    4/15/2011 5:32:32 AM |

    Thank you for all of this information, it was really helpful for one of my classes.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/15/2011 5:53:06 AM |

    Hi Annon,
    NK, a type of lymphocyte cell, is mostly effective against circulating and metastasizing tumors; solid tumors are much less vulnerable to NK action against them. I failed pursuing your link so couldn't read the study, yet the premise that EPA inhibits NK is sound; EPA works  partly because it does keep lymphocytes from getting into tissue cells. Other very common factors that inhibit NK are fats, alcohol and steroids.

    EPA is showing itself to be useful against cancer; I seem to recall several types of neoplastic growths are less with EPA  supplementation. The EPA incorporated into a tissue cell's lipid membrane come into play through a series of steps; benefit is not as the EPA  molecule is being carried through the circulatory system.

  • woly

    4/15/2011 8:05:52 AM |

    Might-o'chondri-AL: can you please do us all a favour and start your own blog? I have started reading the comments section of many blog posts simply to see what you have written. All your posts are incredibly interesting, please keep up the good work!

  • Ensues

    4/15/2011 3:20:29 PM |

    Thanks for the info Frank.  I had indeed read up on niacin.  I started taking 500mg a couple months ago and then bumped to 1000mg after about a month.  I have not had a blood test yet to check the results.  I am hopeful though.  As for flush.  I have tolerated extremely well with really no problems except for one night.  After 2-3 months of no issues I experienced what I would call a crazy severe flush.  My skin was burning so bad I wanted to get it off.  Head to toe, hot and painful.  Not the "mild annoyance" I have read about.  It was nuts.  Lasted maybe an hour and a half.  Drank as much water as I could and a couple of aspirin.  Resumed 1000mg the very next day and have not had an issue since.  Very strange.  Thanks again for the comment.

  • Anonymous

    4/15/2011 4:44:01 PM |

    Be very careful when taking Niacin.  I can not tolerate even the small amount in a B-complex. My blood sugar increases, but even worse I become irrationally angry at the slightest provocation.

  • Anonymous

    4/15/2011 4:57:49 PM |

    Question regarding the reduction in NK cell activity ... could it pose a problem longterm?

    Would it possibly lead to a greater chance of infections (as some rodent studies have shown)?

    If someone had a metastasizing tumor, wouldn't fish oil then be contraindicated? I seem to recall DHA having some immune suppression activity too (not via NK however), but perhaps Vit E would counteract that.

    And then there is also that fish oil/rodent/colon cancer study:
    http://www.emaxhealth.com/1275/fish-oil-increases-risk-colitis-colon-cancer-mice

    Which seems to indicate DHA may be implicated negatively with colon cancer (in mice).

    And finally... I also recall the study testing oxidation values in people, using increasing doses of DHA (which is a bit of a messy way to test, but... whatever).

    http://www.futurepundit.com/archives/006499.html

    Somewhere between the 800mg and 1600mg levels of DHA, urinary isoprostane increased, which probably isn't such a good thing.

    I'm not anti-fish oil, as I take it myself. I am just wondering if too much (2-3+ g), may have some negative consequences longterm.

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/15/2011 7:47:19 PM |

    Hi Anon,
    I have no suggestion on how to dose fish oil; I'd like to hear
    Doc's limitation on use for high
    trigs. This is for orientation on what you are discussing, as I understand things.

    Rodent and human models for chronic disease (inc. cancer) involve immune systems that are dissimilar; thus no cancer treatment has (to my knowledge) come from rodent results. That Michigan Univ. (2010) study fed mice that were geneticly pre-disposed to inflammatory bowels, in addition to fish oil, corn and safflower oils; those other oils can be converted into Arachidonic Acid, which is itself pro-inflammatory in some instances.

    Isprostanes in the urine are a bio-marker of oxidative activity; their existance is not automaticly evidence of damage to healthy cells. Some isoprostanes are also carried in an esterified form by our good old HDL.

    Isoprostanes come in several forms; they are mostly (but not exclusively) by-products of our natural anti-oxidants glutathione and glutathione peroxidase activity.  In other words when see isoprostanes in the urine it shows not only that the body had/has oxidative "stress", but that the body did something about it (ie: glutathione was busy doing it's job).

    DHA apparently works to increase the apoptosis (cell suicide/programmed death) of cancer cells, including bladder cancer. One of the theories explaining this effect is that fish oil integrates into the cancer cell lipid membrane; then it becomes part of a cascade of events that along the way produces levels of endo-peroxides
    (made inside the cell hydrogen peroxide).

    A threshold (ie: high enough
    dose)of fish oil must be reached to sustain a level of hydrogen peroxide that the cancer cell will take as a signal (ROS are internal cell signal molecules)
    to go into apoptosis. While all that hydrogen peroxide is being spun off, again and again, the cancer cell's innate anti-oxidant glutathione is trying to
    keep apace and neutralize it; so an endproduct (but not the endgame of the apoptosis dynamic that can "kill"
    developing cancer) is more isprostanes showing up in urine.

  • Renfrew

    4/16/2011 1:08:20 PM |

    When talking about dosage for fishoil what are we actually talking about?
    Milligrams per pill or mg for DHA/EPA.
    I am reading here 2-3 grams of DHA/EPA. So are we talking about the pure DHA/EPA content?
    1000 mg of fishoil is surely different from 1000 mg of DHA/EPA.

    Renfrew

  • Anonymous

    4/16/2011 5:30:28 PM |

    Renfrew: amounts of EPA/DHA.

    Total content of a fish oil capsule, which is typically 1g, is meaningless without concentration numbers.

    So when 3g is mentioned, it's 3g of EPA/DHA, not simply 3, one gram capsules. 3g of EPA/DHA could be up to ten capsules.

  • Renfrew

    4/17/2011 11:35:46 AM |

    Thanks for the clarification.
    How about minimizing the number of capsules in taking KRILL oil?
    Krill oil is a lot more bioavailable (phospholipids), compared to ordinary fish oil capsules. Less capsules for the same bioavailable amount of EPA/DHA.
    It also contains Astaxanthin which is good for brain, eye and prostate health.
    The ORAC test results in much higher anti-oxidant capacity.
    Why aren't we all taking krill oil??

  • Anonymous

    4/17/2011 5:40:37 PM |

    The reasons against krill oil:

    It's not cost-effective nor is it less capsules for an equivalent amount of EPA/DHA (in fact, it's many more).

    I know of one comparison study which did show krill oil being about 50% or so more bioavailable that fish oil. But krill oil is like 5-10x the price of fish oil (based on EPA/DHA dosing). So one can do the math there.

