Niacin: What forms are safe?

Niacin, or vitamin B3, remains a confusing issue for many people. It shouldn't be.

It doesn't help that most physicians and many pharmacists also do not understand the basic issues surrounding niacin. The only reason why there is any level of prevailing knowledge about niacin is that Kos Pharmaceuticals managed to "pharmaceuticalize" a niacin preparation, prescription Niaspan, that provided the revenue to fund professional "education."

Niacin can be helpful to increase HDL, reduce small LDL particles and shift them towards the more benign large particles, reduce triglycerides, and reduce lipoprotein(a).

So here's a brief description of the various forms that you will find niacin:

Immediate-release niacin--Also called crystalline niacin or just niacin. This is the original niacin that releases within minutes of ingestion. Because it releases rapidly, it triggers the most intense "hot flush." While this form of niacin works wonderfully well, is the safest, and is dirt cheap, the majority of people are simply unable to tolerate the intense flush. It also works best taken twice a day, generating two intolerable flushes per day.

Slow-release niacin--These preparations were popular in the 1980s, since the slow 12 to 24 hour pattern of release minimized the annoying hot flush. But, with prolonged use, it also became apparent that an unnaceptable frequency of liver toxicity developed. Unfortunately, this means that any niacin preparation that trickles niacin out over an extended period, including many of the slow-release preparations now sold in health food stores and pharmacies, have potential for liver toxicity. These preparations should be avoided.

6-hour release niacin--Releasing niacin more slowly than immediate-release niacin but more rapidly than slow-release niacin, 6-hour release (or what the Niaspan people call "extended-release" niacin) is nearly as effective as immediate-release niacin with approximately the same low potential for liver toxicity. It is far less liver toxic than slow-release niacin. 6-hour release niacin therefore offers the best balance between effectiveness and safety. Preparations that show this pattern of release include Niaspan ($180 per month), the poorly-named Sloniacin (about $8 per month), and Enduracin (about $7 per month) for 1000 mg per day. (Some Track Your Plaque Members have also determined that several other over-the-counter preparations have been demonstrated to share a similar pattern of release.)

Then there are the scam products that have no useful effect at all:

Flush-free or no-flush niacin--Inositol hexaniacinate, or 6 niacin molecules bound to the sugar, inositol, has no effect in humans, at least not with the dozen or so preparations that I've seen used. Nor are there any data to document the effectiveness of flush-free niacin. It's also more expensive.

Nicotinamide--This niacin derivative likewise has no effect on the usual targets for niacin treatment.

While I used to prescribe Niaspan, the ridiculous pricing and aggressive marketing really turned me off. I now advise my patients and our online followers to use only Sloniacin or Enduracin, unless you can tolerate immediate-release niacin.

Comments (52) -

  • Mikie

    4/19/2011 7:08:18 PM |

    How about this interesting source of Niacin ... drum roll please ....

    Food.

    Why the pills?  I guess to a hammer the whole world is a nail.

  • Anonymous

    4/19/2011 7:14:26 PM |

    Humans need about 20mg daily of Niacin, which can be met thru diet.
    Lipid modifying effects start to occur at levels above 1000 mg daily (sometimes not until 2000 mg).  It is essentially a type of over dose reaction.

    Tried niacin myself at only a few hundred mg daily.  Was able to tolerate the flushing, but then had the pleasure of passing 2 kidney stones.  Niacin has been given the boot ever since.

  • Anonymous

    4/19/2011 7:47:12 PM |

    Is there a relationship between niacin and kidney stones? I've had a kidney stone before and it isn't much fun.

    I tried Niacin several times, IR, Niaspan, and Enduracin. But I ended up getting heart palpitations on each. I also kinda felt weird, tired and generally lousy. And strangely enough, even though I toughed it out for several months, my HDL went down a point (at 500mg/daily -- Niaspan & Enduracin)

    Just wondering what can be done for those who are Niacin intolerant.

    And I tried the aspirin beforehand, taking with food, etc. Didn't matter in my case.

  • Anonymous

    4/19/2011 8:07:24 PM |

    Well, great...just great.  I've been taking NOW Foods Double Strength Flush-Free Niacin (500 mg) for a few months and now I'm told its for naught at best, and possibly damaging my liver.  There is a slight difference in the chemical name - Inositol Hexanicotinate.  I don't suppose that is significant?

    Anyway, I guess its back to the Sloniacin I took before.  At least that's considered safe.

    Regardless, I'm ever so grateful for this blog.  I learn something from most every post - even when it means I've been doing something wrong.

  • Daniel A. Clinton, RN, BSN

    4/19/2011 10:04:59 PM |

    I know Niacin has the power to make some numbers change, but is there any sort of credible evidence directly studying Niacin's effect on outcomes like heart attack and death? I am not comfortable inferring a benefit from alledged "cholesterol lowering."

  • Tara

    4/19/2011 10:12:41 PM |

    Good reminder post, Doc!  

    Mikie-
    I'm normally a proponent of getting your micronutrients from food, but in the case of therapeutic doses of niacin it's just not feasible.  1000mg of niacin= 19 pounds of yellowfin tuna, 17 lbs of chicken, or 500 cups of asparagus

  • Anonymous

    4/19/2011 10:45:33 PM |

    quote:
    .. but is there any sort of credible evidence directly studying Niacin's effect on outcomes like heart attack and death? I am not comfortable inferring a benefit from alleged "cholesterol lowering."

    It's interesting with niacin, even after discontinuation it seems to have an effect on mortality:

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3782631

  • Anonymous

    4/19/2011 11:09:27 PM |

    Daniel,

    It is my understanding that therapeutic doses of Niacin is VERY cardio-protective (assuming the person in question can tolerate it). Lookup the HATS, FATS & CLAS trials. Check out Dr. B G's blog for more info on this:

    http://drbganimalpharm.blogspot.com/2009/09/cardio-controversies-dr-superko-md.html

    John M.

  • Anonymous

    4/19/2011 11:16:17 PM |

    I've been taking SloNiacin at 1500 mg/day for quite some time. Recently my HDL went up to 60 mg/dl from 50. No problems with flushing or liver fuction or kidney stones. I've become interested in the use of Niacin plus bile acid binding resin (colestipol) to reduce plaque in arteries (PAD). The studies are old, 1980's and 1990's, and of limited number of patients. However on the Niaspan website they claim that Niaspan along with diet and a bile acid binding resin is FDA approved not only to slow down plaque buildup, but also to help reduce plaque that already exists. niaspan.com/heart-healthy/plaque-build-up.aspx  ...  They cite the old studies on the web page.

    I wonder if the claim is substantially true about plaque reduction and FDA approval.

  • steve

    4/19/2011 11:51:44 PM |

    interesting post.  My doctor said that Slo Niacin is less tolerated than Niaspan.  He does not care which you use.

    Separate question: what impact does Niacin have on blood sugars and homocysteine?

  • michael goroncy

    4/20/2011 12:21:50 AM |

    I have reason to treat aggressively this 'spooky' disease of the heart. The science and anecdotal experience of cardiologists (who stay on the 'cutting edge') like Dr Davis and a few others will attest to the overwhelming positive effects of NIACIN.
    I have titrated my Nicotinic Acid (OTC ..100 tabs..cost $11) up to a daily dose of 1.5gm.
    The intolerable flush I concluded is in the main...PSYCHOSOMATIC.
    At first I thought the uncomfortable feeling was unnatural and  possibly harmful but, the science convinced me that it was harmless. The tact I adopted was to enjoy the flush and look on it as a
    wonderful healing zooming through the body. The actual flush cannot harm...the liver is another story.
    Sheesh! The things you have to do to play mind games.
    The use and other add on supplements  have created excellent lipids (Iam thinking of entering them in the State Championships)
    Learn to love the flush..small discomfort-huge benefits.

  • Bobby

    4/20/2011 12:51:34 AM |

    I have been taking good old regular niacin and actually like the flush--it makes me feel like it is doing something. However, my blood glucose is somewhat elevated (104) over what I believe it should be. My doctor isn't concerned , but I'm not sure. Any feed back?

  • Dr. William Davis

    4/20/2011 2:22:21 AM |

    That's great, Tara!

    It would be a great episode of Man vs. Food.

  • Dr. William Davis

    4/20/2011 2:23:55 AM |

    A discussion of the downsides of niacin, even when done properly, sounds like it might be of help to many people.

    I'l put it on the "to-do" list.

  • Dymphna

    4/20/2011 2:29:15 AM |

    Did anyone have nausea with higher levels of niacin? I've tried it but it makes me somewhat sick-feeling.

    Any ideas?

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 12:09:20 PM |

    I'd second the notion to avoid real-slow release niacin...I looked in the mirror to see someone with yellow skin when taking some.

    So what are the available 6 hour release brands?

    And what about pomegranate extracts to help clear plaque buildup?

  • Renfrew

    4/20/2011 12:37:06 PM |

    Good thread.
    I am taking a form of niacin that has 1000 mg of Niacin plus 20 mg of Laropiprant. The Laropiprant is a prostaglandin inhibitor and prevents flushes.
    The brand name is "Tredaptive".

    My LDL Cholesterol went from 160 to 120 within 1 month. Trigs from 75 to 55.

    I combine the tablet with 500 mg of milk-thistle (for liver protection) and have not had any increase in liver enzymes.

    That is really a workable compromise and easy to take as one tablet a day.

    Not sure if this is available in the US though, I am living in Germany.

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 1:06:25 PM |

    I'd be interested in knowing more about the twice-a-day recommendation. I've been taking my immediate-release 2gm/day dose once a day for a couple of years now. (Yes, I get the flush--and my liver numbers are good.)  Dr Davis seems to be saying to take (in my case) 1gm every 12 hours?  Is this easier on the liver?

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 1:22:59 PM |

    Too many adverse effects from taking Niacin.  It's not worth the risk.

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 2:52:24 PM |

    I would like to hear the author's opinions on the best forms of excersise for heart health.

  • Dr. William Davis

    4/20/2011 3:17:43 PM |

    Hi, Renfrew-

    I believe you have earlier access to this preparation than we do.