    And there is also the fact that krill oil has been much less studied than fish oil has.

    Astaxanthin is interesting and one day I'd love to see Dr. Davis touch upon it on this blog, state if any of his patients use it, etc. But if you want astaxanthin, I'd think it'd make more sense and be a lot cheaper just to buy astaxanthin (from algae). I've seen it going for as low as $8 for 120, 4mg caps and even non-sale prices are like $10/60 caps. Much cheaper than krill oil.

  • reikime

    4/18/2011 4:27:51 AM |

    I have considered krill oil as i am very intolerant of anchovies and most fish oil caps contain it.

    Tried the Salmon oil, but ewww...nasty!

    Need the benefits of fish oil, but not the side effects.

    Thoughts? Time to take the Krill?

  • Anonymous

    4/18/2011 9:35:23 AM |

    Hey Dr Davis

    Have a look at Gary Taubes' latest post with blood lipid test results:

    http://www.garytaubes.com/2011/04/before-sugar-were-talking-about-cholesterol/

    Nina

  • Caveman

    4/30/2011 1:12:18 AM |

    Any reason to be concerned with very low trigs? Below are my latest blood test results and the trigs seem to be very low. Does this indicate anything?


    Glucose = 68.4 mg/dl
    HDL = 59 mg/dl
    LDL = 98 mg/dl
    Triglycerides = 17 mg/dl

  • James

    5/23/2011 4:24:46 PM |

    A little confused
    Before I had my latest blood test I thought having low trigs and a good TC/H ratio was the best indicators of CVD. Thanks to Dr. Davis I discovered the NMR LipoProfile and Vitamin D tests and  added them to my panel.

    The good part:
    Trigs: 50
    Total Chol: 198
    HDL-C: 70
    LDL-C: 118 (slightly elevated)

    That gives me a TC/H of 2.8, which I assume is excellent.

    But now, the surprising not so good news:
    LDL-P: 1410 (High)
    Small LDL-P: 613  (High)
    Vit D: 31.4 (Low)

    So, how can I have trigs below 60 and have a high LDL particle number and 43% of them small LDL-P?

    Can anyone help me interpret these results? BTW, I am  a 50 yo man in good shape and weight.

    Thanks in advance

  • Alfredo

    6/2/2011 3:57:56 PM |

    Hi, Dr. , please check your email system, I have not been recieving my emails since you moved to this new site.

    THanks

  • Bill

    6/10/2011 8:48:01 PM |

    The text
    "1) When fasting triglycerides are 133 mg/dl or greater, 80% of people will show show at least some degree of small LDL particles.

    2) When fasting triglycerides are 60 mg/dl or less, most (though not all, since genetic factors enter into the picture) people will show little to no small LDL particles.

    3) When fasting triglycerides are 200 mg/dl or greater, small LDL particles will dominate and large LDL particles will be in the minority or be gone entirely.

    4) When triglycerides are 88 mg/dl or greater after eating, then risk for heart attack is doubled. Non-fasting triglycerides in the 400+ mg/dl range are associated with 17-fold greater risk for heart attack."
    does not appear to be sourced from the sole referenced article in this blog post. The referenced article (Austin et al, 1990) is examining a specific human genetic phenotype in regards to triglyceride, HDL and LDL levels. Is there another source of this information, or are there specific page(s) I can read of the article to derive the same information?

  • Paul Lee

    7/6/2011 12:47:01 PM |

    Just got back from the docs and have mixed feelings as she prescribed a daily statin! However reading up on the low carb sites and on this blog it might not be all bad news! Fasting Triglycerides were 1.1 (96) and TC was 7.1 (6.22) I'm in the UK and hope I hope I've converted properly. I eat low carb, avoid cereals and am reasonably active, in addition to intermittently fasting. I think I've lost weight, that was one of the reasons I went to see the doctor as I thought my weight loss had stalled, but my BMI was down to 23 from 25/6. Its slow but getting there but I did read on some of LC forums that Triglycerides might be elevated whilst actively loosing weight. Clearly there is more work to do and I'm tempted to get a second test. I won't be taken a statin even though its free (provided on the NHS).

  • Rickey

    10/20/2011 5:47:51 AM |

    I know very little about Krill Oil. There had been a bunch of posts regarding Krill oil Brand on the various forums and blogs. After doing all research on internet, i came across with Krill oil Professional, this brand product is awesome. I ordered it online from there website at very competitive pricing. And now iam feeling very much relaxed from my Arthritis joint pain/stiffness relief.

Loading
Cureality | Real People Seeking Real Cures

The myth of mild coronary disease

I hear this comment from patients all the time:

"They told me that I had only mild blockages and so I had nothing to worry about."

That's one big lie.

I guess I shouldn't call it a lie. Is it a lie when it comes from ignorance, arrogance, laziness, or greed?

"Mild coronary disease" is usually a label applied to coronary atherosclerotic plaque that is insufficient to block flow. Thus, having a few 20%, 30%, or 40% blockages would be labeled "mild." No stents are (usually) implanted, no bypass surgery performed, and symptoms should not be attributable to the blockages. Thus, "mild."

The problem is that "mild" blockages are no less likely to rupture, the eruptive process that resembles a little volcano spewing lava. Except it's not lava, but the internal contents of atherosclerotic plaque. When these internal contents of plaque gain contact with blood, the coagulation process is set in motion and the artery both clots and constricts. Chest pains and heart attack result.

So, the essential point is not necessarily the amount of blood flow through the artery, but the presence of coronary atherosclerotic plaque. Just having plaque--any amount of plaque--sets the stage to permit plaque rupture.

One thing is clear: The more plaque you have, the greater the risk for rupture. But the quantity of plaque cannot be measured by the "percent blockage." It is measured by the lengthwise extent of plaque, as well as the depth of plaque within the wall. Neither of these risk features for plaque rupture can be gauged by percent blockage.


Coronary atherosclerosis is a diffuse process that involves much of the length of the artery. It is therefore folly to believe that a 15 mm long stent has addressed the disease. This is no more a solution than to replace the faucet in your kitchen in a house with rotting pipes from the basement up.

The message: ANY amount of coronary plaque is reason to engage in a program of prevention--prevention of plaque rupture, prevention of further plaque growth, perhaps even regression (reversal). It is NOT a reason to be complacent and buy into the myth of "mild" coronary disease, the misguided notion that arises from ill-conceived procedural heart disease solutions.


Image courtesy Wikipedia.

Copyright 2008 William Davis, MD

Red flags for lipoprotein(a)



Lipoprotein(a), Lp(a), is an important cause for heart disease, heart attack, and coronary atherosclerotic plaque.