    This may an interesting, though prescription, possibility for those who have intolerable flushes.

  • Dr. William Davis

    4/20/2011 3:19:36 PM |

    Re: comments about the potential dangers of niacin.

    We always have to weight the risks vs. benefits. If I have, for instance, a 45-year survivor of sudden cardiac death with 3 stents who I meet with BMI 23.0 and a lipoprotein(a) of 450 nmol/L, then niacin is a small price to pay.

    Every situation is unique.

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 4:45:00 PM |

    In regards to the risks - can you direct me to research on that. A personal friend of mine had been on a research program in the past for a major pharma in northern Illinois. What they were trying to do was find exactly how niacin works so the process could be synthesized and patented. The project was not successful. In laying the groundwork for the project he had to look at past use of it in the treatment for heart disease. Older docs he interviewed had used up to 3 grams a day with no adverse effects to their patients. Used as a drug, my friend feels it is the safest non diet way to control Tri's and raise HDL. Personally I have take 2 grams a day for well over a year. No harmful effects, blood work normal.
    Without statins, tri - 151, HDL - 32
    With Crestor 10mg tri 80 to 100, HDL 45.
    With 2 gram niacin - Tri 52, HDL 80.
    I take regular niacin. After a while, you will experience almost no flushing. Your body will acclimate.
    I tout the use of it because it seems a lot of docs have forgotten it's usefulness. Keep up the info when you can.

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 4:59:05 PM |

    I've taken immediate-release niacin since 2003 and the only time I developed elevated liver enzymes was when I split a 4 gram daily dose into three divided doses.  I can take 1 gram three times a day with no problems, or up to 2.5 grams twice a day with no problems.  However, HDL elevation seems to plateau at 3 grams a day.

    Once in the last 3 years my doctor took me off niacin for 3 weeks to perform an NMR lipoprotein test.  With carbohydrate consumption under 70 grams a day and fat intake of 67%, my LDL particle count was over 2,000 and over 75% of them were small and dense.

    Niacin is the only way for me to reduce my small, dense LDL to a safer level.  Diet and exercise is not enough.  I suppose this explains why every male (except for me) has a major heart attack or stroke by the age of 50.

  • Anonymous

    4/20/2011 5:04:31 PM |

    One reason aspirin blocks only part of the flush is that the flush is produced by two separate mechanisms.  The most well known is the release of PGD2 from mast cells.  The other, which is rarely mentioned, is the release of serotonin from platelets.  Serotonin antagonists completely block the flushing due that mechanism (see "Niacin-induced “flush” Involves Release of PGD2 from Mast Cells and Serotonin from Platelets: Evidence from Human Cells In Vitro and an Animal Model", Dean Papaliodis,2008, American Society for Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics"

  • Sara

    4/20/2011 7:42:08 PM |

    I think niacin and metformin are 2 of the most powerful and safest drugs for metabolic syndrome.

  • pjnoir

    4/20/2011 9:39:57 PM |

    High doses of Niacin will increase blood sugars - I'll take my chances with Chloresterol (mind is low enough) then mess with my sugars.

  • pjnoir

    4/20/2011 10:07:25 PM |

    *mine    not mind  
    Sara- since blood sugars go up- how can it be a good choice to improve metabolism?

  • Might-o'chondri-AL

    4/20/2011 11:00:14 PM |

    ? Anyone with input on the supposed benefit of taking Niacin every other day, instead of daily ?
    Someone brought it up once in an old niacin post of this blog, but nobody else seemed to know about that dosing.

  • Christi

    4/21/2011 12:16:02 AM |

    You could also add Protandim to your daily regimen. Pubmed.gov studies have shown Protandim to be extremely helpful in heart disease. It reduces Oxidative Stress and inflammation in the cells. www.dailylifesource.com

  • christi

    4/21/2011 12:18:13 AM |

    You should also add Protandim to your daily regimen. I first was exposed to this product on the ABC Primetime news investigative report. Pubmed.gov has published peer reviewed studies that show Protandim is very effective with heart disease. Check out the ABC news program here: www.dailylifesource.com

  • Anonymous

    4/21/2011 3:18:08 AM |

    Christi:

    I looked up on Wikipedia the supplement Protandim you mentioned. I am familiar with 4 of the 5 ingredients it contains and while the 4 have a good reputation, I am not impressed with the overall product. Most of the studies were conducted in an animal model. If I was looking to raise my endogenous antioxidant levels (SOD, catalase & glutathione) like Protandim claims, I would take GliSODin instead...probably in the form of Life Extension brand Endothelial Defense. I am sure Endothelial Defense is more cost effective and a has meaningful doses of better researched ingredients.

    Pjnoir:

    While it is true that Niacin can raise fasting glucose a few points, this can be more than made up for with a better diet and exercise. In fact, niacin might actually increase insulin sensitivity. Niacin is also extremely cardio protective. The HATS trial showed that Simvastatin+niacin reduced CHD events 89% less than the placebo group.

    John M.

  • Anonymous

    4/21/2011 6:42:52 AM |

    Kenneth....
    After a long period of utterly fruitless treatment with flush-free niacin as high as 4 grams a day, I started good old fashioned immediate release niacin.

    The flushing is manageable. The key is in slowly titrating up to your target dose. I think I went up maybe 50 mg a day every two weeks. I've been at 500 mg twice a day for months. I only get bad flushing when I let myself get dehydrated or indulge in sugar or other pro-inflammatory foods ie fast food or chips, things you shouldn't be eating anyway.

    There is some evidence that flavanoids can mitigate the flush, and I've had good luck with 600 mg or so of quercetin taken with my fish oil half an hour or so before the niacin. Baby aspirin helps, as does celebrex when I happen to take it for aches. I haven't been able to escalate the dose as I started getting muscle pains and fatigue even though my liver panels didn't indicate any problem. Everyone has different reactions, but don't write off niacin until you've given it a fair shot.  

    I will also tell you that Niaspan is NOT in fact flush-free either. I tried it for a short while and found that it simply delayed the flushing. The product literature says as much. The strategy is simply to put off the flushing until you're already asleep, and you pay hundreds of dollars more for that dubious benefit.

  • Hans Keer

    4/21/2011 10:07:15 AM |

    Why pills? Meat, vegetables and fruit deliver all the B3 you need.

  • Anonymous

    4/21/2011 12:36:50 PM |

    Even though I'm pre-diabetic, I've never experienced blood sugar elevation with niacin.

    The tolerance to the flushing develops with continuous use.  Although I've never tried it, every other day dosing may result in a more pronounced flushing effect.

    I've also used quercetin concurrently with niacin and have noticed a decrease in flushing.  I'm very fair-skinned and still experience flushing after all these years.

  • Anonymous

    4/21/2011 12:50:54 PM |

    What would be interesting if people who are using Niacin here tell us, what effect it had on their respective Cholesterol levels (HDL, LDL, Trigs).
    And if they had any issues with increasing liver enzymes or higher bloodsuger.

  • Kent

    4/21/2011 3:16:42 PM |

    Just an observation on the (Niaspan or intermediate release verses the imediate release.  I found Niaspan along with other LP(a) supplements (fish oil, Coq10, Pauling Protocol, low wheat) to work much better than the Intermediate release niacin. My LP(a) started at 198 and dropped to 45 with Naiaspan included in the regimen. I switched to imediate release and it went up to 150. I switched back to Niaspan and the LP(a) dropped back down. Has anyone else experienced this phenomena?

  • Leshme

    4/22/2011 2:30:31 AM |

    Since I began taking 1,000mg of regular niacin/day, my blood platelet count has hovered around 120,000. I have read online that niacin may cause a reduction in blood platelets. Can anyone comment?

  • Anonymous

    4/22/2011 6:52:39 AM |

    I use immediate release Niacin 2 grams a day.  Have used as much as 4 grams a day.

    I find that if I take any other supplements with plenty of fluid/food - usually a glass of tomato juice and a glass of water - and then wait for about 15 minutes before taking the niacin, I don't get a flush except maybe once a month and only slightly.  I use capsules and pull them slightly apart so that I can seperate them before swallowing, otherwise I might get a flush at some random time in the future when the capsules finally break open.  When I used to use tablets, I would chew them up so I wouldn't get a random flush at some future point.

  • Anonymous

    4/22/2011 3:26:02 PM |

    I took Niaspan for almost six months.  My physician started me off at 700mg and I ended up at 1000mg by the time I was taken off of it.  My blood work was somewhat better but nothing spectacular and it sure wasn't good enough for me to endure the extreme flushing I experienced three or four times a week. My whole body turned a dark apple red and I experienced extreme itching over every square inch of my body at once for thrity to forty-five minutes, as if I had millions of ants crawling on me.  I've read comments about how people enjoy this experience and I cannot begin to comprehend that as it was like being tortured to me.  I would scratch myself so much that I tore my skin.  Flushing took place even after taking aspirin and eating yogurt thirty minutes to an hour prior to taking it. You can have your niacin.  I'll stick to my Crestor.

  • Anonymous

    4/22/2011 5:08:25 PM |

    Dr. William Davis said...

        A discussion of the downsides of niacin, even when done properly, sounds like it might be of help to many people.

        I'l put it on the "to-do" list.
    .................

    I scheduled a general checkup in a few weeks, which I'm going to request a purines test, since I've read Niacin might affect gout sufferers.

    I've not been diagnosed with gout, but as it runs in my family, and I've also read that even though females get it less - that changes after (menopause, which I've started).

    Paternal grandfather suffered from diagnosed gout for years - he had many stomach bleeds from gout meds, so was taken off them. His last gout attack landed him in the hospital: Normal diet, IVF @ 125cc/hr, Foley output at end of day: ZERO.

    Younger brother's first gout attack  in late 30's (has one kidney, which probably hastened things). Mother also thinks she had one gout attack after over-indulging on a roast too many days in a row - she recognized her toe as looking like granddaddy's (not her father).

    So I'll play it safe and wait to see that my hormone situation didn't trigger high purine levels before starting slowly on SloNiacin.