How do you know you have it?

Of course, it could be as simple as checking a blood level. But there are also a number of red flags for the presence of Lp(a), tell-tale signs that suggest it is present and contributing to the growth of coronary plaque.

I've seen so much of this pattern over the years that it's gotten so that I can pretty much pick out most of the people with Lp(a) just by either looking at them or by hearing their story. I do this simply by knowing what hints to look for.

Some of the red flags for Lp(a) include:

--High blood pressure in a slender person. Overweight is the overwhelmingly common reason for high blood pressure. However, inappropriate high blood pressure in a slender person can serve to tip you off that Lp(a) is present.

--HIgh LDL cholesterol poorly responsive to statin drugs. For instance, someone's LDL cholesterol of 190 mg/dl will be treated with Lipitor 40 mg, but drops to only 165 mg/dl, a very poor response. This can sometimes point towards Lp(a).

--Family clustering of heart disease in people before age 60. For instance, father with heart attack age 53, uncle with heart attack at age 55, aunt with heart attack age 59, etc. This clustering of risk, more often than not, signals Lp(a).

--Coronary disease or high heart scan score in the presence of relatively bland appearing lipids. For instance, LDL cholesterol 130 mg/dl, HDL 55 mg/dl, triglycerides 70 mg/dl on no medications or other efforts--figures ordinarily not associated with high likelihood of heart disease--yet heart disease is indeed present. This can mean that Lp(a) is the concealed culprit behind coronary atherosclerosis.

These red flags are not perfect. If you lack any of them, it doesn't necessarily rule out the possbility of having Lp(a). They simply serve as signs to suggest that Lp(a) may be lurking.

Once Lp(a) is identified, then the battle begins to gain control over this somewhat troublesome genetic pattern. Resourcesfulness and some ingenuity may be required. However, knowing that you have it shows you where to concentrate your efforts.

Vytorin study explodes--But what's the real story?

The makers of Vytorin, Merck/Schering-Plough Pharmaceuticals, issued a press release about the the Enhance Study yesterday. The news has triggered a media frenzy.

The NY Times reporting of the story:

Drug Has No Benefit in Trial, Makers Say

The 700 participants in the trial all had a condition called "heterozygous hypercholesterolemia," a genetic disorder that permits very high LDL cholesterols. The average LDL at the start was 318 mg/dl.

The Times reported that, while Vytorin cut "LDL levels by 58 percent, compared to a 41 percent reduction with simvastatin alone," but "the average thickness of the carotid artery plaque increased by 0.0111 of a millimeter in patients taking Vytorin, compared to an increase of 0.0058 of a millimeter in those taking only simvastatin." There was no difference in heart attacks or other "events" between the two groups.

(Vytorin is the combination of simvastatin and Zetia.)

In other words, the participants taking Vytorin had 53 ten-thousands of a millimeter more plaque growth than the group taking just simvastatin.

I am always uncomfortable when put in the position of defending a drug or drug company. However, it is patently absurd that this study has generated such attention. I suspect the public and media are waiting for another Vioxx-like debacle, with memories of concealed or suppressed data that suggested heightened heart attack risk that was dismisssed by the drug manufacturer. (That's not to say that the company hasn't been trying to delay or modify the outcome of the study, which they apparently have, much to the objections of the FDA.)

However, at this point, there is no reason to believe that this question possesses any parallels to the Vioxx fiasco.

If we accept the data as reported, however, we might say it calls the entire "Lipid Hypothesis" into question: If LDL cholesterol is significantly reduced but is not correlated with reduction in plaque, is LDL the means by which atherosclerotic plaque progresses? This trial does not answer that question, but does serve to raise some doubt.

Another issue: Heterozygous hypercholesterolemia, and thereby LDL cholesterol, may not be the overwhelming driver of plaque growth in this population. It is probably the number of small LDL particles, a factor which is not revealed by LDL cholesterol. For this reason, heterozygous hypercholesterolemia by itself is insufficient to cause heart disease. Some other factor(s) needs to be present. I would propose that it is the size of the LDL particle: When small, heart disease develops; when large, heart disease is less likely to develop. This issue was not addressed by this study. Readers of The Heart Scan Blog know that conventional LDL cholesterol, the number used in this study, is a virtually worthless number for truly gauging plaque behavior because of its flagrant inaccuracy.

So, there are substantial uncertainties, contrary to the absolute certainty expressed by people like Dr. Steve Nissen (who, by the way, has no expertise in lipoprotein disorders). It is premature to reach any firm conclusions from this study. The only conclusions that I personally come to are 1) Is this yet another reason to question the entire Lipid Hypothesis as it stands? and 2) What would the results have been had LDL particle number and LDL particle size been examined, not just LDL?

I would not automatically conclude that Zetia causes carotid plaque. This is absurd. And I am definitely not one to come to the rescue of a drug or drug manufacturer. I am simply after understanding and truth.

As an interesting aside, Dr. Howard Hodis of the University of Southern California and an expert in carotid scanning for heart disease prevention research, made a comment relevant to us in the Track Your Plaque program:

"Clearly, progression of atherosclerosis is the only way you get events,” Dr. Hodis said. “If you don’t treat progression, then you get events."

Dr. Arthur Agatston in the news



The Miami Herald has a new report on Dr. Arthur Agagtston (of South Beach Diet fame) to announce his new book, The South Beach Heart Health Revolution:
The South Beach Diet doctor takes on cardio care

Agatston, the granddaddy of CT heart scanning, is always at least worth listening to. Although his diet may not be perfect, it clearly has jumped light years ahead of conventional diets like the inane American Heart Association diet. The South Beach Diet focuses on healthy oils, nuts, lean meats, vegetables, and fruits, while slashing grains (except in the often disastrous phase III).

The article lists Dr. Agatston's advice to achieve a "heart healthy" lifestyle:


• Maintain a healthy weight through diet.

• Undergo CT heart scans to check for arterial plaque.

• Do aerobic exercise, along with stretching and strengthening workouts.

• Ask your doctor about taking statins and other cholesterol-lowering drugs.


We wouldn't have CT heart scan scoring (at least in its present form) without Dr. Agatston, who developed the algorithm for scoring years ago in the early days of heart scanning. We also need to credit him with putting together a rational diet despite the counter-information emanating from the Heart Association, the USDA (a la Food Pyramid, the one that makes Americans fat and diabetic), and the American Diabetes Association, among others.

But "Ask your doctor about taking statins and other cholesterol-lowering drugs"? This is where Dr. Agatston begins to falter. While he is putting his enormous notoriety to use, his message is bland and ineffective. "Do aerobic exercise"? We don't need Dr. Agatston to tell us this.

As much as Art Agatston has added to the national conversation on heart disease and diet, he has failed to deliver the message of true heart disease prevention. His approach lacks just a few crucial ingredients like lipoprotein testing, diagnosis of hidden causes of heart disease (like Lp(a)), and vitamin D. (Two years ago I had a patient I saw for an opinion after he'd showed Dr. Agatston his lipoprotein panel. The patient said Dr. Agatston looked at the report and didn't know what to do with it and handed it back to him without comment. He then asked if he wanted his autograph.)

Anyway, the rising tide raises all boats. Agatston's repeated public endorsements of heart scans will help deliver the message that heart disease is detectable in its early stages and should trigger action to follow a heart disease prevention program.

That alone is an accomplishment in a world hell-bent on dragging us into the hospital for procedures.

Take this survey: I DOUBLE-DARE YOU

In a previous post I entitled Heart disease reversal a big "No No", I posed a challenge--a dare--to readers to ask their doctors if coronary heart could be reversed.

Here's what I said:

I dare you: Ask your doctor whether coronary heart disease can be reversed.

My prediction is that the answer will be a flat "NO." Or, something like "rarely, in extraordinary cases," kind of like spontaneous cure of cancer.

There are indeed discussions that have developed over the years in the conventional scientific and medical literature about reversal of heart disease, like Dean Ornish's Lifestyle Heart Trial, the REVERSAL Trial of atorvastatin (Lipitor) and the ASTEROID Trial of rosuvastatin (Crestor). Reversal of atherosclerotic plaque in these trials tends to be small in scale and sporadic.

The concept of reversal of heart disease has simply not gained a foothold in the lexicon nor in the thinking of practicing physicians. Heart disease is a relentlessly, unavoidably, and helplessly progressive disease in their way of thinking. Perhaps we can reduce the likelihood of cardiovascular events like heart attack and death with statin drugs and beta blockers. But reverse heart disease? In your dreams!

We need to change this mentality. Heart disease is a reversible phenomenon. Atherosclerosis in other territories like the carotid arteries is also a reversible pheneomenon. Rather than throwing medicines and (ineffective) diets at you (like the ridiculous American Heart Association program), what if your doctor set out from the start not just to reduce events, but to purposefully reduce your heart's plaque? While it might not succeed in everyone, it would certainly change the focus dramatically.

After all, isn't this the theme followed in cancer treatment? If you had a tumor, isn't cure the goal? Would we accept an oncologist's advice to simply reduce the likelihood of death from cancer but ignore the idea of ridding yourself completely of the disease? I don't think so.

Then why accept "event reduction" as a goal in heart disease? We shouldn't have to. Heart disease reversal--elimination--should be the goal.


I know of one person who actually followed through on this challenge and asked his cardiologist whether his heart disease could be reduced or reversed. As predicted, the answer was no. No explanation followed.

But allow me to reiterate: Heart disease is 1) detectable, 2) quantifiable, 3) controllable, and, in many cases 4) reversible.

What if there was a big payoff to your doctor if heart disease was reversed, say $100,000? That's enough to dwarf the payoff from procedures. Guess what? You'd have doctors fighting for your business, a chance to reverse your disease, ads to that effect, champions of reversal emerging. No new tools would be necessary. They could use the tools already available. Then why hasn't this happened? Is the technology unavailable? Are the treatments ineffective?

No, heart disease is a controllable and reversible process with tools that are available today. But there is, of course, no big payoff for doing it. So the financial incentive remains to do procedures, not to reverse the disease.

But I'd like to re-pose this challenge. Ask your doctor if heart disease can be reversed, or at least reduced. I've even posted a Survey at the top left for anyone who tries.

Again, my prediction: Nobody will try it and nobody will post survey results. Why? Despite my rantings (and those of a few others) about the concept of heart disease being a reversible process, in the public's consciousness it remains a death sentence and the only solution is hospital procedures. My colleagues continue to cultivate this attitude and it serves them well financially.

I'll be disappointed if I prove to be right. I hope that I am wrong. But I don't think that I am.



Copyright 2008 William Davis, MD

Michael Pollan on Nutritionism



The wonderfully articulate Michael Pollan has written another book. Although he presents little new to anyone who read his previous book, The Omnivore's Dilemma: A natural history of four meals, he is such a wonderful writer, with such clever ways of seeing the world, that I couldn't resist this new, less ambitious book.

The new book is In Defense of Food: An eater's manifesto.

As in Omnivore's Dilemma, Pollan reminds us that we've lost contact with real food, foods that our great grandmother would recognize, not the just-add-water, dried, pulverized, sweetened, high-fructose, hydrogenated, shrink-wrapped, artificially-colored products that pass as foods in the grocery store.

In particular, Pollan attacks what he calls the ideology of Nutritionism. "The widely shared but unexamined assumption is that the key to understanding food is indeed the nutrient. Put another way: Foods are essentially the sum of their nutrient parts." He calls this "Nutritionism."

In the section called "Nutritionism comes to market," he uses margarine as the prototypical product of this philosophy:

"No idea could be more sympathetic to manufacturers of processed foods, which surely explains why they have been so happy to jump on the nutritionism bandwagon. Indeed, nutritionism supplies the ultimate justification for processing food by implying that with a judicious application of food science, fake foods can be made even more nutritious than the real thing. This of course is the story of margarine, the first important synthetic food to slip into our diet. Margarine started out in the nineteenth century as a cheap and inferior sustitute for butter, but with the emergence of the lipid hypothesis in the 1950s, manufacturers quickly figured out that their product, with some tinkering, could be marketed as better--smarter!--than butter: butter with the bad nutrients removed (cholesterol and saturated fats) and replaced with good nutrients (polyunsaturated fats and then vitamins). Every time margarine was found wanting, the wanted nutrient could simply be added (Vitamin D? Got it now. Vitamin A? Sure, no problem. But of course margarine, being the product not of nature but of human ingenuity, could never be any smarter than the nutritionists dictating its recipe, and the nutritionists turned out to be not nearly as smart as they thought. The food scientists' ingenious method for making healthy vegetable oil solid at room temperature--by blasting it with hydrogen--turned out to produce unhealthy trans fats, fats that we now know are more dangerous than the saturated fats they were designed to replace. Yet the beauty of a processed food like margarine is that it can be endlessly reengineererd to overcome even the most embarrassing about-face in nutritional thinking--including the real wincer that its main ingredient might cause heart attacks and cancer. So now the trans fats are gone, and margarine marches on, unfazed and apparently unkillable. Too bad the same cannot be said of an unknown number of margarine eaters."