    Please consider including Gout/Niacin info in your article Dr. Davis, and correct any mis-info I might have misinterpreted. I'll ask my GP if he orders liver functions with checkups at my age.

    Shreela

  • Jim (formerly anonymous)

    4/22/2011 11:53:16 PM |

    A Different Anonymous said...

        What would be interesting if people who are using Niacin here tell us, what effect it had on their respective Cholesterol levels (HDL, LDL, Trigs).
        And if they had any issues with increasing liver enzymes or higher bloodsuger.

        April 21, 2011

    I gave my results much earlier.

    I think that people here fail to understand that the very first successful Cholesterol lowering "drug" was niacin, plain old drugstore type.

    Evidently, the first American drug trial of Niacin was run by William Parsons Jr. MD in 1955 who was then a Resident at Mayo clinic. The actual use of Niacin was pioneered by the Canadians, and Parsons heard about it from a visiting Canadian Physician.

    There is therefore well over a half a century of use of Niacin for cholesterol control.

    Many MD's did't like it, because it is an unregulated non-prescription substance. Now there is a prescription form which is very expensive and well promoted with big bucks and drug representatives to push it.

    Dr. Parsons became less of a researcher and more of a clinician in later years. He has published a book "Cholesterol Control Without Diet : The Niacin Solution" which I suggest that you look at (library) or buy, if you are interested in the use of Niacin for cholesterol control.ISBN 0966256875 $14.95. 276 pages.

    With the expensive prescription Niaspan, now made and sold and marketed by Abbott Laboratories,the classical resistance of MD's to use this treatment is falling. No vitamin supplement firm could do this level of marketing for a cheap generic pill.

    From page 196:
    "Since the 1996 edition, there have been no more significant reports of liver problems with niacin. ...... and yet there are still no more than the 18 cases we listed here, 5 of them questionable."

    He also discusses the studies designed to make Niacin look bad, and Statins look good.

    It can be said that there is considerable confusion as to how Statins actually work. The first theory was cholesterol lowering. As evidence for inflammation to be a more dominant mechanism for CHD, there are now more reports that Statins have anti-inflammatory properties. But after all of the millions and millions of dollars spent on Statin R&D, the exact behavior of Statins is still not understood in detail.

    In fact, there were no real good theories for the painkilling behavior of Aspirin until sometime in about the 1960's or later.

    There are tons of information about Niacin out there, you have to go look for them, or buy the books. Well, you can just ask somebody to feed the information to you. That still works as a labor saving device.

  • Anonymous

    4/23/2011 2:23:35 PM |

    Thank you for the reminder to check into my "Now" brand Niacin.  

    Now claims sustained release formula on the bottle but there is nothing in the ingredients to suggest any coating or binding.  Regardless, I have been taking 2grms for a long time last thing at night along with my 2.7grms omega3 and 20mg crestor. Trigs and LDL were well controlled with this combo but my HDL was still only 45.  Then I switched back to eating meat(saturated fat), lowered my grain intake and last blood test HDL was 67.  the down side was my LDL went up 10%

    Regarding the Flush. If I awake after a few hrs into my sleep, often I will feel the flush/itchy skin.  Small price to pay for 90% reduction in a heart attack.

    Trev

  • Anonymous

    4/23/2011 2:45:06 PM |

    http://www.scribd.com/doc/50437/Niacin#fullscreen:off

    excellent summary of Niacin types and explanation  for liver toxicity.
    Trev

  • jbuch

    4/26/2011 2:51:35 PM |

    Excellent article on the Pharmacists knowledge of the different forms of niacin.

    Inspired me to do some more digging and I found this excellent webpage which is a baseline discussion of the ARBITER 6 Trial, with excellent comments on Niacin myths and factoids.

    http://www.theheart.org/article/1022265.do

    In particular, look at the readers comments, evidently almost exclusively MD, numbers 34 to about 57. It is here that some of the common myths and factoids are noted, mostly with literature citations rather than unsubstantiated claims.

    Below is one example.
    ---------------------------

    Niacin Dissolution Rates
    I recently came across an interesting paper on the dissolution rates of various niacin formulations. Niaspan was best in terms of slow dissolution, followed by Enduracin and Slo-niacin. For those interested:

    Poon, Ivy O., Chow, Diana S.-L., Liang, Dong
    Dissolution profiles of nonprescription extended-release niacin and inositol niacinate products
    Am J Health Syst Pharm 2006 63: 2128-2134
    ------------------------

  • Susan

    5/8/2011 7:20:26 AM |

    You might want to take a closer look at Protandim, it's not a simple product and takes a bit of time to take in what it really does in the body. There is proof that it  raises SOD in a human peer-reviewed study. Protandim is proven to increase catalase, glutathione, and a number of other endogenous antioxidants in addition to increasing SOD. The science is there, but how I really know it works is through what it has done for me and quite a number of people I know who have had notable improvements in their health. There is nothing wrong with glisodin, but it isn't in the same class as Protandim.  Protandim is proven to work through the activation of the Nrf2 transcription factor, up-regulating the antioxidant response gene sequence that causes the body to produce it's own native antioxidant products in every cell of the body. This site explains more about it and has links to supportive science:  www.radicalresults.net

  • yves

    5/11/2011 12:37:31 AM |

    Any insight as to whether Nicotinamide may be effective for those with fungal infections?
    http://www.wellnessresources.com/studies/niacinamide_helps_combat_candida_albicans/

  • georgepds

    5/20/2011 4:40:12 PM |

    "Why pills? Meat, vegetables and fruit deliver all the B3 you need."

    Because you would have to eat too much to get a clinical benefit

    You need 1000 to 2000 mg, 4 oz of chicken gets only 14 mg.. so, for the clinical benefit, you'd have to eat ~400 oz of chicken, or about 25 pounds of chicken a day.. just a  tad too much chiken for me


    http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=nutrient&dbid=83

  • Ken Levin

    6/5/2011 11:00:23 PM |

    Hi Dr Davis, I'm a new Track Your Plaque member and noticed two new studies claiming niacin was not helpful in reducing the incidence of heart attack. One study compared Zocor with and without  niaspan (summarized in New York Times about a week ago)  and one studied niacin (not sure which form, heard about the study through a physician)  alone.   Do these studies change your recommendations about niacin for Track Your Plaque members?  Thanks in advance and thank you for your Track your Plaque program.

  • Jonathan

    6/6/2011 5:03:29 PM |

    All I could find around here locally was slow release niacin (capsule shaped tablet).  I pop two 500mg and chew them.  I get a real nice flush.

  • Jesse

    6/24/2011 4:42:46 PM |

    Dr Davis, can you comment on the studies mentioned by Ken Levin above? I would be interested to know the specifics about them, and if they hold nay water.

    Thanks

  • M2

    7/2/2011 6:17:01 PM |

    Dr. Davis, very interested in a response to the niacin studies referenced by Ken and Jesse above.

    Thanks!

Loading
All posts by william-davis

Letter from the insurance company

Claudia got this letter from her health insurance company:

Dear Ms. ------,

Based on a recent review of your cholesterol panel of January 12, 2011, we feel that you should strongly consider speaking to your doctor about cholesterol treatment.

Reducing cholesterol values to healthy levels has been shown to reduce heart attack risk . . .


Okay. So the health insurer wants Claudia to take a cholesterol drug in the hopes that it will reduce their exposure to the costs for her future heart catheterization, angioplasty and stent, or bypass surgery. This is understandable, given the extraordinary costs of such hospital services, typically running from $40,000 for a several hour-long outpatient catheterization procedure, to as much as $200,000 for a several day long stay for coronary bypass surgery.

So what's the problem?

Here are Claudia's most recent lipid values:

LDL cholesterol 196 mg/dl
HDL 88 mg/dl
Triglycerides 37 mg/dl
Total cholesterol 291 mg/dl

By the criteria followed by her health insurer, both total and LDL cholesterol are much too high. Note, of course, that LDL cholesterol was a calculated value, not measured.

Here are Claudia's lipoproteins, drawn simultaneously with her lipids:

LDL particle number 898 nmol/L
Small LDL particle number less than 90 nmol/L (Values less than 90 are not reported by Liposcience)

LDL particle number is, by far and away, the best measure of LDL particles, an actual count of particles, rather than a guesstimate of LDL particles gauged by measuring cholesterol in the low-density fraction of lipoproteins (i.e., LDL cholesterol). It is also measured and is highly reproducible.

To convert LDL particle number in nmol/L to an LDL cholesterol-like value in mg/dl, divide by ten (or just drop the last digit).

Claudia's measured LDL is therefore 89 mg/dl--54% lower than the crude calculated LDL suggests.

This is because virtually all of Claudia's LDL particles are large, with little or no small. This situation throws off the crude assumptions built into the LDL calculation, making it appear that she has very high LDL cholesterol.

Do you think that Big Pharma advertises this phenomenon?

Healthy smoothies

I've now seen several people who have either caused themselves to be diabetic or to have other phenomena associated with excessive consumption of carbohydrates, all by innocently indulging in a carbohydrate-packed smoothie every morning.

Kay, for instance, has a smoothie of a half-pint blueberries, a banana, a scoop of whey, low-fat yogurt, a cup of milk every morning. The rest of her diet was fairly healthy: salads with oil-based dressing for lunch, salmon and asparagus for dinner, only an occasional carbohydrate indulgence outside of her morning smoothie ritual. Yet she had a HbA1c (a reflection of prior 60 to 90 days average blood sugar) at the near-diabetic range of 5.9%.

The mistake most people make when making smoothies is relying too heavily on carbohydrates like fruit. A smoothie like the one made by Kay can easily top 50, 60, or 70 grams carbohydrates per serving, more than sufficient to send blood sugars up to 150 mg/dl or more.