Anyone who reads and thinks a lot about nutrition will find little new here. But nobody says it better than Pollan. While Gary Taubes (Good Calories, Bad Calories) is the real thinker of our age about nutrition, Michael Pollan is the true writer about it.

With books like these making the bestsellers list, I believe that we are gradually seeing rationality return to eating. It makes people skeptical of the glitzy ads that run on TV around the clock. I hope that Pollan's new book will make more and more people leery of the latest health claim that adorn some product. "More omega-3!" "A low-fat snack." "Heart Healthy!" "High in healthy fiber!"

Cholesterol follies

Rudy is a 59-year old man. He's had three heart catheterizations, two of which resulted in stent implantations. Obviously, Rudy should be the beneciary of a prevention program.

His basic cholesterol values:

Total cholesterol 164 mg/dl--pretty good, it seems.

LDL cholesterol 111 mg/dl--Wow! Not too bad.

HDL cholesterol 23 mg/dl--Uh oh, that's not too good.

Triglycerides 148 mg/dl--By national (NCEP ATP-III) guidelines, triglycerides of 150 mg/dl and below fall within the desirable range.


So we're left with an apparently isolated low HDL cholesterol, nothing more. On the surface, it doesn't seem all that bad.

Of course, we need to keep in mind that this pattern landed Rudy in the hospital on several occasions and prompted several procedures.

Should we rely on these results? How about Rudy's lipoproteins?

Here they are (NMR; Liposcience):

LDL particle number 2139 nmol/l--Representing an effective LDL of 213--over 100 mg higher than the standard value (above) suggests.

Small LDL particles 2139 nmol/l--In other words, 100% of all Rudy's LDL particles are small. (Thus, weight-based measures of LDL cholesterol fail to tell us that he has too many small particles.)

Large HDL 0 (zero) mg/dl--Rudy has virtually no functional HDL particles.


If we had relied only on Rudy's standard cholesterol values, we would have focused on raising HDL. However, lipoprotein analysis uncovered a smorgasbord of additional severe patterns. The high LDL particle number comprised 100% of small particles is especially concerning.

Truly, conventional cholesterol testing is a fool's game, one that time and again fails to fully uncover or predict risk for heart disease. One look at Rudy's lipoproteins and it becomes immediately obvious: This man is at high risk for heart disease and the causes are clear.

Of course, many physicians and insurance companies argue that the added information provided by this portion of the lipoprotein test added around $70 more to the expense.

When you see results like this, is there even a choice?

Equal calories, different effects

A great study was just published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology:

Metabolic effects of weight loss on a very-low-carbohydrate diet compared with an isocaloric high-carbohydrate diet in abdominally obese subjects.

88 obese adults with metabolic syndrome were placed on either of two diets:

1) A very low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet (VLCHF): 4% calories from carbohydrates (truly low-carb); 35% protein; 61% fat, of which 20% were saturated. In the first 8 weeks, carbohydrate intake was severely limited to <20 grams per day, then <40 grams per day thereafter.

2) A high-carbohydrate, low-fat diet (HCLF): 46% calories from carbohydrates; 24% protein; 30% total fat, of which <8% were saturated.

Both diets were equal in calories (around 1400 calories per day--rather restrictive) and participants were maintained on the program for six months.

At the end of the six month period, participants on the VLCHF diet lost 26.4 lb, those on the HCLF diet 22.2 lbs (though the difference did not reach statistical significance). Thus, both approaches were spectacularly successful at weight loss.

Surprisingly, blood pressure, blood sugar, insulin and insulin sensitivity (a measure called HOMA) were all improved with both diets equally. Thus, these measures seemed to respond more to weight loss and less to the food composition.

Lipids differed between the two diets, however:


VLCHF:
Total cholesterol: initial 208.4 mg/dl final 207.7 mg/dl

LDL: initial 125 mg/dl final 123 mg/dl

HDL: initial 55 mg/dl final 64.5 mg/dl

Triglycerides: initial 144 mg/dl final 74 mg/dl

Apoprotein B: initial 98 mg/dl final 96 mg/dl


HCLF
Total cholesterol: initial 208.4 mg/dl final 187.5 mg/dl

LDL: initial 126 mg/dl final 108 mg/dl

HDL: initial 51 mg/dl final 54.5 mg/dl

Triglycerides: initial 157.6 mg/dl final 111 mg/dl

Apoprotein B: initial 100 mg/dl final 95 mg/dl


Some interesting differences became apparent:
--The VLCHF diet more effectively reduced triglycerides and raised HDL.
--The HCLF diet more effectively reduced total and LDL.
--There was no difference in Apo B (no statistical difference).

The investigators also made the observation that individual responsiveness to the diets differed substantially. They concluded that both diets appeared to exert no adverse effect on any of the parameters measured, both were approximately equally effective in weight loss with slight advantage with the carbohydrate restricted diet, and that lipid effects were indeed somewhat different.


What lessons can we learn from this study? I would propose/extrapolate several:

When calories are severely restricted, the composition of diet may be less important. However, when calories are not so severely restricted, then composition may assume a larger role. When calories are unrestricted, I would propose that the carbohydrate restriction approach may yield larger effects on weight loss and on lipids when compared to a low-fat diet.

The changes in total cholesterol are virtually meaningless. Part of the reason that it didn't drop with the VLCHF diet is that HDL cholesterol increased. In other words, total cholesterol = LDL + HDL + trig/5. A rise in HDL raises total cholesterol.

Despite no change in Apo B, if NMR lipoprotein analysis had been performed (or other assessment of LDL particle size made), then there would almost certainly have seen a dramatic shift from undesirable small LDL to less harmful large LDL particles on the VLCHF diet, less change on the HCLF diet.

The lack of restriction of saturated fat in the VLCHF that failed to yield adverse effects is interesting. It would be conssistent with the re-analysis of saturated fat as not-the-villain-we thought-it-was put forward by people like Gary Taubes (Good Calories, Bad Calories).

In the Track Your Plaque experience, small LDL is among the most important measures of all for coronary plaque reversal and control. Unfortunately, although this study was well designed and does add to the developing scientific exploration of diet, it doesn't add to our insight into small LDL effects. But if I had to make a choice, I'd choose the low-carbohydrate, high-fat approach for overall benefit.

Is skinny necessary for reversal?

Nothing we do in the Track Your Plaque program guarantees that coronary atherosclerotic plaque or your heart scan score is reduced or reversed.



But everything we do weighs the odds in your favor of successfully achieving reversal: correction of lipoprotein patterns, uncovering hidden patterns like Lp(a), vitamin D, being optimistic--it all tips the scales in your favor.