So what can you put in your smoothie and not send you over the edge to diabetes, small LDL, and all the other undesirable phenomena of excessive carbohydrates? Here's a list:

--coconut milk, unsweetened almond milk. Less desirable: milk, full-fat soymilk
--ground flaxseed
--oils: flaxseed oil, coconut oil (melted), extra-light olive oil, walnut oil
--dried coconut
--extracts: vanilla, almond, coconut, cherry, hazelnut
--spices: cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger
--herbs: mint leaves, cilantro
--cocoa powder (unsweetened)
--nut or seed butters (peanut butter, almond butter, sunflower seed butter)
--tofu
--exotic ingredients (ingredients you wouldn't expect in a smoothie): spinach, kale, cucumber

How do you sweeten a smoothie? This is what trips up most people. If you resort to fruit like bananas, pineapple, or apple, you will readily send your blood sugar skyward. Honey, agave syrup, and sugar, of course, all increase blood sugar and/or have the adverse effects of fructose. Be careful of yogurt, also, for similar reasons.

Therefore, to sweeten your smoothie, consider:

--Small servings of berries, e.g., 8-10 blueberries, 2 strawberries, a few wedges of apple, half a kiwi
--Non-nutritive sweeteners like stevia, Truvia, sucralose, xylitol, erythritol. Also, sugar-free (sucralose-based) syrups like those from DaVinci and Torani are useful. (Just be aware that non-nutritive sweeteners can increase appetite--use sparingly.)

Also, note that, if you have divorced yourself from wheat, cornstarch, and sugars, your desire for sweet should be much reduced. Foods other people find just right will taste sickeningly sweet to you. You might therefore find that foods like peanut butter or coconut milk have a mild natural sweetness; added sweetness is only minimally necessary.

Coming next: I'll share a smoothie recipe or two of mine. Anyone want to share a recipe?

Insulin secretagogue

Dairy products have the peculiar property of triggering pancreatic release of insulin. The research group at Lund University in Sweden have contributed the most to documenting this phenomenon:




Mean (±SEM) incremental changes (?) in serum insulin in response to equal amounts of carbohydrate from a white-wheat-bread reference meal (x) and test meals of whey (?), milk (?), cheese (?), cod (?), gluten-low (?), and gluten-high (?) meals. From Nilsson 2004.

Note that it is the area under the curve (AUC), not the peak value, that assumes greatest importance.

Dairy products, especially milk, whey, and yogurt, are insulin secretagogues: they stimulate pancreatic release of insulin. The effect is likely due to amino acids and/or polypeptides in dairy products. (The effect is less prominent with cheese. Also see this study.)

By conventional wisdom, this may be a good thing, since the excess insulin will blunt the glucose rise after consumption. However, in my book, this is not such a good thing, since most of us have tired, beaten, overworked pancreatic beta cells from our decades of carbohydrate overconsumption. I fear that the effect of dairy products just take us a bit closer to beta cell failure: diabetes.

Good news: The effect is least with cheese.

Be gluten-free without "gluten-free"

While I've discussed this before, it is such a confusing issue that I'd like to discuss it again.

I advocate wheat elimination because consumption of products made from modern dwarf Triticum aestivum:

--Triggers formation of extravagant quantities of small LDL and LDL particle number (or apoprotein B)
--Triggers inflammatory phenomena like c-reactive protein, increases leptin resistance, and reduction of the protective adipocytokine, adiponectin.
--Encourages accumulation of deep visceral fat ("wheat belly") that is inflammatory and causes resistance to insulin
--Increases blood sugar more than nearly all other foods--higher than a Milky Way bar, higher than a Snickers bar, higher than table sugar.
--Is being linked to a growing number of immune-mediated diseases, including celiac disease (quadrupled over past 50 years), type 1 diabetes in children, and cerebellar ataxia and peripheral neuropathies.

This last group of wheat-related phenomena are primarily due to gluten, the collection of 50+ proteins found in each wheat plant. For this reason, people diagnosed with celiac disease are advised to eliminate gluten from wheat and other sources (barley, rye, triticale, bulgur) and to eat gluten-free foods.

Gluten-free has therefore come to be viewed as wheat-free and problem-free. It ain't so.

Among the few foods that increase blood glucose higher than wheat: cornstarch, rice starch, potato starch, and tapioca starch--Yup: the ingredients commonly used to replace wheat in gluten-free foods. They are also flagrant triggers of the small LDL pattern, along with increased triglycerides, reduced HDL, increased visceral fat, increased blood pressure. In short, gluten-free foods lack the immune and brain effects of wheat gluten, but still make you fat, hypertensive, and diabetic.

I tell patients to view gluten-free foods like jelly beans: Gluten-free pancakes, muffins, breads, etc. are indulgences, not healthy replacements for wheat. It's okay to have a few jelly beans now and then. But they should not be part of a frequent or daily routine. Same with gluten-free foods.

Diabetes: Better than hedge funds

Diabetes is where the action is.

While, for virtually all of history, type 2 diabetes was an uncommon condition of adults, the disease has spread so much to all levels of American society that even kids are now developing the adult form. Researchers from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention predict that, by 2050, one in three adults will be diabetic.

The diabetes market is booming, handily surpassing growth of the oil industry, the housing market, even technology. It makes Bernie Madoff’s billions look like small potatoes. In health, few markets are growing as fast as diabetes—-not osteoporosis, not heart disease, not cancer.

Americans are getting fat from carbohydrate consumption, becoming diabetic along with it. While kids hanging around the convenience store gulp down 26 teaspoons of sugar in 32-ounce sodas and 56-grams-of-sugar in 16-ounce frozen ices, health-minded adults are more likely eating two slices of 6-teaspoons sugar-equivalent “healthy whole grain” bread, wondering why last year’s jeans are too tight.

The U.S. is not the only nation affected. Globally, 2.8% of the world’s population are diabetic, a number expected to double over the next 20 years.

Pharmaceutical companies boast double-digit growth for diabetes drugs, growth rates that keep profit-hungry investors happy. Merck’s Januvia, for instance, introduced in 2006, recently catalogued 30% growth in sales, with annual sales approaching $1 billion. Recently FDA-approved Victoza, requiring once-a-day injection, is expected to reap $4 billion in sales per year for manufacturer Novo Nordisk. Such numbers can only warm a drug company CEO’s heart.

Most diabetics don’t just take one medication, but several. A typical regimen for an adult diabetic after a couple of years of treatment and following the dietary advice of the American Diabetes Association includes metformin, Januvia, and Actos, a triple-drug treatment that costs around $420 per month. Two forms of insulin (slow- and fast-acting), along with two or three oral medications, is not at all uncommon.

“Collateral” revenues from the other health conditions that develop from a diet rich in “healthy whole grains,” such as drugs for hypertension, drugs to slow the progression of kidney disease in diabetes, drugs for “high cholesterol,” and drugs for high triglycerides, and you have a pharmaceutical drug bonanza. You, too, would throw all-expenses-paid, fly-the-entire-sales-force-to-the-Caribbean sales meetings.

The global diabetes market has already topped $25 billion and is growing at double-digit rates. Forget the Internet, gold stocks, or solar energy—-diabetes is where the money is. This fact has not been lost on the very market-savvy pharmaceutical industry. As with any successful business, they have devoted substantial resources to develop and grow this booming business.

270 lb man in diapers

Alex is a big guy: 6 ft 4 inches, 273 lbs.

On 10,000 units per day of vitamin D in gelcap form, his 25-hydroxy vitamin D level was 38.4 ng/ml. One year earlier, his 25-hydroxy vitamin D level, prior to any vitamin D supplementation was 9.8 ng/ml.

According to the latest assessment offered by the Institute of Medicine (IOM):

Vitamin D need for a 13-month old infant: 600 units per day

Vitamin D need for a 6 ft 4 in, 273 lb male: 600 units per day

I paint this picture to highlight some of the absurdity built into the smug assumptions of the IOM's report. It would be like trying to fit a large, full-grown man into the diapers of a 13-month old. Few nutrients or hormones (in fact, I can't think of a single one) are required in similar quantity by an infant or toddler and a full grown adult. However, according to the IOM's logic, their vitamin D needs are identical, regardless of age, body size, skin color, genetics, etc. One size fits all.

Just as the original RDA assessment by the Institute of Medicine kept thinking about vitamin D somewhere in the Stone Age, so does this most recent assessment.

90% small LDL: Good news, bad news

Chris has 90% small LDL particles.

On his (NMR) lipoprotein panel, of the total 2432 nmol/L LDL particles ("LDL particle number"), 2157 nmol/L are small, approximately 90% (2157/2432).

Bad news: Having this severe excess of small LDL particles virtually guarantees heart attack and stroke in Chris' future.

Good news: It means that Chris potentially has spectacular control over his lipoprotein and lipid values, achieving statin-like values without statin drugs.

Typically, extravagant quantities of small LDL particles are accompanied by low HDL, high triglycerides, and pre-diabetes or diabetes. Chris' HDL is 26 mg/dl, triglycerides 204 mg/dl; HbA1c 5.9% (a reflection of prior 60-90 days average blood glucose; desirable 4.8% or less), fitting neatly into the expected pattern.

Chris' pattern tells me several things:

1) He overconsumes carbohydrates, since carbohydrates trigger this pattern.
2) He likely has a genetic susceptibility to this effect (e.g., a variant of the gene for cholesteryl ester transfer protein, perhaps hepatic lipase). Only the most gluttonous and overweight carbohydrate consumers can generate this high a percentage small LDL without an underlying genetic susceptibility.
3) Provided he follows the diet advised, i.e., elimination of all wheat, cornstarch, oats, and sugars, he is likely to have an extavagant drop in LDL particle number. Should he achieve the goal I set of small LDL of 300 nmol/L or less, his LDL particle number will likely be around 500 nmol/L. This translates to an LDL cholesterol of 50 mg/dl . . . 50 mg/dl.

In many people, this notion of taking statin drugs for "high cholesterol" is an absurd oversimplification. But it is a situation that, for many, is wonderfully controllable with the right diet.

The American Heart Association has a PR problem

The results of the latest Heart Scan Blog poll are in. The poll was prompted by yet another observation that the American Heart Association diet is a destructive diet that, in this case, made a monkey fat.

Because I am skeptical of "official" organizations that purport to provide health advice, particularly nutritional advice, I thought this poll might provide some interesting feedback.

I asked:

The American Heart Association is an organization that:

The responses:
Tries to maintain the procedural and medication status quo to benefit the medical system and pharmaceutical industry for money
240 (64%)

Doesn't know its ass from a hole in the ground
121 (32%)

Is generally helpful but is misguided in some of its advice
79 (21%)

Accomplishes tremendous good and you people are nuts
6 (1%)


Worrisome. Now, perhaps the people reading this blog are a skeptical bunch. Or perhaps they are better informed.

Nonetheless, one thing is clear: The American Heart Association (and possibly other organizations like the American Diabetes Association and USDA) have a serious PR problem. They are facing an increasingly critical and skeptical public.

Just telling people to "cut the fat and cholesterol" is beginning to fall on deaf ears. After all, the advice to cut fat, cut saturated fat, cut cholesterol and increase consumption of "healthy whole grains" in 1985 began the upward ascent of body weight and diabetes in the American public.

Believe it or not, my vote would be for something between choices 1 and 3. I believe that the American Heart Association achieves a lot of good. But I also believe that there are forces within organizations that are there to serve their own agendas. In this case, I believe there is a substantial push to maintain the procedural and medication status quo, the "treatments" that generate the most generous revenues.

I believe that I will forward these poll results to the marketing people at the American Heart Association. That'll be interesting!

The formula for aortic valve disease?

I've discussed this question before:

Can aortic valve stenosis be stopped or reversed using a regimen of nutritional supplements?

I had a striking experience this past week. Don has coronary plaque and began the Track Your Plaque program. However, discovery of a murmur led to an echocardiogram that measured his effective aortic valve area at 1.5 cm2. (Normal is between 2.5-3.0 cm2.)

Because of his aortic valve issue, I suggested that, in addition to the 10,000 units of vitamin D required to increase his 25-hydroxy vitamin D level to 70 ng/ml, he also add vitamin K2, 1000 mcg per day, along with elimination of all calcium supplements. (I asked Don to use a K2 supplement that contained both forms, short-acting MK-4 and long-acting MK-7.)

One year later, another echocardiogram: aortic valve area 2.6 cm2--an incredible increase.

This is not supposed to happen. By conventional thinking, aortic valve stenosis can only get worse, never get better. But I've now witnessed this in approximately 10% of the people with aortic valve stenosis. The majority just stop getting worse, an occasional person gets worse, while a few, like Don, get better.

Aortic valve stenosis is to the aortic valve as degenerative arthritis is to your knees: A form of wear-and-tear that leads to progressive dysfunction. When the aortic valve becomes stiff enough (i.e., "stenotic"), then it leads to chest pains, lightheadedness or losing consciousness, heart failure, and, eventually, death. Bad problem.

Aortic stenosis typically starts in your 50s with calcification of the valve, getting worse and worse until the calcium makes the valve "leaflets" unable to move. The treatment: a new valve, a major undertaking involving an open heart procedure.

What if taking vitamins D and K2 and avoiding calcium do not just reverse or stop aortic valve stenosis once established, but prevents it in the first place? Tantalizing possibility.

Pressures on my time being what they are, I've not had the freedom to put together a prospective study to further examine this fascinating question. But it is definitely worth pursuing.

Blood glucose 160

What happens when blood glucose hits 160 mg/dl?

A blood glucose at this level is typical after, say, a bowl of slow-cooked oatmeal with no added sugar, a small serving of Cheerios, or even an apple in the ultra carb-sensitive. Normal blood sugar with an empty stomach, i.e., fasting; high blood sugars after eating.

Conventional wisdom is that a blood sugar of 160 mg/dl is okay, since your friendly primary care doctor says that any postprandial glucose of 200 mg/dl or less is fine because you don't "need" medication.

But what sort of phenomena occur when blood sugars are in this range? Here's a list:

--Glycation (i.e., glucose modification of proteins) of various tissues, including the lens of your eyes (cataracts), kidney tissue leading to kidney disease, skin leading to wrinkles, cartilage leading to stiffness, degeneration, and arthritis.
--Glycation of LDL particles. Glycated LDL particles are more prone to oxidation.
--VLDL and triglyceride production by the liver, i.e., de novo lipogenesis.
--Small LDL particle formation--The increased VLDL/triglyceride production leads to the CETP-mediated reaction that creates small LDL particles which are, in turn, more glycation- and oxidation-prone.
--Glucotoxicity--i.e., a direct toxic effect of high blood glucose. This is especially an issue for the vulnerable beta cells of the pancreas that produce insulin. Repeated glucotoxic poundings by high glucose levels lead to fewer functional beta cells.

A blood glucose of 160 mg/dl is definitely not okay. While it is not an immediate threat to your health, repeated exposures will lead you down the same path that diabetics tread with all of its health problems.
All posts by william-davis

Are you hungry?

Eliminate modern high-yield semi-dwarf Triticum aestivum . . . and what is the effect on appetite?

A reduction in appetite is among the most common and profound experiences resulting from wheat elimination. I know that I have personally felt it: Wake up in the morning, little interest in breakfast for several hours. Lunch? Maybe I'll have a few bites of something. Dinner . . . well, I'd like to exercise first.

The wheatless report that:

--Appetite diminishes to the point where you can't remember whether you've eaten or not. It is not uncommon to miss a meal, perfectly content. Calorie intake drops by 400 calories per day, on average, calories you otherwise would not have needed but all went to . . . you know where.
--Hunger feels different: It's not the gnawing, rumbling hunger that plagues you every 2 hours. In its place, you will find that hunger feels like a soft reminder that, gee, maybe it's time to have something to eat because you haven't had anything in--what?--4 to 6 hours. And it's a subtle reminder, not a desperate hunt that makes you knock people aside at the food bar, steal coworkers' lunches stored in the refrigerator, salivating at the mere thought of food.
--The simplest foods satisfy--It no longer requires an all-you-can-eat buffet to satisfy, but a few small pieces of healthy food. (Yeah, but what happens to revenues at Kraft, Nabisco, and Kelloggs, not to mention the revenues at agribusiness giants ADM and Monsanto? Slash consumption by, say, 30%, you likewise slash revenues by 30%. What would shareholders say?)
--Even prolonged periods of not eating, i.e., fasting, is endured with ease.

Hunger and the relentless search for something to eat disappear for most people. By eliminating the appetite-stimulating properties of wheat, we return to a natural state of eating for sustenance, to satisfy physiologic need. We are no longer victims of this incredibly powerful appetite-stimulant called gliadin from wheat.

This is why many diets fail: They fail to remove this powerful appetite stimulant. You might eat only lean meats, limit your calories, and exercise 90 minutes per day, but as long as the gliadin protein is pushing your appetite button, you will want to eat more or you will have to mount monumental willpower to resist it. You can lose 20 pounds on phase 1 of the South Beach diet, for instance, only to regain it in phases 2 and 3 when "healthy whole grains" are added back.

So the key is to remove the gliadin protein from your life, i.e., eliminate all things wheat.

 

Chocolate . . . for adults only

If you've got a serious chocolate addiction and you'd like to make it as healthy as possible, give this X-rated dark chocolate a try.
I call it X-rated because it is certain to not satisfy young, sugar-craving palates, but is appropriate for only the most serious chocolate craver. This is a way to obtain the rich flavors and textures of cocoa, the health benefits (e.g., blood pressure reduction, antioxidation) of cocoa flavonoids, while obtaining none of the sugars/carbohydrates . . . and certainly no wheat!

It is easy to make, requiring just a few ingredients, a few steps, and a few minutes. Set aside and save for an indulgence, e.g., dip into natural peanut or almond butter.

Ingredients:
8 ounces 100% unsweetened cocoa
5 tablespoons coconut oil, melted
1/2 cup dry roasted pistachios
1/4 cup whole flaxseeds or chia seeds
Truvia or other non-aqueous sweetener

Using double-boiler method, melt cocoa. Alternatively, melt cocoa in microwave in 15-20 second increments. Stir in coconut oil, pistachios, and flaxseeds or chia seeds. Stir in sweetener, mixing thoroughly. (Note that the sweetener must be non-aqueous, as water-based sweeteners will separate in the oils.)

Lay a sheet of parchment paper out on a large baking pan. Pour chocolate mixture slowly onto paper, tilting pan carefully to spread evenly until thickness of thick cardboard obtained. Place pan in refrigerator or freezer for 20 minutes.

Remove chocolate and break by hand into pieces of desired size.

"Friday is my bad day"

At the start, Ted had a ton of small LDL particles. His starting (NMR) lipoprotien values:

LDL particle number: 2644 nmol/L

Small LDL: 2301 nmol/L

In other words, approximately 85% of all LDL particles were abnormally small. I showed Ted how to use diet to markedly reduce small LDL particles, including elimination of wheat, limiting other carbohydrates, and even counting carbohydrates to keep the quantity no higher than 15 grams per meal ("net" carbs).

Ted comes back 6 months later, having lost 14 pounds in the process (and now with weight stabilized). Another round of lipoproteins show:

LDL particle number: 1532 nmol/L

Small LDL: 799 nmol/L

Better, but not perfect. small LDL persists, representing nearly 50% of total LDL particle number.

So I quiz Ted about his diet. "Gee, I really stick to this diet. I have nothing made of wheat, no sugars. I count my carbs and I almost never go higher . . . except on Fridays."

"What happens on Friday?" I asked.

"That's when I'm bad. Not really bad. Maybe just a couple of slices of pizza. Or I'll go out for a big custard cone or something. That wouldn't do it, would it?"

That's the explanation. Your liver is well-equipped to recognize normal, large LDL particles. Large LDL particles therefore "live" for only a couple of days in the bloodstream. But the human liver does not recognize the peculiar configuration of small LDL particles, so it lets them pass--over and over and over again. The result: Once triggered by, say two slices of pizza, small LDL particles persist for 5 days, sometimes longer.