But how necessary is it to be skinny, meaning somewhere near your ideal weight?

It is important, but not as important as it used to be. Let me explain.

I used to tell people that plaque would not regress unless ideal weight was achieved and all the parameters of abdominal obesity and metabolic syndrome were corrected. This includes blood pressure, blood sugar, low HDL, small LDL, high triglycerides, and high c-reactive protein. Curiously, though, as we've gotten better and better at reducing coronary calcium scores, I've been finding that complete correction of all parameters, including achieving ideal weight, don't seem to be as necessary to achieve plaque reversal.

I almost hate to say this, but I've even witnessed significant drops in heart scan scores in people with body mass indexes (BMI) of 30--obese.

The necessary change doesn't seem to be weight, per se, but the consequences of weight. In other words, if you remain overweight, but blood sugar, HDL, small LDL, etc. have shown substantial improvement, then reversal is still achievable.

Then is it okay to be fat or overweight?

Reducing weight to ideal weight does indeed tip the scales in your favor, since it represents an observable, perceptible measure of all associated patterns. Dropping weight can also minimize the need for efforts to correct the consequences of overweight--you might need less niacin, fish oil, exercise, blood pressure medication, etc. to succeed at plaque reversal. Achieving ideal weight may also provide benefits like reduced risk of cancers and degenerative diseases of the hips and knees. But, to my recent surprise over the last two years, achieving ideal weight is not an absolute requirement to achieve reversal.

This is contrary to what some others say. For instance, in an upcoming interview with Dr. Joel Fuhrman on the Track Your Plaque website, Dr. Fuhrman argues that 10% body fat for males, 22% body fat for females, accelerates plaque and symptom reversal. Dr. Fuhrman is author of Fasting and Eating for Health, Eat to Live, and a new upcoming 2-part book, Eat for Health, and proponent of high-nutrient vegetarian diets and fasting. Dr. Fuhrman has been helpful in teaching us some important lessons on how to apply periodic fasting to accelerate plaque reversal.

So, which is it, fat or skinny?

If given a choice (which everyone has), I'd choose skinny. But, provided all the parameters associated with overweight are corrected, then remaining overweight doesn't necessarily mean that you can't still succeed at plaque reversal.

If you are interested in knowing what your ideal weight is, there are a number of software calculators and tables available, including the HealthCentral.com calculator and the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute BMI Calculator.


Image courtesy Wikipedia.

Copyright William Davis, MD 2008

MESA Study: Track Your Plaque-Lite?

The long-awaited data analyses from the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) are finally making it to press.

The MESA Study is an enormously ambitious and important study of 6800 people, 45 to 84 years old, that includes white, black, Hispanic, and Chinese participants from six communities around the U.S. (Forsyth County, NC; Northern Manhattan and the Bronx, NY; Baltimore and Baltimore County, Md; St Paul, Minn; Chicago, Ill; and Los Angeles County, California.) Participants had no history of heart disease at enrollment. All underwent a heart scan (either EBT or multi-detector heart scans) at the start. It is therefore the largest prospective study involving heart scans ever performed. It is, not unexpectedly, yielding some fascinating observations relevant to the Track Your Plaque program. The MESA study is, incidentally, funded by the non-commercial, publicly-funded National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and is therefore presumably free of commercial bias.

Among the most recent publications is Risk factors for the progression of coronary artery calcification in asymptomatic subjects: Results from the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) In this analysis of 5700 of the MESA participants, a repeat heart scan was obtained an average of 2.4 years after the first. Conventional risk factors for heart disease were obtained at the start (see below for details under Measurement of Covariates.)

After analyzing the data and risk factors assessed, such as age, sex, race, blood pressure, body mass index (BMI), presence of diabetes, blood sugar, and family history of heart disease, two questions were asked:

1) What risk factors predict heart scan scores?

2) What risk factors predict progression (i.e., increase) in heart scan scores?

(The second question is particularly relevant to us and the Track Your Plaque experience.)

The MESA analysis showed that essentially all the risk factors assessed correlated with both the initial heart scan score, as well as the rate of progression. No surprises here.

But the most eye-opening finding was that the conventional risk factors assessed explained only 12% of the variation and progression in heart scan scores (coefficient of determination, or R squared, = 0.12.) In other words:

--Conventional risk factors like LDL cholesterol, diabetes, and excess weight explain only a tiny fraction of why someone develops coronary atherosclerotic plaque as represented by a heart scan score.

--The great majority of risk for a high heart scan score remains unexplained by conventional risk factors.

--The great majority of risk for progressive increase in heart scan scores also remains unexplained by conventional risk factors.


In light of the MESA analysis, it's no surprise that strategies like reducing LDL cholesterol with statin drugs fails to prevent most heart attacks. It's no surprise that conventional prevention programs that talk about "knowing your numbers," eating a "balanced" or low-fat diet, etc., fail miserably to prevent the vast majority of heart attacks and heart procedures.

MESA confirms what we've been saying these past few years: If you want control over coronary heart disease, you won't find it in Lipitor, a low-fat diet, and other limited conventional notions of risk. Correction of conventional risk factors like cholesterol and blood pressure are, in a word, a failure. I wouldn't even call the conventional approach Track Your Plaque-Lite. They don't even come close.

If conventional risk factors can explain only 12% of the reason behind heart disease, we've got to look elsewhere to understand why you and I develop this process.



Measurement of Covariates
Information on demographics, smoking, medical conditions, and family history was collected by questionnaire at the initial examination. Height and weight were also measured at the baseline examination, and blood was drawn for measurements, including lipids, inflammation, fasting glucose, fibrinogen, and creatinine. Resting blood pressure was measured 3 times in the seated position, and the average of the last 2 measurements was used in the analysis. Medication use was determined by questionnaire. Additionally, the participant was asked to bring to the clinic containers for all medications used during the 2 weeks before the visit. The interviewer then recorded the name of each medication, the prescribed dose, and frequency of administration from the containers.


Copyright 2008 William Davis,MD
All posts by william-davis

In heart disease prevention, shoot for perfection

It really struck me today that it's the people who've chosen to compromise their prevention program who end up with trouble--heart procedures, heart attack, even heart failure.

Take Bob, for example. Bob is 73 years old and had a bypass operation in 2000. The procedure went well and Bob enjoyed 6 years of seemingly trouble-free life. Bob had a seriously low HDL cholesterol for which he as taken a modest dose of niacin, but was unwilling to do much more. His HDL cholesterol was thererefore "stalled" at around 40 mg. (We aim for 60 mg or greater.) We talked repeatedly about the options for increasing HDL but Bob was content with his results. After all, since his bypass operation, he'd felt well and could do all he wanted without physical limitation.