So Ted's one "bad" day per week is enough to allow a substantial quantity of small LDL particles to persist. While a fat indulgence (if there is such a thing) pushes large LDL up, the effect is relatively short-lived. Have a carbohydrate indulgence, on the other hand, and small LDL particles persist for up to a week. It means that Ted's one "bad" day per week is enough to allow his small LDL particles to persist at this level, preventing him from gaining full control over coronary plaque.

It also means that, if you have blood drawn for lipoprotein analysis but had a carbohydrate goodie within the previous week, small LDL particles may be exaggeratedly high.

HDL 80 mg/dl

More and more people in my clinic are showing HDL cholesterol values of 80 mg/dl or higher, males included.

Think about it: Nationwide, average HDL for males is 42 mg/dl and for females 52 mg/dl. Even though these average values are generally regarded as favorable, HDL cholesterol values at these levels are nearly always associated with higher levels of triglycerides, postprandial (after-eating) lipoprotein abnormalities, and excessive quantities of small LDL particles.

HDL particles are, of course, protective and are powerfully anti-oxidative. Higher levels of HDL have been associated with reduced potential for cancer, as well as reduced risk for heart disease.

Following the simple regimen that we follow to gain control over coronary plaque has therefore increased levels of HDL to heights that are uncommon in the rest of the population, levels that readily top 80, 90, or 100 mg/dl. That regimen includes:

1) Elimination of all wheat--Yes, consumption of "healthy whole grains" sets you up to have lower HDL levels; elimination of wheat increases HDL.
2) Limited carbohydrate consumption--While eliminating wheat is a powerful nutritional strategy to increase HDL, non-wheat carbohydrates like quinoa, millet, beans, rice, and fruit can still cause high triglycerides that lead to reduced levels of HDL. Limited exposure helps keep HDL at higher levels.
3) Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation--Because omega-3 fatty acids reduce both triglycerides and blunt the postprandial rise in lipoproteins that can cause HDL degradation, HDL rises with omega-3s from fish oil.
4) Vitamin D supplementation--The effect is slow, but it is BIG. HDL just goes up and up and up over about 2 years of supplementation. Before vitamin D, HDL levels of 60 mg/dl were the best I could hope for in most people. Now 80 mg/dl is an everyday occurrence.

Other factors can also be used to increase HDL levels, such as weight loss, red wine and alcohol, exercise, cocoa flavonoids, green tea, and niacin. But following the regimen above sends HDL through the roof in the majority.

Lessons from the 20-year statin experience

Readers of the Heart Scan Blog know that, while I recognize that statins are useful in a small segment of the population with genetically-determined disorders, they are wildly overused, misused, and abused. In my view, the majority of people taking statins have no business doing so and could, in fact, obtain superior results by following some of the strategies advocated in these pages.

Nonetheless, the 30-year long statin experience has taught us some important lessons. Statin drugs have enjoyed more "research" than any other class of drugs ever conceived. They have received more media attention and embraced by more physicians than any other class of drugs. Combine these social phenomena and I believe that several lessons can be learned:

Small LDL particles and increased HbA1c--An evil duo

Small LDL particles are triggered by consumption of carbohydrates. Eat more "healthy whole grains," for instance, and small LDL particles skyrocket.

Increased hemoglobin A1c, HbA1c, a reflection of the last 60-90 days' blood sugars, is likewise a reflection of carbohydrate consumption. The greater the carbohydrate consumption and/or carbohydrate intolerance, the greater the HbA1c. Most regard a HbA1c of 6.5% or greater diabetes; values of 5.7-6.4% pre-diabetes. However, note that any value of 5.0% or more signifies that the process of glycation is occurring at a faster than normal rate. Recall that endogenous glycation, i.e., glucose modification of proteins, ensues whenever blood sugars increase over the normal range of 90 mg/dl (equivalent to HbA1c of 4.7-5.0%). Glycation is the fundamental process that leads to cataracts, arthritis, and atherosclerosis.

Put the two together--increased quantity of small LDL particles along with HbA1c of 5.0% or higher--and you have a powerful formula for heart disease and coronary plaque growth. This is because small LDL particles are not just smaller; they also have a unique conformation that exposes a (lysine residue-bearing) portion of the apoprotein B molecule contained within that makes small LDL particles uniquely glycation-prone. Compared to large LDL particles, small LDL particles are 8-fold more prone to glycation.

So glycated small LDL particles are present when HbA1c is increased above 5.0%. Small, glycated LDL particles are poorly recognized by the liver receptor that ordinarily picks up and disposes LDL particles, unlike large LDL particles, meaning small LDL particles "live" much longer in the bloodstream, providing more opportunityt to do its evil handiwork. Curiously, small LDL particles are avidly taken up by inflammatory white blood cells that can live in the walls of arteries, where they are oxidized--"glycoxidized"--and add to coronary atherosclerotic plaque.

The key is therefore to tackle both small LDL particles and HbA1c.

Unforgiving small LDL particles

Small LDL particles are triggered by carbohydrates in the diet: Eat carbohydrates, small LDL particles go up. Cut carbohydrates, small LDL particles go down.

A typical scenario would be someone starts with, say, 2000 nmol/L small LDL (by NMR) because they've been drinking the national Kool Aid of eating more "healthy whole grains" and consuming somewhere around 200 grams carbohydrates per day, including the destructive amylopectin A of wheat. This person slashes wheat followed by limiting other carbohydrates and takes in, say, 40-50 grams per day. Small LDL: 200 nmol/L.

In other words, reducing carbohydrate exposure slashes the expression of small LDL particles, since carbohydrate deprivation disables the liver process of de novo lipogenesis that forms triglycerides. Abnormal or exaggerated postprandial (after-eating) lipoproteins that are packed with triglycerides are also reduced. Because triglycerides provide the first lipoprotein "domino" that cascades into the formation of small LDL particles, carbohydrate reduction results in marked reduction in small LDL particle formation.

So let's say you are doing great and you've slashed carbohydrates. Small LDL particles are now down to zero--no small LDL whatsoever. What LDL particles you have are the more benign large variety, say, 1200 nmol/L (LDL particle number), all large, none small. You are due for some more blood work on Thursday. On Tuesday, however, you have four crackers because, what the heck, you've been doing great, you've lost 43 pounds, and have been enjoying dramatic correction of your lipoprotein abnormalities.

Your next lipoprotein panel: LDL particle number 1800 nmol/L, small LDL 700 nmo/L--substantially worse, with a major uptick in small LDL.

That's how sensitive small LDL particles can be to carbohydrate intake. And the small LDL particles can last for up to several days, since small LDL particles are not just smaller in size, they also differ in conformation, making them unrecognizable by the normal liver receptor. The small LDL particles triggered by the 4 crackers therefore linger, outlasting the normal-conformation large LDL particles that are readily cleared by the liver.

This phenomenon is responsible for great confusion when following lipoprotein panels, since a 98% perfect diet can yield dismaying results just from a minor indulgence. But, buried in this simple observation is the notion that small LDL particles are also extremely unforgiving, being triggered by the smallest carbohydrate indulgence, lasting longer and wreaking their atherosclerotic plaque havoc.

I eliminated wheat . . . and I didn't lose weight!

Elimination of wheat is a wonderfully effective way to lose weight. Because saying goodbye to wheat means removing the gliadin protein of wheat, the protein degraded to brain-active exorphins that stimulate appetite, calorie consumption is reduced, on average, 400 calories per day. It also means eliminating this source of high blood sugar and high blood insulin and the 90-minutes cycles of highs and lows that cause a cyclic need to eat more at the inevitable low. It means that the high blood sugar and insulin phenomena that trigger accumulation of visceral fat are now turned off. It may possibly also mean that wheat lectins no longer block the leptin receptor, undoing leptin resistance and allowing weight loss to proceed. And weight loss usually results effortlessly and rapidly.

But not always. Why? Why are there people who, even after eliminating this appetite-stimulating, insulin-triggering, leptin-blocking food, still cannot lose weight? Or stall after an initial few pounds?

There are a list of reasons, but here are the biggies:

1) Too many carbohydrates--What if I eliminate wheat but replace those calories with gluten-free breads, muffins, and cookies? Then I've switched one glucose-insulin triggering food for another. This is among the reasons I condemn gluten-free foods made with rice starch, cornstarch, tapioca starch, and potato starch. Or perhaps there's too many potatoes, rices, and oats in your diet. While not as harmful as wheat, they still provoke phenomena that cause weight loss to stall. So cutting carbohydrates may become necessary, e.g., no more than 12-14 grams per meal.

2) Fructose--Fructose has become ubiquitous and has even assumed some healthy-appearing forms. "Organic agave nectar" is, by far, the worst, followed by maple syrup, honey, high-fructose corn syrup, sucrose,and fruit--yes, in that order. They are all sources of fructose that causes insulin resistance, visceral fat accumulation or persistency, prolongation of clearing postprandial (after-meal) lipoproteins that antagonize insulin, and glycation. Lose the fructose sources--as much of it as possible. (Fruit should be eaten in very small portions.) Watch for stealth sources like low-fat salad dressings--you shouldn't be limiting your fat anyway!

3) Thyroid dysfunction--A real biggie. Number one cause to consider for thyroid dysfunction: iodine deficiency. Yes, it's coming back in all its glory, just like the early 20th century before iodized salt made it to market shelves. Now, people are cutting back on iodized salt. Guess what's coming back? Iodine deficiency and even goiters. Yes, goiters, the disfiguring growths on the neck that you thought you'd only see in National Geographic pictures of malnourished native Africans. Number two: Exposure to factors that block the thyroid. This may include wheat, but certainly includes perchlorate residues (synthetic fertilizer residues) on produce, pesticides, herbicides, polyfluorooctanoic acid residues from non-stick cookware, polybrominated diphenyl ethers (flame retardants), and on and on. If you are iodine-deficient, it can even include goitrogenic iodine-blocking foods like broccoli, cauliflower, and soy. Thyroid status therefore needs to be assessed.

4) Cortisol--Not so much excess cortisol as disruptions of circadian rhythm. Cortisol should surge in the morning, part of the process to arouse you from sleep, then decline to lower levels in the evening to allow normal recuperative sleep. But this natural circadian cycling is lost in many people represented, for instance, as a flip-flopping of the pattern with low levels in the morning (with morning fatigue) and high levels at bedtime (with insomnia), which can result in stalled weight loss or weight gain. Cortisol status therefore needs to be assessed, best accomplished with salivary cortisol assessment.

5) Leptin resistance--People who are overweight develop an inappropriate resistance to the hormone, leptin, which can present difficulty in losing weight. This can be a substantial issue and is not always easy to overcome. It might mean assessing leptin levels or it might mean taking some steps to overcome leptin resistance.

Okay, that's a lot. Next: More on how to know when thyroid dysfunction is to blame.

Do the math: 41.7 pounds per year

Consumers of wheat take in, on average, 400 calories more per day. Conversely, people who eliminate wheat consume, on average, 400 calories less per day.

400 calories per day multiplied by 365 days per day equals 146,000 additional calories over the course of one year. 146,000 calories over a year equals 41.7 pounds gained per year. Over a decade, that's 417 pounds. Of course, few people actually gain this much weight over 10 years.

But this is the battle most people who follow conventional advice to "cut your fat and eat more healthy whole grains" are fighting, the constant struggle to subdue the appetite-increasing effects of the gliadin protein of wheat, pushing your appetite buttons to consume more . . . and more, and more, fighting to minimize the impact.

So, if you eat "healthy whole grains" and gain "only" 10 pounds this year, that's an incredible success, since it means that you have avoided gaining the additional 31.7 pounds that could have accumulated. It might mean having to skip meals despite your cravings, or exercising longer and harder, or sticking your finger down your throat.

400 additional calories per day times 365 days per year times 300,000,000 people in the U.S. alone . . . that's a lot of dough. Is this entire scenario an accident?

Or, of course, you could avoid the entire situation and kiss wheat goodbye . . . and lose 20, 30, or 130 pounds this year.

We got the drug industry we deserve

A biting commentary on just who is writing treatment guidelines for diabetes and cardiovascular disease was published in the British Medical Journal, summarized in theHeart.org's HeartWire here.

"About half the experts serving on the committees that wrote national clinical guidelines for diabetes and hyperlipidemia over the past decade had potential financial conflicts of interest (COI), and about 4% had conflicts that were not disclosed.

"Five of the guidelines did not include a declaration of the panel members' conflicts of interest, but 138 of the 288 panel members (48%) reported conflicts of interest at the time of the publication of the guideline. Eight reported more than one conflict. Of those who declared conflicts, 93% reported receiving honoraria, speaker's fees, and/or other kinds of payments or stock ownership from drug manufacturers with an interest in diabetes or hyperlipidemia, and 7% reported receiving only research funding. Six panelists who declared conflicts were chairs of their committee.

"Of the 73 panelists who had a chance to declare a conflict of interest but declared none, eight had undeclared COI that the researchers identified by searching other sources. Among the 77 panel members who did not have an opportunity to publicly declare COI in the guidelines documents, four were found to have COI.
"

The closing quote by Dr. Edwin Gale of the UK is priceless:
"Legislation will not change the situation, for the smart money is always one step ahead. What is needed is a change of culture in which serving two masters becomes as socially unacceptable as smoking a cigarette. Until then, the drug industry will continue to model its behavior on that of its consumers, and we will continue to get the drug industry we deserve."

It's like having Kellogg's tell us what to each for breakfast, or Toyota telling us what car to drive. The sway of the drug industry is huge. Even to this day, I observe colleagues kowtow to the sexy sales rep hawking her wares. But that's the least of it. Far worse, even the "experts" who we had trusted to have objectively reviewed the evidence to help the practitioner on Main Street appears to be little more than a hired lackey for Big Pharma, hoping for that extra few hundred thousand dollars.
All posts by william-davis

Vitamin D deficiency is rampant

Today alone I've seen several people with severe deficiencies of vitamin D.

We're now checking everyone's blood vitamin D level at the start of the program. The measure that most accurately reflects your vitamin D status is 25-OH-vitamin D3. This is very confusing to many physicians, who traditionally have thought of 1,25-di-Hydroxy vitamin D3 as the standard test to measure. What they're failing to recognize is that this second measure is a kidney product, not a reflection of vitamin D status.

Using 25-OH-vitamin D3, several people today alone had levels of <10 ng/ml, clearly in the category of severe deficiency (generally regarded as <20ng/ml).

The majority of people we see in the office are Wisconsin residents. It's no wonder they're deficient. Although it's mid-May, we've seen the sun only a handful of days this year. And most of the days have been too chilly to wear short sleeves and shorts to permit sufficient surface area for UV exposure.

Living in a sunny climate, however, is no guarantee that you have sufficient blood vitamin D levels. Two recent studies have shown that 30-50% of the residents of sunny southern Florida and Hawaii are also deficient. (Why, I'm not sure.)

Although our experience thus far is anecdotal in several hundred people, my impression is that people who have normal blood levels of vitamin D (we regard normal as 45-50 ng/ml) have a far easier time of halting or regressing coronary plaque.

Vitamin D is among the most exciting nutritional tools we've come across in a long time. The conversation is making the media, which impresses me tremendously, given the fact that nobody stands to profit financially to any significant degree through vitamin D supplementation.

For a wonderful collection of discussions on vitamin D, go to Dr. John Cannell's website, www.vitaminDcouncil.com. You'll find a huge quantity of scientific background and conversation on the whole idea. I believe you will be thoroughly impressed with just how powerful the argument in favor of vitamin D has become.

What if wheat products were illegal?

Imagine if anything made of wheat were illegal: bread, bagels, crackers, pasta, pretzels, donuts, Shredded Wheat cereal, Raisin Bran, pastry, cookies, cakes, cupcakes. . . Your grocery store would then be unable to carry any of these products.

How empty would the grocery store shelves be?

There would be very little. The stores would be filled instead with vegetables and fruits, meats, and dairy products. But aisle after aisle would be empty. There'd be no cereal aisle. There'd be no snack chip aisle. The ordinarily overcrowded bread shelves wouldn't be there.

Bakery? Nope, not there either. Pasta and noodles? Empty. How about cakes and pastries? Also gone.

Getting the picture? American groceries are dominated by wheat products. What would happen to your health and the health of your family if wheat were abruptly removed from your choices? Would you be less healthy?

No. In fact, your health would be hugely improved. You'd lose a significant quantity of weight. Extraordinary numbers of people would lose diabetic or pre-diabetic tendencies. Feelings of sluggishness, sleepiness, and moodiness would dissolve. Blood pressure would be reduced. The incidence of cancer, skin disease, and inflammatory diseases would plumet.

From a plaque control perspective, your HDL cholesterol would rise, triglycerides drop. Small LDL would improve dramatically.

The message: Slash wheat products from your diet. Yes, you'll miss the smell and taste of freshly baked bread. But you'll do it for many more healthy years. And you may do it without a 14 inch scar in your chest.

The sobering tale of small LDL

Every day, I learn to respect small LDL more and more.

Small LDL particles, and its evil partner, low HDL, is among the most common reasons why someone fails to fully gain control of coronary plaque and heart disease risk.

Just yesterday, I saw a slender businessman (6 feet 1 inch in height, 186 lb.) whose small pattern persisted despite niacin, fish oil, oat bran, and raw almonds. We generally think of small LDL as an overweight person's pattern, but in some people the genetics are quite powerful and it can be expressed even in slender people.

The solution: More physical activity and exercise; cut back on processed carbohydrates, particularly wheat products like breads, pasta, crackers, breakfast cereals; think about magnesium (see our two recent reports on magnesium on the www.cureality.com membership website, the latest report to be posted this week); be sure sleep is adequate (gauge this by whether you're energetic during the day and don't fall asleep watching TV or movies). Lack of sufficient physical activity in people with sedentary jobs is probably among the most common reason the small LDL pattern persists.

Ignore small LDL and it can be like a hidden cancer in your body, growing and metastasizing (not literally, of course), fueling coronary plaque growth. Be sure your doctor assesses whether you have small LDL if you hope to gain control of your coronary risk.

Burn off the fat

If you've ever wondered just how many calories you're burning with various activities like yard work, driving, climbing stairs, etc. go to this great website that will calculate it for you: http://www.caloriecontrol.org/exercalc.html.

Here are some examples:


Dancing for 30 minutes(fast, e.g., tango): 193 calories
Yoga for 30 minutes: 204 calories
Washing the car for 30 minutes: 173 calories
Vacuuming for 30 minutes: 88 calories

(All are for a 170 lb person.)

As you see, physical activity does not necessarily have to consist of exercise. It doesn't require fancy equipment or expensive outfits. But it does require you to keep moving. Sedentary work is among the most common reasons I see in my patients for failing to control weight and its associated lipoprotein patterns, like low HDL and small LDL.

If your work is sedentary, then a minimum of 60 minutes of physical activity per day is necessary to begin to correct weight-related patterns. If you gauge by calories burned, then a useful goal is 500 calories per day in physical activity--at a minimum.

Go the distance!

How long should it take to stop or reverse coronary plaque growth? How long will it require to stop your heart scan score of, say, 350, from increasing at the expected rate of 30% per year, slow it down (we say "decelerate") to less than 30%, or stop it altogether? Or, actually reduce your score?

It can vary widely. Several simple patterns do seem to emerge, however. Our experience is that lower scores, particularly less than 100 at the start, are easier to gain control over. Scores of 50 or less, in fact, commonly can return to zero.

Higher scores, particularly those >1000, are more difficult to slow or reduce, though we've done it many times. You'll generally have to try harder and it may take longer. It's not uncommon to not stop plaque growth with a starting score this high until your 2nd or 3rd year of effort.

Sometimes it may take even longer. An occasional person requires four or five years to gain control. And there are, unfortunately, some people who never really gain complete control. They slow plaque growth compared to what it would have been with conventional efforts, but never completely halt growth. Why? Sometimes it's a matter of less than full commitment. Other times, we just don't know. Thankfully, these especially difficult cases are few and the majority enjoy substantial slowing or reversal.