But Bob underwent a stress test for surveillance purposes (which we routinely do 5 or more years after bypass surgery). The test was markedly abnormal with two major areas of poor blood flow to his heart (signalling potential heart attack in future). Bob ended up getting 5 stents to salvage two bypass grafts, both of which showed signs of substantial degeneration.

I've seen this scenario repeatedly: A person is unwilling to go the extra mile to obtain perfection in lipid/lipoprotein patterns, lifestyle changes, and taking the basic, required supplements. Compromises eventually catch up to you in the form of another heart attack, more procedures, heart failure, physical disability, even death.

The message: Don't draw compromises in heart disease prevention. Coronary plaque is a chronic process. It will take advantage of you if you ever let your guard down.

The epidemic of small LDL

Of the patients I saw in my office yesterday, virtually EVERYONE had small LDL.

Small LDL is emerging as an extraordinarily prevalent lipoprotein pattern that drives coronary plaque growth. Previous estimates have put small LDL as affecting only 20-30% of people with coronary disease. However, in my experience in the last few years, I would estimate that greater than 80% of people with measurable coronary plaque have small LDL.

If you have a heart scan score >zero, chances are you have it, too.

I call small LDL a "modern" disease because it has skyrocketed in prevalence recently because of the great surge in inactivity in Americans.

When's the last time you walked to the grocery store and back, lugging two bags of groceries? How many years has it been since you've push-mowed your lawn? All the small conveniences of life have permeated further and further into our activities. Most of us spend the great majority of our day right where you are now--on your duff.

On the bright side, small LDL in most people is reducable by simply getting up and going. But the old teaching of 30 minutes of activity per day is now outdated. This was true when the other hours of your life included physical activities, like housework or a moderately active job. However, if the other 23 1/2 hours of your day are sedentary, then 30 minutes a day won't do it. An hour or more of activity, whether exercise or physical labor of some variety will get you better small LDL-suppressing results.

For most people with small LDL, fish oil and niacin are also necessary to fully suppress small LDL to the Track Your Plaque goal of <10 mg/dl.

A great discussion on vitamin D

If you need better convincing that vitamin D is among the most underappreciated but crucial vitamins for health, see Russell Martin's review of vitamin D and its role in cancer prevention. You'll find it in March, 2006 Life Extension Magazine or their www.LEF.org website at:

http://search.lef.org/cgi-src-bin/MsmGo.exe?grab_id=0&page_id=1308&query=vitamin%20d&hiword=VITAM%20VITAMER%20VITAMERS%20VITAMI%20VITAMINA%20VITAMINAS%20VITAMINC%20VITAMIND%20VITAMINE%20VITAMINEN%20VITAMINES%20VITAMINIC%20VITAMINK%20VITAMINS%20d%20vitamin%20

Our preliminary experience over the past year suggests that vitamin D may be the crucial missing link in many people's plaque control program. We've had a handful of people who, despite an otherwise perfect program (LDL<60, HDL>60, etc.; vigorous exercise, healthy food selection, etc.--I mean perfect)continued to show plaque growth. The rate of growth was slower than the natural expected rate of 30% per year, but still frightening rates of 14-18% per year--until we added vitamin D. All of a sudden, we saw dramatic regression of 7-25% in 6 months to a year.

This does not mean that vitamin D all by itself regresses plaque. I believe it means that vitamin D exerts a "permissive" effect, allowing all the other treatments (fish oil, LDL reduction, HDL raising, correction of small LDL, etc.) to exert their full benefit. So please don't stop everything and just take D. This will not work. However, adding vitamin D to your program on top of the basic Track Your Plaque approach--that's the best way I know of.

MSNBC Report: We need more heart procedures!

A recent headline from MSNBC by Robert Bazell reads:

NEW YORK - Angioplasty, bypass surgery and cholesterol-lowering medications are among the many interventions that have brought a sharp decrease in heart disease deaths in recent years. But, as Dr. Sharon Hayes of the Mayo Clinic points out, there is one big problem.

“The death rates in women have not declined as much as they have in men,” she says.

The piece goes on to suggest that women are getting short-ended in the diagnosis of heart symptoms and heart attack. The solution: More testing to assess the need for procedures like bypass.

This is typical of the device and medication-dominated media consciousness: More procedures, more medication, more devices. Who's paying for advertising, after all? The money at stake is huge. But is this what you want?

Don't be swayed by media reporters with limited understanding of the real issues (at best), consciousness of who's paying for advertising (at worst). Yes, heart disese is often underestimated or misdiagnosed in women. The answer is better detection earlier in life followed by efforts to halt the process--effective, safe treatments for people's benefit, not just profit.

What role cholesterol medication?

A frequent conversation point among my patients, as well as participants in the www.cureality.com program, is "Are cholesterol medications really necessary?"

No, they are not. What IS necessary is to correct all manifest and hidden causes of coronary plaque. Among these causes, in my view, is LDL cholesterol of 60 mg/dl or greater. There are many other causes of coronary plaque--e.g., small LDL particles, unrecognized hypertension, Lp(a), hidden diabetic patterns, etc.--but reducing LDL to 60 mg is still an important part of a plaque-reversing effort.

Insofar as we wish to get LDL to this goal, the statin cholesterol drugs like Lipitor, Zocor, Crestor, etc. may play a role. However, they should only be considered after a full effort dietary program is pursued. Don't follow the American Heart Association's diet unless you want to fail. It's nonsense.

For a more detailed discussion of how to use nutrition and nutritional supplements to reduce LDL cholesterol, go to www.lef.org, the website for the Life Extension Foundation. I wrote an article for their magazine called "Cholesterol and Statin Drugs: Separating Hype from Reality". You'll find the article at http://search.lef.org/cgi-src-bin/MsmGo.exe?grab_id=0&page_id=1295&query=davis%20cholesterol%20natural&hiword=CHOLESTEROLA%20CHOLESTEROLS%20DAVI%20DAVID%20DAVIE%20DAVIES%20DAVIN%20DAVIO%20DAVISON%20DAVISS%20DAVIT%20NATURALBASED%20NATURALES%20NATURALIZED%20NATURALLY%20NATURALS%20NATURE%20NATURES%20cholesterol%20davis%20natural%20.)

Can your plaque-reversal efforts succeed without statin drugs? It depends on your causes. For instance, someone with small LDL and Lp(a) only may do great on our basic program and then add niacin. Unfortunately, another person with a starting LDL cholesterol of 240 mg/dl--sky high--will have more success with these drugs.