Since, in some people, success may take time, you've got to stick it out. Have you ever gotten lost in a strange city only to find out later that the place you were looking for was right around the corner? It can be the same way with stopping coronary plaque growth. If you start with a score of 1000 and, after two years of effort, you've only slowed growth to 11% per year and then give up in frustration, you may have missed the opportunity to have stopped growth entirely in your third year.

All we can do is tip the scales heavily in your favor. We provide you with the best tools known. You've got to provide the commitment, the consistent effort of taking your supplements or medication, making the lifestyle changes, choosing the right foods and avoiding the wrong ones. But you've got to go the distance and not give up too easily.

What you need is an expert in health!

Where can you find an expert in health?

In my experience, they're hard--very hard--to find.

Your hospital? Certainly not the hospitals I know. The hospitals I know are experts in disease, but not in health. Hospitals are helpful when you're sick. But if you're well and would like to stay that way, there's no reason to hang around a hospital. Prevent cancer, prevent heart disease, stay well? There's no place for this conversation in a hospital.

In fact, hospital staff are among the most unhealthy people I come across. Obesity is a nationwide problem affecting millions of Americans. But it's especially a problem among people who work in hospitals. I shudder in horror when I go to a hospital cafeteria and witness the sorts of food they serve in hospitals and see what the staff eat. Should they be regarded as experts in health?

How about doctors? If you associate with physicians like the ones I know, most have lots of knowledge about disease, but little understanding of health. A rare one has insight and interest in health.

I went to a recent meeting with my cardiology colleagues. Food served: pizza, Coca-Cola, spaghetti, fried onion rings, white bread with butter. They all dug in without hesitation. Over half were miserably overweight. Several were, in fact, diabetic; several more, pre-diabetic. I know that at least several are smokers. Experts in health?

Drug companies? Well, they're interested in health only as far as it provides profits. But health for its own sake? Ask anybody from a drug manufacturer about their views on the nutritional supplement movement and watch them sneer.

Food manufacturers? You mean like Coca-Cola, Pepsi-Cola, Nabisco, and General Mills? How about fast-food operations like McDonald's, Pizza Hut, and KFC?

The message: Know where to look for genuine information on health. You won't get it from hospitals. You won't get it from drug company marketing. For the most part, you can't even get it from your physician.

Instead, you're going to witness a broad movement towards self-empowerment in health, fueled by the internet and services like ours (Track Your Plaque). These are information resources that are not driven by profit, intent on providing truth, and not afraid to reject prevailing views.

It does not mean that hospitals are unnecessary, or that food manufacturers are evil, or that fast food should be legislated out of existence. We live in a capitalistic society, driven by supply and demand. Hopefully, demand is borne from educated choices from informed consumers. That's where information that's reliable, credible, and not profit driven come in.

Lipoprotein(a) and small LDL

It's been my suspicion for some time that the combination of lipoprotein(a), or Lp(a), in combination with small LDL particles is a really bad risk for heart disease. People with this combination seem to have much higher heart scan scores for age than others. This seems to be a pattern that we'll see in the occasional woman less than 50 years old who already has a high heaert scan score. (It's unusual for women to have detectable coronary plaque before age 50.)

Very little data exists to support this idea and we are in the process of performing a small study to see whether it's true or not. My gut sense: it's among the most potent causes of coronary plaque around.

Case in point: Even though I spend a great deal of my time and energy advocating heart disease prevention, I still maintain my hospital privileges and skills. I had to cover one of the emergency rooms in town this past weekend (a requirement to maintain my hospital privileges).

One of the patients I saw was a 40-year old man--we'll call him Roland-- suffering a very large heart attack, a so-called "anterior myocardial infarction", or a heart attack involving the most important front portion of the heart. Thankfully, he came to the ER within 45 minutes after his chest pain started. The situation was immediately obvious and I was called to the ER. We quickly took him to the cardiac catheterization laboratory and put a stent in the left anterior descending artery and flow was restored. His chest pain dissipated over the next few minutes.

Nonetheless, Roland was left with a large area of reduced contraction of his heart muscle. Only time will tell how much recovery he'll have.

Roland was extremely lucky. The majority of people with closure of the artery that he'd experienced die within minutes. He did, in fact, "arrest" briefly, i.e., his heart became electrically unstable, though he recovered promptly.

Along with the multiple tubes of blood we required to run tests for his heart attack management, we had Roland's lipids and other measures sent off, as well. Wouldn't you know: Lp(a) and small LDL. This may have accounted for a heart attack at age 40.

Keep a lookout for this when you have lipoprotein testing. Conveniently, niacin can be used to treat both patterns, though higher doses are generally required for the Lp(a) part of the pattern. It's also my belief that the sort of Lp(a) measurement performed by the Liposcience laboratory (www.liposcience.com) is superior. They use a particle number based measure, not a weight-based measure. It is therefore independent of particle size, which can vary. Further work will, I believe, reveal some very important insights into the dreaded Lp(a).

"Please don't tell my doctor I had a heart scan!"

I overheard this recent conversation between a CT technologist and a 53-year old woman (who I'll call Joan) who just had a scan at a heart scan center:


CT Tech: It appears to me that you have a moderate quantity of coronary plaque. But you should know that this is a lot of plaque for a woman in your age group. A cardiologist will review your scan after it's been put through a software program that allows us to score your images.

Joan: (Sighing) I guess now I know. I've always suspected that I would have some plaque because of my mother. I just don't want to go through what she had to.

CT Tech: Then it's really important that you discuss these results with your doctor. If you wrote your doctor's name on the information sheet, we'll send him the results.

Joan: Oh, no! Don't send my doctor the results! I already asked him if I should get a scan and he said there was no reason to. He said he already knew that my cholesterol was kind of high and that was everything he needed to know. He actually got kind of irritated when I asked. So I think it's best that he doesn't get involved.


This is a conversation that I've overheard many times. (I'm not intentionally an eavesdropper; the physician reading station at the scan center where I interpret scans--Milwaukee Heart Scan--is situated so that I easily overhear conversations between the technologists and patients as they review images immediately after undergoing a scan.)

If Joan feels uncomfortable discussing her heart scan results with her doctor, where can she turn? Get another opinion? Rely on family and friends? Keep it a secret? Read up about heart disease on the internet? Ignore her heart scan?

I've seen people do all of these things. Ideally, people like Joan would simply tell their doctor about their scan and review the results. He/she would then 1) Discuss the implications of the scan, 2) Identify all concealed causes of plaque, and then 3) Help construct an effective program to gain control of plaque to halt or reverse its growth. Well, in my experience, fat chance. 98% of the time it won't happen.

I think it will happen in 10-20 years as public dissatisfaction with the limited answers provided through conventional routes grows and compels physicians to sit up and take notice that people are dying around them every day because of ignorance, misinformation, and greed.

But in 2006, if you're in a situation like Joan--your doctor is giving you lame answers to your questions or dismissing your concerns as neurotic--then PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE take advantage of the universe of tools in the Track Your Plaque program.

People tell me sometimes that our program is not that easy--it requires reading, thinking, follow-through, and often asking (persuading?) your doctor that some extra steps (like blood work) need to be performed. The alternative? Take Lipitor and keep your mouth shut? Just accept your fate, grin and bear it, hoping luck will hold out? To me, there's no rational choice here.

Doctor, why do I have heart disease?

I see a great many people in my practice who come for a 2nd opinion regarding their coronary disease.

When I ask patients whether they ever asked their primary doctor or cardiologist why they have heart disease in the first place, I get one of several responses:

1) My doctor said it from high cholesterol.

2) My doctor said it was "genetic" or "part of your family history" and so unidentifiable and uncorrectable. Tough luck.

3) I didn't ask and they didn't tell me.


Let's talk about each of these.

Can heart disease be only from high cholesterol and, if so, can taking a statin cholesterol drug be a "cure"? In the vast majority of cases, in my experience, cholesterol by itself is rarely the only identifiable cause of coronary disease.

Most people have a multitude of causes (e.g., small LDL, low HDL, vitamin D deficiency, concealed pre-diabetic patterns, etc.). This explains why many people with high LDL don't have heart disease and why others with low HDL do have heart disease. High LDL cholesterol is only part of the cause.

Does "genetic" or being part of your family's history also mean unidentifiable and uncorrectable? Absolutely not.

What your doctor is really saying is "I don't know enough to diagnose the causes because I haven't kept up with the scientific literature", or "I don't want to be bothered with this because it takes a lot of time and pays me very little money; I'd rather wait until you need a stent ", or "The drug representatives haven't told me about any new drugs". This is ignorance and laziness at best, greed and profiteering at worst. Don't fall for it. I hope that by now you recognize that the great majority of causes of heart disease are identifiable and correctable.

If you didn't think to ask, now you know that you should. If you and your doctor don't think about why you have coronary plaque in the first place, how can you develop a program to control it?

You need to ask. And you need to get confident answers. "I don't know" or "It's genetic" and the like are unacceptable.

Pill pushers

Have you read the latest cover story from Forbes magazine? It's entitled "Pill Pushers: How the drug industry abandoned science for salesmanship".

It's great reading. (A condensed version is available at the www.forbes.com website: http://www.forbes.com/business/forbes/2006/0508/094a.html. They require you to provide your e-mail address though it's free.)

Drug industry advertising has raised consciousness of all the prescription therapies available for us--that's good. However, they've gone so far overboard trying to squeeze more and more revenues out of drugs that they've cost this country a huge amount in increased health care costs and even lost lives. (Forbes does a great job of summarizing some of these instances.)

Drugs like Lipitor, Crestor, Zocor; diabetes agents; anti-hypertensive agents, etc., that is, medications taken chronically, a huge financial bonanzas for drug companies. Not only do they get $100-200 per month, but they get it month after month after month. That's per drug.

Now not all medications are bad or unnecessary. There are times when they can be truly necessary and beneficial. But don't rely on drug company advertising to tell us when.