Believe me, I am no blind supporter of drug companies and their flagrantly profit-seeking practices which, in my view, are cut-throat, shoving anyone and anything out of their way to increase profits and market share. I share many of Dr. Dave Warnarowski's views on how vicious their tactics can be; see his recent Blog post at http://www.drdavesbest.com/blog/ called "I smell a rat".

Nonetheless, the deep and well-funded research of the pharmaceutical industry does yield some useful tools. You don't have to love the insect exterminator, but if your house is being eaten by termites, his services can be useful. Same thing with these drugs. Useful--not the complete answer, not even close, but nonetheless useful in the right situations. Sometimes antibiotics are necessary, even life saving. That's how cholesterol drugs are, too.

Take it all in the proper perspective. Your goal is not cholesterol reduction, per se, but plaque control, preferably reversal.

Supplement Mania!

Ever hear of "polypharmacy"? That's when someone takes too many medicines. People will have lists of 15-20 prescription medicines, for instance, with crazy interactions and oodles of side-effects.

Well, how about "poly-supplments"? That's when someone takes a large number of nutritional supplements.

Let me tell you about a 45 year old man I met.

In an effort to rid himself of risk for heart disease that he felt was likely shared with his family (brother and father diagnosed with heart attacks in their late 40s), Steve followed a program of nutritional supplementation. You name it, he took it: hawthorne, anti-oxidant mixtures, vitamins C, E, B-complex, saw palmetto, 7-keto DHEA, velvet deer antler, gingko biloba, policosanol, chronium picolinate, green tea, pine bark extract, St. John's Wort, CoEnzyme Q10, papain and other digestive enzymes...He became a distributor for a nutritional supplement company to allow him to afford his own extraordinary program.

To satisfy himself that he had indeed "cured" himself of heart disease, he got himself a CT heart scan. His score: 470, in th 99th percentile. Steve's heart attack risk based on this score was around 10% per year. High risk, no question.

For weeks after his scan, Steve admitted walking around in a daze, not knowing what to do. Years of telling himself that he had effectively dealt with his heart disease risk, now all down the drain.

When we met, I persuaded him that to think that this collection of supplements would reverse heart disease was magical thinking. We trimmed his list down to the essentials and got him on the right track.

Heart disease is controllable and reversible, but not this way. Don't fool yourself into thinking that some collection of supplements will be enough to stamp out your heart disease risk. Just like taking an antibiotic when you don't have an infection achieves nothing, so does taking the wrong supplements.

What does heart scanning mean to you?

CT heart scans can mean different things to different people.


What does a heart scan mean to you? There are several possibilities:

1) A way of reducing uncertainty in your future.

2) A tool to crystallize your commitment to health.

3) A device to help you track how successful your heart disease prevention program is.

4) A trick to get you in the hospital.

5) A moneymaking tool for unscrupulous physicians hoping to profit from "downstream" testing, particularly heart catheterizations.


Like anything, heart scans can be used for both good and evil. How can you be sure that your heart scan is put to proper use--for your benefit and not someone else's profit?

Simple: Get educated. Understand the issues, be armed with informed questions.

If, for instance, you're a 55-year old female with a heart scan score of 90, active without symptoms, and you're told to have a heart catheterization right off the bat---run the other way. This is bad advice. A heart procedure like catheterization at this score in an asymptomatic woman is very rarely necessary. That decision can only be made after a step-by-step series of decisions are made by a truly interested, unbiased party. (A stress test is almost always required in this situation before the decision can be made to proceed with a catheterization.)

Unfortunately, in 2006, getting unbiased advice from your doctor is still a struggle. That's why we started Track Your Plaque---unbiased information, uncolored by drug or device company support, with an interest in the truth.

Coronary disease is drying up!

I had an interesting conversation with a device representative this morning. He was a sales representative for a major medical manufacturer of stents, defibrillators, and other such devices for heart disease.

Since I'm still involved with hospital heart care and cardiac catheterization laboratories, this representative asked me if I was interested in getting involved with some of the new cardiac devices making it to market over the next year or two. "The coronary market is drying up, what with coated stents and such. We've got to find new profit sources."

Well, doesn't that sum it up? If you haven't already had this epiphany, here it is:

HEART DISEASE IS A PROFITABLE BUSINESS!

Why else can hospitals afford billboards, $10 million dollar annual ad campaigns, etc.? They do it for PROFIT. Likewise, device and drug manufacturers see the tremendous profit in heart disease.

The representative's comments about the market "drying up" simply means that the use of coated stents has cut back on the need for repeat procedures. It does NOT mean that coronary disease is on the way out. On the contrary, for the people and institutions who stand to profit from heart care, there's lots of opportunity.

Track Your Plaque is trying to battle this trend. Heart disease should NOT be profitable. For the vast majority of us, it is a preventable process, much like house fires and dental cavities.

Mammogram for your heart

With the booming popularity of "64-slice CT scans", there's a lot of mis-information about what these tests provide.

These tests are essentially heart scans with added x-ray dye injected to see the insides of the arteries. However, to accomplish this, a large quantity of radiation is required. In addition, the test is not quantitative, that is, it is not a precise measure that can be repeated year after year.

It is okay to have a 64-slice CT coronary angiogram. It is NOT okay to have one every year. That's too much radiation. However, a heart scan can be repeated every year, if necessary, to track progression or regression. Once stabilization (zero change) or reduction is achieved, then you're done (unless your life takes a major change, like a 20 lb weight gain).

The tried-and-true CT heart scan is the gold standard--easy, inexpensive, precise, and repeatable. Not true for 64-slice angiograms.

Is your doctor using "leeches"?

What if you went to your doctor for a problem and he/she promptly placed leeches on your body?

Yeccchhhh! Would you go back? I'd bet that you'd run the other way as fast as your bleeding legs could take you. Outdated health practices like "bleeding" are outdated for good reason.

Then why would you allow your doctor to approach your heart disease prevention program by checking cholesterol and then waiting for symptoms to appear? That miserable approach leads to tragedy and death all too often--ask Bill Clinton! He might as well have had leeches!

Don't allow your doctor's ignorance or disinterest impede your prevention program. Get your coronary plaque measured, then attack it from all sides by knowing all causes, hidden and obvious. That's why Track Your Plaque is such an effective program.

I often wonder why more doctors aren't using this unbelievably powerful approach to deal with heart disease. But when I see colleagues implanting stents, defibrillators, and the like for many thousands of dollars per patient, the answers are obvious. Given a choice of a rational, effective program of prevention that pays the doctor a few hundred dollars for his time, versus $2000 to $10,000 for a procedure, you can see that the temptation is irresistible for many physicians.